7 ms·
Georgia's Vogtle plant, a $35B nuclear project
- itsanaccount 3y agoI think its interesting when reading The Expanse that its mentioned fundamental technology is advanced by "tech collectives." Like all organization in that scifi, its touched on only briefly, but reading articles like this and the recent Boeing madness makes me think that the future of humanities technologic progress is not something to be left to the marketplace of capital, where people are fungible, because they're not. That to succeed in complex endeavors we need more complex organizations than gov, business, nonprofit. Probably off topic but if you find yourself in some kind of monastic tech co-op that builds things because they are good first and valuable second, hmu.
- Arnt 3y agoThere's a nice posting bunniestudios.com about how the city of Shenzhen is such a collective for electronics. There are others. I live in an area with a lot of small companies that build complicated expensive products for small audiences. Want a croissant-baking machine? There's long institutional knowhow here.
- idontwantthis 3y agoWhat would be specialized about baking a croissant? Or do you mean you put in flour and butter and croissants come out? I would pay handsomely for the second.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agocroissants (and any other delicate pastry) require precise humidity and temperature control for reliable results. Think PID controllers which control the heat/humidity through the baking cycle, or, conveyer-based systems with zones of specific temperature/humidity. In addition, very modern systems, they are using computer vision systems to dynamically analyze the baking to ensure perfect doneness. More repeatable results with less skilled labor is less waste is more profits.
- omgJustTest 3y agoHMU, can't find your contact details ! anucleonfreezer at gmail.com
- wkat4242 3y agoThe expanse doesn't really paint a very nice picture of the future of human society though :)
- loeg 3y agoIt's also, you know, fiction. You can tell because of the wormholes and aliens and magic.
- wkat4242 3y agoOh yes of course but I don't think it's a coincidence that every Sci-Fi that has enormous megacorporations is also incredibly dystopian. Think also of Blade Runner (it's a core theme in the cyberpunk genre it spawned). And Firefly, probably a lot more. Which Sci-Fi franchise has ultra-powerful corporations and isn't dystopian? Don't forget Sci-Fi is a product of our own civilisation. I think we all know deep down that the current ultracapitalist model will bring us to doom. Because we're already most of the way there. That gets incorporated in to Sci-Fi because people will feel it's more realistic. I always loved the more socialist take of Star Trek (especially TNG). They even did away with the whole concept of money "We work to better ourselves". Pretty revolutionary in the 80s but it feels even more so now.
- zer00eyz 3y agoYou should take a look at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation There is a template for running a business in a new way. Mondragon has sort of reached the limit of what they can do as a single institution. Farmers, have been running coops for a long time. They work and are very effective. Again nothing new here just not in the headlines. I will say that the irony should be lost on no one that rural farmers have a form of working corporate socialism that most urban professionals desire.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoHow? How how how? This silly debate comes up everywhere these days as railing against the current western economic system has come in vogue on the web. But it's not enough to complain, I can fill bookshelves with Reddit comments that do that, we need to imagine solutions! A sibling comment pointed out Mondragon which uses the ParEcon form of economic management which is an actual answer to the question. I'd love to see other answers.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoBog standard industrial protectionism, as used by Alexander Hamilton to industrialize the United States. They don't often mention that part when they talk about trade liberalization, do they? This shit has been understood for centuries, but asset-owners just can't help themselves when they get a chance to pump at the expense of export-makers, even if it's literal communists they are selling us out to. I'd rather not sell out to the literal communists, so let's (continue to) roll back the changes. If we don't do it voluntarily, our hollowed out industrial base will eventually start losing us wars and it will happen involuntarily, with a lot more pain.
- sobellian 3y ago> our hollowed out industrial base will eventually start losing us wars These are not the 1940s, you cannot convert a car plant to produce jet fighters. So the industrial base writ large is irrelevant. If you are really afraid of losing a world war, you are advocating for expanding the MIC specifically. Problem as Eisenhower put it is that you would hang humanity from a cross of iron. MIC spending necessarily crowds out economic activity for civilian benefit. Anyway, our MIC is quite large already.
