6 ms·
Two giants in the satellite telecom industry join forces to counter Starlink
- Syaiful8 3y ago[flagged]
- robertlagrant 3y agoI know this is a downvote-worthy comment, but I have to say I feel like people who don't like Elon Musk think the alternative is someone just like him but with all his flaws removed. The overwhelming alternative is people who never make anything advance and talk like this: > In a fast-moving and competitive satellite communication industry, this transaction expands our multi-orbit space network, spectrum portfolio, ground infrastructure around the world, go-to-market capabilities, managed service solutions, and financial profile
- amarant 3y agoI think a large part of the problem is that a lot of people seem to have trouble consolidating that someone can have both positive and negative qualities at the same time.
- admissionsguy 3y agoPeople are disconcerted by the fact that Musk is just a human like them who happens to wield huge resources. They prefer to think of the elite class as their betters, a separate category, hence the convention for the “ruling class” to have decorum, present curated image, and so on.
- hobs 3y agoHe doesn't meet the standards of behavior of any class that I would associate with.
- throwitaway222 3y agoIt is unfortunate that the left doesn't want to talk to anyone any more. However, IRL I bet you would be bowing and shaking his hand if you had the op.
- hobs 3y agoHilarious comment, I would be glad to reach my hand out so I can squeeze his baby flesh.
- martijnarts 3y agoWhile I think that's at play, I also think it's entirely fair to hold those with more power to higher standards.
- HPsquared 3y agoStandards are set by those with power. A bit of a tautology.
- amarant 3y agoIt is entirely fair to do so. And I'm not a huge fan of a lot of things Elon has written on Twitter. I don't really care about him buying it too much, but that's at least partially because I don't use it and never did. Anyway, what really gets me is people denying that Elon has some real chops when it comes to engineering and business management. A lot of people even take it one step further and pretend like Tesla isn't a capable EV producer, because Elon once wrote something on twitter that upset them. The problem there isn't that they're upset with Elon, that's totally fine, he frequently earns that. But being unable to recognize that he had also done some good work that is completely unrelated to those silly remarks on twitter, that is the problem. This phenomenon should not be confused with criticizing actual flaws in any work Elon has done, which is of course great, but that's very often not what's happening in "discussions" about his companies.
- anonymousab 3y ago> think the alternative is someone just like him but with all his flaws removed Or just some other person, successful or not. It's far from a dichotomy. There are plenty of successful companies and CEOs out there.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago"In a fast-moving and competitive satellite communication industry, we, who cannot move nearly as fast and are therefore no longer competitive, hope that this will somehow make us look like we're still relevant." OK, that's a very cynical take. But Starlink is revolutionizing the business, and historically, merging is what the dinosaur companies often do after the revolution hits. Think of the mergers between Unix workstation vendors as the PC was revolutionizing computing. Merging lets you get bigger. But in a revolutionary environment, faster wins, bigger doesn't. Merging is therefore a useless response. (In fact, it's worse than useless, because it slows you down.)
- jandrese 3y agoI view these mergers as the executives cashing out of their failing company.
- abakker 3y agoYes, now they both get to begin an 18 month "Synergy Period" where both companies focus on navel-gazing to instead of the clients who are cancelling contracts and buying starlink.
- vladms 3y agoRevolutions are much easier to spot afterwards. Maybe Starlink will be a revolution, but maybe more and more people will get better wired access (so new subscriptions will slow). I don't think it's that evident now how it will go overall. What alternative would you propose to merging? If the market re-stabilizes in a different position merging could be successful. If a revolution happens, it will probably not, but still better than doing nothing.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> What alternative would you propose to merging? I don't know. > but still better than doing nothing. Maybe not. Maybe it takes away management attention from figuring out how to actually be competitive in the new environment. "We have to do something; this is something; therefore we have to do this" is rarely the right thing to do. It's often just a mask for "we don't know what to do". On the other hand, "we can't figure out what to do, but we're dead if we don't do something, so we're going to do something and hope that it randomly turns out to be useful" may have a higher expectation value than doing nothing.
- Retric 3y agoWith Tesla the comparison wasn’t nobody it was the original founders continuing to operate the company. Which may have been less successful, but the first Roadster was delivered in February 2008 while he became CEO in 2008. So the EV revolution would have almost certainly started with or without him. SpaceX was a high risk venture that paid off, props.
