7 ms·
iPadOS Identified as Digital 'Gatekeeper' Under New EU Tech Rules
- retskrad 3y agoApple has crippled iPadOS and consumers need the EU to force Apple to make moves that actually benefits the consumer. The fact that the real Chrome browser is not allowed on the iPad means the iPad as a web browsing machine is literally worse than a cheap Chromebook. Most developers put the majority of their effort to optimising their apps for the web and the best extensions are made for Chrome on desktop. Safari is just a piece of junk. The only reason it has any marketshare at all on iOS and iPadOS is because Apple is being anticompetitive and doesn't have to compete with Google. When they do have to compete on MacOS, guess what. People are voting and the vast majority like and chose to install Chrome. Apple users claim Chrome users don't know any better and Safari is so much better but that's the argument Android and Windows users like to make about Apple users in general so that argument is moot.
- hakanderyal 3y agoIs there any public data about browser usage on MacOS? I rarely see people using Chrome on a Mac.
- infotainment 3y agoI’ve had the opposite experience; I’ve literally never seen anyone using Safari on a Mac. Even tech illiterate people always seem to end up with Chrome somehow.
- servus45678981 3y agoAren‘t tech illiterate people the ones using chrome?
- luuurker 3y agoIt depends? If you're a more advanced user, need extensions, and a more complete browser overall, you have to use Chrome(ium) and Firefox.
- danmur 3y agoThey're the ones using Apple products generally so there's certainly overlap with both chrome and safari
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- flohofwoe 3y agoLol, no. An important reason for me to not use Safari is that it doesn't support uBlock Origin, 'tech illiterate people' rarely care about ad-blocking.
- hakanderyal 3y agoI used Firefox before safari because of uBlock Origin, but performance and battery life were big problems. There are ad blockers in Safari gives me the same end result as uBlock Origin.
- JKCalhoun 3y ago> Even tech illiterate people always seem to end up with Chrome somehow. Ha ha, because they are unable to quit the app.
- WA 3y agoSurprisingly hard to find this info. This says it’s 66% for Chrome on macOS: https://www.netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx?options=%7B%22filter%22%3A%7B%22%24and%22%3A%5B%7B%22platform%22%3A%7B%22%24in%22%3A%5B%22Mac%20OS%22%5D%7D%7D%5D%7D%2C%22dateLabel%22%3A%22Trend%22%2C%22attributes%22%3A%22share%22%2C%22group%22%3A%22browser%22%2C%22sort%22%3A%7B%22share%22%3A-1%7D%2C%22id%22%3A%22browsersDesktop%22%2C%22dateInterval%22%3A%22Monthly%22%2C%22dateStart%22%3A%222022-04%22%2C%22dateEnd%22%3A%222023-03%22%2C%22segments%22%3A%22-1000%22%7D https://www.netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx?opt...
- makeitdouble 3y agoAnecdotally, GSuite works a lot better on Chrome than any other browsers I've tried. Unsurprisingly companies opting for GSuite will see a larger share of chrome use, it might as well be preinstalled when handing down the computer or mandated at IT level when the intranet and other corporate SaaS is explicitely tested for chrome first.
- meindnoch 3y agoChrome is a resource hog spyware. I only use Safari, both on desktop and mobile/tablet.
- Allezxandre 3y agoIs it? My experience with Arc (which I would assume would be heavier than Chrome) has been that it adds a lot of scary entries in the Resource Monitor App, but doesn't impact my day-to-day use on my 16 Gb M1 MBP. With Safari, on the other hand, I've experienced audio stutter and delays when using resource intensive wep-apps like YouTube, Figma, Netflix and others.
- meindnoch 3y agoYouTube and Netflix are resource intensive webapps? What is so resource intensive about them? A <video> element?
- f_devd 3y agoNot for YouTube, but Netflix DRM possibly?
- meindnoch 3y agoYou think DRM is implemented in software? :D
- abhinavk 3y agoWidevine DRM for Netflix. AV1 decoding and the SPA for YouTube.
- Hamuko 3y agoApple's M3 has AV1 hardware decoding, so I imagine that shouldn't be a massive issue in the future.
