6 ms·
Doctor at Cigna said bosses pressured her to review patients' cases too quickly
- alistairSH 3y agoAnd this is surprising to anybody?
- Pet_Ant 3y agoThe problem is that what is profitable is marking the case as reviewed. What is needed is skin in the game. Misdiagnosis should have financial penalties like speeding tickets otherwise the optimal most capital-effective solution is a rubber stamp.
- Rinzler89 3y ago>Misdiagnosis should have financial penalties like speeding tickets Bad analogy. Speeding tickets carry no penalties to those who issue them wrongly. You can sue and if you win the local government will eventually pay for the damages, meaning the taxpayers, meaning also you. They have no skin in the game.
- missedthecue 3y agoI have never heard anyone getting paid damages for a traffic ticket. The biggest you can hope for is a case dismissed which still requires direct and indirect costs.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoSpeeding tickets aren't the worst because they are in principle disputable, but they are present and real. SEC fines are so rare and late they aren't a real deterrent. Speeding tickets are regular and actually paid and a deterrent. Some systems are better than other (photo radar), but these are quibbles. The point is that these companies should get hit several times a month with a bill till middle management sees it is a cost center and actually worries about "how do we bring down this number?" and it becomes a bigger problem than "how do we reduce our coffee budget?".
- BobaFloutist 3y agoThey mean the financial penalties should be like the financial penalties of getting a speeding ticket, not that they should have financial penalties for misdiagnosis "like governments have for misissuing speeding tickets". So, there should be misdiagnosis tickets.
- galoisscobi 3y ago> What is needed is skin in the game. Misdiagnosis should have financial penalties like speeding tickets By this logic, would you say that software engineers should be financially liable for any bugs they cause along with people who misdiagnose those bugs in the process of root cause?
- ajmurmann 3y agoI don't think we have a market failure around that. If I introduce bugs that matter the company loses money. If that happens the company will penalize me by not getting promoted or a raise our even getting fired. Both the company and the individual are already held accountable. In contrast, how do I even know my medical diagnosis was wrong? How do I know it could have been better given the facts at hand at the time? There also seems to be no market function at all that gives market feedback to the medical institution Edit: procedures going wrong is of course already highly penalized and insurance for this is a significant cost of our health care.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asoneth 3y ago> By this logic, would you say that software engineers should be financially liable for any bugs they cause Yes. Professional engineers are held ethically, professionally, and in some cases financially responsible for the work they sign off on. Personally, I agree with Dijkstra who pointed out in a speech in 1993 that the term "software engineer" is a hollow sham: > And also the programming manager has found the euphemism with which to lend an air of respectability to what he does: “software engineering”... > In the mean time, software engineering has become an almost empty term, as was nicely demonstrated by Data General who overnight promoted all its programmers to the exalted rank of “software engineer”! But for the managing community it was a godsend which now covers a brew of management, budgeting, sales, advertising and other forms of applied psychology. > Ours is the task to remember (and to remind) that, in what is now called “software engineering”, not a single sound engineering principle is involved. (On the contrary: its spokesmen take the trouble of arguing the irrelevance of the engineering principles known.) Software Engineering as it is today is just humbug; from an academic —i.e. scientific and educational— point of view it is a sham, a fraud. From https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/EWD1165.html https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/E...
- snarf21 3y agoYou are hinting at the edges of the issue: mis-aligned incentives. A big problem is that your health care is tied to your employer for most people (WW2 is over, we need to stop this practice). It makes sense for an insurer to deny everything because it is low chance that the repercussions will come back to their bottom line, some other company or Medicare will get the bill. If once signed up, your healthcare came from one company forever, the math would change. We could finally move to value based healthcare where is makes more money to prevent health problems in the first place.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThis very much sums up the problem.
- ajmurmann 3y agoIt would also enable unhappy customers to move to a different insurance. I'm currently taking a prolonged time off and there was so much more flexibility on the market than what I've ever gotten from an employer.
- dudinax 3y agoThis gives them an incentive to make you unhappy.
- ajmurmann 3y agoAre you saying health insurances don't want customers?
- ceejayoz 3y agoThey absolutely don't want certain customers.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoI mean, I think that is the problem with "insurance" vs "coverage". "Insurance" is about pooling unlikely but costly risk, like getting hit by a meteorite. Unlikely, it happens, but there will be head trauma, CAT scans, x-rays, and hospital stays. That is what insurance is perfectly aimed at. People with known medical issues aren't really looking for insurance, they aren't pooling risk, they are sick. They need coverage. Businesses can easily handle insurance, but coverage is another matter. You are talking about people you know will cost more than they payout. That's charity, and better left to the state than the private sector.
