9 ms·
US city-country mortality gap widens
- toomuchtodo 3y agoUSDA Report: https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/108702/eib-265.pdf https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/108702/eib-265... Related: US Rural Hospital Closures Since 2005 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36302937 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36302937 - June 2023 (153 comments) UNC Rural Hospital Closures - https://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/programs-projects/rural-health/rural-hospital-closures/ https://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/programs-projects/rural-heal...
- imglorp 3y agoIf you live an hour from an emergency room, all kinds of urgent things will become more fatal statistically and lower life expectancy. Stroke, heart attack, trauma. EMS pays careful attention to the "golden hour" of receiving definitive care being a survival factor. If you have to wait longer for transport (because you're rural) and then wait longer to arrive at the ER, then your hour may be up before you're even seen. One mitigating factor is rural EMS sometimes has more advanced care options (allowed by their medical director) than urban BLS because they know it's a long ride.
- delfinom 3y agoLol, the joke here is depending on rural areas. You may wait a few hours just for an ambulance to show up in the first place.
- giantg2 3y agoA huge factor in my personal experience is the quality of care at the hospital. Many hospitals in more remote locations have poor care. Sometimes it's that doctors who can't get the higher paying jobs at the big hospitals go there, and the facilities have lower budgets for many things. I've had family in the medical field who have worked all over the world and have stated that a few specific hospitals serving rural areas are only slightly better than some of the 3rd world hospitals they've seen. They might be bigger or fancier, but the quality of care is poor and the rate of mistakes are high.
- dexwiz 3y agoMany times these hospitals also lack specialists. Some of my relatives will drive an extra hour to a bigger city, even though they live 10minutes from a hospital, because the doctors there don’t have the same specialities.
- supertrope 3y agoIronically physicians earn slightly more in rural areas. Cash is used to balance out the disadvantages of moving to the middle of nowhere. https://resources.nejmcareercenter.org/article/demystifying-urban-versus-rural-physician-compensation/ https://resources.nejmcareercenter.org/article/demystifying-...
- giantg2 3y agoI shouldn't have said higher paying. I should have said more sought after. The rural hospitals are paying more to attract people (where they're able to). They're more willing to lower their standards to fill positions. But they're also less likely to have some of the higher paying specialties that you'll find in the bigger cities.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoRelated: https://www.chartis.com/sites/default/files/documents/chartis_rural_study_pressure_pushes_rural_safety_net_crisis_into_uncharted_territory_feb_15_2024_fnl.pdf https://www.chartis.com/sites/default/files/documents/charti... ("Unrelenting Pressure Pushes Rural Safety Net Crisis into Uncharted Territory") > America’s rural health safety net has been in crisis mode for nearly 15 years. Rural hospital closures, decreasing reimbursements, declining operating margins, and staffing shortages have all coalesced to undermine the delivery of care in communities whose populations are older, less healthy, and less affluent. The mission of the safety net to serve under-resourced communities is unraveling. The latest research conducted by the Chartis Center for Rural Health points to a startling new phase of this crisis as rural hospitals fall deeper into the red, “care deserts” widen throughout rural communities, and the increasing penetration of Medicare Advantage could further disrupt rural hospital revenue.
- lenerdenator 3y agoMakes total sense; the rural areas have been manipulated by the shareholder class into selling out most of their quality-of-life-enabling institutions for scrap. I live in a relatively large Lower Midwestern city. The general attitude of capital and policymakers in the United States after the 1960s became one of confusion about the purpose of the area between the Appalachian Range and Rockies. California was booming, the cities on the East Coast were moving into a service economic model as their factories had been packed up. Why were these people still here? That applies to cities that used to participate in mercantile capitalism (St. Louis is a wonderful example of this) as well as small towns of 150 people. There's a lack of investment that would simply be unacceptable to people in the other parts of the country. Imagine if Amtrak's Northeast Corridor had the reliability of the various Midwestern routes.
