3 ms·
Yeah, electric cars definitely don't make sense for car hire. The main advantage of electric car ownership is cheaper fuel costs long term if you charge at home
by IshKebab 3y ago
Yeah, electric cars definitely don't make sense for car hire. The main advantage of electric car ownership is cheaper fuel costs long term if you charge at home overnight. That obviously isn't going to happen for a hire car, and even if it did the fuel cost of a hire car is insignificant compared to the cost of the hire itself.
On top of that, charging is still way less convenient than refueling an ICE car, and when you hire a car it's usually in a situation where you can't afford inconvenience.
I think electric cars are the future and hopefully I'll never buy an ICE car again, but car hire has got to be the last domain to transition surely?
- apgwoz 3y agoWe use Zipcar for a second car at the moment and the closest one is an EV. I’ve only used it to go (at most) 10 miles round trip, but I’ve picked it up at 15% charge before and had anxiety the whole time… I agree that EV is a poor choice for rental.
- Symbiote 3y agoCan you not see the charge amount before renting it? The equivalent services in Copenhagen show the state of charge of the cars on the map, before paying anything. (There's also free minutes for leaving the car plugged in to a charger at the end, and perhaps because of that it's rare for them to be at a low charge.)
- rokkitmensch 3y agoThis has gotta be the ultimate EV gaslighting I've ever seen. You're clearly not doing EV right, GP!
- Symbiote 3y agoThe FAQ on Zipcar's website says "Our Electric Vehicles are charged overnight by our team, so they’re good to go whenever you are" — but this isn't the case for the GP, so the failing is with Zipcar.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoFor anyone otherwise accustomed to vehicles that even at 5% of capacity can be refilled within 5 minutes once a petrocharger's been found, the suggestion to check the charge level is risible.
- apgwoz 3y agoYou _can_, but if I have a reservation a week in advance, then it’s not much use. Someone could return the car with no batter at 3:15, for my 3:30 reservation.
- Symbiote 3y agoOk, so I see the Zipcar system is set up quite differently to the car sharing I've used elsewhere. Here, there are many more cars, but it's not possible to reserve far in advance. You can reserve for free for enough time to walk to the car (20 minutes?) or pay to reserve for longer. The charge state is shown prominently.
- bitmasher9 3y agoLast domain? Maybe not, but it could be among one of the last. I think heavy loads, cross country, and extremely rural are likely to be among the holdouts.
- thriftwy 3y agoThere's also the (para)military. I can't imagine an electric Toyota pickup performing in a warzone. Maybe that's why Toyota is not making the leap.
- cogman10 3y ago> extremely rural Depends on how "extreme" extreme is. Certainly affordable wouldn't work for rural because range is really needed. However, it's doable now with 300+ range EVs (assuming there's a city within 100/150 miles of your location). One thing that would change this quickly is if V2H ends up taking off. Then you can ditch your backup generator and use your EV in the event of a power outage. For very rural places or off grid places that could be really valuable. But totally agree about the other categories.
- cm2187 3y agoThe article says the cars are unreliable. I thought one of the selling points of electric cars was reliability over an ICE engine. Anyone knows what they are refering to?
- pitaj 3y agoMy understanding is that they're better not in reliability, but in lower maintenance (oil replacement etc).
- cogman10 3y ago> I thought one of the selling points of electric cars was reliability over an ICE engine. They are if you take car of them. Hertz notoriously did not have chargers in their lots and I've read plenty of stories of EV renters getting an EV with 20% of the battery. If they are letting the cars sit and discharge to 0, yeah, that will look like them being "unreliable" and will ultimately wear the battery.
- Rinzler89 3y ago>They are if you take car of them. That also applies to ICEs.
- cogman10 3y agoICE are more reliable than ICE if you take care of them?
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y agoIt might be time to check out the Hacker News guidelines for comments. A couple of relevant excerpts: >Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. >Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cogman10 3y agoIt depends on the situation. It would work great with 2 things in place 1. The rental company has car chargers on the lot and keeps their cars charged at a reasonable level. 2. You are staying at a hotel/location with car chargers. If those two things are in play, then electric rental cars make a TON of sense. Even shorter range ones as you are likely mostly puttering around the location where you are renting. In that case, you are likely to want to do the "drive around all day, charge while you sleep" that most EV owners do. Unfortunately, while some hotels do have chargers, they tend to be the more expensive hotels and they tend to only have 1 or 2 slots for charging. > On top of that, charging is still way less convenient than refueling an ICE car Really depends. Charging is more convenient if you the place you park your car has a charger. Charging is less convenient if you are driving long distances or you need to recharge with no room for downtime.
