5 ms·
> Zoho started allowing African companies to pay for its software in local currencies. This decision has been a major reason for Zoho’s success in Africa as it
by alephnerd 3y ago
> Zoho started allowing African companies to pay for its software in local currencies. This decision has been a major reason for Zoho’s success in Africa as it allowed customers and potential clients to avoid regulatory hurdles around dollar spending
> Zoho has also been aggressive with its pricing in Africa. Zoho One, a bundle of more than 45 products
This is a major reason why Western products aren't landing as well abroad anymore.
This isn't the 1990s-early 2000s where your only options for software and hardware were Western (in reality only American and maybe a couple niche European vendors).
American companies need to actually localize and build the "cultural competency" muscle, which I feel a lot of Western companies lost by being overly dependent on China as a singular market.
This isn't 1989 anymore - Levi's jeans and Coca Cola don't cut it. Just about every major country is capitalist now.
American brands, technology, and R&D still have a lot of staying power and brand cachet (there's a reason Asian tourists love taking a selfie while touching John Harvard's foot), but there needs to be recognition that the delta between the US and other countries in R&D has drastically shrunk now that countries all over the world are much richer and have adopted American style innovation systems.
Localization and greater openness to foreign innovation will help boost our own products, economy, and soft power.
If we become too insular, then we doom our larger economy to the same mistakes France, Germany, UK, and Japan made.
Sticking to principles like Data Security, Privacy, and concierge Customer Support are legitimate differentiators that can by justified by customers to pay a premium.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rapsey 3y agoFrankly it is simply the US dollar being overvalued. It is making US exports way too expensive for most of the world. Google can't really compete and make any money.
- robertlagrant 3y agoThat is definitely a factor. ZIRP from 2008-2015 and 2020-2022 will do some damage to exports.
- johnchristopher 3y ago> Sticking to principles like Data Security, Privacy, Isn't that something Europe has but the US chose not to (at least regarding computer/ad/tech industry) ?
- alephnerd 3y agoEuropean regulators talk big, but European companies (German+French) have really horrid internal security practices. I don't want to name names as it can affect me professionally, but I would never trust a European (German+French) digital platform developed by one of their traditional conglomerates - even a stereotypically non-technical American F500 like Home Depot has way better technical and security practices than some of the European (German+French) conglomerates I've dealt with. These are organizations where managing ACLs are a brand new practice.
- sofixa 3y agoIf we're sharing anecadata, I've interacted professionally with organisations of all sizes and types (from startups to big banks to public sector) from all around the world, and I strongly disagree. Legacy companies exist everywhere. Big banks with weird "security" practices exist everywhere. There's nothing special about French or German companies' digital security. If anything, they're often better than American ones because there's regulations forcing them to deal with some things like securing private data, meanwhile companies like Equifax can leak everything about everyone and not care in the slightest.
- alephnerd 3y agoI wasn't talking about European financial companies - they're actually pretty decent at security because European financial regulators actually have teeth, and the internal platforms for a Deustche Bank or BNP Paribas are fairly forward facing (or at least as forward facing as very large and old conglomerates can be). The companies I'd be worried about are outside the financial sector. I know it's all anecdotal so we're just randos on the internet yelling at each other, but actual enforcement of European data and security regulations (outside of the financial sector) are minimal, and more critically, very basic platform security practices haven't percolated. That said, I can safely say that Equifax has completely revamped their infra to prevent a leak like the one they previously faced. They had a complete rearchitecture and heads rolled.
- dieulot 3y ago> If we become too insular, then we doom our larger economy to the same mistakes France, Germany, UK, and Japan made. What are those? (Besides Japan’s which you’ve answered here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40143090 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40143090)
- snowpid 3y agoActually Germany's and Japan car industry are more innovative than American one's (and much more sucessfull on the international level)
- alephnerd 3y agoThe exact same mistakes as Japan - deciding to concentrate on their large local market which is protected via tariffs, but then completely outsourcing IP in non-target markets via JVs (eg. Renault's JVs in India, Volkswagen's JVs in China, Dassault and Thales JVs in India, Airbus JVs in China), but also failing to attract enough talent from abroad to innovate in these countries. The Eurozone crisis also completely destroyed Western Europe's competitiveness (like the Asian Financial Crisis and Black Thursday did for Japan). American companies make JVs abroad as well, but will also help transfer promising employees to the US, give them a competitive salary, and sponsor their visa process. If you're smart enough to become a MechE for Dassault in India, you're also smart enough to become a MechE for Ford R&D in the US or India. Going from earning €25k in India to €45-50k in France or Germany isn't worth it, compared to moving to America and earning €90-110k. Germany's automotive industry is a great example of this. In the 1990s-2000s, they began a MASSIVE expansion into China. Chinese consumers ditched their bicycles and motorbikes for the VW Jetta. But while VW continued to concentrate on ICE vehicles, Chinese challenger brands in the 2000s began researching EV technology as they were already the goto suppliers for batteries. Fast forward to today, and now German companies are dependent on Chinese EV R&D in order to build European EV platforms.
