14 ms·
AM radio law opposed by tech and auto industries is close to passing
- DerekL 3y agoThe title is misspelled, should be “AM”, not “Am”.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sp332 3y agoHN automatically title-cases everything. After sumbission, OP can edit the title and changes will stick. This also happens with leading numbers.
- abeppu 3y ago> "Requiring the installation of analog AM radios in automobiles is an unnecessary action that would impact EV range, efficiency and affordability at a critical moment of accelerating adoption," said Albert Gore, executive director of ZETA, a clean vehicle advocacy group that opposes the AM radio requirement. Um, what? I'm not an electrical or automotive engineer, but this doesn't sound true. AM radios can be small, light and cheap, and in terms of power, the important components are already in the sound system, right? IDK what would need to be involved to address the issue of interference from the motor, but I also don't think anyone's saying they have to build anything heavy or power-hungry.
- Animats 3y ago"Impact EV range"? When off? Come on. Now, running Unreal Engine in the dashboard actually does affect vehicle range. Some infotainment systems are real power hogs. The great thing about AM radio is that it can receive even if all other infrastructure for hundreds of miles around is down. It's not that you get your initial alert over AM radio. It's that you turn it on after the disaster and get some useful info.
- abeppu 3y agoThe only way I can imagine this plausibly impacting vehicle range would be if the only solution to protecting the radio from interference from the motor involved a bunch of heavy shielding, but I'm hoping no one's actively considering that.
- thsksbd 3y agoNo, but that's the basis that you argue from
- dylan604 3y ago> said Albert Gore man, if that was my name, I would demand my name to always be printed as Al Gore. Imagine the disappointment people would have when I turned up instead of whatever someone might have thought. That's so me to be the epitome of that disappointment
- blendergeek 3y agoAccording to Politico [0], he is the son of Al Gore, the former Vice President. [0] https://www.politico.com/newsletters/the-long-game/2023/01/18/the-political-scion-working-on-ev-deployment-00078289 https://www.politico.com/newsletters/the-long-game/2023/01/1...
- lukeschlather 3y agoI think the biggest thing with this is reliability. I've got a half a dozen cellular radios lying around my house (cellphones) of which exactly one is functional. Even if I paid for a new sim for the others... I'm not sure some of them could work at all with current transmitters, even if the hardware was functional. I've got an AM/FM radio that's 20-30 years old and it still works. At some point it would be nice if we could get back to vendor-agnostic wireless protocols that aren't obsolete every 10 years. Until we have such a thing deprecating AM seems premature.
- doug_durham 3y agoCellular protocols are vendor agnostic. It's just that we keep finding ways to eek more bandwidth out of the spectrum. No one wants 3G or the original CDMA.
- mindslight 3y agoPersonally I was content with 3G, especially 3G voice that was part of 4G LTE until the US carriers were allowed to kill it and force everyone into churning devices. I would likely still be using my S7 if not for that.
- walterbell 3y ago> Yesterday, Senator Edward Markey (D-Mass) revealed that the "AM Radio for Every Vehicle Act" now has the support of 60 US Senators, as well as 246 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives, making its passage an almost sure thing. Should that happen, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration would be required to ensure that all new cars sold in the US had AM radios at no extra cost. Wow, which lobbyists convinced a critical mass of legislators to support a mature, resilient, democratic information delivery platform with content funded by non-invasive advertising, for the benefit of a non-subscribing public?
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoYeah that's the part I find extremely odd, why the fuck are they all so eager to support AM radio when they can't agree on literally anything else. Usually you have to follow the money but this kinda flies in the face of that unless there's some wacky industry shit I don't know about.
- walterbell 3y agoIf this were a Mad Max movie (#4 opening soon), viewers might speculate about storylines for non-AM comms.
- KerrAvon 3y ago[flagged]
- thsksbd 3y agoSupporting this costs senators nothing but is a nice thing to showcase rural constituencies and those living in areas at high risk of natural disasters.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dghlsakjg 3y agoHave you listened to AM radio recently?! If you want to hear the most unhinged broadcasts possible, that’s where you go.
