6 ms·
Scott Adams Blog: The End of Capitalism
- MikeCapone 18y agoOkay, I just skimmed it, but that didn't make much sense. I guess it's a Scott Adams post...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- graemep 18y agoHe is probably right in that the economic system needs to evolve to keep up with technological change, but he misses the most important reason for that (the increased importance of products with negligible marginal cost of production), and he has no reasonable idea of possible solutions. He is not content to be a cartoonist and has so far tried to write about physics (the last part of, I think, the Dilbert Principle) and religion (God Debris, which is a free download - he manages to come up with crude versions of ideas that Hinduism got to millennia ago).
- darjen 18y agoMore like the downfall of crony capitalism, caused by the federal reserve.
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoThis is perhaps the most poorly-thought out post on economics I've read in a long time. Adams is essentially arguing for a completely unrealistic set of draconian regulations to manage every aspect of society, from capital investment to personal health. An example: "Stock bubbles could be avoided by restricting how much money can be invested in stocks, on an annual basis, to keep the price earnings ratios around 15." Err...what? Who decided 15 was the ideal? What about those companies that clearly don't deserve that multiple based on their growth prospects, or companies that clearly deserve more? Why bother with a market at all? He asserts that it's not socialism, but I'm having a hard time seeing how it wouldn't be worse.
- ninjackn 18y agoI agree. He starts off making some good points outlining the vulnerabilities of our economy due to our capitalistic ways. Then he talks about the most ridiculous predictions for the future of the economy, workforce and government regulations. I don’t believe we’re going to be seeing the type of restrictions Scott Adams claims, it would kill America. The only valid prediction he makes is the stronger credit requirements banks might impose but he backs it up as if it was because we were spending too much. What stood out to me as completely ridiculous: “Depending on how bad the economy gets, you could also see rules banning single passengers in cars.”
- derefr 18y agoYou don't believe we're stupid enough to kill America?
- jwesley 18y agoWhat were you expecting from a cartoonist?
- Retric 18y agoCartoonists are good at finding the flaws in the current system but not really finding ways to fix them. So looking for some more reasonable ideas to address his concerns: There are already limits on the kinds of investments low net worth individuals can make and quite possible some for of useary law limiting interest to ~20 - 30% which would cut down how much credit people can get and reduce there payments at the same time. A few changes to how people can invest their 401k's so they need some reasonable P/E and diversification if they have less than say 200k and are over 55 might not be a bad idea. I think most of what he is complaining would be addressed with those changes and something like them might even become law but we would still have capitalism. Because capitalism is about having markets determine price which would still happen based on the actions of people with more money.
- asdflkj 18y agoFurthermore, what were you expecting from a guy who defended Intelligent Design not so long ago?
- annoyed 18y agoidiocracy, here we come!
- hohlecow 18y agoAt the risk of being a hypocrite (mortgage, student loans), why not eliminate credit? Can't afford a $200,000 house or $20,000 car without credit? Guess what, no one else can either. Prices of those goods would fall back to reasonable levels. Can't afford cable, data plan, or fancy clothes? Guess what, you don't need those things, so learn to live without them. What good has credit brought the individual? Inflated prices, slavery to debt. What good has that done for corporations, banks and governments? Trillions worth of good. (Not saying that corporations, banks, and governments are bad, just pointing out that they are the winner with regards to credit.) I realize prohibiting credit instantly would be a huge jolt to the system, but wouldn't it prevent similar problems in the future?
- jdminhbg 18y agoI suppose it would prevent similar problems, much like having one's mouth sewn shut would prevent food poisoning.
- jleyank 18y agoI think this ia a bit naive. Some kind of credit's required to get through the ups and downs of the normal business cycle. Otherwise, "gee, can't make payroll in the last week of a quarter, whack the staff and rehire them in 3 weeks..." Many historians argue that an organized financial market (England, Holland) enabled rapid economic growth and resulting political growth. Yeah, credit used badly is a problem, but used correctly or well it's grease for the system.
- hohlecow 18y ago> Some kind of credit's required to get through the ups and downs of the normal business cycle Isn't that what cash reserves are for?
- jleyank 18y agoIf there is no credit, is there any loans? If there are no loans, there's no income from "cash reserves" - how can you pay anything if you're unable to make money from the deposits people have given you? I think you'll have a different argument and a different result if you wish credit CARDS to go away, rather than credit. If you had to go into somebody's office and sign forms, etc, then you'd think twice about charging the next latte... As I recall, credit cards came from the revolving credit various stores started at some point in the past. They've grown a bit in use and scope since then :-).
