17 ms·
Tell HN: Ever think of applying to YC? Do it this weekend for S24
(Usually I put an "Apply to YC" thing in the HN footer [1] but I forgot this time, so here is my pitch to make up for it.)
If you've ever thought about applying to YC, here's a tip: just do it. It doesn't take long and could change your life, like it did for me and many others.
In particular, if you have either of these two bogus thoughts, ignore them pronto and just go to https://apply.ycombinator.com https://apply.ycombinator.com and apply:
(1) "probably not good enough / won't get in" - you'd be surprised at how many people feel that way, whether because of impostor syndrome, lack of credentials, whatever—and often they turn out to be among the best founders. So this a terrible reason not to apply!
The nice thing is, it's YC's job to evaluate that, not yours. They're looking for aptitude which doesn't look like what most people (probably including you) assume. You needn't look impressive, and you don't have to be a competent founder—you learn that from doing YC. Just be yourself as you are, fill out the application and don't worry about it.
(2) "too early" - there's no such thing. YC looks for good potential founders—meaning anyone who can learn what they teach—and nothing else. You're already yourself, which is all you need.
Some of YC's big successes start off as last-minute applications on a whim; and many start with totally different ideas than what ends up succeeding. It's YC's job to teach you how to play the startup game, and that can start at any time.
("Too far along already" is another bogus notion but I'll stick with the top 2 for today.)
If you know the game Snakes and Ladders [2], YC is a massive ladder in an area where there are no snakes. Sure it's a dice roll, but what reason do you have not to? If you're uninterested in the game, no problem—but if you have any impulse to participate, do it! If you're the "out of nowhere" type of founder YC loves to fund, your chances are likely a lot better than you imagine.
Apply by 8pm PT on Monday 4/22 to get a decision by May 29: https://apply.ycombinator.com https://apply.ycombinator.com.
---
[1] like last October - https://web.archive.org/web/20231011022307/https://news.ycombinator.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231011022307/https://news.ycom...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakes_and_ladders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakes_and_ladders
- Areibman 3y agoWe got rejected (2nd time applying) and ended up raising a substantial seed/pre-seed round at excellent terms a month later. Is there a compelling reason to still apply?
- selfie 3y agoThat means nothing though. If you (N=1) apply to Google and get rejected but take a Facebook job, it doesn't mean people shouldn't apply to Google.
- Areibman 3y agoIt was a question more for us than general public. I think YC is probably the best first check you can get since they invest in companies with nothing more than an idea.
- dang 3y agoThe compelling reason to apply would be that going through YC can increase your value by more than 1.07 or whatever number represents break-even on the standard deal. Whether that's true of your startup or not I can't say, but I do know that lots of founders go through YC after raising seed rounds because they're answering that question with a yes.
- jacobobryant 3y agoI applied 9 times and never got an interview. I've moved on from entrepreneurship (for now?), but would love to know what percentile I'm in for consecutive rejections as a consolation prize ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Y_Y 3y agoYou would say that, wouldn't you?
- dang 3y agoYes, I'm super interested in reaching people for whom YC would be a great fit, but who don't apply because they doubt themselves. Partly because that's been such a big part of my own experience.
- Y_Y 3y agoMy original comment was really meant playfully, I don't think there's any reason to doubt your good intentions. Like many jokes though, there was a grain of earnest feeling there. To be totally pretentious about it, take Koan 16 from The Gateless Gate > Ummon asked: "The world is such a wide world, why do you answer a bell and don ceremonial robes?" If I could rephrase that to "tech startups are so hot, how come you moderate/lurk a forum and just talk about entrepreneurship instead of doing it?", I like to ask it you Dan, or anyone else who thinks YC is cool but isn't quitting their day job to pitch their moonshot.
- winwang 3y agoGoing through the application helps provide clarity to the founders themselves as well.
- spxneo 3y agoyou need to graduate from the "right school/alumni" and i would discourage anybody else from wasting their time
- dang 3y agoThat's definitely not true (I wouldn't be here if it were), and it's mistaken assumptions like this that I'm hoping my post can nudge some people out of. If you noticed any of these phrases in what I wrote: "lack of credentials", "needn't look impressive", "doesn't look like", "nothing else", "out of nowhere", "you're already yourself"...that's why I put all those in there. Edit: oh and "impostor syndrome" of course.
- spxneo 3y agoyou are an outlier and the stuff you wrote is marketing fluff
- HaZeust 3y agoAs much as the YC app is gamed (based on winning applications I've seen from friends and strangers), alumnist is only one piece of the puzzle of a few.
- spxneo 3y agoim not saying you have to graduate from ivy league to get into YC but bulk majority of people in YC are. they are almost always going to favour people from their own league. im basing this off people who are coming from YC and telling me how it is. some folks applied to YC in the past, get rejected and then find some Harvard graduate running with their ideas they submitted.
- willsmith72 3y agoisn't this just correlation vs causation? 2 people submit the same idea. 1 gets in, the other doesn't. yc, basing their decision on the founder themselves and not so much the idea, chose person 1, who had more of the founder characteristics (determination, ... i forget the rest). maybe there's a higher chance that between 2 people, 1 from harvard 1 not, the harvard person has those characteristics. could be they "learnt" it there, or they had to use those same skills to even get into harvard, or whatever. but it doesn't mean they got in because of the harvard degree apply that same logic of thousands of people, maybe it looks like they prefer harvard candidates.
- ipsum2 3y agoCurious about the story behind applying to YC as a founder and ending up as a moderator for hacker news.
- dang 3y agoStartup in W09, worked on it for 4 years, started saying no to pg about moderating HN, ran out of money, needed a job, said yes to pg about moderating HN.
- speps 3y agoSeems like it was a needed option for you at the time. Are you still enjoying it? Waiting for someone to take the baton?
- tptacek 3y agoYou all talk about the work Dan does moderating this place, which, fair enough, but "Launch HN" is low key one of the coolest jobs in startups. The before/after on what those launch posts become after Dan gets involved would knock you out. A sibling comment asked him what his comp was (which is very funny) but it's a question with a simple answer: whatever he's getting, it's probably not enough.
- jedberg 3y ago> whatever he's getting, it's probably not enough. I mean, all YC employees get to participate in the fund, so he's got a small piece of every YC startup, including the ones that he helps with Launch HN. So in a sense he has a lot more control over his comp than most employees.
- elevatedastalt 3y agoHow much are you paid for this job? Is this your only source of income?
- toomuchtodo 3y ago
- datascienced 3y agoAnother (is this bogus?) reason for not applying is I am not in the US and would prefer not to migrate there due to family. Can a founder do YC with minimal time in USA or even do it remotely.
- dang 3y agoThe last I heard (but my information may be out of date), that remains an option.
- threeseed 3y agoYou don't need to migrate to the US. But I believe you do need to be there with your co-founders for 3 months. And if you can't manage that then running a VC backed startup isn't what you should do. Because you will need to visit customers and it's often not feasible to just fly to/from constantly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ant6n 3y agoWhat if all my customers are in Europe?
- jasperstory 3y agoYC is leaning into in-person heavily. But e.g. there was a great team in our batch (W24) with very young kids who flew to SF for in-person events. Some people were unable to come to the US (visa issues) that took part remotely. No requirement to intend to stay in the US – many foreign teams heading back, but many more haven chosen to stay in SF on O1 and other visas (YC helps with this). I think YC admissions see the intention to be based in SF as a net positive, because SF is in most situations the very best place to start a startup (regardless of YC).
- outop 3y agoIt would be nice to be told roughly what the process is before having to 'sign up'.
- dang 3y agoYou're already signed up, because you can use your HN account to log in. (All YC accounts are HN accounts and vice versa.) The process is that you fill out a form and make a 1 minute video* and click 'submit'. (* I know...I hated the video thing too... but it gives a sense of what someone is like that doesn't come through in text, and you just talk for a minute about what you care about. nothing fancy.) (edit: also, if you're the type of founder that my post is trying to reach - the video is very much in your interest. Other people can see potential in you that you don't see in yourself, even after just a minute. Especially because the people reviewing applications have massive amounts of experience with this.)
- ssroovy 3y agoVideo is fine(it's just a minute), but why LinkedIn URL is required(not optional)? LinkedIn is about education, career, and networking. I am under average in all of them, so I'm not registered. This is the only thing which holding me back from applying. Otherwise, I work full-time on kick-ass product for months with 1000+ commits.
- dang 3y agoYeah I can't believe that either. Can you imagine pg being on LinkedIn? Never in a million years. I'm trying to find out who to talk to about this.
- OJFord 3y agoJust enter some kind of dummy text/fake profile URL that indicates you don't have an account? I can't imagine it's seriously a hard requirement; you creating a basically empty account now just to be able to provide a real URL isn't better than 'N/A'.