- ghaff 3y agoI suspect fewer people putter around a location though. At one point if I was just doing a trip with some stops in core Silicon Valley I’d have automatically rented. Generally more likely to Uber it these days.
- dgfitz 3y agoI think you’re underestimating the number of people who fly into an airport and their destination is 1-4 hours away by car afterwards. Edit: and their hotel is a solid 45 minutes away from their work site.
- cogman10 3y ago> I think you’re underestimating the number of people who fly into an airport and their destination is 1-4 hours away by car afterwards. I probably am, because I don't think that's super common. Airports are everywhere. Even for my extreme rural hometown, there's a commercial airport 45 minutes away (Though, granted, we'd go to the airport 2 hours away because it's bigger and we'd have to fly there anyways to get to the 45 minute airport). The full flights and large planes I've been on haven't been to Pocatello Idaho. Which is what gives me the impression that people aren't typically flying to rural destinations. On the other hand, a flight to Atlanta, Ronald Reagan, or Dallas are always filled to the brim.
- williamdclt 3y ago> the fuel cost of a hire car is insignificant compared to the cost of the hire itself. That’s not true everywhere. I’m currently on holidays: the car rental for 6d was 130euros, insurance 40, and gas will be about 60 for 10-15h of driving. Gas doesn’t dominate the price but it’s far from insignificant, and it only gets worse as price increases
- Rinzler89 3y agoBut you save a lot more time traveling with a gas car since you're not looking for charring stations along the route every 150-350km and waiting hours to charge. Also, charging at public chargers isn't that cheap or frictionless. At home yeah, but at stations not so much. Not compared to filling up with gas and being on your way in less than 5 minutes.
- cogman10 3y ago> But you save a lot more time traveling with a gas car since you're not looking for charring stations along the route every 150-350km and waiting hours to charge. While I'm sure it happens, that's never been my experience. You plug your trip into the car's navigation system and it'll plan out the charge stops for you. It's quiet frictionless. Tesla's is really good as it will even plan on sending you to less busy charging stations vs more busy ones (and reroute if that changes). > Also, charging at public chargers isn't that cheap or frictionless. Depends on the network. Tesla's isn't terribly expensive and is extremely frictionless. Electrify America is horseshit, both on cost and ease of use. This is a solvable problem. > Not compared to filling up with gas and being on your way in less than 5 minutes. Behavior ends up changing here if you road trip with an EV. Rather than just getting fuel then going somewhere else to eat you'll usually charge while you eat, use the restroom, or go for a walk. If you really don't have anything else to do, you'll probably just catch a tv show on your phone. That coveted 5 minutes ends up just not being a big deal because you are multitasking with the charging. (Which for me is typically 20->30 minutes).
- Rinzler89 3y ago
- Glyptodon 3y agoFuel costs aren't insignificant, low MPG cars can have fuel be a solid % of the overall rental cost. I think for a moderately efficient (30ish MPG) rental I used for an afternoon a few weeks ago fuel was ~15% of total cost to me. Like $55 in rental fees, $10 in fuel. A rental a had last year for multiple days was closer to like 20%, but I got stuck with a gas guzzler.
- jccooper 3y agoThere's situations where they make sense to rent and vice versa. Business traveler who just needs to go between the hotel and the airport? Great; may not even need to charge. If I'm flying into Vegas to do a roadtrip to the Mighty 5? Nope. Rental companies already have lots of different categories, so it's fine to have a mixed fleet. Just requires some extra infrastructure and consumer education. Which, I know, is in short supply, but can be done.
- atombender 3y agoI rent EVs in Europe all the time, both for long and short trips, and it's never been a problem. (I don't own a car, so it's the only kind of driving I do these days.) You charge the rental overnight or find a fast charger somewhere if you can't find a spot. It's annoying when there's a line, but it's not an actual problem. Reliability has also not been a problem.