- runako 3y ago> with all his flaws removed Most CEOs do not spend $44 billion USD to broadcast their most abhorrent thoughts to the world. Everyone is flawed, but nobody likes a loud boor.
- MangoCoffee 3y agoits his money.
- runako 3y agoSome of it is his money. Some was borrowed.
- cryptonector 3y agoThe lenders knew what he meant to do.
- runako 3y agoLiterally just responding to this: > its his money.
- cryptonector 3y agoBut that some of the money is borrowed can't mean that he can't say the things he does, especially when the lenders knew who he was to begin with.
- runako 3y agoI am not saying he can't say whatever he wants. My initial response was to the notion that any other person as CEO of SpaceX (or Tesla) would also be flawed. Which, obviously. But it is simply not the case that most CEOs are as loud about broadcasting their whims to the world. Tesla is 12th largest public company by market cap, between Broadcom and Novo Nordisk. Those companies have CEOs, but those CEOs do not habitually make controversial statements on Internet fora. It is possible for a person to be flawed, but not to spend effort ensuring wide distribution of those flaws.
- deweller 3y agoSES and Intelsat both strike me as stodgy, old telecommunications companies. I would be surprised if they can find a way to rival Starlink as a consumer product. But I think competition in this space is good.
- TheRoque 3y agoNice pun
- imglorp 3y agoFor some use cases they're not even competitors. You can't do anything real time like a conference call, remote desktop, or gaming with GEO: 600ms latency is out of the question. MEO is marginal at 150ms.
- indigobunting 3y agoAt least on an airplane, they don't want you doing conference calls ..
- Denvercoder9 3y agoPeople in economy seats aren't the only demand for low-latency airplane internet. Probably not even the biggest.
- indigobunting 3y agoIn the U.S., it's banned for all classes (business, first, etc..) https://www.afacwa.org/nocalls https://www.afacwa.org/nocalls
- lxgr 3y agoThat's not the only way to fly, though. Business aviation (i.e. "private jets") has exactly the type of customer for whom being able to make phone calls in-air is a thing where cost is secondary. Gogo even pivoted to that market entirely [1], with the commercial segment now part of Intelsat. [1] https://www.gogoair.com/ https://www.gogoair.com/
- apercu 3y agoSurprised me that that an article about LEO satellites offering commercial services doesn't include Iridium (which may still even have two networks, the original Motorola satellites and the (Thales) NEXT satellites (that were launched by Spacex, starting in something like 2017, if they haven't run out of fuel by now). Maybe 60-70 satellites is too small to qualify?
- jpm_sd 3y agoStarlink is offering 100x-1000x higher bit rates, depending on which Iridium service we're talking about. It's not really a direct competition.
- lxgr 3y agoThe original Iridium fleet was deorbited once the NEXT one became operational. And Iridium is in a very different market segment than OneWeb, Starlink (currently anyway), O3B etc. – they're in the L-band, which allows handheld terminals or very small (i.e. low drag), non-steered/beamformed (i.e. cheap) vehicle antennas, but also severely limits bandwidth. Starlink might shake up that space a bit with their direct-to-cell plans, but they don't have the global spectrum, nor the international landing rights or safety-of-life certifications required to be a viable competitor to somebody like Iridium or even Inmarsat in that space.
- admissionsguy 3y ago> giants in the satellite telecom industry join forces to counter Starlink Sounds promising.. > The acquisition will create a combined company boasting a fleet of some 100 multi-ton satellites in geostationary orbit, a ring of spacecraft located more than 22,000 miles (nearly 36,000 kilometers) over the equator. This will be more than twice the size of the fleet of the next-largest commercial geostationary satellite operator. Huh? > SES, based in Luxembourg Right, the European technological thought From Investopedia: > A mature industry may be at its peak or just past it but not yet in the decline phase. While earnings may be stable, growth prospects are few and far between as the remaining companies consolidate market share and create barriers for new competitors to enter the sphere All good but it has nothing to do with Starlink.
