5 ms·
Cancer signs could be spotted years before symptoms, says new research institute
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[flagged]
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoIn 2020 1,603,844 cancer cases were reported[1]. If, as your link states, "More than 684,000 obesity-associated cancers occur in the United States each year", then your "just look for fat people" metric is missing about a million people, more than half of all cancers cases. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/data/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/data/index.htm
- Pannoniae 3y agoA 50% rate isn't that bad though? Like, I don't think anyone claims that you can't get cancer while not being obese, it's just that obesity is an increased risk factor and needs more attention. As another comment said above, many people ignore the signs of their body, choosing to just suppress them with medicating themselves or ignore them entirely; so they usually don't notice when something is off.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoMost obese people still won't get cancer. And "something is off" doesn't have any reason to be cancer. It's probably any number of other things, and even if you're not obese you can still have things feel off. And there are cancers that you don't necessarily feel off for until they are really far along. If anything these arguments are proof we can't rely on feeling off and we need reliable tests for this, because 99.9% of the time, even if you're in amazing shape, "I feel off" isn't cancer.
- bestouff 3y agoIsn't a sign of a disease called ... a symptom ?
- Retric 3y agoNo, A symptom is a manifestation of disease apparent to the patient himself, while a sign is a manifestation of disease that the physician perceives. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/341611#:~:text=A%20symptom%20is%20a%20manifestation,him%20to%20the%20doctor's%20office https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/34161....
- francisofascii 3y agoThe term seems to be thrown around to mean either. High blood pressure is a sign of other diseases, and some call it a symptom, but it is a measure rather than something people can perceive. I feel like I can tell my blood pressure is high, but I think I am feeling other sensations that correlation with HBP.
- Retric 3y agoPeople don’t necessarily use terms correctly, but it’s ‘feels or experiences’ so poor circulation is a symptom even if people are describing cold extremities. Very high or low blood pressure is definitely something people can notice unlike say latent TB which is only going to show up on tests.
- Spooky23 3y agoA symptom is what you show. A cough is a symptom, detection of a viral protein is evidence of infection. I lost someone close to me to melanoma that metastasized to the brain. It grew for at least 6 months without symptoms. And when symptoms presented, they weren't immediately evident of a tumor until it had progressed. She was being actively monitored for melanoma at the time - having the ability to detect it earlier would have made all of the difference.
- vundercind 3y ago
- Solvency 3y agothis is obvious to literally anyone who is in tune with their bodies, it doesn't take science to say so. Chronic inflammation is a great place to start. Because even if you don't have cancer, it's likely you're trending towards diabetes or some other major illness. inflammation is one of the number one markers for "SOMETHING IS AFOOT". most people are so divorced from being in sync with their physicality, and are so far removed from understanding what normal should feel like, and are often so blunted by prescription medications and other compensatory mechanisms, that it makes "something doesn't feel right" highly impractical sadly. even now, people here will scoff at this notion while willfully turning a blind eye to their own personal pains/afflictions/signals, even though rates of cancer and other diseases are skyrocketing. And this is because it's all wrapped up and embroiled in a scary cognitive dissonance that most people actively work to maintain, because it sucks and it's kind of scary to put a spotlight on your own mortality.
- jf22 3y agoThis is not obvious to literally anyone. You've never met or heard about a perfectly fit person in the prime of their life getting a stage 4 diagnosis of something or other?
- Solvency 3y agosure have. my cousin is a personal trainer who ran a gym studio from his garage. Was in great external physical shape. And his house reeked of mold. Absolutely insanely smelly. My wife warned him for years because she's sensitive to the odor, and he just completely refused to accept that there was mold in the house or that it was a problem or that there was any smell at all. he was later found to have stage2 cancer. just because he looked good, was he ACTUALLY good? no. sleep apnea. aching joints. a random bout of shingles at the age of 39. the list of "things" goes on, and most people have lists like this that they refuse to examine or consider as building blocks of a potentially encroaching larger issue. again, because of fear.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoThe problem is you're treating these like signs of cancer when they aren't. People with mold in their house don't necessarily have cancer, people who get shingles don't necessarily have cancer, aching joints is less than useless as a measure for cancer. You're working backwards, now anything that's incorrect with someone is proof if they ever develop cancer while ignoring everyone who doesn't.
- Spooky23 3y agoThis is really cool. Maybe as this moves on with early detection, we'll be able to deliver custom moderna cancer vaccines are immunotherapies to kill cancers before they can root.
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago[flagged]
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoBut that's not helpful for this. A higher rate of cancer in a population says nothing about the particular individual and whether or not they have cancer. This is a test to show if they are showing early signs of cancer, not the odds they will have it in the future.
- rgbrenner 3y agoIt is true that obesity contributes to some types of cancers, but not all. For example, severe obesity is linked to a 7x higher risk for endometrial cancer. But there's lots of data on cancer and obesity and out of the nearly 2M annual cancer cases in the US per year: "about 37,670 new cancer cases in men (4.7%) and 74,690 new cancer cases in women (9.6%) were due to excess body weight (overweight, obesity, or severe obesity)" So if "looking for fat people" was all you did, you'd miss nearly 95% of cancer cases. Cancer.gov has more data on this page: https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/obesity/obesity-fact-sheet https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/o...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dalewyn 3y agoHaving witnessed my mother fight and pass away from cancer rather recently, signs of cancer are definitely obvious in hindsight but they never strike anyone as such at that point in time. Basically: "Yeah, looking back on it that was cancer wasn't it? God damnit..."
