8 ms·
Evidence of price-fixing in the oil industry?
- google234123 3y agoAnd our government has literally made it its mission to limit domestic oil production (canceling keystone, blocking permits, ceasing to lease federal land. I’m guessing all the net zero regressives were quite happy about the high prices too I remember at the time Biden was asking (failingly) Saudi & even China to pump more oil lol
- Pet_Ant 3y agoIf the prices mean that we move off of oil... we'll it's painful medicine. The planet's capacity to absorb CO2 is limited and too many people are too happy to be deficit spending on that account because it's not as visible. When that bill comes due, it won't be as easy to pay it off with green rectangles.
- highwayman47 3y agoEven if this were true, China, Russia and India aren’t going to reduce their emissions. So they will thrive with the cheap energy and overtake the west.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoThis is old and incorrect. China is leading the way in terms of electrification and EV-adoption, ahead of even the darling child Norway.
- albertopv 3y agoChina is building more new coal power plants than rest of the world combined.
- 0xdde 3y agoAnd more renewables.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThat’s a bit of a red herring. Their rate of growth in coal has fallen dramatically over the last 15 years and other sources are growing rapidly. As a share of the total coal is declining as is oil and renewables is increasing. Assuming this trend continues over the next 20 years coal will become a distinct minority share. But their overall demand for energy is so immense that they’re still adding more coal power plants - and every other source of energy as well. The metric you quoted is pretty devoid of broader context and tells a story that’s pretty skewed when the reality is fairly nuanced. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-source-and-country?stackMode=absolute&time=2010..latest&country=~CHN https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou...
- albertopv 3y agoReality is G7 is getting rid of coal and have carbon taxes, China and India are still building new coal. China is already first world polluter and will be much more with new coal. There are no nuances in this.
- hollerith 3y agoChina does not produce enough oil to run its current fleet of cars and trucks. They get most of their oil from the Persian Gulf and they correctly worry that that supply line will be pinched (or cut off entirely) if the US gets angry at them (similar to how the US is angry with Russia now) or if some actor like Iran stops the flow of oil out of the Gulf. Most of the oil and oil products China gets from Russia leave Russia on ships from Russia's European ports -- another long supply line. So for sensible national-security reasons that do not apply to the US (namely, making sure it can continue to transport things like food to all its citizens if its national-security competitor gets angry at it or if the Persian Gulf becomes unstable) China is interested in electrifying its vehicle fleet since China has plenty of coal with which to generate electricity. Because coal is the fossil fuel that produces the most carbon dioxide per unit of heat produced, it might be the an electric car in China will more greenhouse gas than a gas-powered car in the US.
- google234123 3y agoAs long as you (and the Democratic Party) are honest about it during elections. I’d love for you to say this publically, see how the American people want to suffer and go back to a lower standard of living so that you can feel better about yourself.
- lambdaxyzw 3y agoI'm ambivalent towards American politics, but that's an argument to be made that voting people (and media) don't think in timescales longer than 5 years, and it will be the humanity downfall if we don't focus on the Earth's long term problems. There are no easy solutions, and I don't pretend to have an answer, but "close your eyes and wait for our doom (or a miracle)" is not one.
- mjmsmith 3y agoIf I can't squander my children's future for my own selfish desires, what's the point of America?
- klyrs 3y agoAye? And are Republicans gonna be honest with farmers about the long-term consequences of not swallowing this bitter pill? Are your politicians prepared to talk about the real welfare queens in this country, the truck-driving rural population whose lifestyle is propped up by oil & gas subsidies?
- piva00 3y ago> so that you can feel better about yourself. I don't grasp this sentiment. It's clear it's not about feeling better about oneself but being preoccupied about a materially predicted catastrophe that can tear the fabric of many societies if left without action. Even if it means lowering some standards of living for a while, and spending money to move us out from the high consumption of fossil fuels, it's worth it long term both in economical and social aspects. You don't want a world where social strife due to mass starvation, mass migration, destroying societies that want to protect themselves from the potential millions that will seek refugee elsewhere where they can have food, is possible because it would be a little bit inconvenient to some of the richest folks on Earth. Those will also cause massive economical impacts, broken supply chains, less supply of some raw materials, more protectionism from nations wanting to hoard resources, wars between nations when water sources move borders or disappear altogether. Yeah, there might be some inconveniences that are required, but previous generations had to deal with much worse inconveniences: wars, famine due to crop failure, etc. It sounds really entitled to be offended by being asked to not drive your car so much, shop more locally produced food (and even stuff in general) if possible in your budget, change some ways of business to not require so many flights for simple meetings, so on and so forth. There are lots of low hanging fruits, there's also massive societal changes required, we should be brave enough to be inconvenienced a little to avoid much more suffering in the lives of our kids, grandkids and so on.