- hx8 3y agoThis brings up an interesting partial explanation that we might be able to explore with data. A portion of the healthier and more successful rural population will migrate to urban areas, while a portion of the least healthy and less successful will be stuck and unable to leave rural areas. Urbanization as selection.
- lenerdenator 3y agoTo a point; there's still widespread poverty in the cities these people eventually move to.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoif they're healthy and successful why would they leave? the families with college kids of send their chilluns to school, but plenty return. and with high COL exploding in many cities, all the more reason to come home, esp. if their people are already successful in such areas
- jjk166 3y ago> if they're healthy and successful why would they leave? Because they could be even more healthy and even more successful, or simply just happier, elsewhere. People who can leave will always leave more often than people who can't. > the families with college kids of send their chilluns to school, but plenty return. And plenty don't. Again, those that never leave stay at a higher rate. > and with high COL exploding in many cities, all the more reason to come home, esp. if their people are already successful in such areas The more wealth you have, the less you are deterred by high COL. And COL only goes up in cities because people are willing to pay a premium to live there, often for the economic opportunities.
- jt2190 3y agoArticle title is “City-Country Mortality Gap Widens Amid Persistent Holes in Rural Health Care Access” > The study does not address causes for the increase in mortality rates… differences in health care resources could compromise the accessibility, quality, and affordability of care in rural areas. Hospitals in small and remote communities have long struggled, and continued closures or conversions limit health care services in many places. [perhaps also] persistently higher rates of poverty, disability, and chronic disease in rural areas, compounded by fewer physicians per capita and the closure of hospitals, affect community health.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Within the prime working-age group, cancer and heart disease were the leading natural causes of death I have a lot of extended family and in-laws who live in rural locations. The lifestyle differences between what I see in the city and what I see in their rural locations are stark. The norms around diet, exercise, drinking, and smoking are completely different. Even norms around personal safety and protective gear are completely different. Most of my rural extended family will do things like casually spray pesticides or paint without a mask. I was mocked for pulling out safety glasses and hearing protection for power tools when we worked on a project together once. The study classifies things like heart disease and cancer as “natural causes” and blames lack of healthcare, but my anecdotal experience is that the lifestyle differences could easily explain the difference in heart disease and probably a significant number of the cancer diagnoses as well. Even when healthcare is available, many of them don’t trust it. Statins are still a common debate when I visit, with many of the people in mid-life telling me that they don’t work and it’s just a big pharma cash grab conspiracy (even though statins are dirt cheap now). Refusing to take doctor-directed medication is a point of pride for some, though they tend to reverse course in older life when they see their peers start dying young. Many refuse vaccines for themselves and children due to things they heard on podcasts or social media. And mental health? Don’t dare even suggest that one.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI can’t even get my parents to care about mold after their basement floods for the 10th time in 10 years. They will worry about superstitions about eclipses, but not any long term health consequence from any source that could be labeled “science”.
- hasty_pudding 3y ago[dead]
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt's a machismo built up around preventative behaviors that cost short-term money. If you're a farmer trying to compete in the last 50 years, your concern isn't with the possibility that you might get cancer in 20 years from the neonicotinoids you're spraying; it's making enough money to cover expenses now. But your friend who helps you do all sorts of farm chores, he wants to wear protection when he sprays. He's spent money on this protective gear, money that could have been put towards new machinery or the mortgage. He spends five minutes "dickin' 'round" putting it on. Five minutes that could be spent spraying. Since the span of five minutes is easier for the human mind to comprehend than the possibility of health problems months, years, or decades away, you choose to value the five minutes and tell him to get a move on. When he insists, you call him a wimp. He's now been shamed out of the preventative behavior.
- spiderfarmer 3y ago[flagged]
- gjsman-1000 3y agoI find it patronizing that you assume they must have been brainwashed. For some people, dying more easily is worth it for the sake of freedom. Not the trade you would want to make, but that’s their prerogative.