- snowmaker 3y ago
- estebarb 3y agoMakes sense to apply just with less than a MVP?
- dang 3y agoYes - there's no such thing as 'too early'. Of course if you've been working for a while, you should certainly show what you've made so far. If you consider the rather common case of a YC application where the founders (1) have been working on X, (2) get into YC, (3) eventually drop X, and (4) eventually find something else that goes better...you're essentially skipping to step (4). (Not that the analogy holds in every way, but it does for "should you apply" purposes.)
- ketanmaheshwari 3y agoI wanted to sell samosa on the internet. Would YC be a good place to seek funding for such a business? Samosa because they are versatile across many dimensions: ingredients, taste, shelf-life, and can be easily made in a combinatorics space of these dimensions. They are kind of like how Bubba describes shrimp to Gump. I once wondered if YC is a good platform for such a business?
- dang 3y agoYC is a good platform for founders who want to build a high-growth startup (which is basically the original pg/YC definition of what a startup is). So your question reduces to whether selling samosas on the internet can be a high-growth business or not, and whether you would want to optimize for that.
- all2 3y agoWe have specialized samosa delivery drones and utilize existing shipping and storage infrastructure. Our samosas are "just add water!" variety and are appropriate for a variety of events and occasions! Weddings, parties, wedding parties, parties with incidental weddings, pizza and beer and samosas, Netflix and chill, and so much more! ... I started with a pitch and it became a late night commercial.
- lappet 3y agoholy moly, if you setup a kickstarter for this, a bajillion desis would support it. curious though, are they going to be frozen samosas?
- ketanmaheshwari 3y agoThey could be three types on that dimension: 1. Freshly made and delivered locally on hourly scale; 2. Take and bake or fry perhaps same day; and 3. Frozen for longer term. I find that desis and non-desis alike are samosa fans.
- anon115 3y agohmmmm maybe i should make a video game with yall? its enticing meow idk
- datascienced 3y agoAnother question (as a seperate comment incase dang is replying to the other one): This is the equity deal: https://www.ycombinator.com/deal https://www.ycombinator.com/deal What if I don’t want to raise any more than the 7% (which in itself is $125k I don’t really need but happy to give 7% for the higher P(success)) What if I want to bootstrap from that point or at least keep options open?
- tptacek 3y agoMy understanding is: it's fine. You're not required to do follow-on financing. Perceived preferred access to the market for syndicated convertible rounds is a big reason people do YC, though, so I think most people do end up raising.
- dang 3y agotptacek answered your question, but here's a rule for answering similar questions in the future: YC supports what founders choose. That's partly because it's the DNA of the organization (whose origins go back to a time when founders were much lower on the startup totem pole than they are today) and partly because it's a losing bet to do anything else (which is related).
- scoofy 3y agoThis is my biggest worry. I'd like to get some help building my stupid golf wiki (which I actually think is an extremely profitable long-term venture), but I'm desperately trying to build something that is good for golf, which is a space notoriously saturated with bad actors. I'm honestly even considering going in a not-for-profit direction eventually, so the idea of applying for a bit of VC money honestly hard to square, but the connections would be what's valuable.
- Grustaf 3y agoKeep in mind that if you never raise again, YC still owns 7% so they have no reason to complain. If you're successful, 500k for 7% will have been a good deal.
- SeanAnderson 3y agoYou know, I wasn't going to submit anything, but now I am. I'll almost assuredly get rejected for my half-baked idea, but hey, might as well try. Thanks for the reminder.
- dang 3y agoThat's the spirit :) But I can't count the number of times I've heard about YC saying 'we don't think it's a great idea, but we like the founders'. YC funds founders, that's the whole deal. It's hard for many people to believe this because it sounds too simple and it's counterintuitive in all kinds of ways.
- SeanAnderson 3y agohttps://docs.google.com/document/d/1H2sRRzQHwJX8JAgXUS0vyhZgH_7TjlglFen7XP7sy_I/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H2sRRzQHwJX8JAgXUS0vyhZg... I finished writing up my response. Still need to do the video tomorrow. Like I said, I'm positive this just isn't compelling enough, but hey it was fun answering all the q's :)
- SeanAnderson 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0jLIYKko4U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0jLIYKko4U and here's my 1 min video if anyone is following along :D
- _akhe 3y agoRe: "won't get in" How do I balance this encouraging advice with everything I've heard online about YC basically being a post-Ivy League thing? Seems like there's basically a 0% chance a random person would get into YC. And often those who did get in went to Stanford, Harvard, etc. and don't even have a product - sometimes they don't even know what they're going to build yet. I wrote the idea of VC stuff off long ago. My wife and I have a profitable business here in SF that would be perfect as a startup, but the concept of raising funds to expand literally hasn't even crossed our minds because it seems so geared toward post-grads - like something only Stanford and Harvard people get access to after they graduate. Not only that, we're profitable, and can even articulate a realistic vision about how it becomes the next $100M household name, but the numbers I've read online that most VCs want to see are not realistic - or if we were hitting those numbers I wouldn't even need a VC, we would be able to fund our own expansion. So we're just doing it on our own.
- alephnerd 3y ago> YC basically being a post-Ivy League thing I have a lot of friends of mine who are decade+ YoE first time founders who have done very very well in YC. Lots of Enterprise SaaS companies have went thru YC and done very well - you just don't hear about them as much because Direct Enterprise Sales doesn't require as much marketing. There are similar B2C successes by older founders and non-Ivy/Ivy Tier founders. > we're profitable, and can even articulate a realistic vision about how it becomes the next $100M household name You could easily pitch a Seed or Pre-Seed round depending on the numbers and location right now. I guarantee you that you are a 2nd or 3rd degree connect with plenty of VCs. Leverage that network you have and doors will open The YC label does help to open doors if you don't know or don't have the network to do it. (Note: this advice is US centric)
- tempsy 3y agoHow many years do you have to go back to find 1 company that is on par with a dropbox or airbnb i feel like if you went back 5 years it would be hard to even find more than 1-2 companies that has achieved a moderate level of mainstream success in the same way
- dzink 3y agoThe market is tanking again and interest rates may go up and or continue into next year. YC graduates are expected to present and raise their seed rounds around Demo Day in 3-4 months. Raising any kind of money sets an interest rate that you pay with your equity % to investors (at high interest rates they expect to own more equity as time goes by.) What are the current fundraising terms you guys see for YC startups because the timing looks dicey for this cycle? NVDA just tanked 10% today and with it a whole bunch of AI valuations. Did YC startups from in the 2022 batches see positives or negatives? What is the upside to fundraising in the next few months vs waiting for a better environment? If we have a startup and it’s profitable, does it make sense to apply it to wait?
- dang 3y agoNot only do I not know the answers, I am so devoid of such knowledge that you would find it hilarious. But from my perspective (FWIW) it's all sort of optimizing for the wrong thing. If you want to do a startup, YC is such a force multiplier that none of these details matter in the end. I do know that one reason the YC deal is far larger than it used to be is to give founders resilience against market ups and downs. You get a lot of runway now.
- andrewstuart 3y agoWho cares? Your deepest motivation should be to build something amazing that people want to use, to create a great business, to have fun, to go on a great adventure. If stock market performance plays a major role in your decision to start a business or raise capital then perhaps your motivations might need a rethink.
- dzink 3y agoIt doesn’t in mine, but it does in the VC’s who are investing in YC startups - making them and their LPs a lot less patient due to increased cost of capital for the whole industry.
- im_down_w_otp 3y agoVCs care. The way they make decisions has changed wildly in different ways multiple times within just the last 5 years. There’s a very good argument to be made that they shouldn’t care and that their investment theses should be more stable as well as their criteria, but that’s an academic argument that doesn’t do a whole lot for the founders who have been attempting to fundraise amid those varied VC spasms.
- bennyp101 3y agoDo you need an MVP or an idea? US or international?
- sturgill 3y agoI’ve always been intrigued by YC, but the commitment to relocate is hard to justify. I have three kids (with the oldest finishing up her junior year next month). So I’m not in a place where being in SF for the summer works very well for the family. I remember during COVID that there was a remote option, but I don’t believe that’s available now. So for someone more established (erm, no longer 20) that lives in the middle of the country, I’m not sure it’s a great fit. But man am I interested… I can never quite tell myself “no” and move on either… I’d love to be wrong. Because I’ve got a great one cooking right now!…
- paxys 3y agoFor better or worse, the relocation requirement is probably a good proxy for "can commit to their startup 24x7 without any other responsibilities standing in the way".
- mlhpdx 3y agoMaybe, but that’d be playing into a tired stereotype.