- microtonal 3y ago
- threeseed 3y ago[flagged]
- arccy 3y agoif anything safari is IE 2.0: stagnating / holding back web platform evolution and forced onto you by the OS vendor
- frizlab 3y agohttps://wpt.fyi/interop-2024?stable https://wpt.fyi/interop-2024?stable Just because something works in chrom(ium) does not mean it should work on “the web.”
- mdhb 3y agohttps://wpt.fyi/results/ https://wpt.fyi/results/ Safari has more than double the number of standards tests that fail in their browser alone than anyone else. They are stupidly behind where they should be and intentionally did their best to cripple the web platform as a viable app platform to iOS.
- frizlab 3y agoGiven the standards are basically written because of chrom(ium) features I fail to see how that’s surprising. Firefox, which is literally a browser company, has twice as tests failings compared to chrome. Yes, Safari has more failures, but I would not call it “stupidly behind.” Safari is a decent browser and works well (I use it everyday professionally and personally and have next to no issues). EDIT: I’d like to point there are a lot of “failures” I’m glad are actually not implemented in Safari (e.g. the accelerometer API should not exist in a browser, nor should the API to make my device vibrate, etc.).
- mdhb 3y agoIt’s the least capable browser on the market with the highest number of bugs by a huge margin and produced by the richest company in the world. It’s not by any reasonable standard a decent browser judged against its peers. They do less and they do it worse but with more people than Firefox at least.
- servus45678981 3y agoAtleast there is Safari. Safari is without a doubt better than Chrome - with Efficiency, Simplicity and Privacy. Chrome is spyware and bloated; even more than Chromium lmao
- threeseed 3y agoThe problem is with Chromium. They recklessly add any random API with very little thought given to privacy and security. Which is why advertisers have been able to create browser fingerprinting that can be close to 99% accurate. All cheered on by fools who think Safari and Firefox are stagnant by being more careful and pushing for standards.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y ago> little thought given to privacy and security They do think about privacy, they just want you to have none.
- wil421 3y agoIsn’t this all by design? Google’s not going to take Apple-like steps to stop tracking and fingerprinting.
- Someone 3y ago> Apple has crippled iPadOS and consumers need the EU to force Apple to make moves that actually benefits the consumer I won’t go into whether that’s true, but I don’t think the EU has any objection against companies selling (or attempting to sell) bad products. The EU is acting because they think companies effectively do not have the choice of going around Apple to reach their customers, and that is limiting competition.
- Seanambers 3y ago[flagged]
- cesaref 3y agolinux
- rijoja 3y agoarm
- piva00 3y agoYou like to beat this drum, it's not the first time I read it coming from your username but... It's not the reality, while you ignore companies like Ericsson and ASLM providing basic tenets for high-end manufacturing of network equipment and chips. ARM used to be in the EU until Brexit. No, there are no flashy Amazons, Googles or Apples (or more frivolous and damaging stuff like AirBnbs, Ubers, etc.) from the EU but that doesn't mean it has lost the hardware and software dimension, if you meant "consumer hardware/software" I could give you a little more credit but since you've been beating the same dead horse for a long while on your anti-EU comments in HN it's pretty hard to start any meaningful conversation to understand your point of view. You don't like the EU, that's ok, just try to bring more meaningful arguments than this childish us-vs-them that seems to crop up from you quite constantly when Europe is talked about around here.
- emjoes1 3y ago
- Khaine 3y agoMost people just want to browse websites, they don't want an OS in a web browser running on their OS. Web developers love chrome because it's turning the web browser into the lowest common denominator operating system. It's a terrible idea. I want native apps, I hate web-apps, I hate Electron apps. They all have UI tweaks that don't fit in with native apps, are typically slower and more bloated. But because most web developers are useless, its all that is ever built these days.
- makeitdouble 3y ago> they don't want an OS in a web browser running on their OS. IMHO that ship has sailed. With the current state of the web, what JS needs to do and what it needs access to, any mainstream web browser needs to become an OS in all shape and form. Managing Skype or Zoom on the web is so far away from displaying Craiglist 20 years ago, and users sure want to be able to open a link and interact with the service without having to download an app. And this acceleration in web "pages" becoming full fledge apps is of course partly caused by Apple and its control on what can and cannot be distributed in the AppStore and middlemanning all payments. And god forbid to have multiple versions of the same app with different users for instance.