- jlangenauer 3y agoThis is not exactly the fault of VW/Renault etc. China has quite explicitly encouraged technology transfer as an important strategic imperative for their local firms, so if these companies wanted to play in the (obviously growing) Chinese market, technology transfer was the price to be paid. (Another example of this is the high-speed trains in China - the first generation was built by JVs with Siemens/Hitachi/etc with an explicit policy of technology transfer, but the newest trains in China are now local, built on top of the technology that has been acquired.)
- infecto 3y agoI am not so sure how much of your post really applies to this scenario. Zoho has been around practically for as long as Salesforce has and they have always been the scrappy bootstrapped company that in my opinion focused on the small to medium sized business. MSFT is at such a large size that tailoring the selling experience to a smaller market does not move the needle enough to make a difference for the business. With ~200x the revenue of Zoho, it just might not make sense to focus on these smaller markets and being aggressive on pricing. American companies do not need to localize or build cultural competency when it does not move the needle for them and I don't think we lost that by being dependent on China. I am not even certain how China comes into play on that front beyond outsourcing of manufacturing and cheap imports. Even for booming new economies like Nigeria, the overall benefit for larger companies is so small that its most likely not worth the effort for them to go down that path.
- alephnerd 3y agoZoho would have been American if Sridhar's visa process wasn't messed up. He used to live in Pleasanton like the rest of the Zoho founders, but they were looking at a multiyear GC backlog, so Sridhar decided to return to India. I'd argue it's one of several pieces that show an issue of insular pigheadedness American institutions have. This was fine when the rest of the world was much poorer than the US, but that delta has shrunk massively. > American companies do not need to localize or build cultural competency when it does not move the needle for them I agree to a certain extent, but there have been plenty of major fumbles in markets with large TAMs (Uber in ASEAN, Ford in India) that if there was a bit more localized market research done, they would have done decently well. Korean, Chinese, Indian, etc companies are increasingly becoming competitive, and American companies cannot rest on their laurels.
- chucke1992 3y agoThe thing is that with India - for example - it is a relatively cheap market and those can afford expensive stuff, but western stuff anyway. Also regarding visa - well there are more indians in the visa queue than probably multiple countries combined. If they make it as fast as other countries - indians will just move in millions and millions simply due to sheer amount of people they have.
- resolutebat 3y agoMany people thought Alicloud would eat AWS/Azure/GCP's lunch in the developing world, since they expanded really fast and priced aggressively. But there's a limit to what even extremely price-conscious customers will accept, and their service quality and support was just not up to scratch. Chinese manufacturers are steadily creeping upmarket though: Haier, BYD, Xiaomi, DJI, Anker etc are all producing increasingly solid hardware with software that's distinctly not great, but tolerable (and certainly good enough to compete with Japan/Korea, who don't exactly shine on this front either).
- alephnerd 3y ago> But there's a limit to what even extremely price-conscious customers will accept, and their service quality and support was just not up to scratch I totally agree! I've worked on Chinese CSPs and they are annoying. IMO they could have been much better, but they are extremely insular and fall into the same trap of lack of localization that I mentioned in my comment.
- insane_dreamer 3y agoThose companies you listed, especially DJI and Anker, are the exception rather than the rule. In my experience living there for 6 years, Chinese companies at all levels tend to cut corners too easily and focus on short-term profits. Very few are capable or willing to put in what it takes to establish a brand that can compete with Western brands. DJI was helped by being in a relatively new market without long-establish brands, Anker to a similar extent (and also produces less expensive products). It's much easier to buy a foreign brand (like Geely with Volvo) than to try to establish your own brand internationally. Even huge companies like BYD, Huawai, and Xiomi (smaller but very popular in China) have not made headway except in less developed countries.
- anal_reactor 3y ago> American companies need to actually localize and build the "cultural competency" Not gonna happen. It's much easier to manage a company that has all-American culture, and American market is the biggest anyway, so it makes sense to focus on it as the priority #1 because that's how you achieve fastest growth. When a local company starts growing too much and threatens your business, you just buy it and allow it to run as a subsidiary. All the money, none of the effort.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Not gonna happen Depending on the market and industry, it's already started. Take a look at Google and Meta's ad buy in India, Brazil, and Indonesia for example. > When a local company starts growing too much and threatens your business, you just buy it and allow it to run as a subsidiary. All the money, none of the effort Some do attempt this (eg. Walmart's acquisition of Flipkart) but it doesn't always succeed. For example, Zoho was an acquisition target of Google and Yahoo back in the day. And most countries have regulators that try to bar this kind of a move for competitive reasons. For example, it was Chinese regulators that crashed Intel's attempt at acquiring Tower, and Broadcom's attempt at acquiring Qualcomm, and there's the whole sordid saga around Carl Ghosn's tenure at Nissan.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _chu1 3y agoI'm completely OK with American brands making Americans their primary target again.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoThis is loser talk.