- jajko 3y agoI don't know how US works, but anywhere in Europe doctors making any sort of mistake can and are sued to hell, my wife is one of them (luckily only once and error was done by her senior doctor not herself). Now depends what happened, how much you sue for, but losing license and ending in jail are not impossible results. Its up to judge to decide. If that's not skin in the game then I don't know what is. Compared to 99.9% of IT folks who at worst can lose their jobs and move on (not ideal situation of course, but incomparable pressure for relatively similar compensation).
- ajmurmann 3y agoThis definitely is the case for medical procedures and surgeonts carry high insurance for this. Not sure how this would work for diagnosis though. It's harder to know you were misdiagnosed and even harder to proof they could have done better with the information available at the time.
- banannaise 3y agoI think you're on the right track but not quite there. The incentivized behavior for insurance companiese right now isn't fast review, it's fast denial (which saves money on both review time and insurance payout). We need to make a coverage denial take an order of magnitude more time and effort than an approval, so insurance companies are forced to think real hard about denying access to care, and are incentivized to only deny care in relatively extreme cases. Raise the bar for denial reasons, and forbid generic denial templates.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> need to make a coverage denial take an order of magnitude more time and effort than an approval More difficult or more expensive. A random sample of denials being sent to a public board might do the trick, with a mandatory per-review fee charged to the insurer, and the sample size increasing as a function of reversed denials.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoCMS does do random inspections, but they are far too infrequent (on the order of years between inspections) and the penalties far too low to correctly align incentives. It should be a continuous stream of cases being randomly selected and reviewed.
- bogwog 3y agoThat doesn't make sense to me. Why wouldn't maximizing denials always be the priority for an insurance company? If you make denials slower, it will just slow down all cases. Insurance is fundamentally incentivized to scam its own customers. We need to add more regulation/oversight to reduce situations where management can play tricks to tip the balance in their favor. It's an arms race. The article was mostly about optimizing medical director "productivity levels", but it also mentioned that they outsourced to nurses in the Philippines who were doing a really bad job. Is there any oversight there? Are the nurses being incentivized to maximize denials? It'd be interesting to see how their productivity measurements are calculated too. Of course nothing is going to change (because of something to do with "socialism" I bet), but at least now I know to avoid Cigna.
- mattw2121 3y agoI'd be happy to subscribe to a $10 a month service that acts on my behalf for any denied insurance claims. Their job would be to become the "squeaky wheel". The insurance companies are banking on most people not having the time, energy, or knowledge on how to push back on them. Having a service provider that can do this will cause those insurance companies untold amount of pain.
- steelframe 3y agoThis is a great idea. Having been on the "automatic denial" side of the fence one too many times, I'd subscribe. But I'd want the service to act as an ombudsman for all insurance -- auto, home, health, etc. I suspect the real trick would be to keep insurance company lobbyists from finding a way to shut that down.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI was thinking the same. Insurance companies should get punished if the ratio of denied claims vs accepted claims after appeal. If that ration is high, it’s pretty much clear that insurance denies claims by default although they know the claim is valid.
- acdha 3y agoI agree, but this will be a horrific example of Goodhart’s law unless the appeals are third-party and there’s a SEC whistleblower-level retribution against anyone who tries to bribe or intimidate anyone involved. You need every executive knowing that the penalties will be denominated in percentage points of their annual revenue.
- datavirtue 3y agoYou get fifteen minutes. Per issue. One appointment is fifteen minutes. Can't talk about two issues at one appointment. My wife ran into that the other day.
- hammock 3y agoThis article is about “staff doctors” who are board certified doctors but typically do not practice medicine. Instead they are employed by an insurer, sit in a home office and review submissions for coverage to decide whether to approve or deny
- Hendrikto 3y agoSounds to me like they are employed to deny coverage.
- infecto 3y agoThis has been my larger issue and one of the motivations to move towards a direct primary care doctor (they don't take insurance). There are a lot of issues in the medical system but primary care seems to be one of the biggest offenders.
- santabanta 3y agoIs anyone really shocked about this? This is how capitalism works! Everything is just a means to an end.