- Khaine 3y agoSure, but I don't want a web-app to be able to send me push notifications (all I've ever seen it used by is stupid websites sending what amounts to SPAM), or vibrate my device, or use the accelerometer. ~80% of web usage is looking at web-sites, and most of them are already a bloated mess of JS. If anything, the web would be much better if more sites were like craigslist. That ~20% is not worth the cost in terms of privacy, security, complexity, battery usage. I would rather a native app, or use a competing service that provides one.
- makeitdouble 3y agoYou don't want that, but people are looking at gmail or google calendar on the web, and notifications are a huge QOL. Getting access to the accelerometer feels niche, but accessing the NFC chip, phone contacts, the camera or real time locations would be more common. Dealing with the security and privacy aspects of those would be enough to get near the complexity of an OS. And to note...looking at the facebook app for instance, being native doesn't seem to be a protection from bloat, it will there either way. On the web as a static thing, sure 80% of the web is fine as a static information. The 20% on the other hand are things we care a lot about, and I personally hate the "why don't you install our app?" prompt on every damn site. Reddit is the poster child of this, and god no I don't want their native app. To each their own I guess.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoSafari has it's issues but Chrome isn't the pinnacle anymore, it's clear an enshitification is happening from the team who works on the wrapper UI. - Dark patterns to trick you into Google Pay - Those stupid sign in with your Google account dialogs you can't disable and make the website input glitch in weird ways, steal focus and I don't think they can even be dismissed with esc. - The "Lens" sidebar - Bimonthly popups about "themes" and "Ad Topics" dark patterns - Copying console.logs is now broken in weird ways as of a few updates ago
- oaiey 3y agoChrome is worth a separate investigation from the EU and others. Chrome is massively layer breaching with Google Service. There is a reason why chrome comes as Chrome and as Edge. Because both companies add stuff which no one wants there on top while cooperating on the thing we really want (the HTML, JS, engine). I should really find a fork which is focused on not adding on top.
- crashmat 3y agoisn't this ungoogled chromium? Or base chromium?
- dwb 3y ago> Safari is just a piece of junk ? I'm absolutely for Apple opening up to allow other browsers, but for me Safari is at least fine. I use it for preference on macOS too, it's very resource-efficient.
- kgdiem 3y agoI use Safari on desktop and mobile particularly because private browsing doesn’t share sessions between tabs/windows whereas chrome does. Somewhat niche yes but I loathe chrome for that behavior. Is there a way to turn that off? > Most developers put the majority of their effort to optimising their apps for the web and the best extensions are made for Chrome on desktop Also, I’m guilty of this as a safari user, lol. My extension is available on Chrome + ForeFox but it’s too much of a pain to make a free extension for safari.
- est31 3y ago> and the best extensions are made for Chrome on desktop. Note that Chrome on Android doesn't support extensions either, especially no adblockers. > People are voting and the vast majority like and chose to install Chrome Is it really users voting when Chrome is the only browser that works with some websites? Apple is the only thing standing in Chrome's way of becoming a global browser monopoly. The last time this has happened it was devastating for the web. The web is also way smaller than it is now.
- chongli 3y agoI happen to like Safari quite a lot (battery life, clean, fast/responsive UI, no shilling of Google services). I am dismayed at the direction Apple is heading as a company and I don't at all care for the way they market computing as a luxury product. What frustrates me the most though is how aggressive and pervasive all the big tech companies have become. Attempts to regulate one seem to benefit another. In this case, regulations to force Apple to open up their platform walled gardens will primarily benefit Google and Meta. On the other hand, the regulations to rein in the latter companies (GDPR) seem to have largely failed and only serve to widen their moats with barriers to entry. It honestly feels like we've spawned a multi-headed hydra and it's only going to grow more heads (LLMs?) as regulators struggle to keep up. Does anyone have any different ideas on how to solve this?
- ejmatta 3y ago> Most developers put the majority of their effort to optimising their apps for the web and the best extensions are made for Chrome on desktop. You're changing one monopoly for another in the name of convenience. This is the wrong way to think. We have Firefox and Safari for a good reason, and should support them as to not make another IE.
- r00fus 3y ago> Safari is just a piece of junk. Where does it fall down? Some of the later RFPs for web technology (bluetooth, battery level, etc) aren't supported but I think I agree more with Apple than some random web-app developer. Chrome is the new IE. Forget that.
