5 ms·
EU tells Meta it can't paywall privacy
- ApolloFortyNine 3y agoTo me this is the most egregious opinion that came out of GDPR (I've seen in argued in other GDPR threads). That a company is required to provide a service even at a loss. A company should have every right to deny service. Untargeted advertising pays 90+% less than targeted advertising. If they lose money by serving a user content because they denied targeted advertising, they should be able to deny them service or have them pay up. They're just legislating into law the Meta (and others) have to provide a service at a loss for a growing number of users.
- abyssin 3y agoThey have the right to stop operating in the legal zone where it isn't profitable for them.
- xamolxix 3y agoMeta is free to close shop (in the EU) if it's not worth it to them. Not all business have the right to exist.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoEven further: No business has the right to exist. If your business can't make money because you have to respect the rights and freedoms of your customers, then close your shop up. If your business can't make money because you have to pay your workers enough to live, then close up shop. If your business can't make money because you have to abide the laws of the countries in which you operate, then close up shop. This bizarre entitlement that entrepreneurs have, especially but far from exclusively in the tech space, that just because they want their business to exist and make money that they therefore have this strange innate right to transact and draw profit, even when providing subpar service, paying subpar wages, cutting corners in the work they do, etc. etc. has been entertained for far too long. The way I was always taught it, markets select for firms that provide service well, at competitive cost, and business is a RISK because of those things. Sometimes risks don't pay off.
- chaostheory 3y agoIt’s ironic that you’re talking about entitlement when the EU is more or less telling meta to provide its services for free. Given that many EU countries are part of the 14 eyes alliance, these laws seem more like hypocritical protectionist legislation. They don’t care about the privacy of EU citizens. They only care about the survival of ancient EU companies. Ie why aren’t EU publishers subject to the same terms? Why can they offer targeted ads in lieu of payment? EU protectionism is also one of the reasons why the US is growing tired of continuing to subsidize the EU’s defense.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoMeta (at the time Facebook) decided to provide it's services for free at the time of inception of the product. The EU did not force their hand and they're free to stop providing services to EU users at a time of their choosing. I find it rather amusing how the notion that a business that can't make money in a given region is so wholly incompatible with your thought processes that you just jump immediately to "the EU is trying to get them to operate for free!" Like just... what if Facebook just wasn't in Europe? Like... that would be fine. The planet would continue spinning, Facebook would still make shit tons of money. It's honestly kind of wild how committed you are to this one shitty product remaining available in this one region.
- chaostheory 3y agoYes, it’s this kind of thinking that makes it clear that the EU and the US are no longer allies. It goes both ways. Also if it was such shitty product, why are law makers forced legislate it to death? One would assume that EU users would simply stop using it.
- prmoustache 3y ago> It’s ironic that you’re talking about entitlement when the EU is more or less telling meta to provide its services for free. No. Facebook can paywall their services. What they condition the use of their services while respecting user's privacy to payments. It is like EU fighting against a criminal organization that offer "protection services" if you don't want them to burn your shop.
- user_7832 3y ago> A company should have every right to deny service. Pretty sure that's legal and Meta could do it if they wanted to.
- dspillett 3y ago> > A company should have every right to deny service. > Pretty sure that's legal and Meta could do it if they wanted to. It isn't entirely that blank & white. They can't deny service for refusing to let them do something you have a legal right to refuse to let them do. They can refuse service for refusing to pay, but the relevant laws don't allow giving up your privacy rights to be equated to paying. The law doesn't allow you to “pay” for things with your human rights (of which it considers privacy one). This leads to “pay or no service” being okie dokie, but “pay or give up right or no service” (or just “give up right or no service”) not being. This partly comes from a desire not to create a new underclass, with some able to pay to maintain their rights and the others effectively losing them because they can't afford other options. There would be a two class system anyway (those that can pay and those that don't have the service), but not having access to facebook is not seen as threatening like not having one of your human rights (as defined by relevant law) is.
- em-bee 3y agoa desire not to create a new underclass, with some able to pay to maintain their rights and the others effectively losing them because they can't afford other options this is the key argument why pay for privacy is a problem. unfortunately, given that for now we must assume that all ads are tracking people and are thus violating users privacy, this means that any ad supported service that offers ad free service against pay including youtube and netfix are in violation of this. solving this will be difficult. we need some way to ensure that ads are non-tracking. but i don't know how to do that.
