8 ms·
Ketogenic Diet Intervention on Metabolic and Psychiatric Health
- ThinkBeat 3y ago[flagged]
- DoubleDerper 3y agoFor those looking: "All participants were taught and instructed to follow a KD, (macronutrient proportion 10 % carbohydrate, 30 % protein, and 60 % fat; at least 5040 kJ). Participants were not instructed to count calories, but to reduce and monitor carbohydrate intake to about 20 g (excluding fiber) per day, eat 1 cup of vegetables per day, 2 cups of salad per day, and were encouraged to drink 8 glasses of water a day."
- smt88 3y agoThat seems like a lot of carbs. Would this diet really induce ketogenesis?
- OnACoffeeBreak 3y ago20 g of net carbs seems to be a common starting point for ketogenesis, but, yeah, I am surprised they didn't confirm with a blood ketone measurement.
- keybored 3y agoWhat is supposed to be low? In my casual supermarket label reading you seem to get at least some carbs (non-fiber) from things like cauliflower and other greenstuff. I was happy when I could get stuff that all had at most 5g carbs per 100g. But I was doing very informal low-carb and not keto.
- smt88 3y agoRight, I was kind of getting at that: there's a difference between "low" and "low-enough-to-induce-ketogenesis" when it comes to carbs. For example, the Atkins diet, despite being very low-carb, didn't result in a lot of people accidentally becoming ketogenic.
- cal85 3y agoIt is a tiny amount, and absolutely it would. Ketogenic diet guides generally suggest aiming for 20-50g carbs per day.
- improv 3y agoKetones have been shown to reduce oxidative stress and inflammation in the brain. We've known for a hundred years that it can be effective at treating epilepsy, and increasing evidence is mounting that it can be helpful for Alzheimer's, mental illness, and many other diseases. It's weird that there is such a stigma surrounding keto.
- toolz 3y agoI thinks it's more just stigma around all diets and keto just gets lumped into the category.
- loveiswork 3y agoI used to work in a home for special needs children around 2007, there was a child there who was on a 'keto diet', by order of clinicians, to help prevent seizures. This was well before it entered the zeitgeist as a fad diet. I think the supplement/fitness influencer machine is so aggressive and fraught with misinformation that anything that falls in its crosshair is just squeezed to death.
- markstos 3y agoScience doesn't support keto as an optimal diet for most cases, which I wouldn't call a weird stigma. The book How Not To Die is a good primer on nutrition, major diseases and longevity, and includes references to all the scientific studies references. Meat and dairy have causal or correlations with a lot of terminal diseases, which is bad news for the keto diet. Whole-food plant-based diets fare best in most scientific trials, which is fairly incompatible with keto. Research into optimal diets for longevity also found whole-food, mostly plant-based was what folks that live the longest eat. WFPB has also been used successfully in to address Alzheimer's and diabetes.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoWhat is meant by “whole” when used in “whole food”?
- 3y ago
- marstall 3y agocool study, but i wish they had mentioned ketones role as a signaling molecule - particularly around HDAC inhibition. This has relevance to many diseases, including Kabuki Syndrome, a rare genetic condition affecting neuronal growth. Kabuki mice have been seen to completely recover from their cognitive deficits via a short course of a ketogenic diet.
- heyoni 3y agoGot a link to that study by any chance?
- marstall 3y agosure! https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5224378/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5224378/
- heyoni 3y agoThis is excellent, thank you so much!
- marstall 3y agoout of curiosity - what's your interest in this topic? I follow it because my son has Kabuki.
- heyoni 3y agoI'm researching related genetic syndromes as part of my Satb2 research, which my daughter has. From what I understand seizures are a risk for both of those and ketogenic diets are purported to reduce them. Is your son on a ketogenic diet? or some approximation of one? It seems like it would be hard to get a child to adhere to one.
- marstall 3y ago
- bjoli 3y agoI had a lovely accidental talk with Felice Jacka who I later figured out was one of the top guys out there in the field of nutritional psychology. I might not be the right guy to summarize what she said, but iirc it boiled down to eating minimally processed foods with a high content of dietary fibre. I stumbled on an interview with her about a year after I met her. https://youtu.be/FleMtTEEYlc?feature=shared https://youtu.be/FleMtTEEYlc?feature=shared
- bentt 3y agoIMO ketones are a side effect, not a cause, of any of these improvements. I hypothesize that the actual driver of the improvements is modulation of the microbiome. Keto diets are by definition low in carbs and this starves out certain species in the gut. "A systematic review of gut microbiota composition in observational studies of major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35194166/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35194166/
- mpreda 3y agoInteresting. The effects of a very-low-carb diet, one such that triggers preponderently-ketone metabolism, are very-rapid-onset (24-48h) and massive. They can also be obiectively measured, by measuring the amount of ketones in urine and in blood. So I really don't see how that is compatible with the ketones being a side effect of gut species in your theory.
- bentt 3y agoAh maybe this is a case of my misusing the word "side effect". What I might have said instead is that the generation of ketones is coincidental with the effects of the diet. I'm hypothesizing that the microbiome mediates the changes, ketones or not.
- saurik 3y ago(FWIW, I understood what you meant on my first reading; but, in re-reading to try to understand the confusion, I am guessing the issue is you sort of said the keytones were a side effect "of any of these improvements", as opposed to saying they were merely a side effect of the diet.) Regardless, do you feel the microbiome manages to shift that drastically within 24-48 hours?
- bentt 3y agoYeah sorry for the confusion. I just meant that ketones are a result of the diet. >> Regardless, do you feel the microbiome manages to shift that drastically within 24-48 hours? No, but the population doesn't have to change in order for us to notice the effects of changing our diet. Changing the food we eat and subsequently send to the organisms in the microbiome affects what the various constituent bacteria/fungi metabolize and excrete. These excretions can have rapid effects on us. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9877435/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9877435/ In the longer run, starving some species out and promoting others to take their place would yield a more permanent effect.
- heyoni 3y agoI wonder if this post is timed to coincide with Easter Sunday and everyone sensitive to sugar being more receptive to a study like this.
- francisofascii 3y agoI suspect (and this isn't my idea) Keto works because it reduces the amount of dietary sugar and increases dietary fiber. It is the high sugar/low fiber diet that causes insulin resistance, metabolic dysfunction, microbiome issues, inflammation, etc. So keto may not be ideal, but is way better than the standard western diet.
- rmast 3y agoI thought the “typical” keto diet tends to be higher in meat, egg, seafood, and dairy-based product consumption than the western diet. Which would make it lower fiber, since that comes from plants.
- kcplate 3y agoI can tell you from my own experience of roughly 7 years with eating keto most of the time, that it’s my opinion it’s actually a low calorie diet in disguise. The higher fat and often slower digesting foods deliver satiety faster and better than other diets. When I am strict keto, I eat far less calories because my body is rarely telling me I am hungry and when I do eat…it’s telling me I am full in far less calories.
- egberts1 3y agoSample size: 21 For all we know, they removed the subjects off of their highly-processed food and reverted back to Keto (another form of non-highly-processed food diet). Have they ruled out highly-processed food yet? I did, and seem better for it. Of course, I am only a sample of 1: YMMV.