- thiht 3y ago> Safari is just a piece of junk This hasn't been true for a few years. When I bought my first iPhone a few years ago (the iPhone 12 in 2020), Safari indeed was a piece of junk. But starting the very next iteration cycle (iOS 14 or 15 I think) they fixed almost all the issues I had with it (tons of bugs, including rendering issues on some sites, but also quality of life features, like moving the URL bar at the bottom). At first I used Safari because there was no other choice, today I use it because it's a decent browser and doesn't drain battery too much. Even if Firefox with Gecko or Chrome with Blink were available, I would stick with Safari.
- sillyfluke 3y agoIf the browser release process and scheduling sucks, from a practical standpoint the browser also sucks. I have a M1 laptop and one-before-last iphone SE that cannot open a ticketing website from a major global airline on Safari without an OS update. Irony being I can open the same website on all chromium browsers and firefox without an OS update. If this is not a completely broken experience, I don't know what is.
- wappieslurkz 3y agoThe fact that site doesn't work on Safari but does on other browsers doesn't have to mean it's Safari that's bugging out here, it could just be junk code they developed while only testing on all those browsers -except Safari- until it worked on those. Not a Safari issue in that case.
- sillyfluke 3y agoI think you are completely missing my point here. The website works on the Safari that comes with the latest OS. I can't update the Safari version without updating the OS with a 14GB update. Nevermind the extremely annoying hassle of having to backup the devices before the updates "just in case". I don't have to do that for any non-Apple browser while using the same Apple laptop. [0] I think it was the late and great Joe Armstrong who said, in a tongue-in-cheek remark on object oriented programming, "You want a banana, but to get the banana you need the gorilla holding the banana and the [goddamn] rain forest it lives in." (brackets might be my frustrated addition.) [0] there were other websites that would work seamlessly on other browsers but would throw security errors that disappeared after the OS update, including an email provider that is regular posted about on HN.
- cassianoleal 3y agoI will choose Safari over Chrome any day. My main browser is Firefox, with Safari second. I don't have Chrome installed on any of my devices, and will stay away from it until the unfortunate day when Chrome is finally exactly synonymous with the Web. What I want from my iPad is to be able to dual-boot into macOS. Everything else are small steps with the intent of postponing the ability to run a full-blown OS on the device. Incidentally, you can run Chrome on the iPad if it can run macOS.
- moi2388 3y agoWhat are you talking about? Safari is much better than chrome. Less spyware, MUCH faster, great customization, great tab/history sharing, better caching and much lower resource usage. Literally the only problem is lack of thirdparty apps, but apart from a great downloader and adblocker I don’t really need much. I don’t even want alternative stores, now my mother can download unverified apps from shady sources, before that was too difficult for her to do.
- thedrbrian 3y ago> doesn't have to compete with Google If chrome/google is so good then why aren’t people buying pixels for it? Why does google need the EU to break iPadOS?
- switch007 3y ago[flagged]
- s1k3s 3y agohttps://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_24_2363 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_24_...
- Simulacra 3y agoThis is tangentially related, I guess, but older iPads essentially rendered useless. I have an iPad 2 that could absolutely be used for zoom calls, but the zoom software will not install because apple forces them to require a newer iPad. Whereas I have an old MacBook from 2013 that still works pretty good - AND I could put Linux on it if I wanted to.. Hrm. Can I put Linux on an iPad?
- realusername 3y agoI feel like that's an angle which isn't talked about much by the EU, all these mobile devices should work like normal computers so you can install anything you want on it. Both for improving competition and reducing e-waste.
- oaiey 3y agoe-waste is indeed a valid angle. And extortion of customers (to buy new devices while the old one is still perfectly valid). I mean there is one thing to no longer patch devices but another one is to migrate products away from it.
- jncfhnb 3y agoIs it accurate that Apple forces zoom to not support older iPads?
- kevingadd 3y agoThey require regular updates to the latest SDKs, which makes it nearly impossible to test to ensure your software is still compatible with old devices. The result is that it seems like many developers just drop support for devices they can't test against anymore. Of course sometimes there is a cool new feature in an updated iOS SDK that isn't supported by older devices, so that's another reason to drop support for them in an app. And if you pull in third-party software (facebook login integration, ad middleware, etc) that stuff may also 'move forward' by dropping old device support. I'm not sure it makes sense to ding Apple for this in particular since support for old Android devices is similarly bad on Google's store.