- dspillett 3y ago> this means that any ad supported service that offers ad free service against pay including youtube and netfix are in violation of this. Actually not. Those ad free services are still tracking you. There is no payment for privacy, just payment for no adverts. The data they record while you are using the paid ad-free service can still be used elsewhere, including by that service if you later stop paying to remove the ads. This is bad from a privacy PoV, but at least it is equally bad for all from a rights PoV (rather than creating classes of haves & have nots). There are points where ads and privacy are completely separate issues. If they were separate issues generally than I'd allow many more ads but block the stalky ads/services. Not all online ads are stalky (though the vast majority are), and many ad-free sites/apps/services are still stalky (directly, or via free services that they use such as many SaaS analytics options).
- zoobab 3y ago"That a company is required to provide a service even at a loss." That's the conclusion some privacy folks came to after the GDPR came to life. Those predictions from 10y ago are not materializing.
- basisword 3y agoThat’s not the case at all. If they can’t serve EU users profitably without violating their privacy they have every right to pull out of the market. If you can’t run your business without violating the rights of the citizens then you can’t do business.
- ApolloFortyNine 3y ago> If they can’t serve EU users profitably without violating their privacy they have every right to pull out of the market. The article clearly mentions how they are only 'violating the rights' if the user chooses to agree with it rather than paying a subscription. It's a trade. Why do you think people are entitled to consume free content with no strings attached?
- webloem 3y agoThe EU does not allow you to trade away your privacy rights in exchange for free goods or services.
- curiousllama 3y agoIt 100% does allow exactly that https://www.spiegel.de/ https://www.spiegel.de/
- ApolloFortyNine 3y agoYea that user is just wrong, is though this opinion from the privacy board (who knows if it matters at all) is that pay or consent should be illegal.
- x0x0 3y agoIt is not. It is limited to the context of Large Online Platforms, as defined (iirc) in the DSA. I believe the edpb will later publish guidelines on consent or pay for other companies, which will impact many news agencies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freetanga 3y agoI would argue it’s the opposite: if your business model is unsustainable while observing the law, then you don’t have a business. Close and pull out.
- SigmundurM 3y agoConsent to having your privacy violated has to be actual genuine consent. Charging a privacy fee up to €250 a year I don't think can be reasonably interpreted as genuine consent.
- ApolloFortyNine 3y agoThen what is a reasonable price? They could define it. Though it does sound like in the article the opinion from the board that any price is too much. I also have no idea how they came up with that number, since earlier in the article they mention 9.99 and 12.99 a month.
- dspillett 3y ago> Then what is a reasonable price? They could define it. Not without creating a situation where only those with at least a certain amount of money can keep their rights. > I also have no idea how they came up with that number [€250] Same. If their user numbers and published finances are to be believed then they make (IIRC) ~$25 per average EU user per year (closer to $75 for a US user) so €250 is a massive uplift. Unless of course they are lying about their active user numbers, or at least being incredibly disingenuous about how they calculate those numbers, which many believe is the case, in which case the amount made per active user is higher. Even the €9.99/mo seems far too high if they aren't being deceitful about their active user numbers, which suggests deliberately trying to discourage take-up because being able to stalk for their advertisers is more convenient and likely more profitable (or that they are being deceitful about their active user numbers!).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 39896880 3y agoThe key here is that Meta is not just “A company.” Meta is effectively the communication infrastructure of a vast swathe of EU citizens. The EU has decided they have strong opinions about the administration of this infrastructure.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoSince this came up, it would be nice if they also had strong opinions (and followup actions) about a related infrastructure : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26843068 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26843068
- x0x0 3y agoI think this only bans consent or pay. Nothing in the edpb opinion prevents just charging (we can call it pay or pay).
- nottorp 3y ago> A company should have every right to deny service. Sure. They can pull out of the EU if they can't follow the rules. > If they lose money by serving a user content Btw, don't the users who generate said content have a right to be paid for it? Social networking doesn't generate shit, it's their users that do the work for them. > Untargeted advertising pays 90+% less than targeted advertising. But then they'll be able to drop the targeting infrastructure and reduce their hosting costs by at least two orders of magnitude :)
- Workaccount2 3y agoI think we are going to go back to paywalls and subscriptions for everything. Providers and users have been unable to strike a balance, with users being entitled to free content and providers being shameless about 3rd party data sharing. It's a self-reinforcing cycle, where intrusive advertising perpetuates ad-blocking and ad-blocking perpetuates more intrusive advertising. In my opinion the best solution would be something like what Brave is perusing, a seamless integrated micropayment system where site owners can charge penny fractions in order to view content. Yes, I know, I can easily think of all the downsides to this system. The core problem is that no one has figured out a good monetization method for internet content for 30 years. It's either pay with credit card or pay with personal data.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoEverything commercial. Good riddance I say, the Web has become too commercial. Also, patronage-style funding does work (even if the crowdsourced one somewhat fragile against deplatforming and not exempt of its own issues).