- snakeyjake 3y agoThis is the dumbest goddamned bill to ever exist and it dismays me to see everyone cheering on the iHeartmedia and Audacy bribery. The cover story is that these stations are needed in cases of emergency. If that was actually what was going on congress would allocate funding to distribute portable AM radios to citizens-- radios that can be used when your car is destroyed or inaccessible like it will be in a hurricane, flood, or blizzard. If you even have a car.
- CivBase 3y agoDo you have any idea how much it would cost for the government to distribute portable AM radios to everyone? This law is way less expensive and it's good enough for most use cases.
- Der_Einzige 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksempf%C3%A4nger https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksempf%C3%A4nger Hitler basically sort of did this and it was wildly successful for them.
- massysett 3y agoMy guess: probably about what it cost to distribute Covid tests, but how much that was I don’t know.
- thsksbd 3y ago20 years ago everyone had very many AM radios (car, kitchen radio, alarm clocks, etc). Even today the vast majority of households have at least one AM radio in their car. The best part is that the poorer you are, the more likely you are to have an AM radio. The only people congress would need to subsidize AM radios for are upper middle class laptop warriors.
- msla 3y agoThe problem is that radio stations typically don't have anyone in the booth most of the time, if ever: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minot_train_derailment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minot_train_derailment > The Minot train derailment occurred just west of Minot, North Dakota, United States, on January 18, 2002, when a Canadian Pacific Railway freight train derailed, spreading ammonia gas across the city, delaying rescue operations. The cause was found to be small fatigue cracks in the rails and joint bars, not detectable by the inspection routines then enforced by Canadian Pacific. [snip] > Because it was the middle of the night, there were few people at local radio stations, all operated by Clear Channel with mostly automated programming. No formal emergency warnings were issued for several hours while Minot officials located station managers at home. North Dakota's public radio network, Prairie Public Broadcasting, was notified and did broadcast warnings to citizens. And Minot is one of the bigger cities in North Dakota.
- hnburnsy 3y agoThis feels like the saving of Saturday mail delivery, ugh.
- w10-1 3y agoIt may be politics. 90% of AM radio stations are owned by ~5 companies pushing a conservative agenda, with a similar disparity in programming (i.e., 90% conservative). Most of the 10% of non-conservative stations are in progressive markets, where they have little impact. E.g., in San Francisco, the programming split is ~70/30% conservative/liberal. Here's the (admittedly biased) source, but the numbers would be easily rebutted if untrue: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/talk-radio-by-the-numbers/ https://www.americanprogress.org/article/talk-radio-by-the-n... AM radio licenses are a fixed government monopoly, and it's well within the budget of political organizations to subsidize a radio station, so there will be no change in this disparity driven by market solutions. Assuming the numbers are true, once government policy results in an enduring political bias in media, does the government have any responsibility to mitigate that bias? Does the government have any obligation or even mandate to reach into product design and require certain features - features unrelated to safety, pollution, energy, or any other generally accepted social good?
- eropple 3y agoMaybe by the manufacturers, but I doubt it; see Musk's pivot to conservative pantomime since acquiring Twitter. And Ed Markey is not exactly a conservative politician.
- KerrAvon 3y ago[flagged]
- rpcope1 3y agoIt would be really nice if the FCC hadn't actively tried to kill low power FM and had promoted more low power AM, in conjunction with the FTC or whomever breaking up the big broadcast monopolies. I think mandating AM receivers should come with a push to significantly democratize parts of the bands so that there's more than just the same old stuff across every frequency.
- eru 3y agoThey should auction off the frequencies, and let the winner use them however they see fit. Instead of holding beauty contests. (Especially, the winner should be allowed to run eg better wifi on them, or better mobile phone data.)