- jjkaczor 3y ago> giants in the satellite telecom industry join forces to counter Starlink >> Sounds promising.. This is hilarious to me - because the incumbent players in the satellite networking business were slow, anti-competitive dinosaurs. They were the ones who needed to be "countered" with something that was/is; - cost-effective - low-latency - high-bandwidth They had decades of essentially monopolistic ownership of this "space" and failed to innovate. For as much as I dislike a certain billionaire - SpaceX is doing what all the other incumbent players did not - and honestly that sounds far more promising than dinosaurs merging with each other.
- lxgr 3y agoApples and oranges comparison. Intelsat and SES are mostly GEO players, and that market is extremely competitive. It's just not great for many interactive use cases due to its latency. (SES does own O3B, which is MEO, but it seems to be somewhat of a niche player.) LEO constellations used to be prohibitively expensive until SpaceX brought the cost per launch down massively.
- pdimitar 3y agoPesky free market working as intended! How dare it! But on topic, I remain cautiously optimistic even though I don't seriously think they will pull it off. I mean they technically likely can but are very likely to ask nasty prices.
- drlemonpepper 3y agoIs Starlink going to suffer the same fate as Tesla and X? Willy-nilly org thrashing and "removing 10% of features"? Is there a better alternative to "the one to beat" spending unsustainably, only to fail once all competitors are too far behind to stay viable?
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> same fate as Tesla You mean it’s obliterating traditional western competitors but facing stiff competition from China?
- neogodless 3y agoDefine "obliterating"? While the Model Y is doing great (global top seller, #5 in U.S. for 2023) it's just one model. If you look at the U.S. total auto sales in 2023, Tesla accounted for 7% of the Top 25 best selling models, while the five brands that did better accounted for a combined 67% (and those brands include Ford, Chevrolet and Ram.) Tesla's bet is that just a few models with minimal changes over time (outside of software) will be enough to "obliterate" the existing car sales model of making a wide enough variety of vehicle models for everyone's tastes, and keeping those models fresh and new to keep sales going. Time will tell, but it would be surprising for the Western companies to be obliterated, when their top sellers are still pickup trucks (750K F-series sold in 2023), and there's no competition from Tesla (unless you count the 4000 Cybertrucks.)
- rifty 3y agoYou could say it’s the living results of that fate already. Here’s an HN discussion about firing the leads of Starlink[1] early in development (2018). And another in the following year laying off 10% of the workforce[2] (2019). 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18349991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18349991 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18888641 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18888641
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI think we've seen this before. There was a time when we saw headlines like this but speaking of Netflix. Now Netflix is shit, there are dozens of overpriced streaming alternatives and the promise of something different and better has been forgotten entirely.
- lxgr 3y agoI don't think that's a valid comparison: VOD streaming services have exclusive content deals, making subscriptions extremely non-fungible. (You can't watch "Stranger Things" on Max or "Succession" on Netflix, not even on the gold-plated-platinum plan.) On the other hand, Internet connectivity (net neutrality violations nonwithstanding) is extremely fungible, and satellites have the advantage of not requiring complex terrestrial infrastructure, unlike e.g. cable or cell operators. The only thing tying you to a given constellation or satellite ISP is possibly your antenna and/or terminal, and looking at the aviation space, we're already seeing some interoperable solutions giving airlines interoperability between vendors.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> I don't think that's a valid comparison: Netflix not only had technology no one else had (at that time), but an innovative business model that hinted that it might provide something to its customers that no one else had ever offered to anyone outside of science fiction: the world's entire video library, on demand. Instead though, we get the equivalent of a thousand channels of cable tv, all paid for individually, all overpriced, all artificially restricted. You get that right, Netflix takes shows off its catalog because the contracts ran out, but when CBS+ or whatever it's called now takes shows off its roster, they're just doing it to be assholes. Compare this to Starlink's promise. Tens of thousands of low orbit satellites, providing cheap, low latency, high speed data anywhere on Earth. Tom Hanks wakes up on the uninhabited sandbar in the middle of the Pacific, takes his cellphone out of the ziplock plastic bag, calls his girlfriend and tells her "get me the fuck out of here". The End. They might yet hold onto it, you can hardly do even a half-assed Starliink without SpaceX's launch capability. But what we might have in 10 years scares me. Incomplete constellations because they're squabbling over orbital slots, monopolies and carve-outs through politics, Verizon refusing to let the iPhones it sells to customers access Starlink, instead locking it to Bezos' own Blue Dildo satellite network. It's just not the sort of competition people envision, I think, when they're imagining how competition lowers prices and raises quality. It's just big corporations sabotaging their rivals (and the rivals' customers) through meddling and politics.
