5 ms·
Are young people smarter than adults? Research shows differences diminishing
- EGreg 3y agoWell, it couldn’t just go on forever at the same rate… People just have access to more and better information. But the education system still sucks, especially in many of the more underfunded public schools https://nypost.com/2014/01/12/no-space-no-books-no-leader-no-clue-at-citys-worst-elementary/ https://nypost.com/2014/01/12/no-space-no-books-no-leader-no... Because givem their resources they have mass classes and a lowest common denominator approach https://fensteroneducation.home.blog/2019/09/05/battling-teachings-lowest-common-denominator/ https://fensteroneducation.home.blog/2019/09/05/battling-tea... https://www.nytimes.com/1990/05/30/us/the-highly-gifted-child-hidden-and-often-ignored.html https://www.nytimes.com/1990/05/30/us/the-highly-gifted-chil... Whereas research shows a lot could be better: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_sigma_problem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_sigma_problem https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/04/18/a-better-way-to-teach-math/ https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/04/18/a-better-wa... And across the world in many places it’s even worse access to education I wrote about this back in 2014: https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=158 https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=158 I bought the domain https://teaching.app https://teaching.app and have been building a software solution to try to fix it for kids across the country. It requires multiple moving parts, but based on the above insights including by John Mightor and Bloom. That website goes into much more detail about what needs to be done. PS: gotta love the massive wave of silent downvotes. Why? Not enough substance? Not enough effort spent solving a problem or documenting it? Something you don’t like? Speak up! Ahh nevermind.
- hellerve 3y agoI think the downvotes are coming in because you are carrying out a fundamentally different argument. The article argues that people used to be more intellecutally capable when they were younger and it diminished with age. You are arguing that each generation used to be more intellectually capable than the one before, and that that is diminishing. I’m not trying to accuse you of anything, but it seems like you didn’t actually read the article you were commenting on. Is that possible?
- EGreg 3y agoYes, it is possible. This is a good criticism :) I somehow think the downvotes may be related to something else, though.
- seper8 3y agoYeah, the shameless self promotion without providing any value yourself.
- EGreg 3y agoOn the contrary. I provide a ton of value, for free, in the form of: Identifying the actual roots of the problems people post passionately about, and clearly explaining the underlying mechanisms that lead not just to this problem but many others they might not realize are related Researching for years the best ways to fix it, going out of my way to have substantive discussions with some of the top problem solvers across multiple fields, and publish the videos up publicly Spending over a decade on actually writing the open source software, hiring people, creating jobs, without asking anything from any of you And making it freely available as open source, with documentation, all without taking on VC funding or any of the actual profit-taking and extracting rents that goes on here with “software a service” In literally every way I can, I try to contribute value without taking in return. So you could not be more wrong, and if you’d click the links you’d see that. But you’d rather not even look, because in your capitalist mind, sharing the result of decades of work and over $1 million spent on free open source platforms for the world is “self-promotion”. You’d rather see another startup extract rents for a simple product built around tiny feature, funded by venture capitalists who want to have an exit by selling shares to the public, who will demand more rent extraction and wait for even further enshittification of platforms and society. It’s pretty amusing to me. I currently enjoy staying relatively almost completely unknown, and seeing the reaction people have to the most straightforward application of the above solutions to their own problems. Because I think that even on HN, many people are acting very irrationally and groupthink dominates, and while millions of people actually use my software, 99.99% have no idea who I am, and I get to see how human groups react to form instead of substance. This is btw why we often can’t have nice things, at least not unless the solutions, like bitter medicines, are presented wrapped in candy for organizations. We are a generation of children living on an ecological credit card, one of the most spoiled in history, but think we know better than everyone else. So I kind of enjoy seeing the irrationality as a form of entertainment although on a global ecological scale, it’s sadly quite scary.
