7 ms·
>1.6nm Gotta love how we now have fractions of a near meaningless metric.
by Havoc 3y ago
>1.6nm
Gotta love how we now have fractions of a near meaningless metric.
- s_dev 3y agoWhy is it meaningless?
- Havoc 3y agoIt stopped being an actual measure of size long ago. The nm is t Nanometer anything it’s just a vague marketing thing attempting some sort of measure of generations
- chmod775 3y agoBecause it's not measuring anything, except the tech generation. It conveys about as much information as "iPhone 14".
- gwervc 3y agoIt's at least more easily understandable (lower is newer) than the average tech product naming scheme, especially those by Microsoft.
- tommiegannert 3y agoThe problem is it sounds like something any engineer can understand without domain knowledge, but interpreting it that way is completely wrong. The worst kind of naming. Not just IKEA-style random names (and I say that as a Swede,) but reusing a standard, while not keeping to what the standard is normally used for, and what it previously meant even in this domain. N1.6 is much better for naming node processes. Or even TSMC16.
- bmicraft 3y agoNormally? That "standard" hasn't been used "normally" for 20 years now. Arguably the new way is normal in every sense of the word
- dmix 3y agoDo you think they'll be advertising 0.9nm in the future or switch it up at some point?
- bmicraft 3y agoIntel has already switched to Ångström for the most part
- smallmancontrov 3y agoI see MTr/mm2 a lot, it feels like a better measure, and it feels like the time is ripe for marketing to make a jump. Bigger is better, "mega" is cool, the numbers are hundreds to thousands in the foreseeable future so no chance of confusion with nm. What's not to love? But hey, I don't make these decisions, and I see no indication that anyone in a position to make these decisions has actually made them. Shrug.
- tommiegannert 3y agoYes. By standard I mean that nanometers ("nm") is used to describe physical distances. That's it's normal use, understood by all engineers. That's also how it was born into the semiconductor domain. In that domain, it should have either stayed a description of physical distances, or been replaced. They could invent codenames, or start using a better (physical) metric, if this one is no longer relevant.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- brandall10 3y agoWhile it may be divorced from any particular measurement, doesn't it give an approximation of increased density?
- andrewSC 3y agoprocess/node "size" has, for some time now, been divorced from any actual physical feature on or of the chip/transistor itself. See the second paragraph of: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_nm_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_nm_process for additional details
- blagie 3y agoBecause it lost meaning somewhere between a micron and 100nm. From roughly the 1960s through the end of the 1990s, the number meant printed gate lengths or half-pitch (which were identical). At some point, companies started using "equivalences" which became increasingly detached from reality. If my 50nm node had better performance than your 30nm node because I have FinFETs or SOI or whatever, shouldn't I call mine 30nm? But at that point, if you have something less than 30nm somewhere in your process, shouldn't you call it 20nm? And so the numbers detached from reality. So now when you see a 1.6nm process, it's think "1.6nm class", rather than that corresponding to any specific feature size, and furthermore, understand that companies invent class number exaggerations differently. For example, an Intel 10nm roughly corresponds to Samsung / TSMC 7nm (and all would probably be around 15-30nm before equivalences). That should give you enough for a web search if you want all the dirty details.
- api 3y agoThe same thing happened with chip frequency around the end of the 1990s. Chip frequencies stagnated (end of Dennard scaling if I remember correctly) giving the impression that single threaded performance had stagnated, but since then chip makers have used increasing data and instruction parallelism to squeeze even more apparent single threaded performance out of chips. A 3ghz chip today is usually way faster on average code than a 3ghz chip 15 years ago. They also started expanding into multiple cores and adding more cache of course. For fab processes we should just switch to transistor density. That still wouldn't capture everything (e.g. power efficiency) but would be a lot better than not-actually-nanometers. For performance we really don't have a good single metric anymore since all these performance hacks mean different levels of gain on different code.
- thsksbd 3y ago"For fab processes we should just switch to transistor density." Indeed May I propose transistor density divided by the (ergodic) average transistor switching power?