- dylan604 3y ago>If the prices mean that we move off of oil... we'll it's painful medicine. I'm know I'm an odd duck, but I think the price of gasoline in the US is way too cheap. Even at the highest price per gallon in the US, that's about the same price per liter in Europe. I'm not considering bigOil profits in saying that. I'm saying that until the price of gasoline hurts, nobody will care about the ramifications from using it (if even then). People are less concerned about the environmental effects as they are their personal financial effects, but I'll take it either way if it reduces the use.
- jajko 3y agoThat's political suicide. As much as I wish for what you write to become true, look at how stupidly unimportant (or unsolvable) items made people like trump from 0 to hero. This is majority of US voters, and same applies in many other countries. This would hurt literally everybody and cost given political side couple of elections. Look at how every single politician across all spectrum is playing politics and PC and is on full PR mode 24/7 when on camera. That's not the kind of people who make good long term decisions just because... they are good. Not when they massively hurt back.
- Marsymars 3y ago> That's political suicide. As much as I wish for what you write to become true, look at how stupidly unimportant (or unsolvable) items made people like trump from 0 to hero. Or look at how the carbon tax is killing the ruling party in Canada. It reduces GHG emissions, is structured in a progressive way that's a financial benefit to most people, is strongly supported by most economists, and is wildly unpopular at large.
- bluefirebrand 3y ago> structured in a progressive way that's a financial benefit to most people I think most people are unable to draw a line from the carbon tax to how it financially benefits them It has had a very visible surface level impact of making gas more expensive at gas stations, which is very clearly not a financial benefit for individuals who drive gas cars People need a concrete reason to believe that this puts money in their pocket. Not some just some vague assurance of "This financially benefits you"
- rokkitmensch 3y agoThis attitude of imposing pain that maps trivially to regressive taxation on lower- and middle-class voters is not a good look for the green left.
- hopfenspergerj 3y agoYou can obviously compensate by changing other taxes to be more progressive, this is such a silly argument.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoA nuance is perhaps lost, I'm not saying don't do it, merely that simplistic messaging feeds into the binary crisis.
- mardifoufs 3y agoSure but that doesn't happen. Start by doing that, not by implementing the regressive part first.
- hedora 3y agoInstead of sending the money to oppressive regimes, we should send it to atmospheric carbon capture facilities. It costs about $1/gallon (maybe $2/gallon, with recent inflation) to suck the CO2 emitted by gasoline out of the air, and put it back in the ground. That's a heck of a lot less expensive than dealing with the consequences of climate change, and certainly less than the amount gas prices fluctuate due to price gouging, etc.
- makapuf 3y agoDo you have any source for that 2$/gal CO2 removal ?
- mjmsmith 3y ago"The environmental constraints bit was in retrospect an obvious lie."
- dylan604 3y agoIt was pretty obvious when said without needing retrospect
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoIt's almost as if you have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. Keystone was about pumping oil straight from Canada to the Gulf Coast for the export market, crossing key aquifers to get there. It literally never mattered with respect to US gas prices and never will regardless of what occurs in the future. The US literally produces more oil today than any country has in the history of the world. One of the main reasons its doing so is because oil prices are high enough to sustain production. Making oil cheaper REDUCES production. Wells become unprofitable to pump and maintain. When Trump negotiated a deal to crash the oil market, thousands of people in the industry lost their jobs.