- spiderfarmer 3y agoThat's exactly how the brainwashing works. It makes you believe you're not "free" if you offer up some money in return for the comfort of knowing you , your family and all your fellow countrymen never have to be bankrupted by medical bills. You have to be either radically apathetic or addicted to risk if you think it's rational to dismiss all benefits of universal healthcare in name of a "freedom" that has no benefits at all. According to many studies most people would benefit from it. And most people want it.
- pbnjay 3y agoLifestyle differences in rural areas are much more sedentary now that broadband internet is more available. In urban areas you have social factors and other reasons to walk around or stand up for longer periods. Couple that with the mentioned shrinking of hospital and healthcare access and yeah you’ve got a double whammy.
- apwheele 3y agoI think this is right. For counterpoint though, there will of course be variance, but an opposite hypothesis is a larger proportion have labor jobs (men moreso than women). Grew up in rural PA (mostly farming, some factory work). They exact a significant toll (part of the reason opioid dependence grew IMO). But most of the metrics I have been seeing in terms of death rates show it is both for men and women, so I don't think labor jobs can explain it.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoHold up a sec, are you proposing that life in the country is more sedentary than in urban areas? I'm guessing you've never bailed hay.
- triceratops 3y ago> I'm guessing you've never bailed hay Never had my boat fill up with hay so...no. I'd also guess most country people don't bale hay every day.
- jimbokun 3y agoNeither have most people living in rural areas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- redserk 3y agoAs someone who grew up and lived in a very rural area, most rural people don’t bale hay. Most rural people live like those in the suburbs but are just physically farther away from other people.
- chasd00 3y agoit would be more interesting to see the health differences by profession. It's a lot easier on your body to sit in front of a computer than be a lineman working for the county.
- delichon 3y agoI think you have to work very hard before it's worse for your body than extended sitting. I make my living in front of a screen so try to mitigate it by going out in the yard and simulating someone who physically works for a living.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoNews for you, sitting on your ass is way harder on the body than actually working for a living. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7700832/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7700832/
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoThis is gonna sound silly but, I never sit in chairs normally unless I'm being watched. I've presently got one leg folded under me, and the other tucked up, so I'm not sitting on my ass, I'm sitting on a shin and a foot. And I will probably move in a couple minutes. Is that the same as "Sitting on one's ass", or..?
- jltsiren 3y agoThat's not what the article says. The article is about the health risks of a sedentary lifestyle, which means a lot of sitting with limited physical activity. But even as little activity as 60-75 minutes of brisk walking per day seems to be enough to compensate. It also mentions that watching TV is worse than more active forms of sitting, such as office work.
- chasd00 3y agoi grew up in rural areas around West and North Texas, every single person and relatives i knew that worked in those hard, labor intensive jobs, had bad knees and backs by the age of 55 and were basically crippled by retirement age.
- softwaredoug 3y agoIf I read Figure 1 correctly, overall mortality has actually declined (minus Covid). Even in rural areas mortality has continued to decline while this statistic was tracked. What appears to be the case is its declined _faster_ in urban areas. Figure 2 shows BOTH metro and non-metro increases in mortality for age groups 25-29 and 30-34.
- softwaredoug 3y agoActually looking at other figures, its flat-to-worsening in rural areas since late 90s.
- persolb 3y agoI think this somewhat makes intuitive sense. I think most people caught Covid. Covid was most risky for people who had other illnesses. In the universe without Covid, many of those people would have died anyway. The people who survived Covid were on average healthier than the people it killed... so the life expectancy should go up post-peak-Covid.
- cozzyd 3y agoI wonder what effect the proliferation of rural dollar stores has had. More junk food and fewer health care facilities is probably not a good combo... And has smoking become more common?
- wnorris 3y agoExercise through everyday walking likely plays a key role. Rural Americans drive everywhere and their most significant walking typically will take place only within stores while shopping.