- Turing_Machine 3y agoFrom reading the summary it appears that an SDR would be compliant, plus it wouldopen up the possibility of listening to many other things besides (for one, you wouldn't need a separate FM radio. For another, it could also receive weather data). They're pretty cheap nowadays even for one-off consumer purchases. I imagine the cost would be minimal on an automaker's scale.
- redserk 3y agoWhy focus on AM when we already have a federally run national emergency broadcast service — the NOAA Weather Radio. Go peruse around 162Mhz. You may find you're within 2-3 different transmitters right now. Bonus: Zero political anything to worry about. The weather radio is a completely boring readout of the weather and alerts. It’s simple. It’s beautiful. It would be trivial to support with most existing FM antennas anyways, it already supports national emergency announcements in addition to weather alerts. It even broadcasts a signal telling you where a given alert is targeting. A vehicle could use and correlate its GPS location to notify occupants. AM would require manually switching the radio mode, tuning to find an appropriate channel, and there’s so much crap to dig around. Plus, say a nuclear weapon went off anyways and all the FM transmitters died. Is anyone seriously thinking a lone AM transmitter 2000 miles away is going to help? We had all the communication in the world during COVID and that did nothing to stop people from acting foolish.
- galleywest200 3y agoWhere I live we have signs up all over the place near the mountains that tell you to tune into a specific AM station when flashing for avalanche/weather information. I understand wanting to move past some technologies but we are not going to be able to revamp our entire avalanche system _tomorrow_. Most people I know do not have a short-wave radio, let alone one capable of receiving at 162Mhz.
- labbett 3y agoAM radio over IP (AMoIP)
- userbinator 3y agoI'm in the tech industry and I support this. You can receive AM with very simple receivers. The cost of adding one to a car is miniscule, and it works when other more complex systems don't. Not only emergency broadcasts but things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travelers%27_information_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travelers%27_information_stati... make it important to have a working AM radio in your car.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoAM receivers can be so simple they don't even require a battery. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_radio https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_radio
- speedylight 3y agoI’ve heard that some people with amalgam tooth filling can sometimes pick up transmissions and somehow audio would actually play inside their mouth, not static noise, actual voices talking. It’s quite bizarre but also makes total sense when you think about it!
- yau8edq12i 3y agoI'm sorry but this anecdote sets off my BS detector very hard.
- kragen 3y agoit's probably real but not thoroughly proven: https://www.straightdope.com/21341818/is-it-possible-to-hear-radio-broadcasts-through-your-teeth https://www.straightdope.com/21341818/is-it-possible-to-hear...
- yau8edq12i 3y agoHow on Earth did you arrive at the conclusion "probably real" from that link?
- duxup 3y ago>A big reason for that is electromagnetic interference from electric motors—rather than risk customer complaints from poor-quality audio, some automakers decided to remove it. Is this a hard problem to overcome?
- CivBase 3y agoHow bad is the interference that it might drive customer complaints about AM audio quality?
- roschdal 3y agoAmerica wants AM radio everywhere, Norway wants DAB radio everywhere. Strange.
- tempaccount1234 3y agoBecause it’s cheaper to run DAB than FM and running both with the same content costs too much. But for range, DAB is even worse. The neighboring country’s stations here already stop working five miles behind the border. FM covers 50 miles and since local AM transmission have stopped, in my car I can listen to stations 300 miles away. It sounds like crap but it’s still usable and I tune in often. For sports coverage it was good enough and I miss the times where it was possible to listen to full games while driving. The FM replacement doesn’t cover as much area and there’s no consistent internet coverage to listen via app (and it’s illegal to play with your phone while driving, so once the app cuts out, you can’t restart it)
- rsynnott 3y agoIreland had DAB radio mostly everywhere, but turned it off a few years back; back to FM. Analogisation!
- bparsons 3y agoIn a true emergency situation (like if a big portion of the power grid or internet went down) you need some way to communicate with people. This is a no brainer if you care about public safety.
