4 ms·
Interesting. I will say I find the writing a little off putting. Felt like they wanted to rope in every name, company and person involved here. "medieval haza
by duxup 3y ago
Interesting.
I will say I find the writing a little off putting. Felt like they wanted to rope in every name, company and person involved here.
"medieval hazards" I don't even know what that means but mold is a thing in the modern area too.
Clearly this publication is pro labor unions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_Notes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_Notes), but it is strange that they push this narrative and note how people in the labor union were working in these poor conditions:
"many have required their union workers to build on 12-hour shifts, seven days a week. Despite months of worker concerns, managers waited until early February to take basic precautions against the mold—precautions that might slow construction"
Gee thanks labor unions for helping out?
This article is all over the place.
There's a story here that IMO could have been told, and accomplished the same goals without the internal weirdness of the article sort of pointing back at itself.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThink your response is similarly all over the place. "Despite months of worker concerns, managers waited until early February to take basic precautions against the mold" Doesn't this indicate that the union was raising concerns and needed to push for action? Mold is no joke. I knew a guy that died after working in moldy conditions. He was old, and pneumonia.
- duxup 3y agoI wouldn't assume that.
- darby_eight 3y ago...why not? The article seems to clearly imply it to my eye.
- duxup 3y agoI would think a publication would have explicitly said so in order to as they say "advocates for a revitalization of the labor movement". I got no problem with that goal, it's just a strange article to try to do that with.
- stuaxo 3y agoNot sure why that is - you can see from the first paragraph that there are problems that are the result of poor workers rights.
- replygirl 3y agothe NLRA/B don't cover managers, and union leadership is a separate role from on-the-job management. for the readership of a magazine targeting current or prospective union members and leadership, this is fundamental knowledge, so it won't ever be spelled out in an article it's also worth clarifying that labor notes is _pro labor_, not necessarily _pro union_, and especially not _pro one specific type of union (e.g. industrial vs craft)_. when a labor union fails its members, this is one of the canonical publications covering it
- duxup 3y agoIf the article only works if you approach it as preaching to the choir ... maybe it does make sense. But it certainly makes it a poor article if they're "advocates for a revitalization of the labor movement" beyond the the rank and file union choir who would assume the union took action. You'd think they'd want to appeal to others too. For the record, I don't so much care what the union did or didn't do, my comment was more about the article itself.
- replygirl 3y agoright, i'm not taking a side either, just saying your comment showed you lacked the context to understand what you were reading. as you stated and defended. you made a misinterpretation that can only happen if you _don't know the basics what a union is_ — important context for reading a labor publication targeting labor people.
- Animats 3y agoRight. It's also assuming knowledge about the auto industry. Ford is building what they call "Blue Oval City" near Glendale, Kentucky, an all-new complex of plants. [1] https://bestneighborhood.org/race-in-glendale-ky/ https://bestneighborhood.org/race-in-glendale-ky/
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI think what you are missing is that Labor Unions are people that are generally trying to do the right thing. So were probably working for awhile with the mold, and raising concerns, but as time goes by, and issues are ignored, you have to start complaining louder and louder. Then by the time someone listens, it seems like you are screaming about nothing.
- arrakeenrevived 3y agoThe article directly says the opposite, and reinforces what GP comment was saying about the union not being helpful: > Although Dugan, Shaffer, and other members say their union stewards on site helped press their concerns to management, they say that local and international IBEW officers who visited the facility scoffed at their concerns. Dugan says a local officer refused to file a grievance on his behalf about the mold in January. One worker requested to stay anonymous out of concern that union officials might withhold his future job placements if he spoke out.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoGuess we need to separate the local union members from the national organization. This is a labor focused web site talking about labor issues. Not run by any one particular union, it isn't a union controlled web site that is trying to pump a particular message. It is an article about labor, where the factory, local union, and national union organization, all had some part to play. So this article is covering all of those issues, not trying to be all 'super pro union'.