- forinti 3y agoIt seems to me that they lost their good habits (manual labour and walking a lot) but kept their bad habits (diet and smoking).
- patwolf 3y agoHaving lived in rural areas, suburban areas, and urban areas, I don't see there being much difference in walking between rural and suburban. My guess is that it's a combination of rural areas being poorer (less access to healthy food and extra curricular activities) and the lack of societal pressure to be healthy that comes from living in a more isolated environment.
- SauciestGNU 3y agoI suspect if you closely examined activity levels by distance from city center, you'd see something like a log curve with moderate activity for city dwellers, decreasing as you get farther from the core, to the point where suburban/exurban/rural dwellers have very similar activity levels.
- strken 3y agoI saw a huge difference when I moved from a tiny rural town to a city. I grew up comparatively close to a decent-sized town, in that it was a 20 minute bicycle ride or more than one hour walk to the nearest supermarket, but in the city I found that there was usually a supermarket within a 15 minute walk. In the country my parents had to drive to everything except the pub and playground, and deliberate effort was required to get more exercise. This depends on how walkable your cities are, of course.
- delichon 3y agoThese particular numbers do not include suicide, but those numbers are very bad too. This Time article was written about our county a couple of years ago. I know a few of the people quoted. https://time.com/6218385/suicide-rate-new-mexico/ https://time.com/6218385/suicide-rate-new-mexico/ White men in particular are checking out at an alarming rate. So while this is an "external" cause not counted in the stats of the article, I can't help but assume common causes. The kind of depression that makes you want to die also makes you not want to take care of yourself. It isn't difficult to get state paid medical care here, except for the distance. Appointments at the two small clinics are not far in the future and the medical staff is competent. I doubt doubling or tripling spending there would have much if any effect. I think it's more about people who have chosen to live a more traditional lifestyle and discovering that it's an increasingly poor fit for the modern world. A plague of psychiatrists could descend on our county like locusts and bury every depressed person in talk therapy, and I doubt it would help.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThere's only ~3500 people that live in the county. Due to random noise, there's bound to be some small county with shockingly high suicide rates. This would be a better, less alarmist, way to look at suicide rates: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hestat/suicide/rates_1999_2017.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hestat/suicide/rates_1999_2017... Men used to commit suicide at about ~4x the rate of women, now it's closer to ~3.6x. White people commit suicide at high rates - and have for a long time (compared to other races) - and the growth in suicide in white people is outpacing other groups - but the growth rate is actually higher for white women (~68% vs ~41%).
- jibe 3y agoNot because the male suicide rate is declining, but because the female suicide rate is rising faster than the male suicide rate is rising.
- giantg2 3y ago"There's only ~3500 people that live in the county." The trend follows even when evaluated nationally for the urban vs rural rate. https://www.cdc.gov/ruralhealth/Suicide.html https://www.cdc.gov/ruralhealth/Suicide.html
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 3y ago[flagged]
- bediger4000 3y agoThat is quite a program. On what grounds other than "prop up rural folks" can you justify? Since the US is approximately 80% not-rural, how do you justify the expense and disruption to the rest of us? Because that program will be super difficult for the 80%.
- KittenInABox 3y ago> 5. Stop all forms of immigration for 8 years How would this help rural America? Migrants are absolutely necessary in every form of agriculture save for the microplot artisinal stuff urbanites are known for.
- lettergram 3y agoThey simply aren’t necessary at all. It’s that illegal aliens (they aren’t migrants) can be used as slave labor, lest they’re deported. You can easily pay a US citizen $10/hr. They’d prefer $5/hr. The cost of the overall product is low margin, but not so low margin they can’t afford the extra few dollars per hour a head. I say that as someone who is vary familiar with the practice and have watched it make people very rich.
- LAC-Tech 3y agoI never understood this logic. If you removed the supply of an ever increasing labour pool, businesses would shrink to fit the amount of labour they had available to them.