- abracadaniel 3y agoMore than that, the Keystone pipeline would have increased oil prices in the US. Canada exports most of that shale oil to refineries in the US. The pipeline would have bypassed the US and forced us to compete with other buyers for the oil. The pipeline could only have had negative impacts on the US. https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/energy-markets/market-snapshots/2019/market-snapshot-canadian-crude-oil-is-mainly-exported-two-regions-in-united-states.html https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/energy-markets/ma...
- karagenit 3y agoAccording to the EIA domestic crude production is at an all time high: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61523 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61523
- daveguy 3y agoWe are producing more oil in the US than we ever have.
- knowaveragejoe 3y agoWhy are you so committed to being wrong?
- highwayman47 3y agoI look forward to nothing being done about this and no one being held accountable.
- hypeatei 3y agoYep, wouldn't expect anything else tbf. All the institutions and systems we've created are to maximize profits. No end goal in sight, just make number go up.
- Thiez 3y agoIn Vietnam they know how to deal with this kind of thing. Maybe the people responsible can get the Trương Mỹ Lan treatment?
- spxneo 3y agoinb4 alephnerd but US legitimacy/prestige has taken significant hit in the past 10 years and the trend seems to be accelerating. Truong My Lan may have been a pig to be butchered. Much like SBF/CZ in the US.
- adamors 3y agoDo they? Her story sounds exactly like what happens in authoritarian regimes with people who fall out of favor, nothing more. She controlled the largest bank in Vietnam for 10 years and then suddenly gets sentenced to death? In Russia, these people fall out of windows. This isn't justice.
- elzbardico 3y agoWe're getting there. Now we have Boeing whistleblowers dying suddenly. But let's not forget the fact that a president was killed in daylight and nobody knows what really happened even after some 50 years since the fact.
- colpabar 3y agoFor me the best part was everyone telling us that nothing like this was happening, that something like this wasn't even possible, that corporate greed could NEVER have ANYTHING to do with the price of everything going up.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> The FTC just found evidence that American oil companies colluded with the Saudi government to hike gas prices, costing the average family $3,000 last year. The question is, what can we do about it? Electric cars and heat pumps. This is why people paid a premium (until about a year ago) for electric cars. Fixed costs are better than variable costs.
- trifurcate 3y agoWhat makes you think that the energy sector overall is immune to this while oil isn't?
- flakeoil 3y agoMore and smaller players in electricity production. Half the oil and gas production comes from an official cartel so it's kind of in the oil sector's DNA with price fixing.
- NewJazz 3y agoMore opportunity for substitutions when your fuel is electrons instead of a specific blend of fossil fuels processed in a specific way. That said for profit electric monopolies are indeed a scourge.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoBecause there are multiple ways to generate electricity- including at-home options for many people. There’s also an interesting factor in timing and latency of the grid. Peak usage is typically mid afternoon. While least usage is overnight. There’s essentially excess capacity during the time period that most people charger their car.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNot immune, but more resistant: - electricity can be generated many different ways - many generation sources aren't dependent on resupply. Spiking the price of lithium doesn't prevent existing batteries from working, it only makes new ones more expensive. Solar, wind, hydro and nuclear (to a lesser extent) - electricity supply is heavily regulated, for better or worse.
- chankstein38 3y agoI feel like I recall watching something where an oil exec literally said they were doing this. He was basically saying this was a way to get some profits back after they lost a ton of money during the lockdowns.
- 1980phipsi 3y agoOil industry profits got vaporized by the decline in prices in the aftermath of the shale revolution. Prices fell sharply from 2014 to 2016. So after this, capital discipline became the watchword. That meant they wouldn't overinvest in new wells, keeping supply constrained. While oil futures had some really weird behavior during the lockdowns, the market demand for capital discipline proceeded it.
- alach11 3y agoIt’s pretty absurd that the US government talks out of both sides of its mouth on this issue. There’s an effort to divest from oil, shut down permitting, and discourage investment. And when companies respond to this by reducing investment, there are claims about “windfall profits” and “price-fixing”. There’s no grand conspiracy here. Shale companies over-invested in growth, lost their shirts in 2015, and got punished by investors (or went bankrupt). Then prices recovered, they over invested in growth, and got demolished again as oil prices crashed and even briefly went negative in 2020. Fresh off these two crashes, it’s not surprising at all that companies are exercising capital discipline and not taking on debt to drill. Shareholders don’t want them to do that!