- dangus 3y agoThat sounds like a system that leaves out a lot of people who might be better at starting and running companies than the persona willing to throw their family in the garbage for their company. A startup founder who is 40 years old is 2.1x more likely to start a successful venture than a 25-year-old. [1] The kind of people who tend to have kids and families. And it’s kind of pathetic for an industry that’s supposed to be creating innovations like spatial computing, augmented reality, and fully remote companies to be unable to set up an online school. [1] https://www.founderjar.com/startup-statistics/ https://www.founderjar.com/startup-statistics/
- mdekkers 3y agoThat’s nonsense. Startups are only for the young and unencumbered? I’ve had several successful startups and managed to combine that with a family life as well as time off for R&R and mentally recharging. If this is your belief, I strongly advise you to reconsider your life choices and priorities
- aliljet 3y agoI've long had a bet that these posts contain lurking single founders looking for potential co-founders. So, if you are on the prowl for a jack-of-all engineering founder, shoot me a note. I'd love to see if you might be all-in on what I've got going on or vice versa. Here's building awesome stuff with awesome teams.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sosodev 3y ago"in an area where there are no snakes" Surely that isn't true, right? I'll point out the obvious truth that this funding model encourages businesses that are boom or bust. That seems like a big snake to me. Bust is like taking a snake all the way back to square 1.
- Animats 3y agoWhat happened? Not enough people applied? Here's the last batch.[1] Gives a sense of what's being funded. Ideas: - MoneyNow - leverages the new FedNow instant payment system. FedNow is run by the Fed and transfers money in seconds with a charge of just US$0.045 per transaction. And they mean seconds. If the money isn't there in 10 seconds, the transaction times out. Few banks support it yet, but some do. It needs consumer-facing support. The Fed just does the back end. There's a big security problem with consumer side payments - these are irrevocable no-holds transfers, like cash. Figure out how to handle that. Competes with Venmo and PayPal; could make them obsolete. Venmo isn't really instant; try to withdraw the money you just "received". - Reading Teacher - teach illiterate kids to read with a phone app using AI. Text to speech and speech to text all work now. A true automatic reading teacher should be possible. Gamify it so kids use it. Sell to parents, not schools. - Rust Game Engine - the Rust language ecosystem has some game engines and libraries that almost work, but the open source maintainers got bored and didn't finish the job. Modest amounts of cash would push that over the top. Monetize by selling back-end services for such games. [1] https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/?batch=W24 https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/?batch=W24
- dang 3y agoNo idea how many people applied but I'm sure there's no lack - I just felt bad for forgetting to put the usual footer at the bottom a month ago. And I worry about the comments I see on HN interpreting YC as just for credentialed-elite applicants. It's deeply not true and I have a personal feeling about the question - being one of the uncredentialed-unelite-self-doubting types who could have been dissuaded from applying if I had been reading comments like that instead of pg's essays at the time.
- juped 3y agoThis is just an empirical question, right? What are the proportions of credentialed elites among all applicants and successful applicants? If this number is surprising, it would mean a lot more to people than any amount of insistence.
- JohnTHaller 3y ago
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoOK. I finally gave it a shot. But https://apply.ycombinator.com/bio/edit https://apply.ycombinator.com/bio/edit is broken. So I can't submit my application. Not interested now. You guys need to fix your website.
- dqh 3y agoAre you sure it is in your interest to give up at the first hurdle?
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoI think a firm with 600b in equity can fix an html form.
- dutchbrit 3y agoLet’s say I have an idea but it’s a niche, I know it won’t be more than ~1M in yearly revenue at its best. What is interesting for YC and what not when it comes to potential size?
- dang 3y agoYC's in the business of high-growth startups. You don't have to know how to build a high-growth startup—YC partners are experts in teaching and helping founders to do that. But if you're sure you don't want a high-growth startup, that might mean it's not a good fit. However, your question is trickier than it seems because so many major startups begin as 'toy' or 'niche': https://paulgraham.com/altair.html https://paulgraham.com/altair.html. If you make something people want, there are often ways for it to grow—and perhaps grow big—that aren't obvious at first. The Airbnb founders stuck for a long time with their 'airbed' idea before making the obvious-in-retrospect (but not at the time) leap to a much larger market.
- chenxi9649 3y agoI think one thing that people don't realize is that the YC application process is really one of the best tools for "sharpening" your idea/business. The written applications forces you to articulate your ideas in a concise yet easy to understand way. And as much as YC doesn't recommend this, the mock YC interviews we did with alums was one of those most beneficial things that happened to us. Because so rarely will you get the opportunity to ask dozens of other YC founders to grill your business, and have 80%+ of them say yes. We did about 30 at the time, which is a lot of time to be taken off product/building, hence probably why they don't recommend it, but looking back it *really helped us understand our own business. Given how young/naive/early we were.
- s1k3s 3y ago> I think one thing that people don't realize is that the YC application process is really one of the best tools for "sharpening" your idea/business. I'm seeing this a lot through the comments but I have to ask, why is it? Do people just not think about how their product will make money, who the competition is or how are they going to get customers?
- anamax 3y ago> Do people just not think about how their product will make money, who the competition is or how are they going to get customers? The short answer is "yes, people don't think about those things." The longer answer is that they think that they've thought about those things, but in reality, they put more thought into what they had for dinner last night than they did into those things.
- chenxi9649 3y agoAt least for me at the time, I knew nothing about start ups. Didn't come from a prestigious school. Nor the bay or even US. Didn't work in big tech. The closest thing was that I was studying EE. Honest it was quite inspiring to chat with these founders who were in a different world, and realizing that they're not all that different from myself. So yea, maybe I was young dumb n broke.
- 3y ago
- wg0 3y agoYC is totally a non starter for non US aspirants and it's not YC's fault. Best case scenario - you end up having a company that's registered in US, would be paying taxes in US when it comes to that but you yourself wouldn't be allowed to set foot on the US soil, and even if that, would be shuttling for visa renewals every now and then.
- dang 3y agoThere are tons of international startups in YC including many successful ones. And YC has well over a decade of experience helping international founders navigate all the barriers including visa issues. Don't let this stop you! Edit: I want to emphasize this. Being an international founder is not an obstacle for getting into YC. Hundreds of founders have done it, from all over the world. Probably thousands at this point.
- elbasti 3y agoNot a YC founder, but this is factually not true. YC allows Delaware, Cayman, Canada, and Singapore corporations [0]. Pre-empting the accusation that "cayman companies are about tax dodging": Cayman companies are a great fit for heavily international businesses that do not reside in the USA, but that want to be governed as if they were, because cayman corporate law is basically delaware's. A good example is Nubank, which is a cayman corp that does most of it's business in LatAm. The reason a company like this should not be a delaware c-corp is so that, in case of an acquisition of the companies assets, the holding company doesn't have to pay usa taxes (which is reasonable, since the company didn't have usa operations to begin with). [0]: https://www.ycombinator.com/deal https://www.ycombinator.com/deal
- bcye 3y agoThese are still incredibly limited options for locating your company.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- hi 3y agoRejected nine times.
- reducesuffering 3y agoWhat’s the acceptance rate, 1%, most with cofounders? So if you’re making a video by yourself it’s like 1/500 ? Seems like a better use of time making a video and filling out the app once you have above average team and traction.
- dang 3y agoYou don't need traction. Team is good because having a cofounder is statistically such a huge success factor. But YC does found solo founders, and you shouldn't make a team just to make your application look better - I'm pretty sure doing that would weaken your chances.
- tempusalaria 3y agoI was under the impression that this idea of cofounders being a huge statistical success factor was pretty much just a myth. Moreover, all reasons given by YC as to why you should have a cofounder are qualitative e.g. https://www.ycombinator.com/library/8h-how-to-find-the-right-co-founder#:~:text=So%20let's%20start%20by%20talking,divide%20the%20work%20up%20with https://www.ycombinator.com/library/8h-how-to-find-the-right.... Would love to see the statistical evidence because if anything it seems to be the other way round and this is pretty much just reflective of YC’s personal preference as it were (and many VCs prefer otherwise). Personally I would only advise someone to take on a cofounder if they already know them well and need their skill set. There is so much risk in a poor fit that it far outweighs any theoretical benefit.
- dang 3y agoI don't have citations for you but I don't think it's anything like a "personal preference" - YC has tons of data on this. But it's fine to apply as a solo founder—many do get funded; and you're quite right—the risk of picking a wrong cofounder is also high and is not something one should do lightly (e.g. just to try to improve a YC application).
- tempusalaria 3y ago
- yaseer 3y agoAs a long time HN reader, eventually participating in YCW21, the main thing i would like to highlight is there's so many misconceptions about YC on HN. It would take too long to refute them all, but just remember the HN readerships' view of YC is pretty distorted. ("it's all about VC money" , "it's just for ivy league grads" etc). I could go on, but just read Paul Graham's essays - that's probably the best way to understand how YC thinks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dt3ft 3y agoI’d love to apply, but I’m building FlingUp.com and there is no chance in hell anyone would ever want to fund a lone founder hacking on this project when the kids have gone to sleep.