- guenthert 3y agoAs others have already stated, the safety aspect is just a red-herring. Even in 'merica, most people don't quite spend most of their time in the car. And who has an AM radio at home or with them? Like it or not (I don't), but smartphones is the medium to reach the vast majority of people. And if in a disaster cell phone services is interrupted, that will the be first to be restored (before water and power), by temporary means if necessary. E.g. Cisco has an emergency response team with mobile tech.
- msla 3y agoThe problem is that radio stations typically don't have anyone in the booth most of the time, if ever: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minot_train_derailment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minot_train_derailment > The Minot train derailment occurred just west of Minot, North Dakota, United States, on January 18, 2002, when a Canadian Pacific Railway freight train derailed, spreading ammonia gas across the city, delaying rescue operations. The cause was found to be small fatigue cracks in the rails and joint bars, not detectable by the inspection routines then enforced by Canadian Pacific. [snip] > Because it was the middle of the night, there were few people at local radio stations, all operated by Clear Channel with mostly automated programming. No formal emergency warnings were issued for several hours while Minot officials located station managers at home. North Dakota's public radio network, Prairie Public Broadcasting, was notified and did broadcast warnings to citizens. And Minot is one of the bigger cities in North Dakota.
- seydor 3y agoIf we want to have our uncensored communication back, we need AM radio
- asdefghyk 3y agoBesides the reliability of AM THe internet network and the mobile phone network has many parts. A breakdown in any of these parts would disrupt/break communications A mobile phone cell (depending on technology) is often only a small size or diameter. A mobile phone base station is reliant on the electricity supply. If the wired electricity supply is down ( during an emergency) the mobile phone base state MAY have batteries that will run it for a while. Where for a while would be measured in hours. During emergencies such as flood or fire such base stations maybe out for many days. Broadcast band AM radio signals , normally 500KHz to 1.6MHz can have a reliable transmission range for typical broadcast transmitter normally several KW power ) of RELIABLE 100 miles during the DAY. AM radio range during night can be 1000s KM. The mobile network is prone to failure during emergencies and is hard to make robust. Opposition to AM network usage for emergencies would be from entities that want a small cost reduction in car manufacture.
- ReptileMan 3y ago>Requiring the installation of analog AM radios in automobiles is an unnecessary action that would impact EV range, efficiency and affordability at a critical moment of accelerating adoption That is advanced stupid.
- walrus01 3y agoPeople who think that AM radio is useless in the modern era, have clearly never lived in a city with a 50,000 watt AM station that has extremely regular traffic updates. Info on crashes, bridge and tunnel problems, etc reported by a local who knows all of the choke points and common problem areas is very valuable, particularly because you can get it hands-free without needing to look at an app on a phone or on a car screen. And often more reliable and better than just relying on a navigation app to route you around bad traffic. In the Pacific Northwest you will also get updates on border traffic between Washington and BC, and also WA and BC ferry information.
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> A recent test of the emergency alert system found only 1 percent got it via AM. Only 1%? Surely we can leave 1% of americans behind in an emergency.
- Ylpertnodi 3y agoAs you have volunteered to be a 1%-er, I salute your sacrifice.
- Avamander 3y agoBecause other channels worked? We don't know what the percentage would be if it were actually the only option.
- rapht 3y agoPreserve AM radio for worst-case scenario emergency, where nothing else ever is available -- that's the million year solar flare or the next nuclear winter -- of course. AM is the best at what it does, which is transmitting efficiently, with low power, including in difficult terrain, all with extremely simple hardware. But why the heck mandate thay we can receive it in every car?? I mean, cars are important in America, but why would you need the wordt-case scenario emergency thing in every car! Mandate home radio equipment makers to support it, or mandate one receiver in every house à la smoke detectors. Cheap and easy. But every car? Crazy stupid.
- valeg 3y agoI wish AM Stereo is back in vogue.
- johnklos 3y ago"Requiring the installation of analog AM radios in automobiles is an unnecessary action that would impact EV range, efficiency and affordability"... I think this bull is them telling on themselves, since the cost of adding an AM radio would be practically unmeasurable compared with the cost of the car. So where would this bill impact EV range, or efficiency, or affordability? The only way this is possible is if the EV makers have to make their cars emit less electromagnetic noise, I'm guessing.
