9 ms·
WebGL: 80,000 particles
- skiplecariboo 15y ago1993
- joncooper 15y agoIf you're interested, here's a nice piece of related work: http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/webgl/million_letters/ http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/webgl/million_letters... Also, a paper about pure-GPU implementation: http://www.2ld.de/gdc2004/MegaParticlesPaper.pdf http://www.2ld.de/gdc2004/MegaParticlesPaper.pdf
- ashleyw 15y agoIt's actually 30,000 particles, not 80,000. See the source: "numLines = 30000". If you set a breakpoint at that line (28), then you can edit the variable in the console to whatever you want. You can make it smaller without setting the breakpoint, but any higher results in a "attempt to access out of range vertices" error. I can get it to ~40,000 on my iMac's 6970m 2GB without noticeable slowdown (this is w/ Chrome 20 dev.)
- schwa 15y agoVertex indexes are 16 bit. It's probably set to 30000 for a very good reasons.
- boblemarin 15y agoPlease, check my post below for the truth about the numbers http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4009469 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4009469
- ashleyw 15y agoUPDATE: It turns out the slowdown at 40,000 was due to the Web Inspector being open (I have no idea why!) It's actually still pretty damn smooth at a MILLION particles! Crazy!
- kiloaper 15y agoAmazing! (and works great in Firefox on Win7 as well)
- mike-cardwell 15y agoWorks great using Firefox on my Ubuntu laptop with only integrated graphics too. Although I had to click the NoScript placeholder to allow the WebGL to execute.
- cpfohl 15y agoWow, that's awesome. if you don't let the particles catch up w/ your mouse (and trace circles around them) the gather up in one place and turn white, resulting in some spectacular 'explosions'
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoIf you let them catch up, you can make a sort of pink torus around the mouse.
- degenerate 15y agoI feel like a god creating the universe, really nice effects!
- jQueryIsAwesome 15y agoIf you move it steady in a vertical line it creates two lines that looks like they were smashing against each other. I actually think this could become a game; maybe you show the player a pattern and then he tries to recreate it... or something among those lines.
- donut 15y agoThere is already such a game, kind of: http://www.ea.com/auditorium-iphone http://www.ea.com/auditorium-iphone Some of the levels are pretty hard!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Fizzadar 15y agoAwesome & beautiful, love it!
- tintin 15y agoIs 80000 particles the limit? With Flash you could render +300000 particles years ago: http://www.unitzeroone.com/labs/alchemyPushingPixels/ http://www.unitzeroone.com/labs/alchemyPushingPixels/
- mistercow 15y agoThat demo gets about 19 fps on my machine, whereas the WebGL demo appears to be getting close to 60, so that seems to be scaling pretty similarly. Also keep in mind that the demo you linked to uses Alchemy, which is C/C++ compiled to AVM2, so for WebGL to be getting roughly equivalent performance is pretty damned impressive.
- Father 15y agoActually the 'math' was done using alchemy, the shader was pixelbender http://www.adobe.com/devnet/pixelbender.html http://www.adobe.com/devnet/pixelbender.html However the example was flash then (3 years ago) vs webgl now. This is flash now; a version with 1.4 million particles using the new molehill http://www.simppa.fi/blog/1_point_4_million_particles/ http://www.simppa.fi/blog/1_point_4_million_particles/
- mistercow 15y agoWell, that's looking like about 3 fps; it's a lot more particles, but it's also a lot slower, so I don't know how that balances out.
- lloeki 15y agoFrom the 1.4M page: "On my OsX toy the difference between flash on browser and standalone is insane. 200 000-300 000 particles is pretty much the maximum until it won’t run smooth anymore. I wonder if this is memory related thing? or what? Who knows? Someone from Adobe might… Well anyways. Here’s the same thing exploding 1.4 million particles in 1920×1200 resolution with smooth 60fps." Interesting behavior. On that other JS demo mentioned in a sibling comment my puny 9400m runs at a steady 30fps at 100k with 7~10% CPU on Safari. The same goes for some non-browser pyopencl [0], which uses about 10% CPU. I seem to be hitting a sort of bottleneck here as ramping either up to 200k or using the Flash realtime demo brings FPS down to about the same level. The Flash one though, uses between 20 and 60% CPU and mostly hovers around 30%. Whatever that means. [0] http://enja.org/2011/03/22/adventures-in-pyopencl-part-2-particles-with-pyopengl/index.html http://enja.org/2011/03/22/adventures-in-pyopencl-part-2-par...