- resource_waste 3y agoUS medical is not capitalism. I believe more than half of all spending is done through taxes. 140 years ago the American Medical Association started siphoning resources and clawing power.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoWhat are the penalties for bad faith 'compliance' on something that kills people? Does the company risk being shut down? Do the company officers personally face criminal charges?
- skhunted 3y agoNone, no, and no. The Clinton administration sought to overhaul the healthcare system and there was lots of testimony by employees of insurance companies whose job was to improperly deny claims. Americans have an irrational fear of socialism and if you can convince them that something is socialist they will be against it. What is interesting today is that Republicans campaigned for years on getting rid of Obamacare. When they finally got control of Congress and the Presidency they did not kill it. Eventually there will be another overhaul because these companies just can’t help but be shitty.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBecause the real role of managed care organizations (MCOs, health insurance companies) is to take the heat for government leaders for having a tiered healthcare system where individuals get access to healthcare based on their socioeconomic position. If you are a government leader and you offer healthcare to everyone, you are now clearly responsible for any failures. But with an MCO in the middle, fingers can be pointed all over the place. Different formularies and prior authorization rules can be set for different populations. For example, reimbursement can be lower for Medicaid patients (poorer/younger people), so they end up with less access to doctors, and higher for Medicare (older, likelier to vote), so more doctors are available there. Senators can get their own plan, and the military another, and the tech company employees yet another, and fast food employees, and so on and so forth. This system benefits all the leaders, so it is not going anywhere. In fact, I would bet UK and Canada move towards this.
- skhunted 3y agoAnd yet many countries have successful universal healthcare.
- hermannj314 3y agoWhen I managed a call center, we had employees that were amazing and accurate at repetitive and rapid tasks (1-2 min calls) and others that were comparatively better at slower-paced more deep-dive calls (30-40 min). We had elaborate routing rules that were matched to skill set and training. My job as a manager was to mix all of the data available to me into a plan that worked best for the collective team. Nevertheless, we still had to sometimes let people go that didn't have an effective place in the team. I did not find sufficient information in the article to determine if this was a management problem or a personnel issue. Without quantitative expectations of performance and safety trade-offs, the actual argument being made here is that a doctor can spend infinite time on a single case and never be reprimanded.
- rob74 3y agoThe risk in a call center is generally that someone won't have their issue fixed and will have to call again tomorrow. I would say the risk in denying treatment to a cancer patient is a bit higher than that, so every patient should be entitled to a review of their case that is not skewed to increase the insurer's profits or rushed to meet some "productivity" metrics. Of course doctors shouldn't spend infinite time on a case, but if the only way to not fall behind is to quickly deny cases, then something is wrong...
- hermannj314 3y agoI did not explicitly state that call center and cancer treatment were the same. I was under the impression that management practices can provide insight across industries. There is an obsession that doctors are special and that no rules can apply to them excpet the ones they write themselves. As someone that has had two relatives die due to medical errors, I stopped drinking the cool-aid of God-complex doctors awhile ago.
- crispyambulance 3y ago> Without quantitative expectations of performance and safety trade-offs, the actual argument being made here is that a doctor can spend infinite time on a single case and never be reprimanded. Woah, hold on there, false dichotomy. It's NOT a matter of "Infinite amount of time" vs "quantified expectations with reasonable trade-offs". It's a matter of "a doctor putting in the time to be careful" vs "being pressured to take 2-5 minutes of to make LIFE-CHANGING medical decisions". At the end of the day Cigna cares about hitting their numbers to squeeze every last drop of profit while the doctors are being forced to live with the possibility of making a grave mistake being rushed at "burger-flipper" (or "call-center") time scales. I am on the side of the docs for this one.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoShe'll be replaced with an AI soon enough.
- hornban 3y agoCigna denied my claim for an ER stay for a broken leg because it "wasn't medically necessary". This whole "click and close" thing is so obviously happening that I find it hard to believe that the company is even bothering to deny that they do that. One of the worst parts about this for me was that while I was dealing with trying to get my life back together from that kind of injury, I thought I was also going to go bankrupt as well. In my case, everything did turn out fine because apparently the hospital has an entire department dedicated to dealing with insurance claim denials. This whole system is an absolute joke.
- bende511 3y agoLook, the denial created at least one extra job! Cigna is out there creating jobs, and it only cost you the very real fear that you could have your life ruined from a broken leg!