- ultimoo 3y agoBig fan of YC and pg. I'm waiting for some immigration related things to fall into place before I apply, but it's been several years. Potentially crass question: what is the age or industry experience distribution of a typical YC batch these days? Would a founding team in their early 40s be dinosaurs in a room full of young stars? Asking for a friend.
- ucarion 3y agoI was in the last batch. The average is probably ~28 years old, but there are plenty of founding teams in their 40s and on. Plenty of folks with families. You wouldn't be a dinosaur. Apply.
- NickInSF 3y agoI had the same question. Most YC founders seem to be new college graduates instead of seasoned FAANG folks. I'm in the latter camp and believe I'm better off leveraging my connections because I've aged out of YC.
- dilyevsky 3y agoCo-founder and I are “seasoned FAANG” folks. We went through YC last summer. It’s true - many founders are on younger side, but a good number seemed (i didn’t actually card anyone) to be same age as us and we didn’t feel out of place. Would recommend.
- rapfaria 3y agoI wonder if there is any rules now for funded folks coming to one's linkedin saying "Hey, thank you so much for starring {{insert here YC-AI repo}} on github, that means a lot" when one's never even heard about them before.
- dang 3y agoI don't know but that sounds bad.
- giantg2 3y agoI have a #3 - I don't have a marketable idea.
- dang 3y agoYou don't need a marketable idea. YC cares about founders and that's it. Everything else can be taught. But you're absolutely right that that is on the short list of bogus reasons not to apply.
- giantg2 3y agoWell then I have the real version of #1 - I have no meaningful skills. I have enough problems that I can't even see myself as a founder, stuff like lack of soft skills from a disability and massive home responsibilities.
- radix7 3y ago>You don't need a marketable idea Seems like most of the application is describing your idea.
- dang 3y agoMany of them turn out not to be marketable, though, and that doesn't necessarily count against you. It's not the high-order bit—the high order bit is the founders. Ideas can and do change.
- eggbrain 3y agoI'm going to post something vulnerable, but I hope people take my comment in the right light, as in general I love YC and what it has done for the startup community. I've been building startups for a long time, and have applied to YC several times, mainly with the same idea (although I've always listed 4-5 other ideas I'm interested in as well). I have always gotten rejected, and while that was disappointing, I 100% understood that getting into YC was the exception rather than the rule, as YC had a smaller acceptance percentage than Harvard. After a few batches of these rejections, I decided to take a break from applying and instead build up my startup experience more by working at growth-stage startups, and just in general started focusing on my career as well. Fast forward a few years, and about a year ago YC reaches out to me (via automated email) saying they had identified me as being in the top X% on the Cofounder matching platform, and encouraged me to apply to their next batch cycle. I was reluctant to do so -- I hadn't been thinking too deeply about any new startup ideas in the past few months (so I'd most likely have to apply with a previous startup I had built), but after encouragement from friends and family I decided to take a chance anyways and apply once again. I went all out on the application -- I reached out to some YC friends and mentors to get their recommendations, and had them help me edit and perfect my application as well. I even traveled for a month to San Francisco, just so I could absorb more of the ecosystem, network with as many entrepreneurs as possible, and help give back to the community if I could. I submitted my application, waited for the fateful "interview email" day, and when that day came -- I got the standard "...we're sorry, we're not going to move forward with your application". I'll admit -- getting that email stung. I know looking back there were a lot of things I could have done better (e.g. not applying with the same idea as previous applications, among other things), and just like when I applied years ago, I knew that the chances of getting to the interview stage were slim to none. But yet somehow, that rejection hurt more than any of the others.
- sevagh 3y agoSorry to hear that experience. I've come to discount any form of flattery in intro emails. E.g. when a FAANG recruiter emails me "wow, we were impressed by your public project!", I used to believe it. Now I know it's just a synonym for "join the back of the line of 17,639,838 applicants."
- technoabsurdist 3y agoDo you guys still offer deferred admissions for juniors who wish to join a batch after graduation?
- dang 3y agoI just asked and this is what I got back: (1) if you're sure you want to complete your senior year, just wait till then to apply; (2) if you're not sure, apply now; (3) there's not currently any process for people who want to apply to batches farther out than the next one. I suppose (1) and (2) follow from (3) but there you go :) Either way, good luck and please do apply when you're ready!
- technoabsurdist 3y agoawesome, thank you so much.
- solumos 3y agoCan you give a recent example of a number 1? The problem I see is that a a piece of advice that got thrown out on twitter was "We applied without an idea and we got in, here's how we did it!" and the advice ends up being along the lines of "We didn't know what else to do, so we reached out to our Penn alumni network and got a referral"
- wizcaps 3y agoRe the “won’t get in” point.. We applied a few years ago. I won’t lie, I was sad and disappointed we didn’t get in, but even more so because our application was just ignored. Left a very bad taste in our mouths. I won’t again spend days on an application to have it be ignored. Since then, we have been grinding away at the same business and it’s now making 7 figures, giving us the perfect life of a 20% YoY growth business with no VCs breathing down our necks trying to 10x that growth rate. Not taking VC money was the best thing we ever did, albeit inadvertently. So sure, you won’t get in (statistically), but it could be the best thing you ever don’t do!
- tptacek 3y agoI spent most of the last 20 years in bootstrapped companies, helping grow two of them into 8 figures (which, when you don't have a board, is pretty neat). Bootstrapping is where my heart is, and almost all of the best memories of my career are from times when those kinds of companies were at the knife's edge of maybe having some kind of market fit and maybe just starting to have an identity and maybe just getting up on their legs. If that's your happy place --- again: it is mine! --- probably don't apply to YC. I'm at a company now (Fly.io, W20) that simply would not make sense without funding (we rack hardware all over the world). I've advised close friends through other startups that might could have worked without funding, but worked better with it. I've seen the before/after on YC, years into the life of some companies (Fly.io started in 2016) and the win was significant. It depends on what you're trying to do. But like, pretty obviously, the point Dan is trying to make here is that there are lots of people negotiating against themselves, talking themselves out of taking the swing. And I'm not all that great at business or whatever, but one thing I think I've learned is that overriding the instinct not to take swings, succumbing to the urge to avoid potential nociception, it's a pretty important tool in the toolbox of entrepreneurship. There are good reasons not to apply to YC, but "they will probably reject me" is maybe not one of them, unless your time is very scarce, in which case you probably already know why you're not applying to YC.
- nubela 3y agoYou don't need YC to raise funds.
- maxrumpf 3y agoThe weirdest thing people do is make up criteria that YC supposedly uses to reject people. There was such a huge diversity in our batch: From 20 y/o to 40+. Foreign, domestic. Credentialed, not credentialed. $1M rev run rate, $0 run rate. Just apply.
- reagan83 3y agoThis comment scares me that YC is desperate for applications now after burning through so many early stage founders for years. Has YC peaked?
- tosh 3y agoAlso: reading through the questions in the application form and thinking about them is worth it even if you don't intend to apply.
- jondwillis 3y agois it still no co-founder no go?
- dang 3y agoOh YC definitely funds solo founders (and always has - Dropbox was one famous example, and Renderlet is one that comes to mind from this recent thread - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39907845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39907845). See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40092556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40092556. The way I understand it is: cofounder is preferred because it's so much harder without one; solo founder is second choice; worst is pairing up with a cofounder you don't really know because you think you're supposed to.
- sovnwnt 3y ago> Upload a founder video Yeah definitely not. No thank you. It's a great filter though. I am exactly the type of person who you don't want to see a video of, and therefore perfectly unsuited for YCombinator/SV/etc. which are all about personality.
- dang 3y agoI totally get it as video is anathema to me too, but I think you're drawing exactly the wrong conclusion. YC doesn't care about any social commonplaces (personality, dress, etc.). They just want a sense of who you are as a potential founder. A lot of what might be considered 'negatives' in more conventional contexts aren't negative at all in the YC context, and might actually help an application. p.s. YC is definitely not "all about personality" - I don't know where you got that idea, but the spectrum of YC founders is about as wide as you could get that way. There are extraverted outgoing types and introverted awkward types and pretty much everyone else too.
- sovnwnt 3y agoYou make a compelling argument as usual. Even with all the questions, it's not a lot of effort, you're right. I apply for the diversity visa every year and that's more work for maybe, oh about the same chance of success? > I don't know where you got that idea Admittedly I haven't seen a large percentage, but of the founders I've seen speak, all of them had a certain charm. Granted, there's a bias where people with these personalities put themselves out to be seen.
- dang 3y ago> but of the founders I've seen speak, all of them had a certain charm. Granted, there's a bias where people with these personalities put themselves out to be seen. Correct, and also, people change over time as they learn and become more comfortable in a role. The difference in some founders' confidence even between the start and end of a YC batch (only 3 months) can be striking. That isn't true of everyone, of course, and it's fine if it's not.
