5 ms·
Taking CO2 out of the air would be an expensive way to fight climate change
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoIt seems fairly obvious to me that the most cost effective method would be to stop digging up old sequestered CO2 from the ground and burning it. Is this not obvious to others? A simple, yet very effective old proverb is that when you find yourself in a hole, first stop digging.
- sgt 3y agoCost effective, maybe. But not simple. Far from it. In fact, might turn out to be not so cost effective either if it's almost impossible to force billions of people to change their habits.
- dheera 3y ago> Is this not obvious to others? Unfortunately it isn't. Most people still need to get from A to B and can't afford a Tesla.
- candiddevmike 3y agoIf externalities were factored in, they shouldn't be able to afford gas either then...
- dheera 3y agoI agree with you, but the externalities hit them 30 years later, and the majority of the population are trying to figure out how to even make it for another 6 months (financially).
- prepend 3y agoRight, then they can’t afford to live. Telling people to stop after all this time is a non-starter unless you’re willing to militarily stop countries from burning oil.
- CalRobert 3y agoWell, burning oil kills people, but they can't afford to defend themselves. When you're watching your kids die in your country's fifth freak heatwave/power outage in a year it will be little comfort to know that at least people in rich countries got to have cheap gas.
- prepend 3y agoIt’s not just rich people who have cheap gas. The issue is the billions of poor people who have cheap gas.
- CalRobert 3y agoCertainly, but rich people use an awful lot more. Someone in Vietnam on a 50cc Honda is putting out less carbon than someone in Orange County with an Escalade.
- prepend 3y agoThere’s a lot more people in Vietnam than Orange County. And I expect making them stop using their motorcycle is harder as they have fewer or no alternatives.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThis is almost entirely a problem of shitty political leadership. There are solutions, and a transition is possible, if the emergency was treated like the emergency that it is. But this threaten very powerful established interests, and those interests have been remarkably adept at mobilizing themselves and spreading disinformation, fear, and doubt in the population. Even the most weak and financially friendly efforts are attacked and undermined. Like a carbon tax with a generous rebate -- like here in Canada, and a policy formerly advocated by conservative economists, but now a target of populist demagoguery and will likely be gone after the next election. Conservative and neo-liberal ideological strains have spent 40+ years steadfastly eliminating the ability of central governments to plan and have coordinated industrial/macro-economic strategies in the west -- something they mostly had after WWII. Now we desperately need it.
- meristohm 3y agoYep. Gasoline is far too cheap. We've gotten used to it, taken it for granted, and that's a huge problem. We've degraded the land to the point where most of us can't find enough food locally and rely on food grown and shipped thanks to petroleum. To wean ourselves off will be painful, but not impossible. Building strong local community is a good start; I've got to know a few neighbors now in this rural area and we're starting to offer to pick up groceries for each other, thus reducing the car trips to town. Building trust goes a long way to not needing to do everything yourself.
- simonw 3y agoThink of this problem in terms of how many people would need to change the way they do things. And how many financial interests (with the resources to actively lobby against change) would be affected too. If you have an obvious answer that takes those two things into account I'd love to hear it!
- meristohm 3y agoAddressing things like this is part of the purpose of government (on any level, be it personal, family, community, on up). Regulations can shift our habits. Does a corporation's existence justify its continued existence? Like people, it'll try to keep on going, but it not being a person, it's okay to let these things go. People will lose jobs, but the answer to that is to revitalize the land so we can transition to getting our food nearby, and spending the time to do it- time well spent. Computers, for example, are a fun diversion we enjoy thanks to our curiosity, ingenuity, and cheap (money-wise, not life-wise) energy. I don't consider them essential. Letting go of a lot of our costly and polluting playthings is the way to go. Children cry when someone takes their candy away, and we'll be no different unless we realize that candy is killing us and we exercise our adult brains to change our habits.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y ago> Think of this problem in terms of how many people would need to change the way they do things. Looking to the future, virtually the whole of humanity will drastically need to change the way they do things to cope with the changes in climate. It's likely too late now, but there would be far less changes needed if we stop pumping out so much CO2 into the air and thus reduce the likelihood of climate catastrophes. > And how many financial interests (with the resources to actively lobby against change) would be affected too. Putting financial interests ahead of the health of our environments is how we got into this mess. > If you have an obvious answer that takes those two things into account I'd love to hear it! You've framed the problem in an unhelpful way - you're asking for a solution that perpetuates unsustainable practices.
