5 ms·
Mars had 3/4 billion more years to develop, compared with the Earth. Mars formed first, and cooled first due to its smaller size. One of the outstanding proble
by adastra22 3y ago
Mars had 3/4 billion more years to develop, compared with the Earth. Mars formed first, and cooled first due to its smaller size.
One of the outstanding problems in astrobiology I mention is that the Earth was inhospitable until 3.8Gya, and the oldest fossils of presumably DNA based life (since it matches existing life we can study) was 3.7Gya. Mars was hospitable ~4.5Gya. So either life emerged IMMEDIATELY on Earth and did a complexity speed run before slowing down and remaining stagnant for the next billion years or so, or it emerged on Mars first and Earth was seeded once it was cool enough.
- jerpint 3y agoHow does earth get seeded?
- adastra22 3y agoLook up ALH-84001. The debate about whether the structures inside this Martian meteorite are fossils is too long for a HN post. But in analyzing the rock it was shown that the during the entire trip from when it was blasted out of Mars to when it fell in Antarctica would have been survivable for rock boring microbes. Not just theoretically, but hard evidence. There are structures that would have been destroyed if the rock was heated enough to sterilize, but they survived the trip. Hundreds of tons of rock like this from Mars land every year.
- Qem 3y agoRelated talk: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ekJQUS7WP78&t=57s&pp=ygUPS2lyc2NodmluayB0YWxr https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ekJQUS7WP78&t=57s&pp=ygUPS2lyc...
- iamthirsty 3y ago> Hundreds of tons of rock like this from Mars land every year. 277 total Martian meteorites — with the largest weighing 14.5 kg — is not hundreds of tons yearly.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat's how many have been conclusively classified as Martian out of "the 72,000 meteorites [total] that have been classified". (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_meteorite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_meteorite) That's obviously not the actual total that have ever made it here. https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/meteors-meteorites/facts/ https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/meteors-meteorites/fac... > Scientists estimate that about 48.5 tons (44,000 kilograms) of meteoritic material falls on Earth each day. That has been going on for billions of years. If the 277/72,000 proportion holds that's a lot of material.
- iamthirsty 3y agoWhile I recognize your logic, and even mostly agree, the point still stands that it cannot be conclusively and definitively said (as least as far as we've been alive/can tell) that hundreds of tons of Martian meteorites fall to Earth every year. Or even tons at all. Tons of meteorites in general, sure — but not from Mars.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt is likely given these numbers at least some tons of Martian rock land here annually, which makes the seeding of life concept feasible. I'm on board with "not hundreds of tons", but it's a lot closer estimate than 277 ever. (48.5 * 365) * (277 / 72,000) = 68 tons per year as an extremely speculative estimate here, ignoring entirely probable variances in what hits us (much of which is sand-grain sized) versus what we identify... and again, any estimate here we have to multiply by a few billion years.
- acchow 3y ago> Scientists estimate that about 48.5 tons (44,000 kilograms) of meteoritic material falls on Earth each day. Most of it gets destroyed on entry, right? No organic matter surviving?
- adastra22 3y ago
- ethbr1 3y agoIf there were extra-terrestrial intervention, it would only have needed to be a one-time event. And it wouldn't be technologically hard to do it such that no trace remains over those timescales. So, yes, that's "crazy". On the other hand, it's unfalsifiable in the absence of other theories.
- adastra22 3y agoThere are much saner theories for panspermia.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoLike? You're coming across as very dismissive for no reason.
- dotnet00 3y agoThere are meteorites on Earth which very likely originated from Mars. They're believed to have been launched into space by an impact, eventually finding their way onto Earth. If we're looking for the most realistic options for panspermia to have occurred, they'd be due to a natural event of this sort.
- throwaway173738 3y agoIt’s very much like how islands in the sea are colonized by life. Some event causes a blob of living creatures to enter the sea on a raft and they drift until they make landfall somewhere else. Sometimes they survive long enough in the new place to reproduce.
- berniedurfee 3y agoRats leaping from a sinking ship swimming to shore we were.
- ethbr1 3y ago
- dyauspitr 3y agoVolcanic eruptions throwing rocks into space. A large impact throwing a huge number of rocks into space.