- eru 3y agoYes, solving Bloom's 2 sigma problem would be huge. > But the education system still sucks, especially in many of the more underfunded public schools The problems depend on where you live. (And also whether schools are underfunded or not, and what that even means.) > PS: gotta love the massive wave of silent downvotes. Why? Not enough substance? Not enough effort spent solving a problem or documenting it? Something you don’t like? Speak up! Ahh nevermind. It's best to ignore those.
- sevagh 3y ago>PS: gotta love the massive wave of silent downvotes. Why? Thinly veiled sales pitch.
- EGreg 3y agoExcuse me but what is HN about if not sharing your work that you worked on? Oh, it's also about startups. And about funding them. And building stuff people want. I don't know man. Every time I put in a lot of work (a decade, say) and build something major and substantial to improve the world, and document it, linking to third party reputable sources for everything I'm claiming and saying, and give it away for free... if I share the link on HN, I often get downvoted. It's almost as if talking out of your ass and NOT doing anything to solve the problem, is far more appreciated. Like how people regularly complain about everything related to extreme centralization of control, surveillance capitalism, etc, and I built open source and free software give you an alternative, attracted millions of people in over 100 countries, and give it away for free to you here if you only look:: Web2: https://github.com/Qbix/Platform https://github.com/Qbix/Platform Web2 Documentation: https://community.qbix.com https://community.qbix.com Web3: https://github.com/Intercoin https://github.com/Intercoin Web3 Documentation: https://intercoin.org/applications https://intercoin.org/applications But it gets downvoted because "hey I saw the word web3!" or "hey you're selling me... um... something". This is the "TLDR" generation. Don't like it? Don't use it. Or use the part you like. But how about the 99% of the useful, substantive information which doesn't involve selling anything at all?
- fergonco 3y agoisn't online learning more a problem than a solution? A lot of research shows that we learn better on paper than on screens, that screens have a negative correlation on academic results, etc.
- abduhl 3y agoI downvoted you. Your whole post is a thinly veiled marketing post that is only tangentially related to the topic at hand, as others have noted. Beyond that, your tone is annoying and your additional posts only serve to justify my initial impression.
- EGreg 3y agoFair enough! At least I appreciate the explanation !
- wslh 3y agoWell, the article obviously based intelligence on IQ to be scientifically sound for a paper. First, it is obvious that, in the top, a young smart person will beat an older one in the kind of tests that IQ tests measure. You can see that in sports either, speed beyond strength is one obvious one. In average, young education could play a big role and better education in the old could beat a worse education. For example, an average observation, my father on his late 70s beats people in their 20s in doing mental math not because he is a genius because his generation had a better general education in math than the people at 20s. My dad is far from being a genius, he is not dumb either! but his average skills, as measured by IQ are obviously higher than the average young. Clearly my dad is now slower but also on language skills is fast enough to beat in associations an average young. Now, we are in 2024 and we need to reassess what IQ measures in terms of intelligence pragmatism. Also, the smart individual vs the smart group. For achieve success, even in the research laboratory you should forget about individual IQs and think differently. Another corollary for this is that psychology, at some extent, is time dependant and the trues from the 1900s could be falsenin 2024. It is not like math.
- TheRoque 3y agoIQ tests itself are age relative. The tests already take this into account, that's why your IQ is relative to people in the same age bracket. Basically, when you say "my IQ is 100", it's means that you are in the 50th percentile of the peers of the same age. It doesn't have any "absolue" value, and it shifts with the years (100 IQ 50 years ago is not the same as 100 IQ now)
- nineteen999 3y agoWould have thought the article would have included a discussion of "life experience" as a factor in intelligent decision making, but no, apparently not.
- lordfrito 3y agoExperience is what gets you ahead in life. Smarts help, but experience outweighs intelligence in the most important life decisions. Ask yourself, do you want a smart 25 year old running the White House? Or an experienced 50 year old?
- amelius 3y agoAt this point anyone younger than 60 would have my blessing :)
- throw__away7391 3y ago25? No. 35? Definitely. Somewhere around 60 should be the maximum age to run.