- dimmke 3y agoFuck it, I am going to do this. Thanks for writing this.
- stevage 3y agoAfter all the horror stories I have read on here about YC and VC in general, I'm genuinely surprised that many people are still keen to go down that path.
- kyleyeats 3y agoIt's me. I'm posting the horror stories to increase my chances of getting in.
- anilmr 3y agoI am on a h1b visa and can't really work anywhere outside of my primary employment due to visa restrictions. Has anyone with the similar profile gotten into YC? and if so how did you make it work with all the legal blockades of h1b?
- ganeshkrishnan 3y agoit's not their problem. If you have issues or any issues or they smell any issues, you will be rejected. Too many people take VC/YC personally but try to put yourself in their shoes and ask yourself if your startup would be worth it. Your answer will be their answer
- dang 3y agoI couldn't disagree more! If anyone is feeling this way, please re-read my text at the top because the whole point is to convince you that YC might be a lot more interested than you'd assume. Look at it this way: if there's even a small chance that an application could lead to a major startup, would it make any sense for YC to reject it because of visa reasons (or similar)? Absolutely not. That would be how startup investors fail. On the contrary what would make sense is to fund it and then help get the obstacles overcome. This is a no-brainer and is one of the big ways that YC helps founders—not just about visa issues, but lots of other things - legal issues, cap table issues, prior investor issues, cofounder conflicts, god knows what else.
- ganeshkrishnan 3y agoUnfortunately dang we will always be yin and yang (founders and vc/yc). If I have a thousand applications lying on my desk, my first task would be to remove everyone that has even the slightest issue. There is absolutely no way you would know who is going to be successful so your job is not to find the winners but get rid of the losers. Unfortunately VCs have a power over startups. Any startups they touch will have higher chance to succeed. And when the winds are strong even the chickens can fly so it's not that you choose the right startups, its just that the startups YC chooses become right. Not saying you are wrong but let's just agree to disagree ;)
- jedberg 3y agoYou forgot the best reason to apply -- because just filling out the application makes you think about your business in ways you probably have never thought about it before. I tell every startup I talk to to fill out the YC app, even if they never turn it in.
- sgammon 3y agoWe're not in AI :( and it seems like YC isn't interested in our space. Outside of the current wave of interest in AI I think we would have serious interest. Would you still apply, or wait?
- dang 3y agoThis should occupy 0% of your attention. If you're the kind of founder YC would fund, applying with an AI idea vs a non-AI idea won't change anything. YC supports founders. It's as simple as that, hard as that is to believe, given the assumptions many people make. The reason AI startups are so prominent in recent batches is that it's what many founders want to work on. If you're the type of founder YC funds and you want to work on something else, YC will support you to work on that. If at some point it's clear that it's not working, they may advise you to change—but not because of the AI bit.
- GMoromisato 3y agoMy co-founder and I have applied twice and been rejected twice, and we don't regret it. There is no real downside to applying. In fact, as others have said, applying helps you to refine how you pitch your startup. The only negative is that there's a 99% chance that you will be rejected, and rejections can hurt. But being able to deal with rejection is important in itself.
- dang 3y agoRejection sucks, it's true. But one thing a lot of people don't know is that the chance of being accepted to YC goes up with repeated applications. I even think most founders who YC funds get rejected before they get accepted. (I may be wrong about most* but certainly it's a large chunk.) The main thing is to demonstrate progress since your last application. * Edit: I asked the team and got back: "most is true! for w24 companies, 58% had applied previously"
- OJFord 3y agoI could've sworn there was a cap, like apply and be rejected three times and that's it or something, but I can't find that now - is that not the case? Just could be quite significant to people considering 'just apply' advice quite last minute over this weekend is all :)
- dang 3y agoThat's definitely not the case.
- OJFord 3y agoWell then I think I might have plans this weekend. Thanks!
- dang 3y agoMy informant says "for w2024 most companies applied 0-3 times previously, but it went as high as 12!" (Edit: disappointingly to me at least, 12 turned out to be a bug. The highest number of applications for W24 was 6. Still pretty high!) Good luck with your application if you go ahead with it!
- b3yondtopsecret 3y agoPOOF! "Long time listener, first time caller", as they used to say in talk radio. [This is my first post; please be gentle... :-) ] At least two reasons my apply.ycombinator.com submission will likely forever remain in "Save for Later" mode... 1) Founder's Personal Work and Education Histories: are both (a) highly-structured, and (b) can't auto-link/-copy from LinkedIn.... Like most prospective employers' "lazy" external-facing HRIS'. [Aside: Why can't Workday at least link to/ copy from LinkedIn for job app completion already?!] I'm already spending umpteen hours on-end doing this for all the prospective employers offering jobs I'd prefer to not need to take... And thus I was "spent" when I entered this form. Alternatively... Why can't I just attach my resume? 2) 1 min video, with audio, required. Feel free to label me "shy"/ "tin foil hat"/ have a paranoid threat profile/ etc.... But I'm just not comfortable voluntarily submitting recorded audio/ video of myself for "pre-short-listed" "one-off" use cases such as this. As an HN post from earlier today illustrates... M$FT (and, presumably "et al") can now make a deep fake of me with just one still image and less audio than YC is requesting. Why do I want to help them along? ;-) [Yes, Zoom et al likely has many hours of recorded video of me, because prior employers... And said employers likely signed away my audiovisual likeness without my (explicit) consent because "AI training", etc... And I've had to consent to recorded interviews for job opp'ties (but at least those were post-short-listing)... But I prefer to remain in denial about all that. :-) I've never claimed to be either rational or consistent... ;-) ] And no, my idea(s) aren't Bookface/ Instagrim/ ClosedAI -caliber, so... No biggie, I guess. shrugs Anywhoo... Thanks for reading! :-) POOF!
- taytus 3y agoWe are an early stage startup, $75K ARR (not a lot), 3 engineers, partnership with Accenture in 3 countries, working with top tier brands and got rejected 3 times. We will apply again. Would someone be kind enough to review our application? Thank you so much.
- evbogue 3y agoWhy would I sell my code to you guys when I'm already giving it away for free?
- dang 3y agoIt depends on whether you want to make a high-growth startup or not. If you do, YC can help with that a lot. I guess you might be joking, but there are tons of open-source startups these days, for some definition of "open source" or other.
- pdntspa 3y agoWhat about, "I don't ever seem to have any good ideas worth pursuing" and "everything I can think of doing has already been or is currently being done by people way better funded than me"?
- annoyingnoob 3y agoI'm the only one that cares about ____.
- ultra_nick 3y agoGuys just pick a fun project and apply. If you get in then you get to build a fun project really fast. If not, then just have fun building your project.
- april192024 3y agoYC has increasingly come to resemble a selective community, with an almost cult-like allure. It presents itself to a broad audience, yet only those who share its unique ethos are granted admission. Nowadays, many applicants use the platform not just for entrepreneurial ventures but also to enhance their resumes. Consequently, a number of them lack genuine commitment. Moreover, YC is notorious for advocating an intense work ethic—bordering on having no life outside of work—and for creating a tightly-knit community that some liken to a mob. Although these dynamics are not universally appreciated, many individuals join to benefit from the network. Nepotism also plays a role, as mediocre founders who have personal connections with partners often find an easier path in. In addition, there is a prevalent sense of self-deception among the members who offer startup and life advice, advice they themselves might not be equipped to provide. This is particularly questionable in today’s era of AI and new technologies, which challenges the relevance of their supposed wisdom. Despite these criticisms, if you are young, hungry, and perhaps a bit naïve, giving YC a try could be worthwhile if you feel your vibe might align with theirs.
- 7e 3y agoIt is absolutely a cult which preys on the naïve. It’s amazing that young founders give up equity so cheaply to chase credentials that pay so poorly, on average, relative to FAANG. Someone will win in every YC batch, and it’s YC itself, which holds all the lottery tickets. Most everyone else loses.
- spxneo 3y agoIn asymmetric high risk/reward environments, what YC does is not unusual. When a trade has 99% of failing but 1% will pay for all the bets and then some, you simply cannot take large positional bets that results in equal power dynamics. They've built something heavily coveted and exclusive that people participating cannot see that they are gambling with their time and life. It's very comforting to founders to feel safety in numbers when operating in an illiquid market (the goal is to sell your shares to a buyer whether its secondary market or IPO) but know this: Illiquid markets are rife with manipulation and false positives.
- mandeepj 3y agoThanks, Dang - for the encouragement! You made my friday with this post, so might as well give it a shot as a gratitude
- js4ever 3y agoGot rejected twice. And twice ended up creating great businesses, not billion dollars but profitable enough to have a full team. It's so much better than VC money! No stress, you can really follow your ideas, move at your own pace, have a healthy life/work balance. If you can avoid VCs do it!
