8 ms·
Why I Don't Invest in Real Estate
- al_borland 3y ago>Remote work eliminates the need to live close to work, which means the entire world becomes potential housing land supply In theory, this is true. In practice, it seems people working from home want to be near stuff that can get them out of their homes, so they don’t feel so isolated being at home all the time. Work isn’t the only thing a city offers.
- Swizec 3y agoI work from home. It’s very nice that the gym I go to daily is a 10min bicycle ride away (faster than driving), the farmers market is a 30min walk, there’s 3 large grocery stores in a 15min walk radius, I’ll never discover all the bars and restaurants I can reach with a quick bicycle ride let alone a short Uber, and there’s even a major international airport 20min away by car. Oh and I can run to the Golden Gate Bridge in about an hour. Cities are nice. Oh and there are 2 or 3 elementary schools and countless daycares within a 20min walk as well.
- jen729w 3y agoTrue, but in Melbourne, Australia, this has meant an explosion of cafes in the suburbs. It used to be that most people travelled in to the CBD for work. Hence very expensive housing the closer you were to the city. I don’t think house prices have adjusted yet, but your local shops have. Anecdotally I hear from people all over the place who say that their local shops have had a boost thanks to the increase in weekday traffic.
- jacobn 3y agoWhich probably corresponds to a loss of foot traffic to restaurants & shops in the cities' downtowns. This is very visible in SF.
- master_crab 3y agoYeah this is something I have noticed the last few years. Remote work cuts both ways. Someone in NYC can now do their job in Cleveland. But someone in Cleveland might decide to try and do their job someplace more exciting like NYC. And while people working originally Cleveland based jobs may not get as much money as an NYC based job, there are apparently enough high paying jobs (and trust funds) to support people moving into places like NYC.
- whateveracct 3y agoThe thing is The City isn't the end all be all. For instance, there are a dozen western WA towns and cities smaller & cheaper than Seattle that are full of stuff to do. Bars, restaurants, museums, parks, arcades, etc. And Seattle itself is a 30-60 min drive away from all of them depending on traffic.
- __turbobrew__ 3y agoI moved from Vancouver to a rural area due to remote work. It goes both ways.
- jnwatson 3y agoThe author makes good points about trends, but they are mostly super-long term. In the US, it will take at least a decade before the backlog in housing is resolved, and that's with lots of YIMBY support.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe right reason for not investing in residential real estate is because it’s immoral. Every house owned by a landlord is another house not owned by an owner occupier. The landlord renter system has divided our society into haves and have nots. It’s modern serfdom in which landlords own families. So sure, you can avoid investing in real estate for financial reasons but you can also avoid investing in real estate for the same reason you don’t invest in gambling smoking or fossil fuels….. to invest is to support something fundamentally wrong. No doubt the commenters will all jump in with "but waddabout this, waddabout that, so you want no homes to rent eh!?!". I don't care, my point remains - he landlord/renter system is destroying the fabric of our society, has destroyed the social bargain, is robbing young people of the future and if you're a landlord then you are part of the problem even if you hide your identity and sense of guilt behind a managing real estate agent.
- angusturner 3y agoNot sure why this is down-voted so heavily. In Australia, the property market has been artificially inflated for years with favorable tax incentives that encourage investors to hoard properties and sit on them, while writing off any losses as tax deductions. Meanwhile, renters are being squeezed because landlords are trying to pass on the cost of rising interest rates to their tenants, who are forced to choose between groceries and making rent. And yet, I would bet my kidney that when interest rates fall we won't see landlords pass on the savings to their tenants. As the OP's point, the landlord renter system HAS "divided our society into haves and have nots", and it causing serious bitterness in division in our country. And the issue is politically intractable, because the propertied class are not going to accept any reform that lowers the value of their house.
- apsurd 3y agoI agree with your sentiments, but I'm stuck because renting is paying into the exact same problem isn't it?
- jen729w 3y agoThat’s very absolutist. There’s a place for rental accommodation. I moved to Australia as a backpacker in 2003 and found a cheap rental. What was I supposed to do, buy a house?
- master_crab 3y agoThis is directionally accurate. The issue is of course timing. It takes years, possibly decades before inertia is overcome and prices move down. And in a place as big as America it will always be impossible to time a permanent shift downward, if it ever comes for the handful of metro areas that will always remain alluring.
- a_bonobo 3y agoWestern countries (such as OP's, and mine) have been counter-acting lowering birth rates with higher immigration rates. It's become a political issue in Australia now with a housing and a cost of living-crisis, in times of record-level immigration [1]. It doesn't look like OP accounts much for that. Yes, overall birth rates might be going down, but that doesn't mean that there will be fewer people where OP lives. Chances are the rest of the world wants to live where OP lives. I don't see Australian house prices going down any time soon, and I don't see these trends reverse in my lifetime. And I'm not even that old! [1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/mar/21/migration-numbers-australia-2023-rise https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/mar/21/migra...