- nemomarx 3y agoIf they're lowering investment, couldn't they lower prices?
- singhrac 3y agoI traded crude oil professionally until early 2022 and I remember that was how we justified low domestic production in mid 2021 as well (i.e. "producers think these prices are temporary, so they aren't investing"). In retrospect (and these are all guesses with hazy memory) we probably overestimated the cost of turning an oil well on and off. But exchanging text messages with OPEC to price-fix is damning. An active right wing party would decry this as foreign interference and communism (where's the free market?). Even ignoring the market impact, how can you let domestic producers collaborate with foreign governments to control such a serious macroeconomic input like this? It's like China paying Intel a bribe to produce worse chips.
- jmyeet 3y agoGovernments have two broad ways of fighting inflation. The first way is to raise interest rates. This is essentially a wealth transfer to banks and their owners while hurting individuals and businesses to stifle economic activity. This is what we always do. Why? Because capital owners demand it. The other way cannot be tolerated or entertained. The second way is taxation. Some countries (eg Spain) enacted a windfall profits tax. Unlike interest rate hikes, taxation only targets profitable corporations. It allows a government to redistribute wealth to those who most need it, fund infrastructure and so on. And it disproportionately affects those who price gouging for massive profits, such as in the case of the oil and gas industry. Companies may reinvest profits into their business to avoid these excessive taxes. Great. Perfect. Love to see it. This latest price-fixing scandal is going to turn into a huge deal. This is just the beginning. But it's not th esole reason for price hikes in 2020-2022. A lot of that was because the then Trump administration browbeat OPEC into cutting production in early 2020 [1], which was a truly disastrous policy. You can see the effects on the 5 year view [2] very clearly. [1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN22C1V3/ https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN22C1V3/ [2]: https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/crude-oil https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/crude-oil
- marcosdumay 3y agoIf you insist on controlling the noise in monetary phenomena through fiscal policy you'll have a really bad time. But people are saying the Panama canal has a drought problem. Maybe you can help with a bucket, you'll probably have a larger impact.
- abeppu 3y ago> If you insist on controlling the noise in monetary phenomena through fiscal policy you'll have a really bad time. Isn't that more a political problem than an economic insight though? We know fiscal policy impacts monetary phenomena (PPP loans, stimulus checks, the child tax credit, etc had inflationary effects), but it's too politically easy to spend more, and too politically difficult to raise taxes, and it's definitely too hard to do either in a timely manner in response to changing economic conditions. But if we had given a politically independent body like the Fed control of tax / spend knobs instead of interest rates, and allowed them to evaluate whether to change those things on a scheduled basis as economic data arrive ... maybe that would also work, we'll just never get the opportunity to try it.
- thegrim33 3y agoThe claim: "there’s now evidence that price-fixingp in the oil industry alone may single-handedly be responsible for a little over a quarter of the total inflationary increase in 2021." Ignoring the typo, which makes me completely confident in their ability to accurately report on these events, the claim is: that price fixing / collusion happened. -- Their evidence: "Yesterday, the Federal Trade Commission released evidence confirming that collusion played a serious role in hiking oil prices at that time." They claim that the FTC has evidence of collusion, and they link to a release from the FTC. -- The FTC evidence: "The Federal Trade Commission took action to resolve antitrust concerns [..] the proposed consent order seeks to prevent Pioneer’s Sheffield from engaging in collusive activity that would potentially raise crude oil prices" So .. they took action to resolve "concerns", to be preventative so that "collusive activity" that could "potentially" raise prices doesn't happen, in the future. "The FTC alleges in a complaint that Sheffield has, through public statements and private communications, attempted to collude" .. "Sheffield sought to align oil production" So .. he "attempted" to collude, he "sought" to collude, or he did collude? -- So, to summarize, the evidence uses wording like "concerns, prevention, in the future, attempt", but nowhere states that anything actually DID happen, whereas the author of this article interprets that as evidence that it absolutely did happen?