- simonw 3y agoI'll take any solution that works. We've been trying to convince people to emit less CO2 for decades and that sadly doesn't seem to be working well enough to get us out of this mess.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoSure, but that’s like saying the simplest way to solve water shortages is to just stop drinking it.
- megabless123 3y agonot a fair comparison. water does not have alternatives.
- chii 3y agobut it is a fair comparison - there's currently no real alternatives for fossil fuels. Renewables do not have the density required for a lot of transportation, not to mention fossil fuels like oil are the feedstock for a lot of chemicals required for modern day manufacturing. Some sources of electricity could be replaced by renewables, but not all. And certainly not as cheaply as oil or gas is.
- sanderjd 3y agoWe also do not - yet! - have carbon-neutral alternatives for energy usage, either in amount or kind. This is why people are working both to scale up the kinds of energy use that is already carbon-neutral but which there is not yet enough of, and to figure out alternatives for things that do not already have carbon-neutral solutions.
- nope1000 3y agoAbsolutely and electric cars and heat pumps powered by renewables are great but it's nice to have when we still want to have air travel or meat while maintaining net zero.
- dheera 3y agoI recently moved into an apartment that has a heat pump. I save $50 on my electric bill per month but I also pay $1000/month more in rent because "woo wah it's new and fancy and modern" As long as environmental friendliness is a luxury, nothing is going to happen. This is the dynamic that needs to be disrupted, somehow.
- prepend 3y agoI think everyone understands that but it’s cheap and the world depends on energy. So it’s not they people don’t get it, it’s that the world is working toward getting renewables cheap enough to fulfill current and future energy needs.
- JadeNB 3y ago> I think everyone understands that but it’s cheap and the world depends on energy. So it’s not they people don’t get it, it’s that the world is working toward getting renewables cheap enough to fulfill current and future energy needs. The realization that needs to be reached (but won't, because people don't think that way) to power real change is that it's not cheap; we just don't pay the externalities at the pump, so we get used to thinking that it's cheap.
- sanderjd 3y agoIt is cheap for the people using the energy, because the externalities are not paid.
- sanderjd 3y agoThat is a result, not an action. There's a book that came out recently - "Not the End of the World" by Hannah Ritchie - that starts by digging into a two-pronged definition of the concept of "sustainability", where the first prong is about meeting the needs of current generations, and the second prong (which is the one we usually focus on when thinking about sustainability) is about maintaining an environment in which future generations can meet their needs as well. The problem with most of what we're doing today is that it fails the second prong: future generations won't be able to meet their needs if the earth is too hot to support human civilization. But the problem with your proposed solution is that it fails the first prong. If you were dictator of the world and waved your wand such that nobody ever dug up another fossil fuel, starting from this moment, the result would be upheaval, privation, and death on a massive scale. Human civilization is, at this moment, dependent on digging up those fossil fuels and lighting them on fire. So what the (great many) people who are working on this problem are doing is trying to navigate a path that threads a needle between these two bad outcomes, transitioning away from the dig-stuff-up-and-burn-it model to one that still works about as well - or ideally, even better! - for people currently living, without sacrificing the lives of people who will live in the future. And yeah, pretty much everyone involved thinks that does mean we'll dig up very little of those fossils, on the other side of this transition. But that is more like an effect than a cause. Hope that helps!
- tasty_freeze 3y agoI think that is an uncharitable reading of the person you are replying to. I don't think they want to wave a magic wand and stop all oil/coal tomorrow. But investing time/money/policy to move away from fossil fuels is something we could have been doing since at least the Kyoto Protocol and yet we are doing next to nothing, and in fact are still subsidizing oil companies.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y ago> I don't think they want to wave a magic wand and stop all oil/coal tomorrow. Tomorrow is far too late. We should have started reducing our dependencies on oil since the 1970s.
- 3y ago
- jonnycomputer 3y agoThere is already too much carbon dioxide in the atmosphere for use to not exceed temperature targets. We need carbon capture. And carbon capture in the oceans promises to be much more cost effective.