- vladms 3y agoNot in USA, but people that I know that used to live in the country side in some countries were more than happy to leave to large towns. Complaints: nothing interesting happens, hard to get anywhere, lack of products. I was born and raised in a city so I like cities. I understand different people love different things, but I doubt things can be fixed unless enough people want and are willing to put the effort to do it. My guess is that there will be opposition to many points in your proposal by lots of people (besides politicians and corporations). It's not that people want country side to be "worse" it's just that they like where they are to be "nice".
- _psxl 3y agoThe social politics of public health and medical schools is heavily slanted against focusing on rural Americans. This isn’t an armchair statement. Reduced institutional emphasis and engagement isn’t the cause of these trends, but it isn’t helpful. Rural places would benefit from targeted loosening of healthcare regulations. More local experimentation. Clear eyed view of the road to recovery. Groups like the Cicero Institute have put effort here. Their approach is pragmatic and appears to be effective. Breakthroughs will not come from traditional institutions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- genericresponse 3y agoCan you clarify what you mean by "social politics?" I ask because rural health is effectively its own subspecialty in family medicine. There doesn't seem to be a locality equivalent for other geographic subgroups. This implies, to me, an extra level of focus on the needs of a population.
- evgen 3y agoThe claimed support for this (Cicero Institute) is a right-wing libertarian policy group that is rather notorious for is attempts to criminalize homelessness at the state and municipal level. I would take any policy suggestions they make with a giant grain of salt. In almost all cases "loosening of <X> regulations" involves screwing the poor and disenfranchised as much as possible with regards to X.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoToo much of this far right libertarian nonesense on HN, has really been grinding my gears. Surprised not to also see someone bring up lab leak theories and anti-covid nonsense, somehow.
- shiroiushi 3y ago
- datavirtue 3y agoSome people have been able to map increased glyphosate usage to the rise of chronic disease. I was surprised to learn that glyphosate ("Roundup") was patented as an antibiotic. I was not terribly surprised to learn that it is found throughout our environment. In rural areas you are basically doused in it. Supposedly the effect is to disrupt the gut microbiome, ultimately resulting in persistent inflammation which of course leads to chronic disease and cancer.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThe main thrust of the article appears to be that it's Republicans killing these people by opposing Medicaid Expansion. What is the policy position that explains this decision?
- silverquiet 3y agoThink about putting people into a spreadsheet (and remember that you probably exist in a few yourself, starting with an employer). Presumably your life has some value in expected economic output, and some cost associated with providing medical care. If the second number is greater than the first, then what is society to do? I say this as someone who lives with some physical disability (who fortunately at least has a bit of enough wits to do non-physical work) - it's a rather uncaring country for those with medical needs; particularly those parts of the country governed by the right (I live in South Texas, but not the rural part).
- supertrope 3y agoEven a 1 person = 1 spreadsheet cell analysis takes into account that economic output can vary with human capital investment. Low income countries struggle to break out of poverty traps by draining swamps, vaccinating, and offering universal public education. You can't work productively if you've got malaria or can't read. Otto Von Bismarck instituted sickness funds to deflate support for socialism.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 3y agoTANSTAAFL. E.G., https://thefga.org/research/medicaid-expansion-is-closing-hospitals/ https://thefga.org/research/medicaid-expansion-is-closing-ho...
- h2odragon 3y agoCan't afford to see a doctor. Last Doctor I did see told me they would not do a sweat salinity test because I couldn't afford a diagnosis. Can't buy Sudafed; pharmacies treat the request like you asked them for their virgin daughter. Can't buy anitbiotics at the feed stores no more; FDA took care of that. I've got my own individual reasons to doubt the medical industry; I see my neighbors finding many of their own. We're going to need witch doctors and other unlicensed caregivers before long. Of course, it could be a question of metrics vs incentives, too. Who gets promoted when they juke the stats to say there isn't a problem? "Rural Healthcare" is one of those lovely nebulous goals that can soak up nearly infinite amounts of grant money without ever having to show real results.
