4 ms·
Medium bans AI-generated content from its paid Partner Program
- endre 3y agoit's medium that should be banned
- dkersten 3y agoBoth, really
- aldarisbm 3y agoHonest question... Why? I understand that medium is not absolutely necessary and ideally we would have an open source tool that is easy to deploy. In the meanwhile, I use medium quite a bit.
- barfbagginus 3y agoWhen we use medium, we tell our audience we don't care if they get bombarded with bad UX, like subscription popups. And we tell our accessibility activist audience that we don't want them to read us at all. I immediately nope out of medium articles. I black list medium on my search engines. And I criticize medium authors on HN instead of reading their articles. This is all with the hope of bringing back more accessible old school blogs. If I wrote a blog in 2024, I would use a free GitHub Pages site, and use a markdown based blog generator. This distributes my message for free, without attacking my audience's attention with sign up screens.
- wredue 3y agoYeah. Medium did help to consolidate searching for blogs, but it also vastly increased the extremely low effort, and encourages bringing hot garbage takes to the spotlight. I have yet to find a technical writer on medium that isn’t basically musing about what they learned that day in boot camp, or just regurgitating some stupidity they just read about how “FP is totally actually extremely performant if you just squint really really hard while lying about numbers!” The bar for “good” on medium is already so insanely low that I question their move here.
- sebastiennight 3y agoOr, for the non-technical audience, Ghost.org seems a solid recommendation, followed by Substack.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- felideon 3y agoHow is this policy enforceable? There aren’t any reliable ways to detect LLM-generated text, are there?
- rany_ 3y agoUsing common sense, probably. You don't need an LLM detector to tell that something is AI generated.
- paxys 3y agoYou don't need an LLM detector to tell that something is visibly AI generated. With some minor prompting and editing it can be indistinguishable from any other writing.
- TuringNYC 3y ago>> Using common sense, probably. You don't need an LLM detector to tell that something is AI generated. This could quickly turn into a witch hunt
- barfbagginus 3y agoMany people now believe things are AI generated the moment the writing says something they disagree with. That's fun!
- sebastiennight 3y agoThere's money to make with a Chrome extension that flags comments contrary to your beliefs and tags them as "likely AI-generated misinformation" while highlighting the "report" button.
- barfbagginus 3y agoMaybe there is money to be made. crypto lock the PCs of anyone petty enough to use such an extension. They deserve it. And boom, revenue. Disclaimer: I'm joking - don't do this. It could land you in the big house.
- hk__2 3y ago> Any story using AI help must clearly mention this within the first two paragraphs. What’s AI here? Is the spelling correction tool in Google Docs "AI"? Are the suggestions from my iPhone "AI"? This is the kind of very vague sentence written by someone who doesn’t understand AI.
- lelandfe 3y agohttps://help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/22576852947223-Artificial-Intelligence-AI-content-policy https://help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/22576852947223-Art... > We define AI-generated writing as writing where the majority of the content has been created by an AI-writing program with little or no edits, improvements, fact-checking, or changes. This does not include AI writing tools such as AI outlining, or AI assisted fact, spelling, or grammar checkers > Do I need to disclose the use of AI-assistance such as grammar or spell checkers, outline assistance, or fact verification? > No, you do not need to disclose this use. You must disclose if you are using text or images generated by AI
- barfbagginus 3y agoThis is not very clear about the case where the text is AI generated and substantially edited, fact checked, and improved by a human co-author. I think that kind of writing is perfectly valid. AI contexts can now include primary references, and with human critique, AI can fix a lot of its own style and factuality issues. A good author writing this way will end up writing in their own voice, but spend less time drafting and revising, since they can delegate that to their AI assistant.
- lelandfe 3y agoI believe that would be, from my link, "AI-assistive." Such text would need "a disclosure at the beginning of the story (within the first two paragraphs)." The reason given is, "in practice, AI-assist is often a way to insert small snippets of AI-generated content that often suffers from the same problems as fully AI- generated stories." In other words, readers need a heads up that, no matter how well-edited the text is, there's a chance of hallucinated junk to be found within. I'm sure I'm missing some edge cases, but this all seems pretty darn lucid to me!
- michaelbuckbee 3y agoAll publishers are grappling with this where they want generally higher quality content (defined as more engaging, intrinsic quality is something else) and less low effort spam or retreaded concepts. AI-generated content has really dropped the floor on how cheap it is to produce niche blogspam, and they're saying: "Hey if you're pushing out 1000s of articles a day on a topic and we look at it and it's insane gibberish, we're just going to assume it's no good on principle and ban you." Nobody is getting banned for the "Gray-AI" of assisted writing, where you get help with an outline or use Grammarly Pro to rewrite your sentences into coherence.
- Verdex 3y agoI believe this to be the correct take away. They don't actually want to ban AI content. They want to ban garbage content. If they claim that something is AI content, then it's not like there's a good defense a writer can offer. Short of meticulously recording themselves typing the article up on a typewriter in real life ahead of time. In real time so everyone can see them going through revisions. This is AI and we're banning you, is simply a sufficiently socially acceptable reason to get rid of content that they otherwise don't want clogging up their site.
- red_admiral 3y agoIndeed. xkcd 810 comes to mind.
- monkpit 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/810/ https://xkcd.com/810/
- sebastiennight 3y agoWell someone could easily whip up a prompt-to-video which, given a prompt, outputs an entire article AND a screenrecording of laboriously typing-and-revising from a draft to the final output. It would probably take a weekend.
- neverokay 3y agoHmm, I didn’t consider this. Anyone actually generating AI articles on these types of platforms and profiting? Thanks for letting me know Medium lol.
- dandesim 3y agoJust like many of these schemes, the first person to do it will probably make a good amount of money, but every nth person after that will make much less. There has always been a large group of people trying to spam their way through the Medium partner program.
- htrp 3y agoHow can they tell? as far as I know the state of the art can't reliably distinguish ai generated content.
- wvalurejr 3y agoIs this story not AI-generated? Every sentence feels like it's just repeating the same thing and some of them are... like what is this: 'With the banning of AI-generated content from the Paid Partner program, Medium has further cracked down on distributing this type of content.' With the posting of this post, I am making people more aware that there are posts on HN, further cracking down on not posting.