- sanderjd 3y agoYep! I'm optimistic that we're going to (painstakingly, with a lot of work) get to net-neutral emissions over the coming decades. But then I believe we'll almost certainly want to go net-negative for some period of time. And we'll need to do a bunch of research and experimentation into carbon removal techniques to figure out how to do that. The earlier we start doing that, the better!
- johnsea 3y agoyes, and: Limits to Growth. It was known in 1972. The number of people is too large. Much too large. But what can we do (nothing?)
- meristohm 3y agoYeah, seems we're in a population boom because we can. Lynx population grows with rabbits, wolves with moose, etc. This increased carrying capacity of the earth is thanks to the energy we pull from the ground (and air, water, sun), and in times of plenty maybe we're a little wasteful... How many people can Earth reasonably support? Edit to answer your (rhetorical?) question: What we can do is build strong local connections; that's the first step towards decreasing our level of domestication, per Why We Need to be Wild, by Jessica Carew Kraft.
- Biologist123 3y agoThe one thing we must do is somehow the one thing we cannot do. It’ll send you crazy if you think about it too much.
- oneshtein 3y agoI was downvoted multiple times for this obvious idea. How you plan to strike those coal power stations?
- sanderjd 3y agoI didn't downvote any of this, but for what it's worth I do think it's pretty common to see downvotes for ideas that everyone has seen a million times before, for which the counterarguments are just as well known and only slightly less obvious.
- hncensorship69 3y ago[flagged]
- ndsipa_pomu 3y ago> If CO2 was really a problem, we have the technology to easily pull it out of the air and store it: trees. It's not in any doubt that CO2 is a major problem leading to climate catastrophes (or at least catastrophes for how and where humans currently live). However, trees could be part of a solution in capturing CO2, but humanity is reducing the number of trees, so that's not really going to help matters. https://ourworldindata.org/deforestation https://ourworldindata.org/deforestation
- hncensorship69 3y ago> It's not in any doubt that CO2 is a major problem leading to climate catastrophes There's actually a lot of doubt regarding that > but humanity is reducing the number of trees, so that's not really going to help matters. Sure, so if the CO2 nuts were really serious about helping the planet they'd be organizing to plant massive amounts of trees. Not standing in the middle of highways yelling at people.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y ago> There's actually a lot of doubt regarding that This is the point where you should be providing quality evidence of your opinion. https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/evidence/ https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/evidence/ > Sure, so if the CO2 nuts were really serious about helping the planet they'd be organizing to plant massive amounts of trees. Not standing in the middle of highways yelling at people. I suspect that you haven't really thought through the best way of effecting change and are instead just putting forward a political opinion.
- hncensorship69 3y agoI think we both learned from COVID that shoving links back and forth on the internet does nothing to change someone's mind.
- gmuslera 3y agoThere is no way to solve the problem without taking out what is causing it somehow. But it should not be the only measure taken. Saying so, if the problem is money, the groups that made themselves astronomically rich putting directly or indirectly that CO2 there should be the main component of that economic equation. Essentially they created a problem, got rich doing that, but all the rest of the world is the one that should get poor trying to fix it is a bad pattern.
- jl6 3y agoAt the macro level, everybody got rich from burning fossil fuels. A thousand or so billionaires who got extra rich doesn’t really make a dent on the activities of the other billions of people.
- JadeNB 3y agoI don't think that's entirely true. 100 companies are responsible for 71% of global emissions (https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10/100-fossil-fuel-companies-investors-responsible-71-global-emissions-cdp-study-climate-change https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10... ); I don't have the statistics—I seem to remember reading something on this recently, but I can't find it—but I think that it's not unreasonable to believe that a few billionaires, and now trillionaires, might have a similarly disproportionate impact on emissions.
- nerdsniped529 3y ago[flagged]
- chii 3y ago> 100 companies are responsible for 71% of global emissions these companies emitted carbon to satisfy the demands for goods/services from various populations around the world. By pinning the emissions onto the companies like this as responsible, it is indirectly implying that the end consumer has no responsibility. Which is absolutely not true. The way, i think, to fix it is to price carbon emissions properly. This requires _all_ countries in the world to participate and enforce.