- april192024 3y ago[flagged]
- andrewstuart 3y agoAfter applying last time without success, I tried again this time but this time just did it super quick without investing too much time and effort. I figure if it’s a good idea they’ll be interested and if not we’ll then I won’t have invested too much time in it.
- Mumps 3y agoI'm in the same boat and feel like this is the only logical approach. Such a potential timesink for such low odds. I think the effort should be somewhat symmetric: spend as much time as YC will in reviewing. Especially without feed back signal, you'll never get to improve your application/odds. Dang says above that feedback won't happen because it doesn't scale -- not everything has to scale, Dang.
- ultrasounder 3y agoWow what a timing? Thanks Dang for penning this. My friend and his cofounders are just getting ready to record their demo. Question for @dang. How much does it help to have a paying customer that has at least agreed to do a pilot? Is that sort of signal compensate for " I don't to Stanford"? Asking for my friends.
- dang 3y agoI'm not the best person to ask but I believe it helps a lot! How much signal it adds, relative to others, I couldn't say. But obviously they should mention it in their application. The ability to make something people want is so central to what YC is looking for that it's the company motto; and sooner or later "want" has to mean "want enough to pay for". Sounds like your friends are already there.
- Aveng1991 3y agoBiases are the result of our collective experiences, exposures & limitations accumulated over time. And we all have inherent biases to some degree shaped by our past & present, hence biases with all its flaws is a mental apparatus that people employ to understand stuffs. As such YC or any VCs aren’t immune to forming biases of their own. And given the massive volume of applications they have to go through under time constraints; they must definitely take into account multiple factors and signals that aligns with their biases in the context of their past successes.. And whatever biases that’s taken shape over time, as long as they are right most of the time, it does make it reasonable albeit it’s inherent flaws which might miss out on some exceptional founders in few cases. However biases mostly work in information vacuum or when there’s limited set of information to take way from on ideas that are really early or unexplored. I imagine measurable results on the context of your startup idea is the best antidote to YC biases in most cases. For founders lacking in other aspects; I imagine the only viable option is to weigh in with quantifiable results. YC and other VCs might have their biases in some aspects, but there’s one common bias everyone is victim to which is “RESULTS”. So for simple founders like me who is limited by the structure of the application process, I have found a loophole which is for every section that vaguely masks your background or accomplishments, there are also sections that asks for results and numbers which is where you can derive favorable outcome from. And for that very reason, I am trying to game YC biases by focusing primarily on results.
- Uptrenda 3y agoYC is just a circle jerk for rich kids.
- 1i8eDevbi2fx 3y agoA realistic perspective for non-elites to balance out opinions such as "applying will help you think through your idea" or "the upside is completely worth it". 1. Imbalanced niceness: If you get convinced or are in a good mood, you must know that YC is a private company that works to serve its founders, employees and current startups (any private individual would do that so nothing wrong!). The goodwill that is put into filling out a well researched application will be met in around 95% [1] of cases with a cold email with no feedback. The gain from "thinking through your idea" or having romantic thoughts of getting in will most likely be wiped out with the rejection trauma. Also, to temper expectations, it is useful to know that YC actively seeks elite networks with more vigor than the general public due to obviously higher odds of selection and future success of elite founders (again nothing wrong here but these things should be known by non-elites). Just search "yc mit" for how actively MIT alumni and students are reached out to by YC partners through in-person events. 2. Competition from elites: If a person with an elite background (company or university) applies with a similar idea to a person with a non-elite background, the elite person gets in due to stronger odds of succeeding in hiring, raising follow on money etc. The non-elite person's capabilities will most likely not be compared objectively to those of the founder with the elite background due to lack of resources. It will most likely be assumed that the elite person will pull it through rather than the non-elite. This is one of the reasons many highly capable non-elite founders feel a lot of whiplash because an elite founder with only an idea will often make it through while the non-elite won't. The whiplash originates from there being such small delta between the non-elite and the elite individual in many cases. The claim here is not that all elite get through. The elite are weighed with other elite but it's obvious that there are higher odds of getting through if you're an elite. It must be realized that just a couple hundred elite applicants will almost completely wipe out the odds of thousands of non-elites. I'm a non-elite and I've applied and been rejected thrice and just don't have the strength to go for these schemes anymore. I know "we should learn to deal with whiplash" but I'm done with the way the world is designed. I believe the individual must rise higher than having to depend or listen to such schemes and feel pulled into them while in most cases ending up worse off in the process. Schemes such as these are designed to cause more whiplash to the non-elite without any fault of YC - this is just how the world works. Follow up thoughts Q- Why didn't the non-elite strive harder to become the elite when they had the chance? A- I think we generally thought that we'll hit our home run at the next attempt but didn't know how quickly the odds slide to impossible. Also just ignoring the fact that the elite group is a relatively small and stable number of people that doesn't elastically increase with the population or with with one's capabilities. The elite just get more elite - the lindy effect. [1] assuming 2% selection odds and 4-5% odds of an interview call
- b20000 3y agoi applied several times and never got feedback which doesn’t help
- dang 3y agoYC responds to every application, so unless there was some weird email problem, I can't imagine why that would happen. Especially several times—that is really odd. If you want me to look into what might have happened there, I'd be willing to try if you email hn@ycombinator.com. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40093529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40093529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40092169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40092169
- b20000 3y ago"Rejections usually aren't personalized because that can't scale" that says it all.
- hakdbha 3y ago[dead]
- nubela 3y agoI'll play devil's advocate. I have applied to YC for at least 8 times in my 20s? They rejected me everytime. Not even an interview. I now run a $XM SaaS (scale-up, not startup) growing at Y00%/annum. 100% bootstrapped with a healthy profit margin. Thanks YC. The only thing I'd say that YC is good for is their network of existing startups. Then again, startups aren't the best customers IMO given that they die too much. Advice is free on the internet as marketing material these days. And there are better VCs.
- lordofgibbons 3y agoCongrats on the bootstrapped business! Could you please share some of the marketing for founder resources you mentioned? I'd like to avoid taking investments too.
- nubela 3y agoA simple google will do. Also, most of the advice don't really sink in until you're in the position. Instead of "Just apply to YC", I'd recommend to just start a company.
- mirsadm 3y agoYou only have to look at some of the businesses that launched the last couple of batches. The AI products in particular were of very questionable quality.
- max_ 3y agoDo you mind listening some of these "better VCs"?
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoHas there been any founders that took the money and ran?
- jrflowers 3y ago> could change your life, like it did for me Did you apply to be a mod for this site and if so are they accepting more applications of that sort?
- uptownfunk 3y agoMy friend is part of a team of PhDs working on hard tech research problems without much interest in becoming a viable business (in the sense of counting dollars). It seems like YC would not be the right fit for them, is that correct? They seem to have gotten interest from other VCs but they have the impression that YC is more of a traditional firm focused on startups that are very close to revenue or are post revenue
- deepGem 3y agoI have applied to YC with multiple ideas in the past and have been rejected without interview. In my current iteration what I have going against me - solo founder, late 40s, building in a crowded consumer space. I have no idea what YC looks for and it doesn't matter. I will still apply last minute. Almost all my past applications helped me refine and rethink about my ideas. It is highly discouraging to hear a reject but that's the life of a founder.
- spdustin 3y agoI've thought about it, but the target market for my project isn't a high growth one; it's US middle school teachers (years 6-8, typically). Public schools aren't exactly flush with cash—individual teachers even less so—and while I (and my school teacher wife) think I'm on to something that would change teachers' lives, I can't imagine a world where that market would lead to a six figure MRR. Starting to think I need to find grant money rather than startup/seed money.
- toughyear 3y agoif your idea can be morphed into non-profit one, YC does fund it - but they suggest for charging small fee for your service or product. Worth checking out in that case.
- mikewarot 3y agoOMG - My video was so bad, it took down the server. ;-) Well, I did the thing... I have a very low expectation, but it's worth trying anyway, right @DanG?
- yc-kraln 3y agoNote that I get 422 responses from the server when I attempt to submit the form.
- dalontano 3y agoBeen there, done that, got rejected. As they always point out - like here in (2) - "YC looks for good potential founders" it must have been me (or us back then), not the project.
- saran945 3y agoI don't know how to "Make something people want", still applying it anyways. :)
- thih9 3y ago> what reason do you have not to For starters I don’t have a passport, I wouldn’t want to create a US company, I prefer bootstrapping and dislike unreasonable pressure on growth. I would be interested in taking advice and networking, I wouldn’t mind signing off equity unless it’s too much hassle (US company, relocation) Sounds like local hubs and accelerators would be a better pick for me. Unless YC has a remote & chill option?
- dczx 3y agoSlow the earth's rotation using magnets.