- nextos 3y agoExactly. In the EU, most hot cities have become prohibitively expensive in terms of rental and purchase prices, basically because that is where most jobs are. I don't see a reversal of this trend happening anytime soon, unless there is a massive shift towards remote work. If anything, I think things are becoming worse. I wish I was wrong, as it is a nightmare. Before COVID, a nice rental in the Oxbridge area would cost 1/3 of an average salary. Fast forward to 2024, it is now 1/2. Lot's of people are struggling. I heard the buy-to-let era was over, and that the market was cooling down, but I don't see that turning into lower prices.
- ReleaseCandidat 3y agoAnd even if the population decreases, still (almost) everybody has to live in one of the big cities or centers of tourism to get a job. The irony is that only wealthier people, who can work remotely, can afford to live in villages where living costs are low. Because there is (almost) no work and (almost) no young people live there (any more).
- nradov 3y agoThere are plenty of jobs for oil and gas workers in North Dakota. Plastics manufacturing is booming in rural Ohio.
- thsksbd 3y agoI don't buy real estate because I think there will be a population boom. I buy real estate because I think the dollar will collapse. And because when mortgage rates <3% when all the macroeconomic fundamental scream "bullshit", I have a fairly safe, free, and accessible to leverage.
- imposterr 3y agoIf the dollar collapses who's there to enforce your ownership of said property?
- alchemist1e9 3y agoFiat currency collapse is so common that it’s more the norm than the exception and property rights tend to survive perfectly well even when the government issued currency experiences collapse and high inflation.
- tomohelix 3y agoFor the dollar to collapse in this lifetime to the point you can benefit that way, it will take a major event that would also likely decimate the US real estate market. Maybe for your children's lifetime, if they are lucky. It took Britain nearly 100 years to deflate from its hegemon status. Argubly, with the size and natural advantages the US hold, it will take even longer for them to naturally fall from its top spot.
- alchemist1e9 3y agoJapanese yen is down 20%+ in 2 years. How are property prices in Tokyo in €£$? Nigerian Naira is down 75% in two years. How are property prices in Lagos in €£$? Turkish Lira is down 80% in 4 years. How are property prices in Istanbul in €£$ shall I continue? USD can absolutely have a 50%+ depreciation in next 5-10 years. That is completely possible. Will it lose reserve currency status? No absolutely not. There is no viable replacement. But when we measure in purchasing power or gold or other stable pricing reference it can happen and property prices will not fall in those terms. Printing currency doesn’t strictly cause economic collapse in simply causes a loss in value and faith in the currency.
- purpleteam81 3y agoInvesting in a home is a mixed bag. Whether you purchase a new home or pre-owned, there will always be repairs and some are cause due to the use of cheap products by builders. Determine why you want to purchase a home. Do you intended to pay it off to establish a level of 'rent' control once retired? Is your home a tax write-off based on income? Rigth now in the US there is an affordable housing crisis due to price gouging.
- TheAmazingRace 3y agoThe whole mentality around “a home is your piggy bank and retirement plan” has screwed future generations out of a chance for an affordable domicile. I’m a millennial that “missed the boat” on a property prior to the pandemic. I want to believe this will eventually self correct, but should I be waiting till my twilight years to have a piece of the American Dream? This is why I do cringe about folks that bought before and got in with super cheap interest rates, and then brag about it like they are geniuses. They simply got ridiculously lucky. What are we supposed to do about it? Building more homes isn’t terribly economical due to the obsession with large McMansions, and the rise in interest rates caused a chilling effect, where few want to sell, so we are in a deadlock.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Negitivefrags 3y agoIt’s interesting that you read an article that basically outlined all the structural supply and demand issues around why house prices are the way they are. And then you turn around and blame the “home is your piggy bank” mentality.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jdewerd 3y agoThe "home is your piggy bank" mentality is the cause and motivating force behind NIMBYism. It's not only in the article, it's prominently in the article.
- TheAmazingRace 3y agoThank you. This is exactly my view as well. Folks before me got in when the getting was good, then pulled the ladder up.
- 3y ago
- anonzzzies 3y agoAs a hedge for tech I have been doing up and flipping houses: I agree with OP mostly for the long term but you can make a few 100k on the side in the eu by flipping if you have cash. I personally hate renting out and having guests which is what most people do here; I buy for 50k, do up for 20k and sell for 200. Holding on is lame unless you live in it imho.
- s5300 3y ago[dead]
- jijji 3y agoIt depends where/how you get your real estate. If you're talking about the MLS (retail) market, then yes its probably not a great investment.
- nostromo 3y agoThe inflection point is 1971. https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ 1971 was basically the year the government decided it could print money infinitely. Assets prices used to go up and down, now they mostly go up. The last two times real estate corrected, the Fed gobbled up mortgages like they were going out of style. The 50 years since have been an aberration -- but I'd argue mostly it's been better than before... maybe those good times will come to an end, or maybe they won't. But if real estate crashes hard in the US, so will equities, so don't pretend you're safe.
