6 ms·
The return of never-ending job interviews: 'It can go beyond the pale'
- cableshaft 3y agoI don't know about anyone else, but if they don't have me do at least a baker's dozen worth of interviews, then I start to worry they don't properly value me. Like I'm not the equivalent of a one night stand job seeker. You need to wine and dine me with multiple phone calls, technical interviews, all-day in-person interviews, and interrogating all of my references before I'll even think of playing hard to get by threatening to leave the negotiating table in order to get my fair share of TC and ultimately agree to join your company and stay overnight on a major production screw(up).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chrstphrknwtn 3y agoIf it takes thirteen interviews for someone, or a group of people, to know if I'm worth hiring, then I would assume they have no idea what they're doing. That seems like a waste of everybody's time.
- hinkley 3y agoI kept waiting for the sarcasm tag that never came.
- cableshaft 3y ago/s
- jakupovic 3y agoNot exactly sure if you're being sarcastic or not. But I am for the wining and dining part, accompanied by a good interview it can be fun. The other 12 parts can be skipped.
- mooreds 3y agoThat's what I thought too--is the poster being sarcastic?
- meetingthrower 3y agoYes
- mortenjorck 3y agoPerhaps we should be worried that such a clear (to me, at least) use of hyperbole can nonetheless be seen as potentially serious in this job market.
- cableshaft 3y agoI guess I did need that /s. I thought I was being sufficiently over the top but I guess I wasn't. I hate multiple interviews. The best interviews I've had were a single 45 minute interview.
- tbrownaw 3y agoNo, you were definitely sufficiently over the top. It's just hard to tell if you're poking fun at current hiring practices, or at current dating practices. Or maybe at both.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoWe'll eventually get to the point where anyone willing to jump through these stupid hoops is primarily motivated by greed.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoSomeone jumping through lots of hoops to get a job is greedy? Why would that make sense?
- usrusr 3y agoI guess GP was only thinking of people that do have a job looking for greener grass. For that subset I'm inclined to agree, despite vigorously agreeing with the counter opinions in the general case.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoWhy would looking for a better job be greedy?
- usrusr 3y agoThe not so greedy might certainly be looking, but their willingness to jump through hoops would have a limit somewhere. Require a very large number of hoops to be jumped through and every single hire will be of the kind who would have zero qualms to sell your company internals to the highest bidder if given the chance.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoThis seems like you're bending over backwards to hallucinate some made up exotic scenario that has never happened. Require a very large number of hoops to be jumped through and every single hire will be of the kind who would have zero qualms to sell your company internals to the highest bidder if given the chance. What are you even talking about. What are you basing this on?
- loa_in_ 3y agoUnfortunately the interviewees lose money while they're being interviewed while the interviewers earn theirs.
- yokoprime 3y agoOnly when unemployed
- soupfordummies 3y agoNot necessarily, what about hourly workers or those that have to use PTO/sick day? I would consider burning a PTO day to be losing money.
- postalrat 3y agoYou mean only when employed.
- Arainach 3y agoTime is money. Wasting a vacation day hurts too.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoTime is money, friend.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoMy petty revenge against amazon mistreating my partner when they worked there is to aggressively pursue onsite interviews with them. I refuse to do initial phone screens - a tactic which often works to go directly to onsite since amazon is clueless and desperate. I don't study for their stupid whiteboards and I don't study their stupid leadership principals. I on purpose refuse to use them during behavioral interviews (also refuse use the STAR method). I've had at least 5 full onsites like this. By my calculations, the wasted time and effort from amazon on myself was worth at least 100K given the number of highly paid engineers/managers who wasted their time interviewing me.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoIt's pretty annoying how the article is quite both-sides-ism about the whole thing. Four months to receive an offer? Come on. You get the vast majority of the signal for a candidate in the interview process itself. All of the backoffice deliberations don't require months of meetings. It's just more okay that it gets dragged out because the market is lousy. Call it what it is: indecision and inefficiency.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYeah I really don't get it. If you need to hire people, hire them. If you don't, why are you wasting your time and theirs by interviewing them endlessly? I get that a business may always want to be open to hiring an exceptional person if one becomes available, but that's very often based on an internal recommendation/reference not a response to a job posting. Execptional people generally don't apply to posted jobs, they work their network.