- hnroo99 3y agoTried submitting an application for fun™ but encountered a visual(?) bug. When I tried saving a new founder profile after filling out some sections and tried editing it, I was met with hundreds of repeated rows of work/education/etc sections. Anyone else have this issue?
- eggdaft 3y agoI’ve applied a few times, considering stopping applying. What I’m more concerned about is (a) everyone seems to be incredibly young, I’m not, and (b) being a solo founder means you’re almost certain not to be accepted. Are these correct? Is it worth bothering with?
- hare_krish 3y agoReason 3: 3) They know all your alt accounts and shitposting history (via device_id)
- ankit219 3y agoI find these kind of messages distasteful. When people are focused on building, they need feedback from the market. That rejection/feedback helps, but any other kind of rejection - especially a VC or investor rejection - hurts. You could argue that founders should be used to rejection, still this is a needless rejection - without any specific feedback and from a group not their TG - not something people should spend their energy on. You apply, there is hope, then there is a rejection (given the acceptance rate highly likely), then you see the kind of companies that got in, and it becomes a distraction. That's human nature. You can correct something when a prospect says they do not want your product and understand the reasons, but how do you correct anything when a popular investor passes on and says "they could be wrong"? Yes, "keep building", which they were already doing with more enthusiasm and less distraction before the whole bandwagon of YC alums came along. You could argue that "filling the application gives clarity to a founder". Again genius marketing. That comes at an opportunity cost of talking to their leads, their prospects. At any rate, it takes you away from what you originally set out to do. You get more clarity from talking to your target market than filling an application. Another thing is "people got in applying on a whim". Yes, those are exceptions. But, any average founder understands that if the decision is likely to be determined by what they write in the application and their application video (and several factors outside of their control), they will optimize it to the max. The videos you see are always multiple takes. The applications are always pruned and reviewed and rewritten before submitting. When your goal is getting into YC, all this is worth doing. When the goal is building and growing a product, such advice, no matter how well intended, hurts more than helps the founders. It's okay if YC picks 200 startups out of 15000 instead of 20000.
- practal 3y agoI think applying to YC should be seen as fund raising activity. And pg's essays clearly state that fund raising is a distraction, so when you do that, just focus on it, and get it over with, so you can continue building. I must have applied at least 4 times now with Practal in various forms (at some point it was a different project called ProofPeer), got a rejection each time. The idea has been developed further each time, but in ways hard to communicate to a VC (or anyone, really). Reading this announcement I now have a choice: prepare another YC application in the next 2 days, or finish chapter 2 of my book about the logic used in Practal instead [1]. I think the choice is obvious, there is indeed such a thing as applying too early. I mean, I am not going to pivot to something else, there is no idea other than Practal I will ever be interested in. Working on anything else feels like a waste of my time. Hopefully I have something to show for when the winter batch comes around. [1] http://abstractionlogic.com http://abstractionlogic.com
- he11ow 3y agoFor anyone saying "I definitely won't get in" here's a counterpoint that has little to do with whether your application succeeds or not: Do it for yourself, not for the approval. I found that filling in the application, without even sending it, is a useful exercise. It makes you think hard about what it is you are trying to achieve with whatever it is your building. It's very helpful when you come to talk with clients. You know how they say launch fast, launch early? That's part of it, because launching means talking about it to other people. Those people will have questions or objections or an incomplete understanding of pre-existing solutions. A lot of the application is about this kind of stuff. Personally, I wanted to fill the application irrespective of YC. I figured, if I'm serious about building something useful, I shouldn't just build it and que sera, sera. I should know what to focus on. And since they've learned a bunch about building companies, if they care about something enough to ask about it, that's a good pointer that I should care enough about it to be able to answer it. For example, I filled it in when a solution was just an idea, as if it were already built. So it made me set expectations, and clarify what I want this thing to be. Then, once it was built, the first thing that happened when that solution met with clients was this: I'd give them the short description I've written in the application, and they'd ask - Oh, but does it have to do just that? Without the application, there wouldn't have been the short description, without which there wouldn't have been the useful client feedback...So, again: do it for yourself, not for the approval.
- brainless 3y agoThanks for sharing this. I have one question: given similar quality of applications, is it just a dice roll? I am asking this as a trying founder who: - has built early stage engineering at multiple startups - has applied many times and been rejected - is reading about many others who have been rejected and ended up building without funding It does not change my chances but it would expand my perspective.
- dang 3y agoI don't think it's just a dice roll, no, but it's a helpful metaphor for communicating the 'what have you got to lose' sentiment. But I don't think I understand your question fully - do you want to explain?
- brainless 3y agoHey, thanks for getting back to me. What I mean to ask is: given high number of applications, how does YC generally pick within a bucket of similar applications? Similarity based on domain, product status, etc. If there are 40 which are quite similar, what then?
- dang 3y agoI'm not involved in the process so not the best person to answer but I think it boils down to: team, team, team. Not that YC assesses every team perfectly, of course, but it's the principle. Domain, product, and so on, are relevant, but mostly for what they reveal about a team. If there's already a product with users and/or revenue, it proves that these founders a.k.a. the team is able to build a product that gets users and/or revenue, which is the kind of team YC wants to fund. For example.
- brainless 3y agoThanks for sharing this.
- zulban 3y agoA great way to contradict the claims here about requiring ivy league credentials would be dropping some statistics on acceptances. Curiously nobody - for or against - has done that.
- bodantogat 3y agoI wish I had applied when the sessions were still remote. Can't leave my fam for 3 months(I'm on the east coast)
- I_am_tiberius 3y agoI would apply but my co-founder has a kid and can't move to the US for 3 months. Also, we don't want to setup a parent company in one of those 4 suggested countries.
- rfrey 3y agoIt's one of my great regrets that I didn't get into YC in 2007. There was no Dropbox yet, but we were building essentially the same thing except integrated into Windows rather than on the web, with an office collaboration focus. (Doing it on the web was such a better idea!) I vividly remember droning on at Jessica through a dry demo because I thought the team that showed the most features in the least time would win. We ended up with a modest exit - life changing but not stop-working-life-changing. There was so much startup wisdom that we didn't know, that has now become Obvious and Trivial, that I think we would have learned. We made every mistake YCombinator warns against, and I like to think we wouldn't have if we had only been told. Would have been well worth the (IIRC) $14k they were offering at the time. Now with kids and so on the residency requirement makes it tough. But even in my dotage as I am, with 5 startups in my past, I think it would be worth it.
- huhtenberg 3y agoDan, can you share stats on the age distribution between those who applied and those who got accepted? Clearly there'd be a spike in the 20s, but I'm really curious what the long tails are like.
- jerrac 3y agoHow much time do you actually have to spend in San Francisco? I've seen 3 months mentioned, but also relocating...
- LucaLuk 3y ago[flagged]
- sebastiennight 3y agoApplied for the 3rd time (B2B AI SaaS, 300% YoY growth, $109k revenue last month). Decided to take a risk with the founder video. On my first 2 applications I did what everyone does and shot 100 takes to get one "right"... On this one though, I shot the whole video in one take (with warts and all) and used our own software to edit it, and then used that as the demo as well[0]. In a way, it feels like I can't win on this video thing - if we follow instructions to "not edit" the founder video, the result is 100 takes for a basic video that is unworthy of a video-based startup. - If we use our own tool, the video is "too polished" (even though it took less work to do!). Hopefully the application stands on its own merits. A year ago I took the first rejection hard. I really really hate applying for stuff or having some kind of "jury" reviewing things when the only truth is what the market wants and whether people use what I've created. So as an engineer I prefer marketing to fundraising, by far. If we don't get into YC I'll just keep bootstrapping. I see the value though, because with the right pointers we could grow way way faster. So, fingers crossed! [0]: https://my.onetake.ai/b9502ad6/9dcd6eb6/ https://my.onetake.ai/b9502ad6/9dcd6eb6/
- justhw 3y agoYour app is great. Good luck.