- peteradio 3y agoWe couldn't fill the job locally, nobody could meet the requirement of extremely low ethics.
- thallium205 3y agoNine times out of ten it’s because the provider did not document or code it correctly when they billed your insurance. Of course the insurance companies always get the heat but it’s probably the minimum wage biller at the office that justified the bone set with an incorrect urinary tract infection diagnosis code that will obviously get denied. In the future it’s useful to call the provider and ask for a copy of what they submitted to your insurance.
- Spooky23 3y agoMedical establishments are stupid everywhere. If your employer doesn’t choose an insurer or self-funded benefit administrator like Cigna, you don’t have these issues. I have had a generous United Healthcare plan for 15 years. That time period included a high risk pregnancy, a spinal fusion, and a high risk cancer treatment program. I’ve had zero billing issues. Zero. We did have some prescription formulary issues that were a result of some drugs being specialty drugs with a different process. My sibling has Cigna, and literally has a problem of some sort with 80% of claims. The latest is an 8-year olds ear infection was determined by Cigna’s subrogation process to be related to a car accident.
- mhardcastle 3y agoIn most companies, "operations" staff is among their lowest-paid: customer service, cashiers, bank tellers, factory workers, etc. They are used to constant adherence to strict metrics. Medical care is strange in that the operational staff includes doctors, who will bristle at their expertise and years of schooling culminating into being judged on how many reviews (or appointments) they can churn through. It's an interesting issue that I sense naturally causes this kind of conflict.
- resource_waste 3y agoThe reason this is so incredibly bad, is that there is no competition in Medical. Each special interest group carved out a chunk of taxes and Power, and now they seek to expand through taxation or higher prices/lower quality. I own a clinic and our most maligned incentives are that medicaid patients have basically free care, so they will somehow find themselves getting more visits than someone who has private insurance is paying out of pocket until deductibles are met and is much more cost conscious.
- halostatue 3y agoTo me, the most surprising thing—and that it isn’t garnering more attention—is that the initial determination is that the relevant medical records and billing are reviewed by nurses in the Phillipines. I’m sure they’re competent, but that sending these records to a foreign location where HIPAA does not exist is a matter of course should have people up in arms.
- ceejayoz 3y agoHIPAA does permit this (https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/2083/do-the-hipaa-rules-allow-a-covered-entity-or-business-associate-to-use-a-csp-that-stores-ephi-on-servers-outside-of-the-united-states/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/2083/do-the-...) if a BAA is in place. (I think it's probably a bad practice, but it's a legal one.)
- halostatue 3y agoI figured it did and should have been clearer that I believe it to be an ethical problem, because groups like Cigna are masters of finding just the level of unethical that they can perpetrate without crossing the line to illegal, most of the time.
- speckx 3y agoUgh! > The "click and close" practice was common at Cigna, where doctors would quickly deny coverage requests by simply copying and pasting denial language prepared by nurses, rather than thoroughly reviewing each case.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- belval 3y agoNot exactly the same thing, but I recently used a service of telemedecine provided by my employer to get a prescription (not pain medication but still not that casual) and my mic didn't work but instead of waiting ~30 seconds for me to plug in my microphone, they literally took the name of the medication from the chat, closed the call and sent me my prescription with no words being exchanged. I'm happy I got what I wanted, but at this point what's their service, rubberstamping requests for money?
- gdw2 3y agoOften we measure what's easy to measure, not what's most important, because important things are often hardest to measure. "Handle time" (or velocity) is easy to measure, so we measure it. Quality is important, but its hard to measure. What we choose to measure gets focused on, so handle time (or velocity) ends up taking focus from quality, or customer satisfaction, etc, etc.
- hollywood_court 3y agoIt's wild that the "Greatest Country in the World" still hasn't managed to figure out this whole healthcare thing.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoExcept it has, just as a business that uses you as raw material for its money printer.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoAnnecdotaly: I was recovering from hip surgery. Further PT denied even though I was still in pain and didn't recover 100%. I'm 35. Not 75. I expect to get back to hiking 10 miles. But their denial lead to more pain, and an appeal takes at least 30 days. There should be a law that says you are guaranteed continued treatment when your appeal is pending. That way they actually have the incentive to do it properly. Now whether that again is a close and deny... yea, not sure what the solution is there.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 3y agoThe weird thing is that doctors have to put up with this kind of shit from insurance administrators, who are their inferiors on the social ladder.