7 ms·
Liu Cixin's War of the Worlds (2019)
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://archive.ph/RRBLj https://archive.ph/RRBLj
- alex_suzuki 3y ago(2019)
- metabagel 3y agoSpoilers, LOL
- tb1989 3y ago[flagged]
- ein0p 3y ago[flagged]
- donatzsky 3y agoThe simpler, and much more likely, explanation is that those countries don't want to upset China, since doing so tends to be bad for trade. Just ask Latvia (I think it was) what happens if you make it a point to recognise Taiwan.
- ein0p 3y agoI don’t see how it is more likely given that the US has spent several trillion dollars on wars against countries which posed no threat to it, the consent for which was entirely manufactured by mass media. I think it’s more likely that this is a psyop.
- card_zero 3y agoUyghurs are Turkic, and Turkey makes only mildly disapproving comments on the situation because China is anti-american, and having solidarity with that is perhaps more important than having solidarity with Uyghurs. Meanwhile, China being douchebags to Uyghurs may indeed be exploited by America as an opportunity to say "look China are douchebags", sure, why not.
- ein0p 3y agoIt’s just weird how the country which currently officially spends tens of billions of dollars on genociding Muslims in Palestine also has the balls to run such psyops of dubious veracity against anyone else.
- bsnnkv 3y ago> I just feel that it is very tragic if a person cannot choose his own nationality and destiny. The really miserable people, such as North Koreans and many Chinese, if you are willing to help them, you should say no to the visa system and let the national borders cease to exist. I think you would enjoy reading the Terra Ignota series[1]. [1]: https://www.adapalmer.com/series/terra-ignota/ https://www.adapalmer.com/series/terra-ignota/
- m3kw9 3y agoIf you can’t separate the books world and the person, then you are just gonna make everything hard to be enjoyed. Every person has issues either you know it or not, say your favourite writer, you just haven’t found out a secret that pisses you off about them yet.
- fransje26 3y ago> To overuse the word "concentration camp" is to disrespect the tragic dead of World War II. What? No. Not at all. The exploitation and killing of prisoners in concentration camps predates WW2, and the use of "concentration camps" to describe those camps is fully appropriate. From the killing of the Boers by the British, to the genocide of Armenians by the Turks, to the killing of undesired by the Germans, to the forced internment, "re-education" and sterilization of Uyghurs by the Chinese.
- tb1989 3y agoyou are right. But what I mean is that there is no need to make exaggerated reports, but it should be discussed from the perspective of the Chinese government's serious violations of laws and human rights, even if the Chinese government will argue that "this is my internal affairs." Exaggerated reporting is a barbaric and dishonest act that does nothing to solve the problem and prevents the public from understanding the true context of the matter.
- fransje26 3y agoThere are no real receivable counter-arguments to the fact that forced-sterilization of a population group fully qualifies as "genocide", and, as such, warrants to be widely and thoroughly reported, with all the gravity an alarm necessary for such a serious matter. We can go even further by adding that in such blatant violations of human rights, requiring a "balanced" reporting considering "the other side's" views is not much more than an attempt at diluting the seriousness of the situation to distract away from the facts. But then again, in the light of current conflicts in some parts of the world, it seems to be a favored approach.
- gamepsys 3y ago> Because his writing style is so poor and very wordy, there are almost no golden sentences Did you read it in Chinese? I have only read English translations of his work, and I assumed the style issues were more related to the translation than anything else.
- tb1989 3y agoYes. In fact, Liu's Chinese writing level is far lower than the average Chinese writer. In the original Chinese version, there are actually many words that are offensive to female (this is understandable considering his Chinese background and age). But as far as I know, these are optimized in translation. So his imagination is better amplified.
- schwartzworld 3y agoUnlikely, since the translator is an author in his own right, and his work does not suffer from this problem.
- silenced_trope 3y ago> His political leanings are clear. Of course, when asked about Xinjiang, his reply can hardly be used as a criterion for whether he has been brainwashed. If he publicly said this in China in the way that Westerners think he has been "brainwashed", he would have been arrested. lol this is always one of my pet peeves with Western "journalists". "Hey I've got this celebrity/author/whomever from China here, let me try to have a Barbara Walters moment and ask them a profound question about something-controversial-in-China that will get them or their family killed!" I'm not sure what the solution is, but I'm convinced it's just journalists patting themselves on teh back.
- janalsncm 3y agoI mean even coming from a democracy I don’t feel responsible for domestic or foreign American policy. It’s not even really a gotcha question. I don’t run the country.
- jnovek 3y agoI just finished Deaths End this morning so I'm experiencing that ponderous glow that you get after reading something thought provoking. Without going into spoilers, Death's End makes everything so... huge. It really made me feel tiny in our universe. These are good books with some flaws. You should read them.
- mvdtnz 3y agoI absolutely loved the whole series. I have never been as disappointed at a screen adaptation as I was at the netflix show. I couldn't get past episode 2. Terrible.
- perihelions 3y agoYou haven't watched many Netflix adaptations! If the sensation of being banished from 10-dimensional cosmological heavens down into dead 3-dimensional purgatories could be meaningfully be experienced by humans, that ineffable tragedy, it would be the sensation of being forced to watch the Netflix flattening of a book you once dearly enjoyed.