- DanielBMarkham 18y ago"...The economy is now too complicated for even the regulators to know when a con or a huge mistake is happening..." I stopped after this sentence. The economy has always been too complicated for experts to understand. That was the beauty of what Adam Smith identified -- with billions of people, billions of "unseen hands" control the division of labor. The current crises is the 15th crises since the civil war that involved some sort of mortgage gimmicks. We have fraud and economic panics going back to the 1600s. Nothing new here to see, Scott. After you blew it with the statement above, you continued to go off the rails with the rest of the article, all because of your belief that economies can be engineered. That's a farce that Smith observed in his day. You'd think that a basic education would take most people beyond that point.
- timr 18y ago" The economy has always been too complicated for experts to understand." Adams' thesis doesn't rest upon any assumptions about the complexity of the historic economy. He's simply acknowledging a fact: the economy of today is much faster than it has ever been before. Scammers can effectively hide behind the speed of their actions. That's new. Once upon a time, regulatory agencies like the SEC had a fighting chance of catching stock scams, because the market was slower. It was still efficient, but because there were fewer players, making fewer plays per billionth of a second, they had a chance of stopping crime. Today, the best that the SEC can do is to (maybe) catch these guys in retrospect -- and there's absolutely no chance that they're catching all of them. Thanks to modern technology, market manipulation can happen at the speed of light.
- JulianMorrison 18y agoThere are two ways to speed up antiscamming that I can think of. It could become automated, AI-controlled, with a machine capable of pulling the trigger at computer-speed. Or, it could become distributed, one-on-one. The latter seems to me to have better scaling characteristics. How about this as an idea: suppose somebody starts a financial market which from day one has a system of guarantors. You have to be introduced by a member, who thereby takes full personal responsibility for your bankrupt losses.
- theschwa 18y agoWhat he's talking about is essential Corporatism; its been tried, and it doesn't work. In fact, its more of a continuation of our current trends which have caused these problems in the first place.
- Allocator2008 18y agoI think one thing similar to one of the things he said is to limit the amount of tax free equity one can hold in a 401K plan. Like say if you hold more than 50% of your 401K as equity, there will be a tax incurrance. That way, government is not "dictating" your portfolio, but it is "encouraging" you to have a well-balanced, more conservative portfolio. Dictation by the government on one's portfolio I don't think would work any better than prohibition worked, but small things here and there I think can be done to encourage people to have more conservative holdings, and therefore keep a lid on market "bubbles". That said, I think I have concluded that capitalism will never go away, simply because we are the "gene machines", programmed towards the best interest of the "selfish gene", and therefore, we will always have a "greed is good" mindset. It is in our DNA. We can't escape it. A socialist society would never happen in the long run, because quite simply the competition of genes would not allow it. No political or economic theorist can beat natural selection. Survival of the fittest is universal, it created us, and our markets, and will continue to shape our lives, like it or not. My opinion anyway.
- maxwell 18y agoCapitalism is just a system that replaced heredity with exchange values as the economic imperative. It's only been used by a few primate tribes for a few hundred years. It's about as significant to the genetic tree of life as this sentence I'm writing is to the internet. And it's dying anyway; this site, for instance, implements a postcapitalist economic system.
- turkishrevenge 18y agoAh, the "human nature" argument. Is there anything more insidious? This idea, like all others before it, is one of those that rule. "Greed is good" is the creed of our epoch. Before, in feudal society, it was "We rule because we have divine right". In the end, it's just justification for the actions of a ruling class.
- petercooper 18y agoPerhaps your health insurance premiums would be based on your body mass index and whether or not you smoke. You mean it's not already? I'm an ignorant Brit with state healthcare (mostly) in this regard, but doesn't insurance work this way in the US? Our car insurance varies on gender, age, employment, and all sorts of factors - shouldn't health insurance be based on.. well.. your claim risk too?
- bmj 18y agoNot unless you are paying for your own insurance. This is, however, how life insurance works.
- petercooper 18y agoI'm surprised anyone's self employed in the US with the various hurdles (higher taxes, choosier health insurance) :)
- jderick 18y agoI thought this was going to be funny?
- known 18y agoWe need both Socialism and Capitalism to build and sustain a great nation. 1. Prevent race to the bottom aka Socialism 2. Promote race to the top aka Capitalism
- chaostheory 18y agoto me the future isn't about some new variation of the decrepit systems that already exist (capitalism, socialism, democratic republics, ...). when you think about it, those systems are just hacks meant to maximize the good parts of humanity (cooperation, innovation, ...) and minimize the bad parts (corruption, ...). imho what we have now is the acme of those systems I feel that if humanity can survive long enough (with our scientists and current infrastructure intact), eventually we can make those systems obsolete by fixing the root of the problem: basic human nature - specifically the part where sub-systems try to maximize their efficiency at the expense of the system as a whole. bureaucratic systems (no matter how large or small) can limit it (temporarily), but they can never eliminate it in the long term... to me the answer is human evolution through artificial means.... a shared consciousness (aka the borg); though i'm sure it'd have its own set of problems...