5 ms·
Brown economists: Ancestral history explains roots of income inequality
- ars 18y agoInteresting results, wrong conclusions. Plus they didn't separate cause and effect. "He demonstrated tht [sic] the number of years since a society made the transition from hunting and gathering to agriculture is highly correlated to the level of income in the country today. That is, the earlier the agriculture development, the higher the income." Or exactly the other way around - the better the person is at producing, the earlier they managed to switch to agriculture. Or in less politically correct terms, the smarter the people, the more they make today, and the earlier they managed to figure out agriculture. "Second, the influence of population origins suggests that there is something that human families and communities transmit from generation to generation — perhaps a form of economic culture, a set of attitudes or beliefs, or informally transmitted capabilities — that is of at least similar importance to economic success as are more widely recognized factors like quantities of physical capital and even human capital in the narrower sense of formal schooling. If we understand which culturally transmitted factors are important and what contributes to their emergence and propagation, we might be able to design policy interventions that could help less successful groups and countries to close their developmental gaps." Uh hu. Or maybe they are just smarter, and intelligence is heritable. But they can't say that since it basically means that there is nothing poor counties can do, except encourage immigration and intermarriage. So they make a fluff feel-good conclusion.
- msluyter 18y agoI again recommend Jared Diamond's "Guns, Germs and Steel," for the refutation of "they were just smarter" argument.
- ars 18y agoWe aren't talking about europe anymore though. Nor are we talking about colonialism, this is much more basic, and those argument don't work as well.
- rsheridan6 18y ago>Or exactly the other way around - the better the person is at producing, the earlier they managed to switch to agriculture. Or in less politically correct terms, the smarter the people, the more they make today, and the earlier they managed to figure out agriculture. It might have more to do with when they first had to switch to agriculture. Paleolithic hunter-gatherers had a better lifestyle and better nutrition than early farmers, so why start farming if you don't have to? Farming is tedious, backbreaking labor which gives you grass seed to eat, while hunting is something men do for fun even when they don't have to, and gives you meat. I don't really see the connection between farming and intelligence. Which would you rather trust a stupid person to do: plow a field or kill a lion with a spear? My first thought was that adapting to the tedious, persistent labor of farm life would lead to useful traits in a modern economy, unlike hunting, which is more like a leisure activity.
- ars 18y ago"Paleolithic hunter-gatherers had a better lifestyle and better nutrition than early farmers" I don't think that is true. Early farmers also hunted plus they had the grown food, so they did better. "I don't really see the connection between farming and intelligence. Which would you rather trust a stupid person to do: plow a field or kill a lion with a spear?" Kill a lion with a spear would be my answer - that requires strength and agility - but not much in the way of intelligence (witness animals that hunt). Farming does require intelligence, when to water, when to plant, what to plant, when to harvest. The calendar was invented specifically to help with those. After a while anyone could do it (which is why you think it's for stupid people) - but at the start? That took quite a lot of thinking, and experimenting.
- cambellg 18y agoOr, just postulating here, maybe the capital that is transmitted is just that. Capital. That and tribalism/nepotism could explain these results as well.
- gaius 18y agoSingapore would disprove that theory.
- cambellg 18y agoWhat aspect of Singapore's history gives lie to the theory that a tribe w/ portable resources will recirculate those resources within itself as it expands globally?
- gaius 18y agoSingapore had no resources other than the brains of its people; they were the underclass who were booted out of Malaysia with just the shirts on their backs.
- cambellg 18y agoOk... then they were colonized by a wealthy tribe. Where's the dichotomy?
- gaius 18y agoThey became the wealthy tribe once they were free of the mainstream Malaysian class system.
- DabAsteroid 18y agoThey became the wealthy tribe once they were free of the mainstream Malaysian class system. Malays have little to do with Singapore's economy.
- 18y ago
- m_eiman 18y agoI dunno, maybe they should look into if maybe Europe invading the rest of the world and killing off various percentages of the populations could be a factor?
- gaius 18y agoUhh, dude, if you read your history then pretty much everywhere has invaded everywhere else at some point, and populations that aren't being invaded are just as often killing each other. So while it happens, it's not a data point here.
- m_eiman 18y agoSure, but I'd guess that there's a difference if resources are transferred back and forth within a small region, i.e. neighboring countries warring for a few hundred years, compared to some other country far away taking the resources with them after a successful invasion. And then continue to take everything they can get their hands on for the next few hundred years... It pools the resources in a single place, and as a result it also pools the ability to refine those resources in the same place (because its pretty hard to learn refining if you don't have anything to refine). Maybe it could be compared to how a town supported by resource producing villages made it possible to specialize in a trade that wasn't viable in a village setting. And the killing off part was mostly a reference to diseases brought (without intention) to the Americas that more or less killed the civilizations there. But maybe I'm just brainwashed by the people on the left.
- gaius 18y agoConsider Zimbabwe. Its wealth was well, wealth, not money that's easy transferred, but fertile farms and abundant mines. Stuff that's inherent to the country itself. But Mugabe has brought it from the "breadbasket of Africa" to the brink or ruin (in fact, perhaps given the latest news from there, over the brink). Where did that wealth go? It wasn't transferred out by fleeing Europeans. It didn't even go into his Swiss bank account. It was simply destroyed.
- kingkongrevenge 18y ago> that there is something that human families and communities transmit from generation to generation -- perhaps a form of economic culture, a set of attitudes or beliefs, or informally transmitted capabilities Hmmm, what ELSE might be transmitted from generation to generation. I just can't put my finger on it...
- joe_the_user 18y agoSo the idea is: 1. Find a correlation around a bit of data relating to a very broad tendency in history. 2. Draw an unwarranted conclusion 3. ??? 4. Profit