- bko 3y agoCongrats on your success. Why would you even want to join YC? They give the same deal to everyone. So you're lumped into a batch that basically has 30% of people in it with just an idea. It's pretty offensive if you actually proved yourself and your business idea. But don't worry, you prob still won't get in
- sebastiennight 3y agoI don't compare myself with others much. Why should I care if there are earlier-stage startups in there? We always think that our current stage is pretty high up the mountain already (see a rough July 2022 ARR update[0] when I thought I was on top of the world) but if you zoom out, you see things with much better perspective (18 months later, the whole year of 2022 looks way less impressive[1]) If we're on the road to $100MM+ in ARR, the current spot we're at will be flattened to almost zero when you look back with perspective a few years down the line. So there's that. And then, "why join YC", well the answer is simple. - We are growing, but we could grow so much faster. Everything is still on a shoestring budget. - We have an epic roadmap and could grow the product to mind-boggling levels of awesome. YC could help us shave years off of that. - Plus we finally cracked breakeven acquisition on cold traffic but we're strapped for cash. - And finally, I've joined several founder "communities" in the last few months (online and local) and those are all just a dump-your-promo Slack channel with zero added value or interaction. The local "startup" events are full of startup consultants on the hunt, designers, would-be employees and the like (but zero founders). So it feels a bit lonely when you've got a challenge which is clearly in the "thousands of founders must have solved this exact same problem before, so why should I bang my head on the wall" category. So: advice, founder-friendly terms, a network of peers, and not having to chase investors for capital. That's why I applied. [0]: https://nuro.video/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Capture-de%CC%81cran-2022-08-04-a%CC%80-06.30.40.png https://nuro.video/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Capture-de%CC%... [1]: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSEOGmySAAyvnYt3BWJrfCp4M4HkiVqVN3vqNYnCefTRb7dL2GXjOdSjMy4uZsB2JXdIl6IzPq4yGDH/pubchart?oid=1322887853&format=interactive https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSEOGmySAAyv...
- diimdeep 3y agono. never.
- alexashka 3y ago> If you've ever thought about applying to YC, here's a tip: just do it Please don't. Imagine you are looking for a plumber and there are 1000 postings, 900 of them people who've watched a couple of youtube clips about plumbing. Does that sound like a good idea to you? This is what's ruined the internet (and society). Instead of domain experts being thoughtful, we have marketers being full of shit. Oh well :)
- gardenhedge 3y agoI just checked out the form and I'm pleasantly surprised. For some reason, I was sure it had questions like "what's your super power?"
- dangc8k 3y agoSo does it bump your chance to practice mock interview questions? I feel it's a waste of time and energy. Or am I wrong to assume some of the brightest people YC accepts have it down pat?
- mettamage 3y agoAlright, yolo, I just did it. I did it because of these reasons: > (1) "probably not good enough / won't get in" - you'd be surprised at how many people feel that way, whether because of impostor syndrome, lack of credentials, whatever—and often they turn out to be among the best founders. So this a terrible reason not to apply! I have nothing going on at the moment. I am starting to apply to new jobs (have an interview with Google coming up). But I'm open to do the entrepreneurship thing. I always wanted to do it for years, strongly (I created my study program in such a way that it'd help if I'd ever do entrepreneurship). Nowadays it's not strong, I'm simply open to it. > (2) "too early" - there's no such thing. YC looks for good potential founders—meaning anyone who can learn what they teach—and nothing else. You're already yourself, which is all you need. Well, I don't have a project started. I have nothing. I did build stuff in the past and I do have a bunch of ideas, which I showed in my application. So let's see if there is no such thing indeed ;-) > Some of YC's big successes start off as last-minute applications on a whim Basically this.
- LeicaLatte 3y agoi recently updated my iOS chatbot and it grew to 100$ mrr. do i have a chance? is it me or the market? :)
- ProAm 3y agoDo they still take 7% of the company off the bat?
- chaibiker 3y agoShould we apply? https://www.movably.com/ https://www.movably.com/
- MOARDONGZPLZ 3y agoThe title of the post indicates you should.
- tpae 3y agoNo thanks. I've applied every year for the first ten years since I was 20 and have not received any feedback on my rejections. The only times I did not apply, I went on to raise series A & B. I've seen friends get accepted with nothing but an idea and a Stanford degree.
- julesvr 3y agoDoes anyone know if there is a way to expedite the decision-making process? We've received a term sheet and are under some time constraints to respond.
- dang 3y agoIf you email hn@ycombinator.com I'll try to help. All YC's group partners are speaking at Startup School today so it might be hard to wrangle one immediately!
- nkulkarni-tbd 3y agowe got into YC, and decided not to take the offer. Even the act of applying was immensely valuable; it created structure and momentum for us and is the reason we're a company today. so apply apply apply! (I'm not going to engage on whether or not YC is for you -- it's a personal decision, and it's an awesome program and we have great founder friends who loved it.)
- wildermuthn 3y agoDang is basically saying what we all know: it is very difficult to predict future performance of people, and YC deliberately tries to avoid common traps like “where did you go to school?” I mean, they still ask, so they aren’t exactly all-in on avoiding noisy heuristics, but they have a history of finding founders who can perform at a level most would-be founders can’t. Like the blub paradox, only past high performers can recognize future high performers. YC uses the “are you one of us?” heuristic, which isn’t perfect since many “high performers” are accidents of fortune, but it is (as of now) still the best way to identify high-impact people — be one yourself and talk to people. It’s the same story with hiring, especially in sports drafting. Even with million-dollar budgets and years of game-film and intensive pre-draft workouts, sports teams are effectively guessing when they draft someone. Analytically, it would be better to trade down for more picks. Dang’s post is analogous to trading down, in the sense of letting people know that the net is wider than most of us think, precisely because high-performing founders don’t fit the same mold as high-performing non-founders. Having said all that, I’d be very surprised if the people reading all the applications and conducting all the interviews were all true high-performers. Surely some proportion, if not a majority, would merely be excellent human beings that were fortunate enough to find success. In fact, perseverance and grit may not be as important to founders as we think. It may be that the trait of never giving up is just very effective at leveraging fortune — given enough time, something good is bound to happen. This feels like an algorithm-smell. What we really want are founders who don’t need fortune, not those who optimize for fortune. PG is a good example. I only know what he’s told us, but it seems to me that his defining trait is not grit. After one obvious pivot, he worked hard, provided value to users, and exited. Now, anyone who works 18 hr days for years has grit. You can’t succeed at something without persevering at it. But that’s not what stands out about PG. Neither does his intellect. There’s plenty of brilliant people in the world. What stands out about him is his genius — a unique mental perspective that sees straight lines where others see jagged lines. He and his partners basically invented the web-app. Where others saw a broken road going nowhere, they saw a highway to immense value. The problem with genius is that it is really hard to distinguish from delusion. Someone tells you the road is straight but you see nothing but curves — what is one to think? When the person telling you this obvious untruth is also brilliant, it makes it that much harder to discern genius from delusion. PG writes about this when talking about “black swans” — the best ideas are the ideas that seem wrong but are actually right. To return to YC and applying, I think it is likely that the brilliant geniuses (like PG) have largely moved on to other things that seem of far more interest to them. Raising children, speaking from experience, definitely fits that bill. If true, then what remains of YC would be brilliant, persevering, but not necessarily genius. That still makes for a world-class accelerator, but one that would struggle at identifying the best founders. I would propose a new heuristic: has the applicant ever accidentally discovered the truth of something already known to be true, but which the applicant was unaware of. Did they make a straight line out of a broken one, without knowing it had already been straightened by others. Call this the “unknowingly reinventing the wheel” heuristic. When did the applicant accidentally reinvent the wheel? As stupidly black-swan as it sounds, I want founders who are not merely brilliant and persevering, but also genius enough to invent something as profoundly valuable as the wheel. I bet there are plenty of people in this thread who have unknowingly reinvented the wheel, and would love to hear the stories!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dexderp 3y agoI like the quote in your about @ Dang. Very helpful: "Conflict is essential to human life, whether between different aspects of oneself, between oneself and the environment, between different individuals or between different groups. It follows that the aim of healthy living is not the direct elimination of conflict, which is possible only by forcible suppression of one or other of its antagonistic components, but the toleration of it—the capacity to bear the tensions of doubt and of unsatisfied need and the willingness to hold judgement in suspense until finer and finer solutions can be discovered which integrate more and more the claims of both sides. It is the psychologist's job to make possible the acceptance of such an idea so that the richness of the varieties of experience, whether within the unit of the single personality or in the wider unit of the group, can come to expression." Marion Milner, 'The Toleration of Conflict', Occupational Psychology, 17, 1, January 1943
- dang 3y agoI'm glad! I finally got a copy of the paper and unfortunately that quote was the only interesting thing in it, as far as I could tell. But Milner is fascinating and did many other things - for example she wrote a brilliant book called "A life of one's own" about experiments she did with self-observation. She was already using the word 'mindfulness' in 1934.
- zh3 3y agoThe parent comment about conflict made me think that surely Montaigne must have an essay "On Conflict". Not so, but a quick search turned up [0]. More generally Montaigne's writings (which you may well know) are sometimes cited as "mindfulness" long before the term was invented [1]. [0] https://psyche.co/ideas/for-montaigne-verbal-jousting-is-the-only-way-to-reach-truth https://psyche.co/ideas/for-montaigne-verbal-jousting-is-the... [1] https://thehouseilivein.me/2023/10/21/my-year-with-montaigne-on-mindfulness/ https://thehouseilivein.me/2023/10/21/my-year-with-montaigne...
- bambax 3y agoThe forms to apply seem to have a bug where textareas often lose focus. Also, does the product demo video have to be uploaded? Why not allow users to paste a link to an existing video?