- cjf101 3y agoFour months for an offer sounds a lot more like a terrible salary negotiation tactic. The longer a candidate will wait for an offer, the less money they might be willing to accept. It's definitely not going to get you the best candidate, but it might get you the cheapest one.
- red-iron-pine 3y agothat's a whole quarter + a month where you didn't have a body and stuff didn't get done. maybe they'd be slow at first and a burden until they're up to speed, but that means you start that process sooner. they either needed the exact, perfect candidate, or else they wasted a lot of time
- hinkley 3y agoIn four months you’d owe me another 1% just for inflation. But the last time I interviewed I got a callback after less than two months and they found I’d already had a new job for a week and a half. (In retrospect I should have followed up with them, as the new place was throwing red flags).
- dep_b 3y agoIt's kind of fascinating to see companies I've interviewed at, where I did well enough in my honest opinion to get something of an offer in yesterday's market where they didn't even went for a better candidate but simply reposted the job the same week. What is the idea? They just have it up to find that one 0.1% developer that happens to walk through the door? I can't imagine companies simply want to wait to roll out features they are planning to build in such a dynamic market. Something you think of today is launched by your competitor tomorrow. If you have an unfilled vacancy for two months more stuff will be rolled out two months later.
- paxys 3y agoEvery new feature is built by one developer doing 90% of the work and a dozen others doing the last 10%. As long as the company has the 90% developer on the project, it really doesn't matter whether the new hire happens today or 6 months from now. The feature is going to remain on track.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoI don't know, on a lot of projects the last 10% seems to take 90% of the time.
- owyn 3y agoExactly. I consider myself to be one of those last 10% developers who enjoys the work it takes to get good, valuable projects from mostly done to actually done (software is never done but you know what I mean). The geniuses have already moved on to the next project. You need a mix of both at any company.
- imiric 3y agoNot every company is urgently looking to fill a role. It might be more acceptable for them to wait for a candidate who is a better fit, than to hire someone they're not thrilled about, and increase the costly risk of it not working out.
- Foobar8568 3y agoNumber of job interviews to get into any company (or almost) as an external person... 1. Sorry something is really fucked up in HR.
- TRDRVR 3y agoJust a periodic reminder that 'Beyond the Pale' is a pro-colonialist phrase that many believe was was part of Britain's Centuries-long campaign to eliminate Irish culture. https://www.grammarphobia.com/blog/2012/12/beyond-the-pale.html https://www.grammarphobia.com/blog/2012/12/beyond-the-pale.h...
- tgv 3y agoIs that one of those "it becomes true if you repeat it often enough?" There's at least one other attribution, and it's probably just as made up.
- selwoot 3y agoThat's the exact opposite of what the link you included says. From https://www.grammarphobia.com/blog/2012/12/beyond-the-pale.html https://www.grammarphobia.com/blog/2012/12/beyond-the-pale.h... As for the relationship between the two expressions, the OED has this to say: “The theory that the origin of the phrase [‘beyond the pale’] relates to any of several specific regions, such as the area of Ireland formerly called the Pale … or the Pale of Settlement in Russia … is not supported by the early historical evidence and is likely to be a later rationalization.”
- wrs 3y agoAlso from the article: a “pale” is a fence. “Beyond the pale” used to require a suffix (e.g., “beyond the pale of reason”) but eventually by itself started to be short for “beyond the pale of acceptable behavior”.
