5 ms·

GitHub bans Neovim plugin creator and deletes repos

dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
Sad to see that the "ban first, make human contact extremely hard" has now affected GitHub. Hopefully they reverse it, but definitely a sad to see the "open source community" website go this path.
- db48x 3y ago
  They were bought by Microsoft; what did you expect?
- dzhiurgis 3y ago
  All these antitrust cases and no politician raising this issue.
  - catlover76 3y ago
    Those are 2 different things. Political appointees (not the same as politicians) might be in charge of deciding whether to bring antitrust lawsuits, but politicians do not, and in any case these things are mostly worked on by career civil servants.
deleted 3y ago
[deleted]
kstenerud 3y ago
They didn't delete his repos. He's just been shadowbanned, and is now running the Kafkaesque gauntlet of trying to figure out why he's been banned and then getting reinstated (maybe).
- dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
  I mean if the end result is that no one can access the repos how is that not basically deleting them? Are we just arguing semantics because the end result is the same?
  - kstenerud 3y ago
    The difference is that deleting them would mean that they're gone forever, and if he didn't have backups he's screwed. Shadowbanned means that he can still access his code and move it elsewhere even if he doesn't have backups. It also means that if he gets the shadow ban reversed, the code will once again be available. If it were deleted, that would not be possible.
    - dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
      The user in question can't actually access his profile or his repos. He's not shadbowbanned, he is actually banned.
      - kstenerud 3y ago
        > The user in question can't actually access his profile or his repos. He's not shadbowbanned, he is actually banned. "When I log into my account, it's all there, the code, the issues, everything (read: shadowbanned) so once this is resolved it should be seamless for you." "It’s important to note I didn’t lose access to my account, all the repositories are there, issues, pull requests, stars but I’m effectively shadow banned, I’m the only one who can see it."
        dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
        Selective reading strikes me once again.
        kstenerud 3y ago
        Happens to all of us ;-)
catlover76 3y ago
[dead]
shrimp_emoji 3y ago
On the plus side, if the appeal fails he won't be training Microsoft's AI anymore. :D (Get me off this rock pls.)

Sad to see that the "ban first, make human contact extremely hard" has now affected GitHub. Hopefully they reverse it, but definitely a sad to see the "open source community" website go this path.

db48x 3y ago
They were bought by Microsoft; what did you expect?
dzhiurgis 3y ago
All these antitrust cases and no politician raising this issue.
- catlover76 3y ago
  Those are 2 different things. Political appointees (not the same as politicians) might be in charge of deciding whether to bring antitrust lawsuits, but politicians do not, and in any case these things are mostly worked on by career civil servants.

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]

kstenerud 3y ago

They didn't delete his repos. He's just been shadowbanned, and is now running the Kafkaesque gauntlet of trying to figure out why he's been banned and then getting reinstated (maybe).

dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
I mean if the end result is that no one can access the repos how is that not basically deleting them? Are we just arguing semantics because the end result is the same?
- kstenerud 3y ago
  The difference is that deleting them would mean that they're gone forever, and if he didn't have backups he's screwed. Shadowbanned means that he can still access his code and move it elsewhere even if he doesn't have backups. It also means that if he gets the shadow ban reversed, the code will once again be available. If it were deleted, that would not be possible.
  - dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
    The user in question can't actually access his profile or his repos. He's not shadbowbanned, he is actually banned.
    - kstenerud 3y ago
      > The user in question can't actually access his profile or his repos. He's not shadbowbanned, he is actually banned. "When I log into my account, it's all there, the code, the issues, everything (read: shadowbanned) so once this is resolved it should be seamless for you." "It’s important to note I didn’t lose access to my account, all the repositories are there, issues, pull requests, stars but I’m effectively shadow banned, I’m the only one who can see it."
      - dont_dox_me_bro 3y ago
        Selective reading strikes me once again.
        kstenerud 3y ago
        Happens to all of us ;-)

catlover76 3y ago

[dead]

shrimp_emoji 3y ago

On the plus side, if the appeal fails he won't be training Microsoft's AI anymore. :D (Get me off this rock pls.)