- K0balt 3y agoAM radio is most useful for its resilience in the worst case scenarios and for its reach to underserved populations. It benefits from comparative simplicity and longer range than FM. It can also be trivially connected to digital modes for even longer ranges and reliable data transmission. Crude receivers can be made from readily available materials and require no local source of power. Maintaining a national network of AM broadcasting stations by ensuring economic viability is a low cost method of ensuring communications resiliency for the nation under the worst of circumstances. I can’t say for the difficulty of filtering EMI from EVs, but assuming that a vehicle already will have some kind of audio system, AM radio is a <2$ add to an existing radio receiver. Think of it as a 2$ per car one time tax to ensure improved worst case CCC capability for the nation in the face of the most acute threats to the population.
- cushychicken 3y agoThat’s kind of far out that Ed Markey and Ted Cruz are the co sponsors of this bill. For the record: I love Ed Markey. I’m in his congressional district. (Technically, I’m in his town - his registered congressional address is in Malden, MA!) I’m kind of surprised to see him co sponsor with Ted. But I’m pleased that the two of them are working together. We need more public examples of this - or more publicity for the examples of this that go down. I’m sure there are lots. They’re just not as cinematic as culture war stories.
- throwaway01uau2 3y ago178 comments and nobody mentioned https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Radio_Mondiale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Radio_Mondiale !? It provides high quality digital broadcasts on the same spectrum as AM and with way more power efficiency. Receivers cost nothing and are immune to EV radio noise.
- ugjka 3y agoThey have their own thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HD_Radio#HD_versus_DRM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HD_Radio#HD_versus_DRM
- millerm 3y agoMaybe people could learn what a portable transistor radio is. Maybe they could just give you one with your car. Sell one for $2.99. Is a car really your best option to be in in an emergency? Sometimes you need to get out of that car, maybe find shelter. That car radio is not going help you at all while down in a cellar as tornadoes have ripped through and destroyed everything including your car.
- gpvos 3y agoMeanwhile in Europe the AM bands have become nearly empty by now.
- nemo44x 3y agoCould they just toss a simple AM radio into the glove box that plugs into a port for power?
- webdoodle 3y agoAM can propagate so much further at night, when the ionosphere isn't causing distortion. I'm not looking for good quality, I'm looking to hear stations further away. I absolutely don't want to have to use internet access as a substitute, where now i have to transmit just to receive.
- pridkett 3y agoDriving home from Burlington, VT after the eclipse. Traffic was crawling. Cell data wasn’t working. FM seemed like all automated stations from far away. Yknow what did provide information on traffic and scaled to the huge influx of people in the area? A news station on AM radio. But that brings up a bigger problem, many many radio stations are essentially on autopilot or run from a distance without the ability to address local situations. Without support for truly local stations, AM radio may be present, but generally without significant value.
- darby_eight 3y agoAlso a big fan of AM radio in vermont, but the flipside of this is that it's been used to peddle misinformation for decades.
- 15155 3y ago[flagged]
- badhackernews 3y ago[dead]
- gibbitz 3y agoQuite the opposite. This board should be responsible for making sure all "fringe" voices are heard, not just the alien conspiracy, ultra right-wing and religious zealotry groups. I haven't been confronted with any programs about satanism, fairy folk, living on the Sun or say... gay rights on Midwestern AM radio.
- 15155 3y agoI don't disagree - maybe an open auction house/marketplace for AM time slots. If the spectrum is a public resource anyway...
- darby_eight 3y ago
- mmis1000 3y agoI am not sure if it is a country wide thing or not. But in Taiwan. Most emergency radio and music radio including illegal radio sites are in FM instead of AM. (probably due to sound quality) The AM is really obsoleted here. I am surprising there are still a lot of people using am radio. Do people use it for emergency radio only or some other reasons?