- gentleman11 3y agoA variant: government of canada/province jobs that re-post your job every season; requiring you to fully re-apply and re-interview over and over with your boss while they endlessly try to replace you, no matter how well you did. Until you get promoted or they find somebody they like better and you have to move 500+ km to get a different position I honestly think amazons stack ranking is less humiliating and skeezy
- FeloniousHam 3y agoI have heard of a similar policy with State jobs in the US, in practice it's a formality (maybe because it's easier to fire people here). Sounded like "good governance" kabuki--I've never heard of anyone losing their job then.
- lazide 3y agoAll I can say is, wtf?
- Chris2048 3y agoMaybe, but hopefully you'd have a massive advantage at your own job. There is the perception of public jobs as being a lock in without competition - maybe this is meant to fix that?
- jdlyga 3y agoStack ranking is the first HR thing that agile development practices warn against. It discourages teamwork.
- blovescoffee 3y agoI’m sure agile development also discourages reposting a job and making the employee re apply.
- willhslade 3y agoThis actually happens? Which branch or all branches?
- 3y ago
- toldyouso2022 3y agoSimilar to what social media did with dating, it also created the delusion in managers that the perfect candidate is out there.
- hackable_sand 3y agoAlready 2 months into my job search marathon and going strong. I must be doing something right because I don't even have to wait for the first interview!
- wallstthrowaway 3y agoI remember going through 16 interviews to be hired by a top tier Wall Street investment bank. I was an experienced hire, lateraling over at this point I was only hired after I got an offer from a competitor (following about ~6 interviews there, most of which were over the phone) and forced my top choice's hand Fast forward 18 months and I was laid off along with hundreds more. As it turns out, my two superiors weren't liked at all, so when the market slowed, their peers took the opportunity to get rid of them... and I became irrelevant as I had nobody to work for. In hindsight, it's somewhat obvious that it took them this many rounds because they were not certain they needed someone to work for the guys everyone disliked. I got a couple of deals done, had a couple more lined up, generated millions of dollars of revenue to the bank, clients liked me... but it wasn't the right place or the right time. If I could do it all over again, I would have been more upfront and a tougher negotiator with them from the outset. I either want full commitment or it's not worth it. Tell me upfront how many rounds of interviews you need and I'll tell you if it's worth my time and the brain damage.
- ylee 3y agoI've never worked for a tech company. But I have worked for two bulge-bracket investment banks. So it's been interesting to read of how tech companies recruiting works. During my initial training/orientation period as a new analyst at Goldman Sachs in 1999, the person conducting the meeting asked people to stand up if they had had 5, 10, 20, etc. interviews for their job offer. One person stood up when the group was asked who had had more than 40 interviews. I was very unusual in only having four interviews before my GS offer. For that job, I'm pretty sure the person looking to fill the role personally contacted my college's recruiting service (because she had received her MBA from there). For the second job, at Citigroup, I saw a Craigslist listing either by the person himself or his assistant, talked to someone I knew at the firm who worked near him, then reached out to the person directly. In both cases the person hiring did my first (and, in the second case, the only) interview, and I never talked to a true HR person, let alone recruiter, before receiving the offer. I've been told that this sort of hiring does happen in tech, but it sure seems rare compared to all the stories I read here.
- hollywood_court 3y agoWhen I first moved back to Alabama, I took a job running 6 different 5 axis CNC machines for a Korean company. They had a policy that forced every new hire to go through a temp hire process and work for at least 3 months before being hired on with the company and receiving benefits and decent pay. There was no way I was going to allow myself to do the same work for less pay and no benefits for 3 entire months or more. So after my first week I told the materials engineer that I would need to leave early on a Friday because I had a job interview. I told him that at 9:30am and by 1pm he offered me a full time position. I was the only person who had ever skirted around the temp hire process and it upset quite a few people. But I knew what I was worth.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoKudos for knowing your worth and maximizing the leverage it gave you.