- mrguyorama 3y agoA reminder to the audience that Ford's labor unions voted to reduce their wages by like 30% back when Ford was struggling in 2009. A labor union WANTS to work, so they can make money. They aren't going to strike the second the first moldy crate comes in, because they want money. They will do their damndest to work within the system to solve things, because they worked very hard to build those resolution systems into their working contracts during the previous negotiation cycle. Union laborers didn't want to stop working, they wanted to stop breathing in mold.
- davorak 3y ago> "medieval hazards" I don't even know what that means but mold is a thing in the modern area too. A definition from google "medieval" -> primitive or very old fashioned. The implication is that those running the operation have an old or primitive mindset or safety standards.
- cptskippy 3y ago> The implication is that those running the operation have an old or primitive mindset or safety standards. What? That isn't at all what it said. > But under all the high-tech green fanfare, several construction workers, including some who wished to be anonymous, say the site has been gripped by mold and respiratory illness—medieval hazards that workers feel managers neglected in the pressure to quickly open the plant. They were contrasting the high tech and modern nature of the plant to the medieval hazard of mold. The assertion being that mold isn't a modern day problem. Mold, insects, vermin, and disease were common everyday problems in medieval times that were overshadowed by the more pressing needs around food scarcity and clean water.
- singleshot_ 3y agoIt’s a medical hazard, but the editor is as illiterate as the author.
- davorak 3y ago> medical hazard Ha, ok that seems really likely now that it has been pointed out.
- arrakeenrevived 3y agoFWIW I agree with you. The title hardly makes sense to me as well. "Ford's Battery Flagship" - even after reading the article I'm still not sure what this is. "flagship" is used only in the title and nowhere else. Based on my knowledge of Ford, I would assume their "flagship" would be the F150, but this article seems to be talking about some sort of battery factory that a South Korean company is building? Similarly, "socked by mold sickness" is a weird phrase. Feels like an inappropriate use of "socked" here. If the project is delayed because workers are getting sick, just say that. The title strikes me as a failed attempt at clickbait, and immediately makes me distrustful of the rest of the article, which is confirmed by the "all over the place"ness that you mentioned as well.
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago"Flagship" means important. The press release seems to indicate it's importance. https://corporate.ford.com/articles/electrification/blue-oval-city.html https://corporate.ford.com/articles/electrification/blue-ova... ""FORD TO LEAD AMERICA'S SHIFT TO ELECTRIC VEHICLES WITH NEW BLUEOVAL CITY MEGA CAMPUS IN TENNESSEE AND TWIN BATTERY PLANTS IN KENTUCKY; $11.4B INVESTMENT TO CREATE 11,000 JOBS AND POWER NEW LINEUP OF ADVANCED EVS FORD TO BRING ELECTRIC ZERO-EMISSION VEHICLES AT SCALE TO AMERICAN CUSTOMERS WITH THE LARGEST, MOST ADVANCED, MOST EFFICIENT AUTO PRODUCTION COMPLEX IN ITS 118-YEAR HISTORY""
- stuaxo 3y agoYes, flagship is pretty normal usage, very strange quibble to have.
- ajmurmann 3y agoI don't think the word "flagship" is the issue. The issue is that no other noun follows. If this was "flagship factory" or "flagship truck" it would be much clearer. To me the headline wasn't clearer do to "flagship" being followed by "socked" which I am most commonly used to seeing as a noun rather than a verb, especially in a news article rather than a conversation in a pub.
- dotancohen 3y agoI kind of get the impression that it's another EV hit piece. The fact that the factory will be making EV batteries has nothing to do with the mold problems, yet the reader is constantly being reminded of it.
- elevaet 3y agoI've been noticing a lot of these "EV hit pieces". What's going on with that? Is it organic? Are there nefarious actors (ahem ... oil?) trying to stem the tide? What's going on?
- duxup 3y agoI'm not in on the hit piece theory here but I do think that anything novel-ish often gets mentioned no matter how relevant it is to a larger topic.
- jimbob45 3y agoBRICS/OPEC has a very vested interest in making sure EVs never achieve deep market penetration.
- wobbly_bush 3y agoBRICS and OPEC are two very different things. Except one country in BRICS, the remaining ones are oil importers. They would gladly get rid of that dependency for national security reasons alone.