- marcosdumay 3y agoYour numbers give Mars an extra ~800 million years. Nothing even close to 3/4 billion. Besides, deciding what was inhospitable for early life is an exercise of noisy assumptions. I'd bet the error margin is larger than that difference.
- Shatnerz 3y ago3/4 billion = 750 million, no?
- caseyy 3y agoLong billion vs short billion?
- williamcotton 3y agoDidn’t the “long billion”, aka a trillion, stop being used sometime in the early 20th century on British English, if not earlier?
- b800h 3y agoSome of our books in UK school in the 1980s listed 10^12 as a billion. That doesn't mean it wasn't officially changed in the early C20th though.
- Teever 3y ago????????? 800 million is greater than 3/4 billion?
- xattt 3y agoAt this point, given how much Mars had been roved, why hasn’t some fossil record been discovered yet? At the very least, I would expect something akin to chalk left behind by proto-diatoms that had calcium carbonate skeletons.
- adastra22 3y agoHow would we know? It’s not like like we have a geologist over there with a rock hammer breaking open rocks to look for fossils.
- psunavy03 3y agoYet.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI think it’s actually pretty darn stupid that we aren’t running one way missions.
- seoulmetro 3y agoFeels like a conspiracy when you run into these super simple, realistic use cases of generic but progressive ideas. Things kids can think up, that we can most certainly do that would put us insanely ahead but ... we just don't? Like, why do we visit the moon but not have people stay there at all? Why are there no structures there? Why do we ignore the Earth's mysteries a lot and go directly to Mars?
- Razengan 3y agoI, and I bet other people bored on Earth with nothing to look forward to, would gladly sign up for a one-way trip to Mars.
- andrewflnr 3y agoThe people who would be valuable in that role, namely highly trained scientists, mostly aren't interested in what's effectively a suicide mission. They have better options and things they're tied down to on Earth.
- jl6 3y ago> Earth was inhospitable until 3.8Gya There is much uncertainty about this. The early Earth was a volatile place with a lot of raw materials and energy available, and a lot of chemistry happening. I wouldn't rule out that some part of Earth may have had the right conditions for life right from the beginning. Certainly if we expect life to be able to survive a ride on a piece of ejecta from Mars, it's plausible to imagine it surviving in some boundary niche amidst the heat and fury of the Hadean Earth.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> wouldn't rule out that some part of Earth may have had the right conditions for life right from the beginning Even if it was, it wouldn't have survived the impact that created the Moon.
- jl6 3y agoBear in mind that hypothesized impact is estimated to have occurred around the 4.5Gya mark. That’s still a lot further back than 3.8Gya. And I still wouldn’t categorically rule out microscopic life/life-precursors surviving the event somehow.
- Kerbonut 3y agoWhat if Mars collided with Earth and that's what killed Mars and transferred life to Earth and also made the moon?
- adastra22 3y agoGeological evidence shows that the earth’s crust was molten until 3.8Gya. This corresponds with the ending of the late heavy bombardment on the moon, which Apollo samples dated. It’s hard to imagine life persisting in or around a magma ocean.
- bmitc 3y agoI think generally speaking people refer to life arriving and then staying as the start of life on Earth. You're probably right that it could have been and likely was spontaneously popping up and then disappearing on Earth prior to the pretty massive window as when we believe life to have "began" on Earth.
- paxys 3y agoThat still doesn't answer the question. How did life start on Mars?
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThat's a different question though, and you're right that this wouldn't be answered in the scope of this discussion.
- Intralexical 3y agoThe longer time period would be partially offset by Mars having over three times lower surface area than Earth, though.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoComplexity speed run to stagnation isn’t suspect at all, thats exactly what you’d expect when there is suddenly a new environment to exploit for life. Mutations are always happening. At some point a subpopulation will emerge that has a lucky few mutations that grant it an edge relative to others in fitness, then it will dominate the environment until the factors that confer success either change, or these mutants fall short of a more fit upstart mutant population. Its something you see play out even today, when an invasive species is introduced to a new environment where its traits serve it well, and quickly outcompetes native species. Its also why we better be damn sure the mars sample return is absolutely sterile lest we contaminate our planet with extraterrestrial microbes.
- kerhackernews 3y agoCouldn't it just be that simple life isn't rare as long as the conditions exist for it to form. It took a very very very long time for even oxygen producing life to form after that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]