- Draiken 3y agoI (thankfully) just got hired and it took 7 interviews. 6 of which included live coding. And I got lucky, as they could've said no after all that time investment. I understand that hiring is hard and I've had bad hires before, so I know it's definitely costly. I've had candidates with years of experience that couldn't code, so I get some of it. But at the same time it's almost insulting to have to prove that I know how to code 6 times over, with 15+ years of experience. I don't know what the solution is, but it's definitely not to steal even more free time from interviewees.
- rokkitmensch 3y ago"Steal" is an interesting word to use, since they don't really get much for their time spent like that. I don't have a better one, but it strikes me as a lose-lose deal if it falls through after all of that.
- Draiken 3y agoAgreed, it might not be the best word to describe it. I guess one aspect is that on other interviews they at the very least pay for all the work you end up doing. You're normally sacrificing your leisure time which, under normal circumstances, is worth even more than your normal rate. But because of the power imbalance involved, you're expected to do it for free. It just leaves a sour taste in your mouth.
- j_m_b 3y agoWe're just beginning to experience a shuffling of the top companies. Remember FAANG? Just look at how bad the products are these companies churn out. Google search is a degraded experience, Apple released vision pro, and the N for Netflix should probably be N for Nvidia. It makes sense that the larger and mid-sized players are indecisive and taking things slow, the status quo is working out great for them. Why change it up? You're not innovating anymore, that was long ago extinguished by the bureaucracy that inevitably comes with a large organization. The easiest way to increase profits is to reduce payroll. However, there is going to be a lot of smaller companies that will quickly start eating the lunch of the larger companies in terms of hiring. They're going to be able to move fast and hire quick while the labor pool is oversaturated. This is a growing pain that happens during these times of reshuffling. We'll see amazing new companies that will make FAANG orgs look like Sears Holdings. This cycle has happened since before you entered the labor market and will continue long after you retire.
- a_vanderbilt 3y agoThe market ebbs and flows and your assessment of the innovation happening at Netflix vs. Nvidia is evidence of that. Google used to be a cornerstone of what defined a FAANG, but now it's become the new Microsoft, while Microsoft has been busy re-inventing itself. Amazon is flattening out, FaceBook (ahem, Meta) is searching for their next moonshot, and Apple is about to incur the wrath of regulatory bodies that their curated experience may or may not survive. I think COVID was the pivotal moment for these companies for the reasons you allude to: bureaucracy. The Goog grew way to fast to try and capitalize on cloud going up during the pandemic, but they hired too many middling people. Most companies did, but they cannot afford to do so then or now. Nvidia is a wonderful case study in management doing leaps and bounds without being "busy", because like Valve, their winning move was to let everyone else make unforced blunders. CUDA isn't exceptional. It's OK, it's alright, - but it's certainly better than the broken mess ROCm is. Intel said "meh" and left the entire market open, despite tailored compilers being their strong suit. Now Intel is getting pounded by AMD and ARM, and AMD GPUs are a laughing stock in the fastest growing market space at the moment: AI and Machine Learning. The companies that capitalize effectively on AI/ML now will be winners in tomorrow's market. I've worked in startups long enough to know what the end of ZIRP will do to a company.
- yunwal 3y agoI recently had a really good interview experience. 2-3 hour project. Then, after they reviewed it, another hour and a half meeting the team (no live coding, just talking about experience/fit). These takehome projects used to annoy me, but after this experience, I think I’d be fine with them being the standard as long as companies give feedback. Much better than 4 cycles of interviews. I’m also pretty certain they learned more about me through that than through leetcode-style problems that are in ChatGPT’s training set.
- greatgib 3y agoIf you want insanity, try the "Datadog" hiring process. I don't know how efficient it is, but from my point of view it is the most stupid one that I have encoutented: Imagine that they tell you to take "weeks" to train specifically for their 5 leetcode interviews process. And still, at this point, it is just to "determine your level". Will it be done then? no, you will still need to do more interviews with a few different teams to see which one can be a mutual fit between you and them. And I guess that you will still have management/HR interviews to complete that.