- natch 3y agoI have no inside info but it stands to reason that big oil, legacy auto, and short sellers of EV-associated stocks would not be opposed to negative coverage of EVs.
- gruez 3y agoGiven the pro-union affiliation of this publication that the parent commenter mentioned, as well as the fact that EVs take less labor to assemble and maintain, my guess would be that they're trying to protect their jobs.
- araes 3y agoGenerally in the same place, just not for the same reasons. A lot of journalist writing is inherently sensationalistic, because the metric has become an ambulance chasing and gross out horror metric. Personally, have more issue with the automaton-like reactions of the workers. 1000 workers, who are holding fundraisers to help each other find other work, and recover from illnesses, smell mold so strong it "hits you when you walk by the plant, and yet almost no personal responsibility. Have to be forced to wear masks. Don't just buy bleach and nuke the area into oblivion. Boxes had large Do Not Bring Inside, boxes are brought inside. Obviously illegal behavior. Where's the documentation of provable illegalities? Every phone's got a camera with timestamps. (also a serious issue with the military barracks situation. You went home to this every night? Took years and a Reuters expose? [1]). However, still sympathetic. "Electrical workers complained to foremen." Objects replaced just prior to safety inspections. Months of mold complaints, largely ignored. 12 health or safety investigations, half closed, half limbo. Must be infuriating working in technician industries. Reuters investigation of SpaceX was basically a deja-vu story. "Bad safety results? Stop reporting." [2] These days it seems better to go to a journalist, than the safety agencies, they're far too financially motivated. "Good for Kentucky business. Die of mold? We'll give you a plaque somewhere, in a decade or two once the money's extracted." [1] https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/02/16/military-families-basing-housing-may-soon-be-able-withhold-rent-disputes.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/02/16/military-fami... [2] https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/spacex-musk-safety/ https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/spacex-m...
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThe Reuters SpaceX story is full of nonsense. Starting by claiming they had a scoop
- TylerE 3y agoYes, this sort of writing is very common from heavily slanted/borderline propaganda sources. Strongertowns is the same way. Lots of scare words, minimal substance.
- hakdbha 3y ago[dead]
- samirillian 3y agoa) I like the language use. The title is punchy, and it makes you check it out just because you want to know what it means. Medieval hazards sticks with you. b) there’s not a lot of money in being a commie journalist so this is probably some volunteer. c) I live in Kentucky and had not heard about this. d) re Kentucky, this place is wet
- h0l0cube 3y ago> "medieval hazards" I don't even know what that means but mold is a thing in the modern area too. Maybe. But the situation sounds unlike any modern workplace I know of: > Worker complaints piled up until, on December 8, Abel management hired the firm Environmental Testing & Consulting of Kentucky to take “limited samples” for mold. Their report, sent to Abel less than one week later, found seven types of mold inside the wooden crates, including three in “heavy” concentrations. It also noted an “intense mold odor” inside the containers. > To limit exposure, the report included a recommendation for handling the wooden boxes: “DO NOT PUT INSIDE.”
- cptskippy 3y ago> "medieval hazards" I don't even know what that means but mold is a thing in the modern area too. The author was just trying to convey that these days we remediate mold issues, where as in medieval times mold was just something you lived with because you had bigger issues. They were trying to juxtapose the fact that the this was suppose to be a modern state of the art battery manufacturing facility with the fact that they were being told to just live with the mold. Imagine they popped open a crate and it was infested by rats. Would management have just told them to work around the rats?
- myaccount2131 3y agoThe comment here is out of place, as the general point of the article is sufficiently said. I'm not sure why this is top comment, it's detractive of discussion. A better solution would be to summarize your findings, and state that the article was poorly written. 'Socking' the author is clearly anti-discussion, distracting, and not worth the toxicity other than a quick offhand remark to accompany an opinion that talks of the main topic at hand
- readyman 3y agoLabor Notes is pro workers. It's a very well-established and highly respected publication that advocates for strong unions (controlled by workers) over weak unions (controlled by bureaucrats).