- prmoustache 3y agoAren't iOS and iPadOS essentially the same thing?
- olex 3y agoApple argued they are separate platforms, and got around the EU requirements with that. So there are no third-party app stores and browser engines on the iPad available yet. Until now, that is.
- agust 3y agoSo basically Apple managed to delay the application of the DMA to iPadOS by 7 months.
- rsynnott 3y agoApple claims, not particularly plausibly, that they are not.
- gregoriol 3y agoThe timing of the split was great. Thankfully the EU proves to be not that dumb.
- FinnKuhn 3y agoThey were the same system, but iPadOS has seen quite a few updates that were specific to iPadOS in recent years and didn't get all of the iOS updates. Therefore I would say that they are different systems, even if they stem from the same system similar to how different Linux distributions are different operating systems even though they have lots of similarities.
- Kwpolska 3y agoI would say they're the same system, differing by some #ifdef's.
- prmoustache 3y agoA linux distro produce different deliverable medias for server, desktop and mobile use, as well as for different architectures. That doesn't mean the OS is not the same.
- kkfx 3y agoUnfortunately people never learned the power of freedom, so they regularly jump from a cage to another... The is no law to help, only culture.
- jiriro 3y agoApple is doing such a great job with their privacy features. - Private Relay - Hide my Email Your ISP cannot see your web browsing. So can’t Google. One time disposable email address for an unknown web site registration form. All of this nicely integrated in all your iPhone/iPad/Mac and Safari with a great convenience. Chrome – someone wrote it here - it’s such a resource hungry piece of crap. The only reason for Chrome is feeding Google/advertisers your online behavior. I guess the possible reason the EU saying iPadOS is a gatekeeper is Google/advertisers heavy lifting.
- k8sToGo 3y ago> Your ISP cannot see your web browsing You really are falling for those snake oil VPN ads. Btw. What will you do when Apple bans your account because you hold your iPad wrong? All those nice hide my emails won’t be accessible any more.
- throwaway290 3y agoEver heard of a case where Apple banned a legitimate user with no recourse? Plenty of such for Google
- fsflover 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40177617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40177617
- throwaway290 3y agoThat's not banning, that's a security measure working. In Google the stories are of specifically getting banned for violating T&C or something https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34016389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34016389, not getting locked out. And if you are locked out you can go to Apple Store or call support, tried that with Google?
- 3y ago
- solarkraft 3y agoFinally. The distinction was so silly.
- jsnell 3y agoWhile I think it's the right outcome, the reasoning from the EC is horrifying. The real problem is that iPadOS was never a separate platform in the first place, and should have been grouped with iOS. The EC could just have ruled on that. Instead they seemed to have accepted Apple's fiction about these being separate platforms, and then to get the outcome they wanted they just ignored the own inclusion thresholds. Look, the EC set these thresholds. They had years to review those thresholds. And the moment they produce an outcome the EC didn't want, they just go "lol, the threshold was never 45M users, it's actually about being 'close to 45M users'". Will everyone now be judged on the basis of being pretty close to the threshold, or was that a one off for Apple? What even counts as "close"? Are we talking 40M? 30M? 20M? What a clownshow.
- Hamuko 3y ago>"An undertaking shall be designated as a gatekeeper if [...] it enjoys an entrenched and durable position, in its operations, or it is foreseeable that it will enjoy such a position in the near future." iPadOS being close to the threshold with forecasted growth seems to very much fall in line with the DMA.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- labcomputer 3y agoSo, again, why isn't Spotify a gatekeeper at this point? This ruling shows that the quantitative thresholds are pure fiction (which was the old justification for leaving them out). Spotify has clearly an entrenched and durable position (the government of England formally declared them a monopoly)... and they are using their market power to strong-arm others: Look at all the Spotify-only or Spotify-first streaming playback devices (Teslas, for starters). They pay massively lower rates to artists than other streamers (like Apple Music) for another example. As for consumer harm, I seem to hear nothing but complaints from friends about Spotify's latest AI-generated playlists and poor user interface... those again speak to entrenched and durable market power. It really makes me question whether Europe has such low rates of corruption as everyone says.
