6 ms·
"Strong focus on aesthetics" contributed to collapse of Norway timber bridge
- te_chris 3y agoTruly a generational parable for our times.
- voisin 3y agoArchitects’ first commandment: always prioritize function over form.
- trgn 3y agoFunction over form is a false equivalency, a modernist fetish. Architect's first commandment should be to strive to a perfect integration of beauty, usefulness and durability. There are many real world examples, so it's not a trade-off. Plus, that "strong focus on aesthetics" seem to be a throwaway comment in the report, and it is disputed by the design studio who built the bridge.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoIt presupposes a false _dichotomy_, one that misunderstands the nature of beauty. A building's beauty will in large part be a matter of its _function_. It it not just a matter of decoration, which is important, but does not exhaust the aesthetic concerns of an architect. The Pantheon in Rome is an especially nice sign of contradiction, but it is hardly alone. We are human beings, not some consumerist homo economicus that exists merely to eat, shit, drink, and copulate and in a bestial manner. Let us care about the beauty of our environment. This can be done even within means. Beauty is a transcendental. Those who attack it, or insult it, who denigrate it, who dismiss it are misanthropes and enemies of the entire human race.
- trgn 3y agoright on!
- zdragnar 3y ago"prioritizing function over form" is not a dichotomy, merely a statement that when the two are in conflict, function should win. That does not strictly mean that the two are always in conflict. I am more than a machine without feeling, but I prefer my bridges to not collapse when I drive on them, no matter how pretty they are.
- chx 3y agoNah. Have you seen the Sydney Opera House?
- hilux 3y agoUnsurprisingly, this is Wurster Hall, home of the Architecture School (aka "College of Environmental Design") at UC Berkeley: https://www.sosbrutalism.org/cms/15892267 https://www.sosbrutalism.org/cms/15892267
- trgn 3y agoHorrific, but salvageable. Put on a wide overhang flat roof, so rain no longer streaks down the wall, and wash/paint it. Then, it will just be a large no frills classroom building. Not great, but no longer offensive either.
- MeImCounting 3y agoIve never understood why this style of architecture is seen as "horrific" and "offensive". It looks nice. I like to see the materials a building is made of. I am so sick stucco and paneling trying to hide the material a building is made of. If you want to paint it paint a mural. Why must everything be sterilized and flattened.
- trgn 3y agoBecause they didnt bother to put a roof on it for ideological reasons (postwar architects were obsessed with cubes, purely because it made a statement), so rain streaks down and those skidmarks looks awful on big concrete slabs. So they at least need to wash it and put on a roof that prevents it from happening again. Apart from that, this building is fine overall. It's odd though, because I would call this building sterilized and flattened as well!
- MeImCounting 3y agoThe rain streaks look great to me as well! Its kind of like a pair of well worn leather shoes has creases and lines where the foot bends or how a well worn pair of jeans fades on the knees and wrinkles. Not that I am against a roof for this building, or even adding some materials like brick or maybe timber could be interesting. I think this about lots of 'brutalist' buildings: theyre gorgeous as is and might be improved a bit and receive less hate if they used more materials than just concrete and glass. Brick, Timber, and stone even after all people love all the Frank Loyd Wright stuff and he used plenty of raw materials.
- constantcrying 3y agoAny good design is a collaboration of art and engineering, where the end result accomplishes the technical requirements and integrates itself into the world around it in an appropriate way. Neither of these can be considered alone, function has a form of its own, just like form has a function of it's own. Architects aren't structural engineers and only in dialogue good infrastructure can be created.
- Aeolun 3y agoI’m fairly certain good ‘infrastructure’ can be engineered. If you want something pretty that integrates into the world around it’s not solely infrastructure any more.
- constantcrying 3y agoBad architecture is harmful to the people who have to interact with it.
- Aeolun 3y agoWhat is considered good architecture these days is also harmful to the people that need to work in it. So many new buildings seem to think that all space needs to be given over to being impressive, instead of dedicated to the people that work in it.
- bell-cot 3y agoSounds miserably similar to this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_International_University_pedestrian_bridge_collapse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_International_Universi... Though the FIU one collapsed within a week of the fatally flawed span first being installed.
- wrycoder 3y agoThat was due to a design calculation error, not some aesthetic concern.
- bell-cot 3y ago> The new pedestrian bridge was designed to connect the campus to student housing in a dramatic, sculptural way and also to showcase the school's leadership in the ABC method of rapid bridge construction.[16][17] And from my recollection of coverage at the time - FIU's administrative pressure to deliver their dramatic & leading-edge-construction bridge, quick and cheap, lead to all sorts of corner cutting in the engineering & fabrication.
- jeffbee 3y agoTo me the root cause was they just could not see a way to inconvenience even one single driver ever. They had to grade separate pedestrians from cars over a freeway and a gigantic parking lot. Universities should be pedestrian focused. The bridge could have been designed correctly. But the fundamental issue was the bridge didn't need to exist.