- jseliger 3y agoDitto, except for myself: https://jakeseliger.com/2023/07/22/i-am-dying-of-squamous-cell-carcinoma-and-the-treatments-that-might-save-me-are-just-out-of-reach/ https://jakeseliger.com/2023/07/22/i-am-dying-of-squamous-ce... One problem is: how often do those signs turn out to be cancer, versus something else? There are now circulating tumor cancer DNA tests (ctDNA), though they're presently expensive: https://www.natera.com/oncology/signatera-advanced-cancer-detection/ https://www.natera.com/oncology/signatera-advanced-cancer-de.... If they get cheap enough, they'd be interesting as part of, say, an annual blood panel. Mine were like $5k each, however, so that's not going to happen in the general population in the short term. I was using the Signatera tests to try to determine whether I should start prophylactic chemotherapy after a total glossectomy. The answer turned out to be "yes," but three days before I began chemo, a CT scan ordered to ascertain whether I could use a jaw-stretcher device showed six to eight new tumors, less than two months after the surgery. So the direction was correct.
- Dalewyn 3y ago...God damn, man. I'm glad you're still here with us, but I... don't know what to even say.
- joelfried 3y agoThank you for speaking and not being silent when life is hard.
- sam2426679 3y agoAccording to an oncologist I spoke with, there are “shedders” and “non-shedders,” i.e. whether a tumor sheds DNA into the bloodstream or not. Apparently I’m a non-shedder :/
- Bostonian 3y agoEarly treatment of cancer is not always better: "Surgery for early prostate cancer may not save lives. Most men just as likely to survive with limited or no treatment" https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/surgery-early-prostate-cancer-may-not-save-lives/ https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/surgery-early-prostate-cance.... I wonder if this is true of other types of cancer.
- eftychis 3y agoI think this is unique to prostate cancer. As it says the average age of men getting it is 67. From experience and from data I had seen, a lot of times, the surgeons simply believe the patient is too old to have any surgery. And when they die -- e.g. family I had -- they note down the cause of death as natural causes. When you are 80-90+, practically everything gets written as natural causes. Finally, with prostate cancer, from what we know it is not a question if a man will have prostate cancer but if the man will die before prostate cancer becomes serious or appears. That is if we doubled the age of survival to 200 years I think we would expect virtually every male at that age to have gone through prostate cancer.
- tptacek 3y agoThat may be the case, but the other failure mode for early cancer testing is that you identify disease signals which will not turn out to be meaningful in the long run even without intervention. Iatrogenesis is a big problem with a lot of this stuff: the follow-on treatment for an epithelial precancer hit from your stomach is not harmless. This is a reason I've read evidence based medicine people use for arguing against routine whole-body imaging.
- eftychis 3y agoYes. I was touching solely the likely unique characteristics of prostate cancer. Maybe I need to clarify, but that is what I got the comment I was replying to indicated.
- yes_man 3y agoThere was a meta-analysis published in JAMA last year which concluded that screening is unlikely to prolong lifetime for other than colorectal cancers: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/article-abstract/2808648 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/articl... > The findings of this meta-analysis suggest that colorectal cancer screening with sigmoidoscopy may extend life by approximately 3 months; lifetime gain for other screening tests appears to be unlikely or uncertain. I am neither a physician nor qualified to comment on the article itself, but remember reading an MD commenting on it last year saying efficacy of screening was better in the 80s-90s, but with contemporary cancer medicine and improvements in surgery, we can now treat bigger cancers so early screening doesn’t necessarily prolong life expectancy. I would not take medical advice from myself or that article though. But to your comment, I doubt it’s only prostate cancer where early screening and treatment might not yield any returns
- trekkie1024 3y agoSemi-related: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02640-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02640-w
- NickM 3y agoCells mutate and become cancerous all the time, but the immune system is usually able to recognize this and shut down the errant cells before it becomes a problem. It's only when the cancer gets lucky with the right site of mutations that it's able to evade the immune system and grow unchecked. Early diagnosis would obviously be a good thing if we can reliably tell which cancers will become a problem. My concern is that most patients may have a hard time understanding this distinction, and we may end up with people demanding screenings and treatments that they'd be better off without. In case anyone thinks these fears are unfounded, keep in mind this is already a problem with thyroid cancer. Thyroid cancer is very common and frequently harmless, but increased screening is leading to more people being treated for it, and it's unclear whether this is a net benefit.
- noncoml 3y agoBut that’s not what the article says? From what I understood they were able to identify only those that end up developing to cancerous tumors. Not the ones that you mention?
- nradov 3y agoNot all cancerous tumors are really dangerous or worth treating. For example, prostate cancer is common among elderly men and they often die of something else before the tumor causes serious symptoms.
- beacon294 3y agoThat's actually no longer recommended. Men are living longer and treating the prostate is almost always recommended now.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> It's only when the cancer gets lucky with the right site of mutations that it's able to evade the immune system and grow unchecked. What happens if you happen to have some cancer mutations while you're young and healthy - but also super sick and your immune system is busy with other stuff?
- arrosenberg 3y agoFor what it's worth, this isn't new, just a new investment. There are a ton of companies in the cell-free biopsy space for early cancer detections, with the biggest name being Grail. We're more or less in the engineering/process improvement stage of early cancer detection, not the pure research stage.
- consf 3y agoEarly detection of cancer is crucial for successful treatment and improved outcomes. So happy to see those kind of news.
- j45 3y agoAgreed. Between all of the technical dissection and interpretation that is sure to ensue here, the human aspect, tempered with not getting hopes up, is that progress like this is invaluable for the many who can't access the best treatment, vs the few who can.