5 ms·
Apple further explains why Game Boy emulator iGBA was removed from app store
- talldayo 3y agoNot surprising at all; the App's screenshots bared more than a passing resemblance to GBA4iOS: https://github.com/CocoaBob/GBA4iOS https://github.com/CocoaBob/GBA4iOS Really just makes you think how much easier things would be if you could simply distribute Open Source apps safely on iOS. This one-two step of ad-ridden forks and who-knows-what isn't making things any easier for users. Nobody wants good software to be polluted with anti-features and redistributed by someone that isn't the maintainer.
- ericmay 3y agoOpen source software wouldn't solve this problem if you could "simply" distribute open source apps on iOS because you could indeed just clone an app like this, make it open source on Github or something, and then distribute it without anyone in the way. Unless of course you want to start adding various validation technologies, in which case it's just Apple all over again except there's nobody to point the finger at anymore.
- talldayo 3y agoDepends on who does the validation. I've never had a problem downloading downstream forks on F-Droid, because more often than not the authoritative source is ranked right above it. The big problem for iOS users that want iGBA/Delta is that they can't download it to their device, despite the fact that the code is already written and freely available. Now third-parties are taking advantage of that demand. This would be circumvented if the legitimate version was easy to get. Deceptive forks should still be removed at the store/repository's discretion, but the same goes for proprietary knock-offs like the Lastpass trojans and fake banking apps. It's less of an "Open Source" issue and more of an "App Store" one.
- soperj 3y agoSo not being able to get the actual version at this point is better somehow?
- everdrive 3y agoAgreed with all your points, but the clear issue here is wrongly believing that any apps on iOS / android can be: free from tracking, stable UI over time, trustworthy, privacy-preserving, non-addictive, etc. There are some rare exceptions to this rule, but for the most point smart phone apps are bad for the user, and built to favor the company who's provided them.
- talldayo 3y agoI don't think it's wrong to believe that. It's hopeful and perhaps overly idealistic, but the sentiment of "good software" still exists. People still develop it, albeit slowly and to a smaller audience. Enabling installation routes that aren't solely money-extraction machines will go a long ways towards changing things. It won't inherently stop people from abusing social media or screen time, but it might stop people from watching ads or paying money to use a PDF reader. That's a win in my book.
- apetresc 3y agoThe tl;dr seems to be that Apple pulled it because it's just a white-labeled build of Riley's (of AltStore fame) Delta/GBA4iOS, not because it's an emulator. The README on Riley's repo says: > Due to the licensing of emulator cores used by Delta, I have no choice but to distribute Delta under the AGPLv3 license. That being said, I explicitly give permission for anyone to use, modify, and distribute all my original code for this project in any form, with or without attribution, without fear of legal consequences — unless you plan to submit your app to Apple’s App Store, in which case written permission from me is explicitly required. So it sounds like Apple is going out of their way to enforce the non-standard licensing clause of some third-party developer (who until this weekend would have been considered a somewhat hostile party from Apple's perspective)? Is there any precedent for this, or is it just a convenient excuse?
- hiatus 3y agoI see this in the bitbucket readme: > The GBA4iOS codebase is distributed under the GNU GPLv2 license. That being said, I explicitly give permission for anyone to use, modify, and distribute my original code for this project without fear of legal consequences — unless you plan to submit your app to Apple’s App Store, in which case written permission from me is explicitly required. Dependencies remain under their original licenses. It says it is GPL then adds additional terms—is that even allowed by the license?
- layer8 3y agoI don’t understand what exactly Apple’s objection is, given that the original is GPL’d open source and not present on the app store. One person’s “knockoff” is another person’s fork.
- Retric 3y agoApple doesn’t want the App Store filled with 100,000 copies of the same thing. So they are very strict around how different forks must be because of how low effort these copies are. The rules are simply a pragmatic response to their business goals.
- layer8 3y agoBut there was no alternative present on the app store. Apple also doesn’t define any clear rules here, they seem to decide in a very ad-hoc fashion.
- asddubs 3y agoit's not a fork unless source is available (even if it's a name replace copy-paste job) and other license terms are followed.
- layer8 3y agoTrue, but that’s not the rationale Apple gave here. I would understand if they rejected the app on grounds that it is violating the GPL terms, which would be rather easily fixable by the submitter, and then the app could be reapproved.