- smallmancontrov 3y ago> These are not the 1940s, you cannot convert a car plant to produce jet fighters If your understanding of supply chains is so poor that it does not encompass more than a single vertically integrated entity, this deficiency will lead you to catastrophically incorrect conclusions like: > the industrial base writ large is irrelevant This in particular: > If you are really afraid of losing a world war, you are advocating for expanding the MIC specifically is an egregiously inept straw man. Not only are many industrial machines dual use, most are dual use. In fact, I propose a challenge: I'll name an industrial machine that is dual use and you respond with one that isn't. We go back and forth until we have settled the matter. I'll start: plastic injection molding machine
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jmyeet 3y agoEarly in the piece it makes the fairly standard pro-nuclear claim that nuclear is "... historically been among the safest forms of power generation" [1]. It bases this claim on three criteria: (1) air pollution (2) accidents and (3) greenhouse gas emissions. Greenhouse gas emissions is an obvious win. But let's look at the other 2. Both are quantified in terms of deaths, which is the most favorable metric to nuclear because it says nothing about clean up costs and ecological or environmental damage. Case in point: almost 40 years later, the Chernobyl Absolute Exclusion Zone is still quite literally 1000 square miles. A worse example (for the nuclear industry) is the Fukushima clean up costs. The core is still incredibly dangerous and will continue to be probably for centuries. It needs to be actively cooled. This feels a bunch of tanks with radioactive water that is expensive to treat and controversial to release back into the ocean once its deemed "safe". We have no way of removing the core so this will continue for decades to come, possibly over a century. Fukushima will cost billions in maintenance for decades to come, so far has cost >$70 billionn and will likely approach $1 trillion byh the time it's all over [2]. Now, consider US nuclear power regulation. The Price-Anderson Act limits liability for nuclear power incidents to $500 million per site with a separate total ($10 billion?) per year [3]. The industry has a self-insurance fund to pay for disasters like these but the size of that Fukushima clean up cost to date would have exceeded that multiple times already. So who picks up the check? The government. Nuclear power simply transfers wealth to private industry while private industry assumes almost none of the risk. We would need to trust such companies to maintain and operate plants safely when we all know that economic incentives will be to cutback on safety, inspections and maintenance to maintain and increase profits. That's why nuclear power is a terrible idea. [1]: https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy [2]: https://cleantechnica.com/2019/04/16/fukushimas-final-costs-will-approach-one-trillion-dollars-just-for-nuclear-disaster/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/04/16/fukushimas-final-costs-... [3]: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10821#:~:text=P.L.%20109%2D58%20set%20the,the%20limit%20to%20%2416.6%20billion https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10821#:~:te....
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lokar 3y ago
- echelon 3y agoI live in Georgia. I'm happy we built this, but I'm so unhappy about the mismanagement and the added cost to my power bill. Despite the danger, nuclear is exactly the kind of thing I want a SpaceX-type company to tackle. Nuclear should be orders of magnitude cheaper. It should be developed at a frenetic pace, with even the scary failure modes being tolerated. Safety doesn't matter to the degree we think it does when literally thousands of people die in traffic accidents, and hundreds of thousands to preventable diseases. We don't even need to build near population centers to get this off the ground. We have so much space to build and test safely in complete isolation. We're in this spot because of the decades of fearmongering from the greens and the geopolitical adversaries masquerading(!) as greens. We also have this deeply-held reverence, and perhaps even guilt, because we built the bomb. This thinking has held us back so unfathomably much, and for nearly a century. Nuclear could propel us forward as a civilization if we'd just let go of the fear.
- renewiltord 3y agoThere are a bunch of Small Modular Reactor companies (Nuscale is probably the most well known in the media but venerable Westinghouse has one too). Elon Musk might be the world's foremost genius at handling government-related businesses (i.e. identifying where a startup can unblock government leaders who want things done but can't use existing orgs - electric / space) and he's stayed away from nuclear. I suspect a SpaceX analogue cannot be built in this field. Part of why renewables are beating SMR companies is incrementality. You can build and expand power projects and scale up from small installations up high. It's surprisingly hard to find economical places to build this in the US. Even geothermal in completely uninhabitable places gets met with opposition from groups like the Burning Man guys. I'm sure we'll conquer these regulatory things within the next half century, but until then we're in trouble and insistent on walking the precipice.
- throw0101d 3y ago> There are a bunch of Small Modular Reactor companies (Nuscale is probably the most well known in the media but venerable Westinghouse has one too). SMRs are mostly useful for small grids. Efficiency for large grids comes from large reactors (>700MW, and perhaps even 1000MW) that are built in a pipeline (I've heard the term "Large Modular Reactor"). When the province of Ontario built out its CANDUs it built them in pairs, and plants had 'packs' of fours and eights. It was a fairly standardized design and so the supply chain settled down and could churn out components.