- Youden 3y agoThe problem isn't that they charge at all but that they charge too much. The court ruled that a "reasonable" charge can be asked but at an ARPU of $45, it seems Meta is asking users who value their privacy for twice as much money ($120/yr) as the average user gives them in ad revenue.
- ajmurmann 3y agoHow does the court decide what's "reasonable"? What does "reasonable" even mean? Isn't it up to consumers and the company to find the equilibrium price? Does the court have some arcane economic formulas I'm unaware of?
- 39896880 3y ago> Isn't it up to consumers and the company to find the equilibrium price? Remember, Facebook’s users are not the consumers. They are the sources of surveillance capitalism’s crucial surplus: the objects of a technologically advanced and increasingly inescapable raw-material-extraction operation. Surveillance capitalism’s actual customers are the enterprises that trade in its markets for future behavior.
- ajmurmann 3y agoWho is paying the $120/yr? Advertisers or consumers?
- 39896880 3y agoRecall that the fee was only implemented to comply with the EU regulation and ostensibly to make up for the revenue not gained from selling behavioral information. If you want to test who Facebook’s real customers are, look at whose interests they put first.
- ajmurmann 3y agoWhy does this matter? Users and Meta mutually agree to this. What kind of nanny state prevents grown adults from entering a contact that hands nobody else?
- fnordian_slip 3y agoThis is sibling to the complaints many in the US like to voice against minimum wage (that it makes it impossible for some businesses to stay afloat). The obvious counterargument imho is, that no-one owes these people a profitable business. If you can't do business without exploiting people or destroying their privacy, you can't do business. Someone else will come along and fill that niche without the exploitation or destruction of privacy, and they deserve our custom more than these other entities. And if no-one is able to fill it, that's OK, too. Not every possible idea needs to be profitable.
- waffleiron 3y ago> That a company is required to provide a service even at a loss. They don't > A company should have every right to deny service. They do. >They're just legislating into law the Meta (and others) have to provide a service at a loss for a growing number of users. They don't. --- You can't just do something illegal just because you are offering a paid version where you don't do the illegal thing.
- JohnMakin 3y agowoo boy defining meta products as “providing a service” is a stretch. They’re absurdly thin wrappers around a platform whose only purpose is to hoover up your data and sell it.
- ptx 3y ago> Untargeted advertising pays 90+% less than targeted advertising. Perhaps if this kind of targeting is banned, the advertising budgets will be spent of untargeted advertising instead, raising the prices of non-targeted advertising? Perhaps advertisers (at least those with useful products) will find that less invasive targeting is good enough, such advertising e.g. knitting-related products next to knitting-related content?
- 66fm472tjy7 3y ago> A company should have every right to deny service Plenty of utility companies are already being forced to provide service. As the EDPB opinion says, a lot of big tech is > decisive for participation in social life or access to professional networks, even more so in the presence of lock-in or network effects > Untargeted advertising pays 90+% less than targeted advertising I don't think that such a large difference is rational. "Untargeted" advertising can still be based on the content being viewed, just not on surveilling the viewer. > If they lose money by serving a user content because they denied targeted advertising, they should be able to deny them service or have them pay up. As I understand it the opinion does not categorically rule this out > Controllers should ensure that the fee is not such as to inhibit data subjects from making a genuine choice That is why NOYB also focuses[0] on the fact the the fee is disproportionate: > The current average revenue for programmatic advertising in the EU is € [1.41] per user - across all websites per month [...] visiting the top 100 websites can already cost more than € [1500] per year if you do not consent to tracking --- [0] https://noyb.eu/en/statement-edpb-pay-or-okay-opinion https://noyb.eu/en/statement-edpb-pay-or-okay-opinion, https://weis2019.econinfosec.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2019/05/WEIS_2019_paper_38.pdf https://weis2019.econinfosec.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/...