- dbsmith83 3y agoHow old are you? Usually this introduces a lot of bias in what your idea of a reasonable age is :)
- throw__away7391 3y agoA lot closer to 50 than 25.
- ghusto 3y agoMaybe somewhere around 60 is a good cut-off point, but 35 is still too young to have gathered necessary life experience to make you suitable.
- Ekaros 3y ago
- marvin 3y agoMaybe IQ fell with advanced age previously, due to cognitive damage caused by disease or other environmental factors. And this is less prevalent today.
- moi2388 3y agoNo, they usually compare scores of youngsters now with that of their parents cohort when they had the same age. This is called the Flynn effect. But it’s tapering off, probably because nutrition health and education can only improve so much (don’t think any of those have changes substantially since the 80s/90s), which would explain why you see this effect get smaller and smaller now. Your idea might also be correct, but I thought they were actually talking about the Flynn effect here. I might be wrong though
- kypro 3y agoI've experienced this so profound changes in my cognitive ability in my own life, but interestingly they don't seem to show up in IQ tests I've taken. My IQ today in my mid 30s is about the same as what it was when I was 16. However there's not doubt in my mind that I'm far less creative, far slower to reason and far slower to grasp concepts today than in my early 20s. In some ways I notice I'm smarter in the sense that these days I have more knowledge to fall back on so I wonder if this biases my IQ score a bit. For example, when I take IQ tests I often recognise patterns like the fibonacci sequence which I wouldn't have been familiar with in my teens. In many ways I'm a more capable human, but specifically for tasks requiring creativity and adaptability, I'm far less able than I was in the past. I'm an amateur musician and throughout my teens and early 20s I enjoyed writing music. I still do enjoy writing music but I've noticed in recent years I seem to lack the creativity to write anything I care for. I think this is partly that I have too much experience which biases my creativity and I fail to do anything interesting because I fall into familiar patterns. But even in areas where I have less experience I seem to struggle to be as creative as I once was. I guess the only way I can describe it is that it's like that intellectual rebelliousness I once had is not there anymore. Startups are also harder today because I find I'm slower to adapt to modern approaches and lack creativity in similar ways I do in music. It's depressing as hell. I wish I could extract my knowledge and have my stupid old creative brain back. At least then I could do interesting stuff. Sharing because I don't know if anyone here relates. I'm only in my 30s too so if this is the trend I'd hate to think how uncreative and boring I'll be as I get older.
- lordfrito 3y agoI wonder how much of this has to do with the way Search/Google have reprogrammed our brains in the way we generally approach and solve problems. Our internal models of the world are changing. Youth today are overconfident in their intelligence, because anything they want to know is on their smartphone, literally at their fingertips. Older people have biases as well, and can fall down rabbit holes like Q-anon etc. Perhaps the more computers think for us, the smaller the cognitive differences between us become.
- appplication 3y agoI think about this a lot. I’ve noticed I have a much worse memory than I used to and I have rationalized this as due to not needing to retain some bit of information, but rather retaining the patterns by which any information could be re-retrieved. The simplest example of this most are familiar with would be how much worse we are at directions/recalling street names since GPS became ubiquitous.
- lazide 3y agoWe typically remember what we need/use. When was the last time you needed to remember a street name to get somewhere?
- packetlost 3y ago> Perhaps the more computers think for us, the smaller the cognitive differences between us become. I think it's the opposite. The wealth of information on the internet is only as good as your ability to both understand and apply it, but also filter out irrelevant, misleading, and outright false content. The bell curve is still there, but it's probably moving to the right globally as nutrition and education get better. That being said, I'm very concerned with widespread manipulation via subtle propaganda. Ads are a (mostly) benign form of this, but I find it hard to believe governments aren't at least attempting it.
- lordfrito 3y agoI suggest subtle propaganda has already taken over the internet.. I noticed a tonal shift around 2010 or so, something felt off... the old internet died at that point. It's never felt right since, and I take everything... everything I read with a grain of salt.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]