- antisthenes 3y ago> For fab processes we should just switch to transistor density. The marketing departments of silicon companies are saving that as their ultimate weapon.
- jl6 3y agoIt’s not meaningless, it’s near meaningless. That’s what the nm stands for, right?
- blackoil 3y agoNumber represents transistor density. 2nm has ~twice the density of 4nm. If you ignore nm as unit of distance it makes sense.
- phonon 3y agoDimensions go by 1/root(2) to double density...so about .7 per generation.
- _heimdall 3y agoThey're using the wrong units if we need to consider the nanometer as something other than a measure of distance.
- defrost 3y agoIn some applications it helps to be fluid in exchanging distance as time with time as distance. http://dataphys.org/list/grace-hopper-nanoseconds/ http://dataphys.org/list/grace-hopper-nanoseconds/ and the field of play here isn't 1D linear .. it's somewhere sort of a bit slightly > 2D (elements can be stacked, there are limitations on how much and how close)
- exe34 3y agoWait till you talk to theoretical physicists who set c=h-bar=1.
- _heimdall 3y agoI have more fundamental concerns to talk with a theoretical physicist about first :D Time to kick an ants nest here... Quantum mechanics is a useless study that had no business being a scientific field. The most fundamental principles, like quantum superposition, can never be tested or validated and therefore could never be used to be predictive of anything other than similarly theoretical ideas.
- exe34 3y ago
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoWonder how long until its back to round numbers? - 800pm
- mazurnification 3y agoIt will be 18A first.
- __alexs 3y agoTSMC N5 is indeed about 30% more Transistors/mm2 than N7 as you might expect so seems reasonably meaningful?
- thsksbd 3y ago1.6 nm is 16 A. If they continue the BS for much longer, the "feature size" will be smaller than the lattice of Si.
- __alexs 3y agoYou're the one calling it a feature size, not TSMC.
- lostlogin 3y agoI’m sure you agree that the measurement given is a marketing term and is generally unhelpful beyond ‘it’s smaller than the current number’.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Tagbert 3y agoit also seems to be a roughly proportional change in density so why would it be unhelpful? Just because you can't point to a specific feature and say that is 1.6nm, doesn't make the label meaningless as so many try to assert. It is a label that represents a process that results in a specific transistor density. What label would you prefer?
- highwaylights 3y agoI hear it also has many megahertz.
- zzz999 3y ago[dead]
- audunw 3y agoThe metric means what it has always meant: lower numbers mean higher transistor density on some area (the digital part) of the chip. What more do you want? It’s as meaningful as a single number ever could be. If you’re a consumer - if you don’t design chips - lower number means there’s some improvement somewhere. That’s all you need to know. It’s like horse powers on a car. The number doesn’t tell you everything about the performance under all conditions but it gives a rough idea comparatively speaking. If you’re a chip designer then you never cared about the number they used in naming the process anyway. You would dig into the specification and design rules from the fab to understand the process. The “nm” number might show up in the design rules somewhere.. but that’s never been relevant to anyone, ever. I really don’t understand why so many commenters feel the need to point out that “nm” doesn’t refer to a physical dimension. Who cares? It doesn’t have any impact on anyone. It’s very mildly interesting at best. It’s a near meaningless comment.
- spxneo 3y agowhat is a rough rule of thumb for each 1nm reduction? What does that increase in transistor density look like each year? If the jump is bigger (5nm->3nm), does that rate of change increase too? trying to understand the economic impact of these announcements as I don't understand this topic well enough
- Havoc 3y ago>The metric means what it has always meant That's just patently wrong. The measurement used to refer to feature size [0]. It used to be a physical measurement of a thing in nanometers hence nm Now it's a free for all marketing team names it whatever the fuck they want. That's why you get stuff like intel 10nm being equivalent to AMD 7nm. [1]. It's not real. >Who cares? You...else we wouldn't be having this discussion [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor_device_fabrication#Feature_size https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor_device_fabricati... [1] https://www.pcgamer.com/chipmaking-process-node-naming-lmc-paper/ https://www.pcgamer.com/chipmaking-process-node-naming-lmc-p...