- dspillett 3y ago> That a company is required to provide a service even at a loss. No. The company is required to provide any services it provides without breaking the law, which includes privacy legislation. If they can't operate without making a loss without breaking the law, then they are not forced to make a loss, they can always just stop service. > A company should have every right to deny service. They do, but not on the basis of refusing to consent to a reduction of your privacy rights as defined and protected by the law. If they should be able to break piracy laws in order to be able to provide service, what other laws / human rights / other should they be able to break too? If a delivery company can't turn a profit without being faster by ignoring road safety laws, should we allow them to break those laws in order to keep offering their services? > Untargeted advertising pays 90+% less than targeted advertising. If stalky advertising did not exist, non-stalky advertising would attract higher prices. The difference in success rate between targetted and untargeted advertising is incredibly small (the difference is orders of magnitude smaller than that pricing differential) in real terms so those doing the advertising would not miss out much. Advertising as a whole, targetted or not, is not nearly as successful as the industry would have us believe. This is why so much effort is made to try make some adverts seem as much as possible like personal recommendations instead of paid promotions, and so much effort goes into other forms of astroturfing (fake reviews, paying to have bad ratings dropped, etc.). The advertising industry is conning its own customers to an extent as well as us, cleverly abusing statistics to make their services look as worth paying for as possible. This is not unlike parts of the spam industry: those buying access to send to mailing lists are conned into believing a higher rate of return is possible than is actually likely. The advertising/spam industry gets paid, the advertiser pays in money, we “pay” in irritation.
- mschuster91 3y agoGooooooood. Now it's time to target the myriad of newspapers that have all chosen to go that same path - and even if you pay, you still get heaps of tracking crap.
- freetanga 3y agoTurn off JavaScript. That works most of the time for me.
- coldpie 3y agoRather, use NoScript and use its allowlist as needed to fix poorly made websites.
- vincnetas 3y agoThe burden to fight this should not be shifter to end user. It's like saying buy a gun to ensure your safety. It's police job to ensure public safety.
- balozi 3y agoSay what now? Public safety and personal safety are two very distinct concepts that often coincided. But not always.
- ryandrake 3y agoA good compromise might be to shift the burden onto the browser. Browsers are supposed to act as the User's Agent, not as an enabler for web companies to do whatever they want. If browsers were actually doing their jobs, they would be rendering only what the user wants and dropping the rest into /dev/null. You wouldn't need dozens of extensions just to make the web sane.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThat still seems like a very unequal application of law. Newspapers -> disable JS, Meta -> even if you consent, it's illegal
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- noisy_boy 3y agoHit them where it hurts, don't click on ad/affiliate links. The lesser the validation of ads resulting in sales, the lesser the value of advertising on these platforms and consequently, lesser the value of data collection for targeted ads. Click-starve these fuckers.
- aspyct 3y agoYou pay for impressions.
- exe34 3y agoI've only ever clicked on ads by accident. Does anybody actually click through and buy? The few products I came across through ads, I googled for them at a later date, and I can't even think of any that I ended up buying.
- cess11 3y agoYes, it's common that people don't really distinguish between ads and other things that show up on their screens. Many also hook up their accounts to shady companies that quiz them and tell them what kind of wizard they are because they think it's fun to have the screen tell them little stories where they are involved.
- otterley 3y agoJohn Gruber’s take should make folks think twice about what’s going on here: “”” What makes this all the more outrageous is that many major publishers in the EU use this exact same “pay or OK” model to achieve GDPR compliance — and none offer a free alternative with non-targeted ads. Don’t hold your breath waiting for Der Spiegel to offer free access without ads. Christ, they don’t even let you look at their homepage without paying or consenting to targeted ads. And Spotify quite literally brags about its ad targeting. But Spotify is an EU company, so of course it wasn’t designated as a “gatekeeper” by the protection racketeers running the European Commission. They’re not saying “pay or OK” is illegal. They’re saying it’s illegal only if you’re a big company from outside the EU with a very popular platform. “”” https://daringfireball.net/2024/04/edpb_meta_pay_or_ok https://daringfireball.net/2024/04/edpb_meta_pay_or_ok
- cess11 3y agoHe could have checked whether Spotify is hunted by data protection authorities before he claimed they don't. I wonder why he didn't. https://www.edpb.europa.eu/news/national-news/2023/imy-issues-administrative-fine-against-spotify-shortcomings-regarding_en https://www.edpb.europa.eu/news/national-news/2023/imy-issue...