- asddubs 3y agoI'm not positive the app store terms are compatible with the AGPL
- Retr0id 3y agoThe source has a GPL license next to it, but there are additional licensing conditions that make it proprietary: > Licensing > The GBA4iOS codebase is distributed under the GNU GPLv2 license. That being said, I explicitly give permission for anyone to use, modify, and distribute my original code for this project without fear of legal consequences — unless you plan to submit your app to Apple’s App Store, in which case written permission from me is explicitly required. (emphasis mine) https://bitbucket.org/rileytestut/gba4ios/src/master/ https://bitbucket.org/rileytestut/gba4ios/src/master/
- mondobe 3y agoI'd guess Riley Testut (creator of GBA4iOS, which this app ripped off) is working on putting emulators on the App Store. (I don't know if he's announced this intention or not, but it seems likely) His emulator collection "Delta" is the flagship app of AltStore, which uses Apple's Developer program to let you sideload apps without jailbreaking your iOS. It's all pretty above-board, and if Nintendo wasn't the one to take this app down, it would be a perfect fit.
- lxgr 3y agoPorting a bunch of GPL-ed emulators to iOS and then claiming exclusive distribution rights in the App Store (but not actually distributing it there!) seems at least dubious, in my view.
- asow92 3y agoIs the issue just that the developer didn't give credit, or that even giving credit was enough to violate the guidelines?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- markx2 3y agoButtons. You need buttons. Analogue Pocket Everything Game Boy and so much more. https://www.analogue.co/pocket https://www.analogue.co/pocket
- jsheard 3y agoOr any of the multitude of Chinese emulation handhelds, which are generally cheaper, can emulate systems like the PS1/N64 which can't feasibly fit onto the Pockets FPGA, and are available in more ergonomic horizontal form factors. The Pocket is a nice piece of hardware but it's far from the only option if you want real buttons. Here's a primer on the current <$100 market: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UGr42nOv54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UGr42nOv54 . Above that price bracket there's options like the Retroid Pocket 4/Pro, which get into the territory of being fast enough to emulate the Gamecube/Wii/PS2.
- dotnet00 3y agoOr any controller and android phone clip
- talldayo 3y agoYeap. Analogue Pocket is neat, but pretty much anyone that can afford one probably already has hardware capable of playing Game Boy games in their pocket. Unless you're a stickler for FPGA gaming, I think most people would prefer to buy a cheap Bluetooth controller and play that way. It's not like most people still have their cartridge of Yoshi's Cookie to play on anyways.
- Dwedit 3y agoIt's very easy to screw up the controller when designing a device. And if the built-in controller sucks, then it's completely worthless no matter how powerful it is. D-Pads especially are hard to get right. You can either be way too lenient on diagonals, or way too hard to hit diagonals. I had a Chinese handheld where you couldn't consistently hit Down while holding Right. Sonic runs into the enemy because his roll attack didn't start.
- gamepsys 3y ago
- bilekas 3y agoI’m actually okay with this I can see why apple don’t want to open the floodgates of cloned open source apps and games floating through. However I’m surprised they’re willing To say they will allow rom loading on “retro” consoles considering Nintendos extremely strict history on the matter..
- astrange 3y agoNintendo doesn't stop people from writing retro emulators, nor do they have a way to do that.
- jsheard 3y agoCase in point, emulators have been available on the Android store pretty much forever and as long as they keep it clean by not distributing copyrighted ROMs or BIOS files directly in the app it's never really been an issue. Nintendo probably doesn't like it but they have no cause to have them taken down.
- tiltowait 3y ago> Notably, Apple confirmed to us that emulators on the App Store are permitted to load ROMs downloaded from the web, so long as the app is emulating retro console games only. Speculation (and conclusions!) all over the internet, including this site, post-emulation announcement was that Apple wouldn't allow retro game emulators, so this confirmation is pretty exciting[0]. [0] For some reason, any time someone says something like this, someone has to jump in and point out Android has allowed emulators forever. To anyone tempted to do that: so what? We aren't talking about Android.
- idle_zealot 3y agoThis is an odd requirement. It would make sense to require that no BIOS or decryption keys be distributed with the app, but the requirement for "retro" only is pretty arbitrary.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]