- throw0101d 3y agoThe Decouple podcast recently had three-part series on Vogtle: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGySq7QBRiY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGySq7QBRiY * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfkoMUmmUCI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfkoMUmmUCI * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbKf_TbI000 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbKf_TbI000 It mentions a few 'macro' issues with Vogtle: the first being the choice of using an AP-1000 design (Westinghouse Toshiba). Not because it is/was necessarily 'inherently' a bad design (the guest, James Krellenstein, describes himself as an "AP-100 fanboy"), but rather because it was (at the time) never built before. That, combined with the fact that the US had little/no institutional knowledge of building nuclear plants means that a whole lot of learning needed to be done. Contrast this with another available (at the time) option, the ABWR, which GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy had building been for over a decade in Japan. Between ABWR build beginning and commercial operations it took about 4-5 years on average: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_reactors#Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_commercial_nuclear_rea... They had a ready-to-go supply chain, with plenty of experience. Tied into the fact that the AP1000 was a new design, they decided to start building before 'detailed' drawings were only ~40% done. So they had the high-level view design done, but the drawings for machinists and pipe fitters needed were not ready, and so that added to delays, as they had to first create them, and then there was all sorts of back-and-forth to refine them. These issues were called out in the article: > When Vogtle’s Units 3 and 4 were approved by Georgia regulators in 2009, the reactor model, known as an AP1000, had never before been built. (It was Westinghouse’s flagship model, combining massive generation capacity with new “passive safety” features, which allow reactors to remain cooled and safe without human intervention, external power, or emergency generators in the case of an accident.) It later emerged that the reactor’s developer, Westinghouse, had not even fully completed the design before starting construction, causing a significant share of the project’s costly setbacks. While that was bad news for Georgians, it could mean a smoother path ahead for future reactors. > “In the course of building Vogtle,” Kozeracki told Grist, “we have now addressed three of the biggest challenges: the incomplete design, the immature supply chain, and the untrained workforce.” Somewhere in the podcast they also go over some interesting 'bureaucratic minutiae': the plant was originally approved under a part of the regulations where everything is submitted 'all at once' and approved 'all at once', but any later changes to the design may take longer. As opposed another part where the design is submitted in parts, which may have been better as it would have allowed for gradual refine of the plants and submission when they were 'actually' finalized. It also doesn't help that the US has so many 'one-off' nuclear plants, so that experience in one cannot be directly transferred between them. Contrast that with France, which has a fairly cookie-cutter fleet, or even (closer to home) the province of Ontario which has CANDUs everywhere (which were generally constructed in pairs and were often ordered in four- and eight-packs). Some CANDUs are currently undergoing refurbishment, and the project is on-/under-budget and ahead of schedule. Interview with the fellow in charge of the refurb program: > Gary Rose, VP New Nuclear Growth at Ontario Power Generation, walks us through the CANDU refurbishment program whose stunning successes have laid the foundation for deployment of the west’s 1st grid scale SMR, the GE Hitachi BWRX-300. * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHTtthahwjs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHTtthahwjs Of course now that the AP1000 has been built twice (Vogtle Units 3 and 4), plans exist and there's experience. The question is whether any new plants that are going to be built will use that experience, or choose yet another design.
- epistasis 3y agoThere's two separate ideas when it comes to technology: what it can be, and what it actually is. After nearly 70 years, I think we need to take a hard look at what nuclear actually is. And it's a fantastically complex, wondrously large, construction project, that has to last a long long time without big repairs. To the best of our knowledge of technology and industry, something like that does not typically get cheap. We may get slightly better at doing it, but there's a vanishingly small chance that we will hit a 10x reduction in cost for nuclear, and almost certainty that we will not hit a 100x reduction in cost. For anything like that, we'd need a massive new tech breakthrough such that it would be considered an entirely new technology. That breakthrough would be the underlying tech, not using neutrons and chains of nuclear reactions to generate heat. In contrast, we have several technologies in hand that are going to see a 10x-100x reduction in cost, and even at current prices are competitive or the market leader: wind, solar, and batteries. Look at any part of the country where there's an electricity market with any sort of freedom of generation, and new generation is dominated by wind, solar, and batteries. That's going to get more extreme in coming decades. Energy generation is going to get ever cheaper. (That doesn't mean that grid electricity will necessarily get cheaper, utilities will recoup lost revenue by making transmission and distribution more expensive, because they are very good at tricking regulators.)( In any case, give nuclear a shot. But current attempts are skating to where the puck was 5-10 years ago, and they won't finish until the puck has spent 10-15 years more of shifting towards ever cheaper solar, wind, and batteries. We all grew up with nuclear as the power source in our science fiction stories. But without a SF level advance in nuclear technology (e.g. direct neutron momentum-->electricity), we know that nuclear will at the very best be a tiny player in the future energy world.
- Manuel_D 3y ago> To the best of our knowledge of technology and industry, something like that does not typically get cheap. History demonstrates otherwise, though: nuclear was cheap in the late 1960s and early 1970s [1]. This is a period of time where nuclear power was built at scale, with the same designs built repeatedly. A production run of 40 steam generators is much cheaper on a per-unit cost basis than a production run of 4 steam generators. Lower numbers of nuclear projects following 3 Mile Island reduced this economy of scale, resulting in higher costs per unit. It's quite amusing to see someone talk about a 10-100x reduction in the cost of intermittent sources so confidently, yet discounting the possibility of cheaper nuclear power despite the historical precedence. Unfortunately, renewable costs have largely flatlined and started to increase [2]. 1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421516300106 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030142151... 2. https://www.economist.com/business/2023/12/04/the-renewables-business-faces-a-make-or-break-moment https://www.economist.com/business/2023/12/04/the-renewables... Relevant chart: https://www.economist.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,quality=80,format=auto/content-assets/images/20231209_WBC618.png https://www.economist.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=600,quality=80...