- otterley 3y agoHe didn't say that Spotify had never been investigated or found liable for misbehavior. He said that Spotify is permitted (as of now) to continue to target its ads and content, which is true.
- coretx 3y agoThe EU should be more consise and tell everyone not to paywall security. Puting people at risk only to subsequently charge them protection money is a textbook example of a criminal enterprise.
- greggsy 3y agoYou’re thinking of racketeering, which this is not.
- littlestymaar 3y agoPutting all your personal data you've put on Facebook, and all the relationship you have there behind a paywall really is racketeering.
- littlestymaar 3y agoIt would be grate indeed, but the commission has limited power, and if member states (at least a qualified majority of member states) aren't onboard with such a move, then the commission is helpless. At least member states aren't interesting in protecting American megacorps like they protect their own businesses, and that's why that happens.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoThat last sentence is not entirely true : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40025198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40025198
- lycos 3y agoI never accepted the new terms in the Instagram app, it keeps asking again every now and then but you can get around it for a while and use the app. I'm very curious whether that means they are using my personal data for targeted ads or not, but I also don't remember the last time I saw an ad (maybe became blind to them)
- kelthuzad 3y agoPaywalling privacy makes it look a bit like extortion: "nice data you have there, would be too bad if someone were to exploit that data. We could protect you...for a fee."
- reustle 3y agoSo then don't use the product? It's free, and your data is the price currently.
- deely3 3y agoThis simple solution does not help, unfortunately. (This is how Facebook collects data on you even if you don’t have an account) https://www.vox.com/2018/4/20/17254312/facebook-shadow-profiles-data-collection-non-users-mark-zuckerberg https://www.vox.com/2018/4/20/17254312/facebook-shadow-profi...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoCreate a problem, sell the solution.
- jqpabc123 3y agoJust make "personalized" advertising flat out illegal without opt-in --- due to the fact it is built around privacy violation. Problem solved. The EU is just trying to dance around doing this.
- account42 3y ago> Just make advertising flat out illegal Agreed.
- jqpabc123 3y agoI'm not against "context sensitive" advertising. It can even be beneficial at times. If I specifically express a need or interest in a particular product --- for example by doing a search, some ads are not unreasonable. What is blatantly unreasonable and just plain dumb are these ads following me all over the internet on totally unrelated web sites for weeks or months --- long after I have made a purchase and no longer have any need. In a great many cases, "personalized" ads are totally ineffective and waste the advertiser's money while being nothing but a nuisance to the consumer --- squandering his time, attention and communication bandwidth and violating his privacy. Allow those who disagree to "opt in". This should be fair enough but the ad industry knows full well that there would be very few takers.
- orwin 3y agoAnd context sensitive advertising is nice and easy tbh. Affiliate links to professional tools or paint in a decoration/woodwork blog goes a long way. Probably if you're big you might want stuff a bit more complex, but for hacker it's quite good. The electronic blog I follow only have affiliate links as ads, and they seems to do quite well.
- Nextgrid 3y agoIt is illegal as per the GDPR. The problem is that GDPR enforcement is severely lacking, even in Facebook's case where there is plenty of evidence of bad faith as opposed to legitimate mistakes. (please don't bother posting that "enforcement tracker" link - what matters is not the absolute count/amount of fines but said metrics relative to the total amount of breaches and/or estimated profit earned from them)
- from-nibly 3y agoFacebook is the scum of the earth, but you don't HAVE to use Facebook. If you don't like their terms don't use it. I can see a case where you must be allowed to end the contract with Facebook and have them delete your data or whatever, but I can not figure out why people think that Facebook is some publicly owned entity. Should I be able to go to my neighbors house and say they don't get to set the rules on the tools I borrow from them? Their my neighbors tools, they don't even have to let me use them. Facebook isn't paywalling privacy unless they are actively spying on you without you using their products, which would be a completely different situation. Or if they were outright lying to you about what data they collect and what they do with it, again though completely different situation. They are paywalling their product, you know, like how walmart "paywalls" milk.
- timeon 3y ago> They are paywalling their product, you know, like how walmart "paywalls" milk. So you can take milk from walmart without paying if you agree to tracking? Analogies are not arguments.
- dns_snek 3y agoGreat! It's been a long time coming, now chase after everyone else doing the same exact thing.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoI'm ramping up my ublock origin usage by a lot at this point. I didn't know that with the annoyances list you can remove most of the pooup blockers (cookies, paywalls, newsletters)