- dataengineer56 3y agoIt's worth saying that Ars Technica has an extremely anti-Musk viewpoint and often publishes articles targeted against him and his companies. As others have pointed out, these two companies merging is unlikely to rival Starlink and the article may be mostly wishful thinking.
- panick21_ 3y agoNot really in Space. Eric Berger is very pro Space, so much so that he is very often accused of being a SpaceX fanboy and other things. He has written a book about SpaceX and has good relationship with SpaceX and Musk. He is the Senior Editor for Space.
- lxgr 3y agoThey're absolutely competing with Starlink. SES operates, among many other satellites, the O3B fleet, a MEO constellation providing high-throughput, low (compared to GEO) latency data connections for marine, aviation, and defense users. Intelsat has a partnership with OneWeb (itself owned by Eutelsat), a direct Starlink competitor in LEO. Intelsat also runs most of what used to be Gogo inflight (the satellite part of it anyway) for several US and international airlines. Just looking at the commercial aviation market (i.e. in-flight Wi-Fi), between their deployed GEO, MEO, and LEO solutions, they serve a significant fraction of the market today.
- adolph 3y agoOneWeb is at 634 satellites as of 2023 and hasn't had a launch since. Starlink has 10x that number. They may be competing but that isn't competitive. Before I looked just now I thought they had more in flight. https://oneweb.net/resources/launch-programme https://oneweb.net/resources/launch-programme https://spaceflightnow.com/?s=oneweb https://spaceflightnow.com/?s=oneweb
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThey are also Starlink partners though.
- wil421 3y ago
- reddog 3y agoTwo giants of the buggy whip industry join forces to counter the railroads.
- blackhaz 3y agoThat's exactly what is happening.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, just like in your example, both alternatives aren't exactly equivalent and have different benefits.
- sealthedeal 3y agoNot to be to conspiracy theory, but I just don't trust these types of companies with supplying satellite internet to the world. Something about Musks Free Speech, anti big gov, while at the same time effectively being one of the largest government contractors makes me trust him. And as im writing this im realizing how much I now don't trust him or anyone anymore lolol...
- ogtms 3y agoThe merger is to get rid of the lawsuit from Intelsat regarding the 5G frequency clearing in which SES got scammed by Intelsat last minute. next gen o3b m-power satellites are already broken and delayed: https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/ses-o3b-mpower-satellites-will-have-a-significantly-shorter-life-after-power-issues/ https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/ses-o3b-mpower-sa... 99% of SES Profits come from their legacy Video (satellite tv) business
- PaywallBuster 3y agojoin forces to counter Starlink = more like: M&A leftover the space industry players Doesn't look like they could counter starlink in anyway anytime soon
- rapsey 3y agoThese companies just circling the drain.
- Dig1t 3y agoThese companies are not offering a competitor to Starlink and it doesn't sound like they plan to.. MEO has latency that is 3X higher than LEO, these are not going to be useful for the same things. I read this article the opposite way, it seems this is just a big merger in the industry which will mean less competition. Also mentioned in the article: >Viasat [...] last year purchased Inmarsat I didn't know this happened, but that's another example of a big merger reducing competition. This article seems like some positive spin on an event that would otherwise be construed as bad for customers and the industry as a whole.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoThis is just two companies going for a monopoly that would otherwise have been investigated. Now they can point at Starlink and say “look, competition!” While they fuck their customers.
- mjlee 3y agoThey're not the only ones, Amazon is working on Project Kuiper. "Project Kuiper is an initiative to increase global broadband access through a constellation of 3,236 satellites in low Earth orbit (LEO). Its mission is to bring fast, affordable broadband to unserved and underserved communities around the world." https://www.aboutamazon.com/what-we-do/devices-services/project-kuiper https://www.aboutamazon.com/what-we-do/devices-services/proj...