- shkkmo 3y agoAM is good for long range coverage and North America has a lot of really empty areas that make this long range more useful than it is in denser areas. AM stations in the USA carry a variety of content while being a bit heaveir on "talk" stations over music when compared to FM.
- BeetleB 3y ago> But in Taiwan. Most emergency radio and music radio including illegal radio sites are in FM instead of AM. Taiwan is tiny. You need only a few FM towers to cover the whole country. FM's range is low. AM's range is much, much higher: "However, during nighttime hours the AM signals can travel over hundreds of miles by reflection from the ionosphere, a phenomenon called "skywave" propagation. (Shortwave stations, which operate using AM modulation on several bands between between 2.3 MHz and 26.1 MHz, also use this phenomenon to broadcast still greater distances, up to thousands of miles.) Because of this change in signal propagation from daytime to nighttime, if every AM station kept its daytime operating power at night, massive interference would result. (For a similar description, see Hours of Daytime-Only AM Broadcast Stations, First Report and Order, BC Docket 82-538, 95 FCC 2d 1032 (1983) [ PDF ] and related [ MO&O ])." https://www.fcc.gov/media/radio/am-stations-at-night https://www.fcc.gov/media/radio/am-stations-at-night In the US, it's used for all kinds of stations - mostly junk talk shows and sports. And yes, emergencies. When driving on highways, you'll often see signs with lights telling you to tune into a certain AM frequency if the lights are flashing (e.g. landslide ahead).
- oatmeal1 3y agoThis article left me with two questions: Why can't FM be used to transmit emergency info? How many people in an emergency are even going to know to turn on AM radio?
- mtillman 3y agoI wasn’t aware of this law so it may or may not be a good law. One thing I noticed was the statement that it will be offered at “no extra cost” which is a bizarre thing to say. Can’t a manufacturer of a large thing with many components just slightly increase the cost of each part to cover the cost of the required thing? What fantasy land do people have to live in to think that something will be forced on a company and that company won’t somehow make up the gap somewhere else? It’s not like airbags or rear view cameras are magically free.
- jesboat 3y agoIt means no extra cost relative to the same car without an AM radio, I think.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- ellisd 3y agoThe last emergency AM broadcast I recall being relevant to my life in the United States was the 1994 Northridge Earthquake, pre-SMS. All the copper phone lines were overloaded from calls and this was the only medium to receive information. Our family sat in the minivan in the driveway and tuned to KFWB News 980 AM right as their station returned to air on backup generators. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KFWB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KFWB It no longer broadcasts news, but AM station KNX could/would effectively do the same.
- squarefoot 3y agoAM frequencies (medium and short waves) with the right propagation and time of the day condition travel well beyond the horizon, following the Earth curvature, without the need for repeaters in the middle. That's how people in non free countries can get news coming from abroad while all their local FM, TV, internet and cellphones are heavily censored. There are some good reasons to keep AM working.
- nfriedly 3y ago> Requiring the installation of analog AM radios in automobiles is an unnecessary action that would impact EV range, efficiency and affordability... I find that hard to believe. I understand that EV motors cause interference, but this seems like a solvable problem - and even if not, it could still work when the vehicle is parked.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pajko 3y agoAM transmitters and receivers are a lot easier to make from scratch than FM, and it covers longer distances (mainly due to the lower frequency band). So it's a better fit for emergency and end-of-the-world situations.
- Gualdrapo 3y agoMy father, who was a farmer, used to carry an AM/FM radio with when he was working. He vehemently forbid us to switch it to FM - batteries lasted longer on AM.
- nikau 3y agoSounds like an excuse he made up to stop you changing the radio station
- pooper 3y agoAdults lie or worse, they don't even know the truth themselves but they still need to be seen as knowing everything. I am an adult now and know better but my mom still tries to speak with authority, when I've known for decades at this point that being an adult doesn't automatically make you wise or even knowledgeable.