- virtue3 3y agoin the actual FTC release: "Through public statements, text messages, in-person meetings, WhatsApp conversations and other communications while at Pioneer, Sheffield sought to align oil production across the Permian Basin in West Texas and New Mexico with OPEC+." "Sheffield, for example, exchanged hundreds of text messages with OPEC representatives and officials discussing crude oil market dynamics, pricing and output. In discussing his efforts to coordinate with Texas producers under a production cut mandated by the Railroad Commission of Texas, Sheffield said, “If Texas leads the way, maybe we can get OPEC to cut production. Maybe Saudi and Russia will follow. That was our plan,” he said, adding: “I was using the tactics of OPEC+ to get a bigger OPEC+ done.”" "NOTE: The Commission issues an administrative complaint when it has “reason to believe” that the law has been or is being violated, and it appears to the Commission that a proceeding is in the public interest. When the Commission issues a consent order on a final basis, it carries the force of law with respect to future actions." This is also legalize, so he hasn't been PROVEN to yet; but it's obvious they have a lot of things to go through here.
- objektif 3y agoPG and all the other smart people were making fun of average citizen on twitter when they blamed corporations for some of the inflation.
- somenameforme 3y agoI wouldn't quite rely on this article as a game changer. The author's evidence for his shocking headline is exclusively him assuming his own conclusion, and then adding a healthy helping of fudgery on top of that. From the article --- How do you aggregate just the oil industry? Well, it’s pretty clear that in 2021 and 2022, the industry did fantastically well, with the “the top 25 companies [making] more than $205 billion in profits in 2021,” and an “even more astounding” amount in 2022. Of course, not all profits are due to price-fixing, but $205 billion is just the top 25, not the whole industry. And profits got much much better the next year. So let’s layer on a rough guess of a $200 billion increase in profits in 2021 that Scott Sheffield implies, which is 27% of the total corporate profit increase that year. That’s a pretty astounding amount, more than a quarter of the total inflationary increase being a result purely of a price-fixing scheme. --- So he's assuming that 100% of inflation is caused by corporate profits (which is beyond absurd), and then stating that since the oil industry made up 27% of total corporate profits (using evidence that seems to be wildly hand-wavey at best, even though the exact numbers are readily available), that they therefore caused 27% of all inflation. And somehow, the giant price-fixing conspiracy (which is a gross misrepresentation of what the FTC is saying) was the reason they made these 27% of profits (which is absurd).
- NewJazz 3y ago"smart people"
- abeppu 3y agoOk, so any time bad corporate behavior causing inflation comes up, I have to wonder -- how much oil stock would you need to own for this contribution to inflation to be good for you (outweigh your increased costs)? When price increases cause greater revenue to asset holders from consumers, there's some spectrum of spending to asset holding, and most people that own nothing are losing out, and Warren Buffett who owns a lot but is famously modest in his lifestyle is benefiting ... but how would you estimate where the breakeven point is? Is a lean FIRE person benefiting? Exxon stock has had a really strong 3 years, but we don't get to observe the counter-factual of how it would have behaved without this price-fixing.
- mistrial9 3y agoall that assumes perfect selfish behavior by each individual investor. Most stocks are not held by individuals, and most individual adults are not invested in stocks. The rational question raised here is not terrible, but several assumptions in it, together, make the mental model that has enabled rampant destruction of the one and only natural Earth in the past two decades with full knowledge of it.
- abeppu 3y agoAsking who benefits does not require us to assume perfect selfish behavior from all investors, nor does it require us to assume that people who benefit from this behavior to want it to continue. I don't think it requires the mental model you're alleging at all. I'm fully in favor of taxing carbon at a rate which reflects its actual externalized costs, as well as other emissions. I've argued that DAs should charge oil companies with manslaughter when people die in heat waves. I don't drive a car, I don't eat animals, and I plant native wildflowers. Being opposed to the destruction of the planet does not mean I should not ask "who actually benefits from economic trends that everyone complains about?" Piketty argued that the share of growth that goes to capital vs labor will determine a great deal about how inequality changes over time, and insofar as artificial price increases are just increased revenues to asset holders, this behavior has importance not just today but in shaping the future. > Most stocks are not held by individuals Isn't that a distraction? Even when stocks are held by, e.g. an insurer, another company, ultimately ownership of most wealth tracks back to some collection of natural persons. Even in cases where 'ownership' doesn't track back to people, there are still beneficiaries, e.g. people who have pensions don't directly own the assets that the pension fund holds.