- 0xbeeffade 3y ago>I'd argue mostly it's been better than before... maybe those good times will come to an end[...] "And the gods of the copybook headings, I notice outlast them all."
- aunty_helen 3y agoSpanish cities are dense (and very walkable) because at one point in time everyone went home for siesta. There’s a bit of a white elephant in this article, no mention of mass migrations. People not only want to be in a city, they want to be in a good city. Whether that’s idealism, climate related, conflict related or opportunity related there are many drivers pushing people from everywhere to just here.
- Arete314159 3y agoI think the next 10-20 years will be an era of local real estate highs and lows. Long before actual submersion, the effects of rising seas will affect property in the forms of more frequent storms, flooding, and the effects on groundwater like in the Florida condo collapse. Inland, many parts of the world will start having water scarcity, or fire risk. Instead of an all-over rising real estate market, I think prices in places like Florida, parts of Texas, Louisiana, etc. will crater due to uninsurability. The places that are still standing undamaged in 15 years' time will be incredibly expensive. The only tricky part is knowing where those places will be exactly. The areas that were "sure things" just a few years ago, such as the Pacific Northwest and Vermont, have been shown to be not nearly so certain. Lytton, Canada spontaneously combusted, while VT has had many damaging storms and floods. So it's a guessing game at this point. One could make the argument that renting is the best gambit, because that's the only way you won't get stuck with a climate change "lemon."
- solatic 3y agoOr, don't invest in real estate because, if you're not supremely wealthy, purchasing a house will both drastically concentrate / un-diversify your holdings and result in you spending multiple years of earnings (hundreds of thousands of dollars) on mortgage interest. You not only need for the house to continue increasing in value, you need it to increase in value above what you paid in mortgage interest, above what you pay in transaction related expenses (real estate agent commissions etc.), above the cost of capital improvement (i.e. repairs), above the return you would have earned on the money had you invested it instead of paying mortgage interest, plus an expected rate of return on the entire property that you would need to actually sell, which is illiquid, and you may find that you would want or need to sell at an inconvenient time, i.e. when interest rates are high, making it more difficult to realize a return. Sure, you don't need to pay rent to a landlord, or moving fees. But if/when purchase prices are so far out of whack compared to rents, it's better to invest the difference in your diversified portfolio instead. And if you really want to invest in real estate, you can invest it in real estate ETFs instead, which are more liquid and do not require such a large financial outlay as to concentrate your portfolio. Don't get me wrong, there are other reasons to buy a house. But they're usually emotional, not financial.
- reify 3y agoSome basic facts. 10 years ago one person buys a house for £100K 10 years ago one person buys a house for £250K They both buy their houses in accordance with the level of income they earn. The person who bought the £100K home could not afford the £250K home. 10 years later house prices have increased by 100%. The person who's home is now worth £200K still cannot afford the house which is now worth £500K even though, on paper he is £100k richer. The person who owns the £200K home can only buy the expensive £500K house if he increases his mortgage which involves increasing their earning capacity. Back in 1982 I bought my first home for £29,500 (cheap as chips) with a 25 year mortgage. The mortgage adviser said that over the 25 year period I would pay back £160,000 in interest. 42 years later that same house is on the market for £360,000. On paper I am considerably richer today than I was 42 years ago. This is meaningless. I have no access to that money. I cannot just sell my home and have loads of cash in my bank account. I would be homeless. I cannot buy a cheaper home because my home was cheap when I bought it and is still cheap. As a 25 year old I loved my new home. I looked around at all the more expensive homes and thought that one day I would buy one of them. Naively misunderstanding that as my home went up in value so would all the other homes around me even the more expensive ones. After working all my life I finally retire. My dream is to sell my home and move to the seaside and enjoy my final years and die in peaceful surroundings. Alas, my home will not sell for enough money to buy a home near the seaside. I remain forever stuck in the home I bought 42 year ago. It is increasingly more difficult for young poeple to buy their own homes. Unless you are earning £120,000 per annum you cannot afford the house that I bought for £29,000 when I was 25 years old. Who really benfits from home ownership? Who really benfits from ever increasing house prices? Who really controls house pricing? Banks and estate agents!
- nemo44x 3y agoYou’re totally ignoring interest rates which since 1982 have trended downwards significantly. Combined with inflation this is why properties have gone up in cost. A home will be priced based on the monthly payment the buyers are willing to make and that includes principal, interest, and taxes. As interest goes down, principal goes up. In general this is good as more of the buyers monthly payment goes into equity instead of bank profit. You can sell your home and get loads of cash and buy a smaller place or rent. Many people “downsize” when the kids are grown and often move to lower cost of living areas. Also, your home is an asset. You can borrow against it. Considering you have not had a monthly payment for nearly 20 years you’ve had ample opportunity to save more money and upgrade your property if you’ve wanted.