- RandomWorker 3y agoThe numbers I’ve seen for this technology are currently it’s about $100/tonne CO2. And it would take 6.9% of global GDP to go net zero.
- blagie 3y ago> According to the new report by research firm Rhodium Group, the US needs to spend roughly $100 billion a year on CDR in order to scale up to a level that would help the country meet its climate goals. That's not expensive. That's less than $300 per person per year. The US spends $800B on military. If $100B were to make a dent in climate change, that's a bargain. I'd consider the US spending anything short of $1T / year here reasonable, sustainable, and likely economically-beneficial. That's about 3% of GDP, for reference. The reason for having a military is to be disaster-ready. Even medical spending is something like 1/3 of our GDP, and reducing pollution would help there. Any way you run the numbers, $100B is not much here, and critically, those costs would go down as we invest and technology improves. I'm very far from the far-left fringe in terms of believing in some of the horror stories around climate change -- the discourse is polarized -- but even taking relatively right-wing estimates of impact, it's hard to see how a spend on that order is not justified. The problem here is people don't see the difference between large numbers. $5M, $5B, and $5T all simply look "big."
- simonCGN 3y agoEqually, reports say that without actively taking CO2 out of the air, we will not meet our climate goals.
- candiddevmike 3y agoI think the only truly carbon negative way of doing that is through plants, possibly including burying them. I don't trust any carbon capture company to be truly negative, there is always too much hand waving with their math.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoYes, I think this is true.
- mvkel 3y agoYes. Short of a tech breakthrough, the cost isn't dropping quickly enough. Although we humans are known for tech breakthroughs. Ironically, afforestation is one of the cheapest and most effective ways to install air purifiers at scale.
- henearkr 3y agoBut afforestation is too slow compared to the rate of new CO2 emissions, so that it will do little to nothing to avoid the huge peak in atmospheric CO2.
- mvkel 3y agoRight. Hence the required breakthrough
- sanderjd 3y agoNot only are we known for tech breakthroughs, but this is how they happen. That is, people first have to be working on problems, trying (and mostly failing) to get things to work, in order to make those breakthroughs.
- mvkel 3y agoThat's been my ongoing frustration with climate tech. Problems need to feel urgent enough to gain sustainable support from society, but climate change doesn't feel urgent, despite it being a five alarm fire relative to the last few millennia. I suspect we won't get serious about breakthroughs until 2100 or so. Fingers crossed for fusion.
- sanderjd 3y agoFor what it's worth, I get where you're coming from on this in theory, but in practice I don't think this thesis has been borne out. If this were right, we wouldn't have solar power scaling up by hundreds of gigawatts per year, or the EV and charging network deployment we're currently seeing, or a bunch of recent progress on geothermal power, electrolysis, and heat pumps (including for industrial heat). I'm not sure which part of your thesis is wrong though. Maybe people do feel sufficient urgency to work on all this? Or maybe people are actually capable of working on things without needing a "five alarm fire" to motivate them. I tend think it's the latter, personally.
- karol 3y agoAlso there is no reason to do it as it's not a man-made "climate change". People need to adapt, not fight it.
- JadeNB 3y ago> Also there is no reason to do it as it's not a man-made "climate change". People need to adapt, not fight it. Even if you believe it's not man-made, the historical way that organisms "adapt" to climate change is by going extinct in favor of new organisms that can handle the new climate. "People should just go extinct" is, I suppose, a proposal that one could make, but I don't think it's useful along any axis.
- hackeraccount 3y agoThat's because other animals (mainly) rely on natural selection to deal with environmental changes. Humans can use what's effectively Lamarkian selection to deal the environmental change.
- qaq 3y agoIf only we could invent a thing that you can plant and it grows by itself and absorbs CO2
- thatwasunusual 3y agoNot a likely solution. https://www.co2meter.com/blogs/news/could-global-co2-levels-be-reduced-by-planting-trees https://www.co2meter.com/blogs/news/could-global-co2-levels-...
- meristohm 3y agoCouple it with decreasing our demand for energy and you just might be onto something.