- bilsbie 3y agoWait until they find out about OPEC.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe US has no control over OPEC. It absolutely has control over monopolies and cartels within its borders. That’s part of the story; something can be done about this behavior in this jurisdiction and situation.
- mcconaughey 3y agoIgnoring the fact that this article doesn't clearly state the "evidence" that the FTC found in this "conspiracy", it misunderstands what occurred with US Shale producers from 2010-now. In the 2010s, US Shale Producers got hyped up on strong oil prices and the explosion of fracking. They massively overproduced, leading to the price cratering and a large majority of producers going out of business. Oil and gas was in severe distress from the late 2010s to the negative price drama in 2020. When prices rebounded in early 2020s, there was a lot of scar tissue in the industry about overproduction. Producers are now extremely conservative. They are also well aware that clean energy is on the horizon and want to draw out this good cycle as long as they can. Opposite to what the conspiracy theory states, OPEC and US Shale do not want prices to go too high in the short term, as this shock would accelerate the clean energy transition. They definitely want strong prices, but this $80-100 range is probably the sweet spot. Below $80, they might pull back, which is what we see from OPEC. But this certainly isn't some "conspiracy" to elevate oil to $200/barrel. These participants are sophisticated and are not that shortsighted. I think the typical Democrat-Party view that "oil bad" and "oil corrupt" lacks nuance. It also ignores the profligate government spending that is driving excessive consumption (travel, etc.) causing a lot of these market dislocations the past several years. Now, they want to point the finger at some grand conspiracy. This seems not far off from Q-Anon on the other side of the political aisle.
- a123b456c 3y ago"If Texas leads the way, maybe we can get OPEC to cut production. Maybe Saudi and Russia will follow. That was our plan,” he said, adding: “I was using the tactics of OPEC+ to get a bigger OPEC+ done.”"
- wolverine876 3y ago> When prices rebounded in early 2020s, there was a lot of scar tissue in the industry about overproduction. Producers are now extremely conservative In corporate America generally, it seems to be a widespread strategy to limit supply and drive up prices. Sometimes it's done explicitly and illegally, such as in rental housing (look up RealPage). Is there evidence that it's particular to shale production? > I think the typical Democrat-Party view that "oil bad" and "oil corrupt" lacks nuance. You said it, then said it lacks nuance.
- kristianp 3y agoNews article with a more concise telling of this story.: https://edition.cnn.com/2024/05/02/energy/oil-ceo-opec-scott-sheffield/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2024/05/02/energy/oil-ceo-opec-scott...
- dogman144 3y agoI knew a trader in Texas in the 00’s. Worked with to oil traders. Total hearsay but heard stories from this person of traders in TX calling friends they grew up with who worked in Cushing Ok (large pipeline exchange or w/e the technical term is) to adjust the flows a bit over lunch and then change it back. So, I believe it
- chasd00 3y agoIt happens, Enron traders were turning off power plants in California that Enron owned to drive up electricity prices (and cause rolling blackouts). They only got caught after the implosion, i'm sure things like that happen all over the place in many industries.
- quickthrowman 3y agoHow did it cost the average family $3,000 extra for gas in one year? I drove 12,000 miles last year and spent less than $2,000 on gas (480 gallons @ 25mpg, $4/gal), does the average family drive 100k miles a year or am I missing something. I suppose if you add in all the gas (and diesel/bunker fuel) that you pay for indirectly through transportation costs, you could come up with $3,000 per family. It is more or less impossible to collude with the Saudis to raise the price of natural gas in the United States (lack of transport), so they must be talking about gasoline.
- tbcj 3y agoIt is in the article how the cost is not necessarily just from a family’s use of oil but the additional cost added to other things (like food, goods) because it costs more to transport those because of higher gas prices. Those costs are passed on to families so your grocery bill is higher because of it too.
- wakawaka28 3y agoHave you heard of OPEC? Lol
- readthenotes1 3y agoLarry Summers shows once again that "serious economists" are as reliable as "serious astrologers"...