- tannerc 15y agoThis is wonderful. Turn on some good music and play around with this, makes me think it would be a fine music video for some remixed songs.
- keeran 15y agoReminds me of Gravilux http://www.snibbe.com/store/gravilux/ http://www.snibbe.com/store/gravilux/
- nullspace 15y agoI get a dialog box : "There's no WebGL context available.". :\ Using Google Chrome 19.something on Ubuntu, with open source radeon driver.
- sigkill 15y agoChrome 18, nVidia GTX260M, on Windows with official binaries. Same error.
- jonsen 15y agoI got the same box on Safari OS X. Then found 'Enable WebGL' on the 'Develop' menu.
- zurn 15y agoChrome blacklists most opengl drivers on linux (except the proprietary nvidia one) since old mesa based drivers don't work too well with webgl. You can change this in about:flags, "override software rendering list" (and restart)
- nextparadigms 15y agoIt looks very impressive. I'd love to see some kind of game using particles like that, something like Osmos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pso6UBicLWU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pso6UBicLWU
- Flow 15y agoSpheres of Chaos... Mmmm. http://www.spheresofchaos.com/ http://www.spheresofchaos.com/
- starwed 15y agoThat would be a great game to port to the web.
- BHSPitMonkey 15y agoFor what it's worth, I wrote a simplistic Osmos clone last year using 2D canvas drawing (not WebGL). It's fairly inefficient, but anyone's welcome to hack on it and make something cool with it. http://stepheneisenhauer.com/demos/browsmos/ http://stepheneisenhauer.com/demos/browsmos/
- p0nce 15y agoWell you can render many spheres with tiled rendering. http://www.gamesfrommars.fr/demojsv2/ http://www.gamesfrommars.fr/demojsv2/
- windsurfer 15y agoI used particles pretty heavily in my (inneficient) WebGL game Up and Above: http://littlesquareblock.com/upandabove http://littlesquareblock.com/upandabove It's not nearly as efficient as this demo, but it's at least a game. There are at least a dozen areas I could fix up to prevent the GC from going nuts if I was so inclined, but it works fine for most people.
- timtadh 15y agoPretty neat game. WebGL is still a little clunky on Linux but I was still getting a playable framerate (but just barely).
- windsurfer 15y agoThat's good to know. We get really bad performance on linux because of the AA I think.
- tretiy3 15y agocore i3, 3Mb ram ubuntu 12.04 works nice. great job! thanks
- bananaoomarang 15y agoSeem to work well here (under Arch Linux, Chrome dev channel, nVidia proprietary drivers)
- windsurfer 15y agoNice, I am an Arch user too :)
- tbundy 15y agoThis is awesome. Also like his Lego survey stats app http://minimal.be/lab/legoStats/ http://minimal.be/lab/legoStats/
- CodeCube 15y agoThanks for taking literally 10 minutes of my time ... pretty badass, am always mesmerized by particles :)
- notJim 15y agoThe code for this is quite readable and well-commented, and seems to be actually really short as well.
- boblemarin 15y agoMuch of the code comes from a WebGL tutorial (context and shaders creation, and the shaders code). I added the interactive parts, the particles and tweaked the shaders.
- hemancuso 15y agoThe most impressive bit of this is that it it keeps under 20% CPU on my Mid-2010 MBP [Chrome 19]. It's hard not to imagine another cyclical shift towards browser centric development, away from rich client apps, when you have Chrome pulling off tricks like this. Things that would've seemed impossible in 2008, the last time everything was moving to the browser. Give Apple/ARM/Intel/Samsung a few more cycles in mobile [more RAM, if nothing else!] and you might need to reconsider the disadvantages of native apps in favor of all the advantages that centrally hosted applications offer [no Apple fee, no pirating, continuous deployment, cross-platform, etc, etc.]. I long for a vibrant open-source project that builds quality widgets and elements for people to use inside this framework. Let's not pretend jQuery mobile et. al. are anywhere close.