- oneshtein 3y agoAlgae with nitrogen fixing organelle (nitroplast) can be such "plant", because it will need air, water, and micronutrients to fixate CO₂ and NO₂, so it can be used as fertilizer, which will offset cost of CO₂ fixing. See https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-90204-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-90204-8
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolf550e 3y agoI very much hope Casey Handmer's Terraform Industries succeeds. It's the best case plan I'm aware of for dealing with CO2. Put carbon capture, electrolyser and sabatier style reactor directly next to solar panels, produce Methane, pipe it directly into normal natural gas pipelines, use it to produce fuel and everything we currently use oil for, so everything that uses this methane is carbon neutral. https://terraformindustries.wordpress.com/ https://terraformindustries.wordpress.com/
- namuol 3y agoDo they account for methane leaks in their “carbon neutral” calculations?
- wolf550e 3y agoI don't know but I guess they don't intend to leak a lot from their own device/tank and once they have sold it to the pipeline they consider it "consumed". The idea is to capture the same amount of CO2 from the air as is in the methane that is consumed.
- namuol 3y agoIgnoring external factors like this is how we got into this mess.
- djklanac 3y agoGiven climate change's existential consequences, the price seems like a steal. Compare it to 2023 DoD budget of $773 billion [1] and the _net_ interest the feds paid on national debt in 2023 of $659 billion [2]. Certainly, we should implement numerous intervention strategies to combat climate change. Government spending seems largely unaccountable to citizens outside of the lobbyist elite. Why not, at least, spend some Monopoly money on something that might actually work? Edit: spelling 1) https://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/Documents/defbudget/FY2023/FY2023_Budget_Request_Overview_Book.pdf https://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/Documents/defbudg... 2) https://www.crfb.org/blogs/2023-interest-costs-reach-659-billion https://www.crfb.org/blogs/2023-interest-costs-reach-659-bil...
- jfengel 3y agoIt's not just expensive. It's solving the wrong problem. You can't capture CO2 unless we have vast amounts of carbon free energy. If we have vast amounts of carbon free energy, we'll stop adding CO2. At which point the problem stops getting worse and (very gradually) improves on its own. If the problem has gotten to the point where the amount of CO2 is itself a danger, it means we're still adding CO2 to the atmosphere, and sequestering CO2 just isn't an option. So this is considering a scenario that isn't just expensive, but effectively impossible. And worrying about "things we might do some day" misses the fact that we need to stop using fossil fuels right now. Plotting to remove the existing carbon just isn't helpful and makes things worse.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoActually, even if we stopped putting carbon in the atmosphere immediately right now, we'd still need carbon capture to meet our targets.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoDoes someone thing this is not true?
- kiba 3y agoWe need the technology to less gradually improve our solution after going carbon zero, but going carbon zero takes the highest priority. So carbon capture should still be funded, but it would be on the backburner. I don't know what is the appropriate funding. A billion dollars per year, maybe?
- jonnycomputer 3y agoI think we are already well on our way to going to net zero wrt energy production and consumption.
- sanderjd 3y agoGood news! You've just done a good job of describing the current situation. And you're right that this is good.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Olesya000 3y ago[dead]
- scary-size 3y agoThis article a few weeks ago gives a good overview of the current state of carbon capture: https://cleantechnica.com/2024/02/15/ccs-redux-best-carbon-capture-facility-in-world-creates-25x-more-co2-from-use-of-product/ https://cleantechnica.com/2024/02/15/ccs-redux-best-carbon-c...
- simonw 3y agoThat website is a great example of how density of advertising impacts perceived credibility. Is that information accurate? It's hard for me to tell, but the amount of junk on that page (especially on mobile) gives me a really bad first impression.
- scary-size 3y agoReader view is definitely advised! It does link out to some sources, but it’s not quoting any studies.
- schnebbau 3y agoIt's the year 3052. Human numbers have dwindled since the runaway global warming that eventually triggered the water crisis. The biggest cities are now barren ruins. Humanity survives in tribal pockets near the poles, making do with scavenged old tech from the past. A breakthrough! Someone discovers an old harddrive that contains information on why we didn't fix this when it was still possible... An extraterrestrial event? Nuclear war? An incurable disease? Technological limitation? "It was too expensive."
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoIt might be expensive with current technology, but cost will likely get down with more research + as a side effect it will be a basis for terraforming of planets and creating controlled environments on the Moon, i.e. domes in craters.