- gumby 3y ago> Apple's business user numbers exceeded the quantitative threshold elevenfold, while its end user numbers were close to the threshold and are predicted to rise in the near future. C'mon EU! This is as bullshit as the US's TikTok ban justification. Apparently they define a threshold but then use a number that doesn't reach said threshold as justification to take action. We're not talking about troops massed on a border here: if they defined a threshold for action they should not then use it to justify action when the target hasn't been reached yet. Regardless if you agree or disagree on the EU's position, it's hard to support the rule of law when it's explicitly arbitrary like this. > Business users are locked-in to iPadOS because of its large and commercially attractive user base, and its importance for certain use cases, such as gaming apps. This, on the other hand, made me laugh: business users are locked into a platform because it's the only place they can play games?
- zamadatix 3y agoDo you also never support going to the hospital because your fever hasn't hit 40C yet even though you tick a bunch of other boxes and are nearing that temperature anyways? The thresholds are meant to be a cap, not a floor, and that's perfectly easy to support. Also worth noting it takes ~half a year for things to get going so if you wait until the exact moment to start things that's ~half a year the law would be ineffective at its goal. The quote about businesses and gaming is in reference to businesses as the producers of apps trying to reach customers, not as the consumer themselves.
- gumby 3y ago> Do you also never support going to the hospital because your fever hasn't hit 40C I think that's the wrong metaphor. Regulation functions well when it is 1 - clear, unambiguous, and consistently applied and 2 - conservative, in the sense of being a bit "behind the times". By this I don't mean reactive. There are cases when those approaches can't be followed, for example when you see an army being built up on a border, medical cases (not just the one you cite, which isn't a regulation, but drug approval) and other incipient life-threatening cases. But those cases are messy, often wrong (but with a risk vs cost profile that makes it worth doing), and often controversial. But this is simply an ipad. The kind of metaphor I think of is I'll speed at 120 km/h when my passenger is bleeding profusely, but if I'm late to a contract negotiation, well, I still have to drive the speed limit. A sense of arbitrariness discourages compliance with the rules. Consider the EU ETS. They already had an example to follow (the north american SO2 trading scheme), had the emissions and other data, and it is indeed an issue killing people. But they took the time to make sure it was right, and it works great, a little grumbling aside. At the end of the day the ipad is even less than that, and so clarity and consistency serves the wider goal.
- doix 3y agoThe iPad is such an amazing piece of hardware crippled by software in my opinion. My girlfriend has the first iPad Pro that came with an m1 and it's so well built. The screen and battery life are amazing, but I personally can't use it for anything apart from watching videos. She uses it for drawing stuff in Procreate, and is pretty happy with it, but it feels like such a waste. The "desktop" experience is so bad that she also has a macbook pro for "real tasks". In reality, if the iPad wasn't so gimped by the software, she wouldn't need the macbook. I guess Apple realizes this, which is why they put in the limitations. I really hope the end result is that Apple just ends up shipping OSX on the iPad pros instead of iOS. Highly unlikely, but a man can dream.
- goosedragons 3y agoYup. I liked my 2017 iPad Pro, hardware as decent and I mostly enjoyed the UI at the time but a lot of my work was simply impossible to do because of Apple's arbitrary software bullshit. I tried working around it by logging into my desktop at home but that was flakey and annoying for a number of reasons (sometimes WiFi networks would block the ports, sometimes I needed to see something not viewable over text, etc.). The iPad accessory ecosystem is also just ridiculously overpriced. $200+ to $300+ for a keyboard/mouse combo that will if you're lucky will maybe work on the next model you upgrade to and only works with a single device is insane. Then the stylus is $130 more. They make the MS Surface accessories look cheap. I don't want OS X on the iPad. I genuinely think that would be a bad experience but they do need to not cripple iPadOS.
- iamdamian 3y agoI’d be happy just being able to run arbitrary commands on a proper CLI.
- Jsebast24 3y agoIpadOS anti-virus - Soon on the App Store!
- user_7832 3y agoLike Avast? Or McAfee? [0] - https://apps.apple.com/us/app/avast-security-privacy/id1276551855 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/avast-security-privacy/id12765... [1] - https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mcafee-security-privacy-vpn/id724596345 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mcafee-security-privacy-vpn/id...