- jitl 3y agoHuh, what were your complaints? I thought they did a pretty decent job - although I finished Death’s End in 2019 so it’s been a while. They preserved the most important parts in my mind, and otherwise the compromises seemed acceptable. I had low expectations and was pleasantly surprised.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago(2019) Discussion then: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20202063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20202063
- TheGRS 3y agoThe books are very imaginative. Not always a fan of the prose, and the character development is lacking, but I think this is a great new take on the alien invasion genre that tries to put all of the current theories about extraterrestrials (or lack-thereof) into a very big plot. Part of the draw of the first book is how much it talks about communist China from an insider perspective. I found those parts the most interesting by far, with some of the more interesting sci-fi ideas emerging toward the end. The next 2 books basically go down a speculative fiction path with the first book's ideas set in motion. I always felt like the books were a fan fiction of certain blog posts I've read about the Fermi Paradox or the Great Filter. Any self-respecting sci-fi nerd needs to read them, and all 3 of the books. They probably won't wow you in the same way other award-winning authors have, but they should be thought-provoking.
- binarymax 3y agoThose aspects about communist China made it hard for me to get into. I read about 15 pages and gave up. Maybe it was also the writing style, or maybe it’s been too long since I’ve read a novel and it’s my fault for not having the patience. I think I need to give it another try.
- luyu_wu 3y agoI'm happy most of the comment section is discussing Liu Cixin's works instead of this article, but having made the mistake of reading said article I have a bit of a rant. This journalist seems so intent on making everything political (from the beginning to the end of the article) that it reads like they have no interest in anything he's actually written. The author of this article never describes a single genuine question about his works that it honestly makes me a bit sick. So many quotes are taken so wildly out of context that they contain a few words placed awkwardly in the author's wall of text and opinion instead of representing genuine conversation. One of my favorite parts: "Liu’s posture slackened slightly as we ate. The drinks had warmed him, and the heat of Sichuanese peppercorns seemed to stir him from his usual reticence. I decided to inch the conversation toward politics, a topic he prefers to avoid." The author reads as genuinely manipulative, and it was clear Cixin already stated he wasn't interested in discussing politics in the authors previous attempts... Maybe have some decency and respect?
- TheGRS 3y agoYea I can see this in the article as well. And anyone who has read the books can probably see this wasn't the authors real interest. I can see where someone with their pulse on international politics might read into Trisolaris vs Earth being some sort of a proxy for China vs USA. But my take is that the author was just writing about sci-fi ideas from their personal perspective in China. Chinese history, politics, and culture plays into how the plot unfolds. But it didn't feel to me like they're trying to say much about the international politics of the situation. Instead the plot marches ahead into speculative fiction steeped in some current-day theories about the universe. There's certainly a lot of dabbling in human emotions and conditions vs aliens who don't share those same ideals. But like "how does the USA respond vs China" is like an afterthought of the book, can't remember if that even really came up.
- luyu_wu 3y agoYeah, I would agree. I think the author was trying to force a narrative too much (they were trying to compare Trisolarians coming to WHAT exactly?). To the counterpoint as well, I think much of 3-Body it was actual a motivational tale that humanity would set aside its differences and come together in times of crisis.
- poochkoishi728 3y agoThis needs a spoiler alert. The article unexpectedly gives away how humanity deals with the aliens in the second paragraph, revealing details you wouldn't know yet having only watched the Netflix show. Unfortunately I guess I took one for the team..
- simonblack 3y agoA country should never take on another country who has more men of military age and which has far more manufacturing capacity. That way lies destruction. Just like Japan, while starting off WW2 with a more powerful military, couldn't maintain it's ascendancy over the US with its bigger industrial might and bigger population as the War in the Pacific progressed from 1942-1945, I fear that the US will not be able to maintain its power against a China that's four times bigger in population and maybe 10 times bigger in manufacturing capacity when War in the Pacific 2.0 begins in a couple of years.
- psadri 3y agoSo what’s your plan?
- simonblack 3y agoI don't have a plan. I'll just have to take each day as it comes, though I am expecting lots of bad stuff to happen. Because I'm old enough to have outlived a lot of my peers, I can accept that I won't be a survivor without too much angst, but I certainly won't be happy about it.
- xandrius 3y agoIf you think it's going to be US vs China, you're going to be absolutely wrong. If it remains a cold war then it's about friction and who can last longer but if it becomes active, the world will split into 3 factions as WWII and the numbers will shift.
- simonblack 3y agothe world will split into 3 factions One of those factions will be the West. Unfortunately for the West, the West is too small to be a major player and will be a big loser in WW3. Modern warfare is just arithmetic, and the West just doesn't have the numbers that stack up. The whole of the West is smaller than just China by itself. Also China has far more manufacturing capacity than the whole of the West combined. The West is going to get its ass kicked big time. If you put Russia and China together, you get something that has the huge raw material and energy resources of Russia plus the advanced technology of Russia plus the huge manufacturing capacity of China plus almost a quarter of the world's total population. A very hard combination to overcome.