- ajross 15y agoCPU utilization is the wrong metric. Your CPU is mostly idle because it's feeding a tiny set of commands to the GPU each frame, and then idling waiting for user input and/or vsync. The GPU is running full-tilt, but unfortunately there's no good OS-level tool to show that. One of the reason CPU utilization is so low is that this is a demo. Most of the "logic" is just a straightforward computation of the mouse position, and the particle coordinates are all figured out from that in the shader engines. Real apps and games have real data that needs to be crunched. (Edit: I just checked the source, the particle positions are actually computed in Javascript, the shaders are just straight rendering. And I don't see anything particularly clever about the implementation, it's just a bunch of array accesses. V8 is doing an amazing job on this.) But broadly, you're right: the need for highly optimized native code to drive a modern GPU has mostly disappeared. A javascript interpreter (well, V8) is more than good enough.
- boblemarin 15y agoThe particle positions are indeed computed in Javascript, and even if the version you tried only had 30000 of them, the "real 80000" version [ http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html ] does not raise my CPU usage that much. A more clever way to code that animation would be to pass the mouse position to the GL shaders that would compute themselves the particle positions, and I think modern GPUs are very optimized for that kind of stuff. Please don't be too rude, cause it was my first WebGL experiment.
- quaz3l 15y agoYup spent a solid 45 minutes not doing work.
- Jyaif 15y agoYou can get 100 times as many particles by doing a pure shader based solution. Still, very impressed by the speed of JS.
- Davertron 15y agoFor anyone who's curious like I was, just go to http://minimal.be/lab/ http://minimal.be/lab/ for a full listing of other cool stuff he's worked on.
- fuzzythinker 15y agoLove the portrait, audioSnake, and jQuery.eraser
- chucknelson 15y agoWow, that is pretty impressive.
- thu 15y agoFrom this tweet, it seems it is actually 30000 particles: https://twitter.com/boblemarin/status/204943143798448129 https://twitter.com/boblemarin/status/204943143798448129
- ashleyw 15y agoYeah it is: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4008846 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4008846
- boblemarin 15y agoWhen I wrote that experiment (nearly one year ago), I started with 80000 but finally went for 30000 because it was smoother on my laptop. I just forgot to change the title when posting (it was a long ago, and I wasn't expecting it to get much attention). If you want to benchmark the same page with 80000 particles, try this link : http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- daenz 15y agoCan someone give us a screenshot or video for those of us without webgl enabled?
- boblemarin 15y agoyou can see screenshots and videos on that page : http://checkthis.com/7ezv http://checkthis.com/7ezv (the WebGL animation is part of an interactive installation)
- 38leinad 15y agoany idea why i get the JS error "requestAnimationFrame is not defined" when I run the HTML page on my local system. Same browser (firefox 12)) renders the online-like just fine. As i understand this method is part of the browser's JS api. So, why is it not defined if I run it "locally"?
- banthar 15y agoHave you downloaded all the files? requestAnimationFrame is defined in http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/RequestAnimationFrame.js http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/RequestAnimationFrame.js
- tudorw 15y agocircling the particles to try and trap them is fun, makes me feel a bit like one of those machines they try and trap plasma in :)
- goostavos 15y agoThis is.. this is really quite neat. Is there a way to start experimenting with webgl using python?
- alan_cx 15y agoJust in case people have missed the link at the bottom of the page: http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html http://minimal.be/lab/fluGL/index80000.html
- mxfh 15y agoDon't know how many of these 3.7 million static data points are rendered live, just found this way more impressive: http://www.chromeexperiments.com/detail/swiss-addresses-in-3d http://www.chromeexperiments.com/detail/swiss-addresses-in-3...
- mbell 15y agoVery cool, love it, wasted much time. Very small bug I thought I'd mention: If you resize the browser window the center of the particles no longer tracks the mouse pointer location but rather appears to be offset by an amount depending on the resize that happened. W7/C19
- BowlOfChilli 15y agoMe loves it, awesome.
- louhong 15y agoWould love to see this hacked to work with Kinect or the leap.
- DigitalSea 15y agoWorks absolutely flawlessly in Chrome, impressive stuff. Can't wait to see a company like Blizzard release a HTML5 MMO in a few years time (it'll definitely happen). Imagine a game like Diablo 3 in HTML5? Wow.
- bananaoomarang 15y agoThis is pretty awesome, I hacked it so it's color-morphs now! Awesome stuff.
- nixisfun 15y agoOn my core i7 it does not go above 7% core usage. Very nice.
- mouseroot 15y agopretty cool i would like to see this put into use for a webgl sands game
- Tomis02 15y agoDoesn't work in Opera 12. Meh.