- eptcyka 3y agoIf you want to grow, you target customers, not Americans or American customers.
- crossroadsguy 3y agoIs it some sort of MATA (with T standing for "Target")?
- jajko 3y agoUS is tiny. Sure, economy is currently a multiplier, but less than 5% of world population lives in US. If you are a bit smart and grok those numbers, you will leave such... non-smart opinions behind, or competition will steam roll you. Or don't, rest of the world deserves some good economical growth too, much more than spoiled west TBH.
- elzbardico 3y agoThe problem is that with giant trade deficits since the the Reagan Era, either Americans scale down their consumption habits by a lot, or America needs to export more. America can't rely on the global appetite for the US dollar and US Treasury Bonds forever to keep consuming what other countries consume. The Petro Dollar is not going anywhere anytime soon, but it definitely has a future expiration date. The global demand for the dollar and US bonds won't disappear tomorrow, but it will cool down somewhere in the future, and thus America can't let go of international markets, unless it wants to downsize a lot. And the problem with Downsizing is that due to the absurd levels of wealth concentration, the middle-class and the poor are really poorly equipped for such a thing. We are not on the 50's and 60's anymore when the US share of the global GDP was almost half of it, if we measure it using PPP, it is only about 15%, less than China. America can't just rest on its laurels, it needs to be globally competitive.
- high_na_euv 3y agoNot only currency, but Albo outdated payment methods like credit card or PayPal only? What?? Srsly? What about other robust methods like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blik https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blik
- StefanBatory 3y agoThe price of being first - you are much slower to make any new changes. I'm Polish, our internet infrastructure is miles better than German. Paying via phone is norm. Were I cross the German border, I'd think it's a museum. But we didn't do anything particularly right. We just could implement our infrastructure on the newest ideas, while for Germany they're stuck with what they had as pioneers.
- itikasp 3y agoHello alephnerd, Loved reading your insights. I am one of the editors of this story, and I was surprised when the reporters told me that most other tools (Google and Microsoft) did not allow African entrepreneurs to pay in local currencies. That does seem like something that can be easily fixed, if there's will. Here's hoping that all global companies make the playing field even for all global entrepreneurs.
- alephnerd 3y agoMy hunch is Zoho is using Razorpay (YC W15) internally for payments. A company like GOOG can't justify using a product like Razorpay that is directly competing with internal platforms. > That does seem like something that can be easily fixed It's a very hard problem due to KYC, AML, and a multitude of other compliance and legal headaches. That's why Stripe and Razorpay can justify multi-billion dollar valuations.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> A company like GOOG can't justify using a product like Razorpay that is directly competing with internal platforms. This does seem silly, though, even though it's probably already obvious to say. If they want to build something, and why not, build an integrating service over the top of that one and the internal ones, and figure out how to select the one to use based on the currency/location/etc.
- alephnerd 3y agoNo company ever pays a competitor. It's partially for financial reasons (why should I pay you to undermine my lead) as well as competitive (the competitor can extrapolate our own internal trends, and then potentially use it against us in competitive deals). This is why Walmart is famous for forcing every single one of it's vendors not use Amazon services in a Walmart related SKU (eg. If I'm selling a SaaS to Walmart, I either need to migrate the Walmart portion to GCP or Azure, or not get the Walmart contract).
- 3y ago
- derelicta 3y agoWhat mistake did Japan make btw?
- tuyljhoiuu0u78 3y ago[flagged]
- addicted 3y agoOnly made them a top 5 economy with a tiny population, few natural resources and little to no land. Sounds like being a U.S. vassal state is an excellent place to be. Which is actually truer than one may think. Most U.S. “vassal states” do excellently, including much of Europe, Israel, Saudi Arabia, etc. The primary reason behind that is they are not vassal states. The U.S. doesn’t have vassal states (outside of maybe Puerto Rico) and yes it has expectations of its allies but those are surprisingly low compared to even the shitties states to be vassals of. Compare what the U.S. expects of Saudi Arabia or Japan (what impositions does it place?) to what Russia expects of its vassal states (many of which it has literally taken over by force), or China (look at what China is doing to BRI countries like Pakistan and Sri Lanka…hollowing their economy out and getting paid for the privilege…) or even India (which has gone on an all out economic war against Mauritius because a couple of clowns in their government said something they didn’t like). Heck, even to the extent China or India are succeeding economically it’s because of the U.S. economic ties. China is almost entirely built by American investment over the past few decades. And even the subject of this specific story, Zoho, part of the Indian IT ecosystem, is entirely a result of US economic partnership starting in the 90s. It’s not an exaggeration to say that American “vassal statehood” is literally the only path to economic success and prosperity since WW2.
- patrickaljord 3y agoThe recent decline of Japan caused by American restrictions and vassalization is well documented, same for Germany.
- 3y ago