- zamadatix 3y agoIn disaster or end of world situations why do you want your emergency radio to be a car? Likely hard or hazardous to get to to get to, decent probability of not being functional in the situation, and wont have power for long otherwise. AM is great for emergencies so put a wind up in your emergency kit. If, for some reason, you need to take it to your car then go ahead. Want one at home and one in your car? Go nuts.
- shkkmo 3y agoConversely, a car is probably the single most important tool most people will own in an emergency situation. It provides a generator, radio and source of heat that can be more easily moved than any alternative. Sure, fuel usage becomes a problem, but a car provides more of a stop gap in emergencies than most alternatives. I say this as someone who generally dislikes cars and wishes our infrastructure was designed to make them less necessary. They are great in emergencies and decreased car ownership does mean having to make up the slack in emergency preparedness in other areas.
- superkuh 3y agoThis is an important law to pass. Not because of it's intended effects but because of the unintended. I strongly support it. Electrical vehicles' switching power supplies are terrible radiators of low frequency radio. As the articles say, this radio interference is why auto-makers were removing AM radio. If this regulation passes to law it will have the unintended effect of making auto makers not pollute the entire world's shared radio spectrum and prevent it's use by all. The FCC should have stepped in to bar production of many of these vehicles but I guess congress has it accidentally covered. We can only hope that other nations pass similar legislation. It is entirely possible to minimize and mitigate these conducted and radiated emissions. It will just mean hiring RF/Power EEs to know where to put the caps, how to run a controlled impedance line, etc.
- mlyle 3y ago> It is entirely possible to minimize and mitigate these conducted and radiated emissions. Reducing EMI down at medium wave from motor drives is really, really hard. Filter networks that keep most of the switching frequency out of the motor and motor wiring are big, cost money, and reduce efficiency.
- dylan604 3y agoso instead of making the silent electric cars make some sort of noise for pedestrians to hear, they should all just carry a device susceptible to the EMI an EV generates to allow for proximity awareness of a silent EV approaching. /s I know nothing about the technicalities of why this specific EMI is hard to eliminate, so I'm asking an honest question. Why? What makes it difficult to block this EMI? Where is it being generated (I'm assuming the motor windings??)? Is there not some sort of cage that can be built around the motors by lining the wheel wells to block the EMI?
- theatrus2 3y agoSimple: motor inverters are switching power in this frequency range. It’s already below FCC limits for unintended radiation - it’s not going to block AM activity far from the vehicle, but putting the antenna in the midst of all that radiated noise is challenging.
- itishappy 3y agoAM radio does still have one big thing going for it: It works when cell service doesn't, such as in the deep woods or during a cell service blackout. On the other hand, as I don't keep a radio in my house, I guess we're all expected to go turn on the radio in our cars if cell service drops? I'm not sure that'll be a response many people think of... I'm not sure that's an argument against an AM emergency broadcast system, but I'm also not sure if cars are really the place to mandate them. I wonder if there's regulations requiring government organizations (post offices, libraries, and/or police stations) to keep AM receivers on-hand?
- UncleEntity 3y ago> I guess we're all expected to go turn on the radio in our cars if cell service drops? That would be the first thing I would do if the power/cell service was out and the emergency sirens were going for a while. Not too sure I agree with a mandate to require a radio to be installed in every new vehicle as there are a few reasons I can imagine someone would order a car/truck without one. Maybe they intend to immediately replace the factory system with a full on custom block thumper or a company doesn't want their employees to get any funny ideas by listening to NPR or something.
- ghaff 3y agoI’m not sure I’d know how to listen to AM radio over the air. Don’t think my Honda has one. Don’t know about my stereo receiver. Think I have a many decades old transistor radio in th house somewhere because I ran across it a few years back.
- uxp100 3y agoIt is very likely both your Honda and your receiver tune in AM.
- al_borland 3y agoUsually you press some kind of source of band button they will toggle through your options. AM/FM, or AM/FM/XM/CD/AUX/CarPlay/etc. Once you’re on AM, it works just like FM from a user perspective. Just tune to the station you want, or hunt until you hear words or music instead of static.