- jacobgkau 3y agoI think that's more of an auxiliary issue than the "fundamental" one. Space is limited, and a nice (and non-collapsing) bridge could be more convenient for pedestrians than however things would be laid out on the ground even if there wasn't a road there. Safe bridges should be able to exist, whether one would have been needed in this exact spot in an alternate reality or not. It's also very telling for you to condense "a freeway and a gigantic parking lot" down to "one single driver ever." Five motorists wouldn't have been killed by the collapse alone if "one single driver" was the only one who ever used it.
- bunabhucan 3y agoThe actual report with animated video and english subtitles: https://www.nsia.no/Road/Published-reports/2024-03 https://www.nsia.no/Road/Published-reports/2024-03 I translated some of the norweigan paragraps that include "estetik" but I can't figure out if they mean "they should have used steel" or they mean "the diagonal members should change direction to keep them in compression" or both.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoI think this is the quote that is most relevant > En kombinert stålbjelkebru med betongdekke var mulig, men ble utelukket på grunn av estetikken og begrensningene i veigeometrien under og på brua. which states that aesthetics and road geometry together ruled out a combined steel and concrete bridge. there's also: > Artikkelen beskriver avslutningsvis at det i pre-designfasen var flere retningslinjer knyttet til utformingen av brua. Videre står det at teamet som prosjekterte brua ble påvirket av andre prosjekter på den aktuelle tiden, og at Oppland fylke var et skogsbruksfylke der tre har vært et viktig byggemateriale. Dette, kombinert med fordelene av det lette dekket, medførte at en trebru var det beste alternativet. Kombinasjonen av tre og stål gjorde det også mulig å utforme brua som ønsket, uten ekstra avstivning ved aksene. But in the end the above just amounts to "they could have built a conventional bridge but wanted something prettier": basically aesthetics contributed to the collapse because it was the primary reason they built something novel. Had there instead been some site specific geometry that forced a novel solution, one wonders if they had blamed that...
- everybodyknows 3y agoWell, either would work: Steel can be easily fitted to take tension loads; Or the wood could be oriented to be in compression, with the ends butted against other structure thus relieving the bolts of most of the load. Here's one that combines both techniques: https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftse4.mm.bing.net%2Fth%3Fid%3DOIP.e3DLYJkxlxYOH4FmJu1mpwAAAA%26pid%3DApi&f=1&ipt=17c2ef43a960d997e565187191c5e989c8a94ba8cc53a30b24990b42fa45d011&ipo=images https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F... What was done instead concentrated the tension stress onto a small central core section of the member, with rest transferred to wood grain-aligned, therefore weak, sheer faces within the timber. Thanks for the video: To anyone who's spent some time working with wooden garden gates, that's enough to tell the story.
- Glyptodon 3y ago> "A short construction period, span lengths and reuse of existing foundation were framework conditions for the planning of the bridge," it continued. > "These framework conditions, combined with the choice of material and a strong focus on aesthetics, contributed to the structure not being robust." Given that it doesn't look that remarkable it seems odd that a little asymmetry couldn't be accounted for. Or was someone out there saying "we'll never build symmetric bridges, our river is too good for them..." Because the rest of the article makes it sound more like an engineering failure.
- mperham 3y agoThe key line IMO: Tretten Bridge was designed while building regulations in Norway were in transition from a national system to European codes. Provisions for this transitional period enabled the project to follow the older national standards, which unlike the Eurocodes did not account for block shear failure.
- 3D30497420 3y agoKind of. I should have thought the engineers involved would have been good enough to design a bridge that would have lasted more than a decade, even if the regulations weren't as rigorous.
- blackbear_ 3y agoSomehow I feel like it's not the engineers who needed the regulations...
- Quekid5 3y agoOne would hope... but corporate structures can apply a LOT of pressure which can end up impairing judgment or resistance to decisions by higher-level executives. It might or might not be the issue here, but it's definitely been seen in past disasters. (It's similar to the more readily/well understood "peer pressure", but even more insidious.)
- anigbrowl 3y agoYeah, I'm not sure why the editorial focus on 'aesthetics'.
- rdtsc 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tretten_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tretten_Bridge The ironic part is "The bridge replaced a steel truss bridge built in 1895 at the same location". Engineers in 1895 knew how to use steel trusses and built a bridge that lasted 100+ years, and in 2012 they decided to use glued wooden beams and it fell apart in 10 years. Well perhaps Plan Arkitekter and Norconsult can take a trip to the archives and see what the engineers in 1895 knew before building any more structures.
- loeg 3y ago> Engineers in 1895 knew how to use steel trusses and built a bridge that lasted 100+ years It's a little too strong of a claim. Plenty of poorly designed steel bridges from the 19th century have collapsed as well, despite the superior material.
- rdtsc 3y ago> Plenty of poorly designed steel bridges from the 19th century have collapsed as well That's true. But I only meant that particular bridge, which did last for 100+ years. So, when the architects and the engineers go to the archives to relearn a few things, they can focus on the ones which haven't collapsed.
- hellofellows 3y ago+ why even remove the steel bridge in the first place?