- jonhohle 3y agoI’m sure you’ve run down a lot of options already but in case you haven’t come across these (or to anyone else with similar issues): > Can't buy Sudafed; pharmacies treat the request like you asked them for their virgin daughter. If you have a Costco when you go into town, you can get 24 generic for about $3 and can buy 3 boxes at a time from the pharmacy. 6 if you are there with someone else on the card. I’ve never been given a funny look about it and stock up whenever our family seems like they might be getting sick. I’m not sure what the limit is beyond single visit, but for a family of 6 we’ve never had an issue having enough on hand. > Can't buy anitbiotics at the feed stores no more; FDA took care of that. JASE seems expensive, but then and others will give you prescriptions via telemedicine. I used a teledoc during COVID to get the verboten prescription and it wasn’t any more expensive than a pharmacy clinic or urgent care.
- ofcourseyoudo 3y ago[flagged]
- red-iron-pine 3y agoits a problem that fixes itself, really.
- jajko 3y agoThe feedback loop takes many decades, and due to voting a lot of damage is continuously done. Also poorer less educated folks tend to have a lot more children. Unless you are fine with waiting 5000 years till it resolves itself via this way, if it ever actually does.
- skissane 3y agoIf we just project current demographic trends into the future under the assumption they won't change (obviously a false assumption), then in a lot less than 5000 years (arguably even less than 500 years) the clear majority of people in the US will be either Amish or ultra-Orthodox Jewish or some other high-fertility ultra-conservative religious minority. Amish tend not to vote, but when they do they tend to skew Republican; ultra-Orthodox Jews tend to vote Republican at the national level. (Many vote Democratic at state/local levels, which seems to be mainly driven by the pragmatic awareness that in Democratic supermajority states such as NY and NJ, you get much more political mileage by playing the Democratic politics game than by voting GOP–however, by the time they become the state's demographic majority, they likely will have turned the state red, so that reason for them to vote Democratic wouldn't apply any more.)
- lolsal 3y ago> its a problem that fixes itself, really. Is your lack of empathy an urban thing, or would you attribute it to something else?
- dpkirchner 3y ago
- HPsquared 3y agoI'm a bit skeptical of the age grouping. 25-54 is a very wide range, and I would assume cities have more 25-year-olds, whereas the countryside will have more 54-year-olds.
- 082349872349872 3y agoI think that's part of the point: US agricultural policy since at least the 1970s has been "get big or get out", so you'd expect remaining rural populations to be more marginal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earl_Butz#Secretary_of_Agriculture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earl_Butz#Secretary_of_Agricul... (It's possible to still have viable family farms in 2024, but it requires a willingness to have both (a) economic inefficiencies, and (b) legislative restrictions; although the Home of the Brave might be willing to implement a similar program, the Land of the Free is certainly not)
- coldtea 3y ago>I would assume cities have more 25-year-olds, whereas the countryside will have more 54-year-olds. Would that be true? For the same total population on each (say, 1M in cities vs 1M in the countryside) I'd expect the countryside to have higher birth rates and younger marrying couples, so younger demographics. Whereas cities have more career focused people, who marry later (if ever), have less kids, and have them at a greater age.
- inanutshellus 3y agoRegardless of where you're born, high-paying jobs and the promise of professional growth are in the city. So 18+ (heading-to-college-and-after) leave their rural homes and rarely go back. Even if they manage to go to a local university, schooling leads to a niche job in some /other/ city far away from home. Not only that, but agricultural jobs have been dwindling for decades. Anecdotally, (before my time) my high school used to shut down in the middle of spring so all the teenagers could harvest tobacco. These days that's just grandpa on a giant harvester.