- speedgoose 3y agoYou have more pictures on the Norwegian Wikipedia page: https://no.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tretten_bru#/media/Fil%3ATretten_bro_(1895).jpg https://no.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tretten_bru#/media/Fil%3ATre... The old one wasn’t wide while the new one had two lanes and a normal sized sidewalk.
- TylerE 3y ago
- m3kw9 3y agoApp makers, you’ve been warned
- jszymborski 3y agoTretten Bridge, not to be confused with (Lower) Trenton Bridge, the most passive aggressive bridge in the world. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/4f/2023-09-19_22_25_43_Night_view_west_towards_the_Trenton_Makes_Bridge_from_the_east_bank_of_the_Delaware_River_in_Trenton%2C_Mercer_County%2C_New_Jersey.jpg/1280px-2023-09-19_22_25_43_Night_view_west_towards_the_Trenton_Makes_Bridge_from_the_east_bank_of_the_Delaware_River_in_Trenton%2C_Mercer_County%2C_New_Jersey.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/4f/20...
- hellofellows 3y agodamn... world doesn't buys but takes..by force?
- HPsquared 3y agoCould also be "Trenton active, the world passive"
- HPsquared 3y agoSnappy, inspiring... I like it
- keybored 3y agoIt’s like the body of an OSS maintainer and the mind of a HN commenter. Well in the body of a bridge.
- bell-cot 3y agoHere's the daylight view: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:2023-09-04_13_02_10_View_northwest_towards_the_Trenton_Makes_Bridge_from_the_east_bank_of_the_Delaware_River_at_low_tide_in_Trenton,_Mercer_County,_New_Jersey.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:2023-09-04_13_02_10_View_... I'd say it is a very conventional (& rock-solid) steel through-truss bridge, with a bunch of neon 'tude tacked onto its side.
- jszymborski 3y ago
- _hbro 3y agoThe idea that a "strong focus on aesthetics" contributed to the failure of a bridge doesn't make any logical sense. Employing a strong focus on aesthetics doesn't preclude also having the necessary focus on stability and safety. Bridges fail because they were not designed or engineered properly.
- digging 3y agoI don't agree; to me it states they were so focused on aesthetics that they weren't able to see structural flaws. Like tunnel vision. Seems like the best way to state this phenomenon IMO.
- c048 3y agoIt can also easily mean they were willing on taking risks, like using unproven techniques, skirt close to minimum safety requirements or even ignore certain rules, just so it would look prettier.
- akira2501 3y ago> Employing a strong focus on aesthetics doesn't preclude also having the necessary focus on stability and safety No, you just have to pay a lot more for it, and civil projects don't typically allow for endlessly ballooning budgets.
- SoftTalker 3y agoAre you familiar with Scandinavian civil projects? They tend to be quite attractive, IMO.
- akira2501 3y agoBuilding pretty things on land is significantly easier than building them over water. Engineering is the art of tradeoffs. You want to pick your "aesthetics" battles somewhat carefully. Which also means you're going to want some _solid_ justifications for incorporating them into a retrofit.
- karaterobot 3y agoErr, the actual quotes make it sound more like plain old engineering troubles, made more complicated by the discrepancy between older and newer building codes. > "A short construction period, span lengths and reuse of existing foundation were framework conditions for the planning of the bridge," [the report by the NSIA] continued. I understand why a design website would emphasize the design aspects though.
- blt 3y agoNever seen a truss where the diagonal members are all one direction like that. Also bit weird that the strongest part of the bridge is not the middle of the longest span, but it does not appear to be cantilever. Disclaimer: I am a mere Poly Bridge player.
- btbuildem 3y agoThat's so strange! Looking through the photos on the page, there's one showing the bridge still intact. It's almost as if someone accidentally flipped the materials -- the members that work in compression are were made of metal, the members under tension, out of lumber. That's the opposite of what each material is naturally strong at.
- ars 3y agoActually wood is stronger in tensile: "tensile strength of soft- woods parallel to grain at 12% moisture content generally ranges between 70 to 140MPa. The compression strength is lower and is usually in the range 30 to 60 MPa." Steel is similar in strength both ways, although it varies a lot depending on how it was annealed. (The harder the metal the better compression is vs tensile.)
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoThis is true but the main concern with compression loads is buckling, which generally happens well before the material yields to normal stress. This means that compression members need to be much stiffer in bending, and so generally bulky and geometrically large, with a big moment of inertia. Whereas tension members can basically just be wire rope. Wood can easily be built up into a much larger cross-section than steel for the same cost and less weight, so it makes sense to use it for compression loads.
- btbuildem 3y agoWow, fascinating. Thanks for the correction!
- exabrial 3y agoreminds me of "modern" web development.
- notatoad 3y agoSomewhat amusing to see this headline on deezen, the site that usually celebrates a "strong focus on aesthetics" above all else.
- varjag 3y agoBookmark this for the next time you read "if construction engineers built like programmers" trope.
- blagie 3y agoTo be fair, it was really pretty!
- liftm 3y agoI suppose assthetics is in the eye of the beeholder?