- coldtea 3y ago
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoAvoid syndicated content. Actual article: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/city-country-mortality-gap-widens-rural-health-care-access/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/city-country-mortality-gap-wide...
- garciansmith 3y agoAm I wrong in thinking it's the opposite? CBS notes and links back to KFF, and the reporter, Jazmin Orozco Rodriguez, works for KFF.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoAhh fairplay, my mistake. Misunderstood what "also ran on CBS News" meant. Weird for them to post where else things were syndicated if they're the source.
- hereme888 3y agoMy experience for years living in several very rural areas of the US leads me to believe that one big factor is "positive peer pressure" and quality food availability. "Southern" people's rural lives may be calmer and richer in nature, but their hobbies and lifestyle are quite unhealthy. In big cities there is more social pressure for being good-looking, mainly a healthy BMI and muscles, both which are protective against cancer. They're also "food deserts" where supermarkets and restaurants with healthy food are extremely scarce. I've been to towns where you'd be hard-pressed to find any vegetables in their menu besides tomato sauce and a pickle. Health literacy is also abysmal. I don't see how they can avoid a heart attack with such food menus.
- delfinom 3y agoIt's quite ironic that rural living is devolved to processed food garbage in America. I come from rural Poland, vegetables were very much on the table every day be it fresh or pickled. Rural regions are the ones that should be more capable of being self-sufficient compared to say a city because you actually have fucking land.
- abduhl 3y agoYes but the push towards expansion and financial leverage means that you and your family are out working all day every day. So you have land but you don’t have any fucking time. Beef jerky and Red Bull it is then.
- dexwiz 3y agoMuch of rural America grows corn or soybeans. You can drive for literally hundreds of miles and only see these two crops. And it’s not even a corn that is edible, it’s grown to be processed or fed to other animals. Vegetable production is isolated to a few areas. Even then they are often limited to a few crops with narrow seasonality. You can grow vegetables in these areas but it’s not profitable.
- Kon-Peki 3y ago> Much of rural America grows corn or soybeans. Not in the parts of rural America this article is focusing on. In Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, etc, where they grow ridiculous amounts of corn and soybeans, the land is way too valuable to allow widespread poverty to occupy it. I’m not saying it doesn’t exist, but it’s nothing like the scale of the rural south.
- screwturner68 3y agoI don't want to live anywhere where I can see my neighbor. These people are choosing this lifestyle. These same people are a massive tax on society because we have to subsidize this lifestyle because it's very expensive to provide services to places where nobody lives. Why would you build a hospital where only 10,000 live? Why spend $5000 to drag fibre to someone's house so that they can pay $50/month for internet access? How can you afford to pave a road where one person has 800ft of frontage and pays $1500 a year in SALT? Again, at the end of day this is a choice and their choice costs everyone. I can't really feel sorry for these people, it's what you get when you want to go it alone.
- abduhl 3y agoWe need places where nobody lives to produce things. You cannot farm acres of land where everybody lives, it has to be done where nobody lives. You can’t raise cattle where people live because the cattle has to live there. I suppose the converse view is that city dwellers are externalizing the cost of their existence and so we should see huge increases in prices for staple goods until rural dwellers are paid appropriately and we have equitable outcomes with respect to mortality between rural and urban populations.
- shiroiushi 3y agoOh please, not this dumb argument again. Have you actually ever visited or lived in rural American areas? These people are not farmers. Building a road to a farm is fine, but there's a huge network of roads out there just to service non-farmers who choose to live rural lifestyles and expect everyone else to subsidize this lifestyle for them.
- trallnag 3y agoShouldn't you use "we" instead of "these people"?
- shiroiushi 3y agoYes, his first sentence is incongruent with the rest. I think he meant to add quotes around it, as it's a stereotypical thing that rural dwellers would say. The rest is an accurate argument, complete with dollar amounts, about why their lifestyle is unsustainable and needs subsidization to continue.
- OfficeChad 3y ago[dead]