10 ms·
You can't leak users' data if you don't hold it
- okeuro49 3y ago> Our first product is an iOS app designed to help you capture the best moments in your life I have increasingly come to the belief that mediating our life experiences and social interactions through apps isn't good for us. Your website "Matter" [1], to be honest, seems completely dystopian to me and an indication of all that's wrong with the relationship between technology and society. [1] https://matter.xyz/ https://matter.xyz/
- haltIncomplete 3y ago[flagged]
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoWhile I actually liked the primary point of the author regarding privacy controls, and I feel some of the commenters here are being a bit harsh regarding tangential issues or missing some of the crux of what he wrote, I also so strongly agree with your point that I couldn't let it go. Apps aren't going to make you happier. If you want to be happier, go for a walk outside and go hang out with your friends, in person.
- Retric 3y agoThat assumes quite a bit of freedom that may not exist for many people. An Uber driver waiting for their next passenger isn’t able to go hang out with friends, but they can play on their phone, or read a book.
- josephg 3y agoSure; but it’s probably true for most of us most of the time. I’m on HN right now instead of playing piano or going for a walk. I think I need the reminder sometimes.
- djbusby 3y agoGo for a walk right now!
- gremlinunderway 3y agoYeah but saying "you ought to go outside / relax / rest / spend time with family" and then saying "not everyone can because shit sucks" is missing the point. Shit does suck, for a lot of people, in a lot of ways. Acknowledging that is good, but then saying the alternative for that is people to play on their phones? How about advocating for people to be able to make a wage or living and have time to hang out with friends?
- dylan604 3y agoBefore devices, people were able to find ways to kill time at work just fine. As a human, we're perfectly capable of surviving without the device. I know that seems antithetical to zillenials, but it will be more than okay to look away from the screen for an extended period of time. Personally, having a driver sit their counting the number of red cars or counting the number of different state license plates is equally purpose serving as doom scrolling. In fact, it's probably much less detrimental to their mental health. It saddens me a wee bit that people think that the devices much be attended to to this extent.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoUsers didn’t consider them just fine, as they immediately abandoned them when given the chance.
- albumen 3y agoThat doesn't mean it's not harming them. Have addicts made the right choice by indulging their weakness?
- Retric 3y agoNew and fun isn't the same as addictive. We don't consider people watching TV, listing to the radio, or reading books as addicts yet people decried each of them as they became ever more popular for ruining the youth etc. People like stimulation and seem to indulge when it's new, but most people also get used to it relatively quickly.
- dylan604 3y agoI think you're trying to move the goal posts. The apps on the new are absolutely without a shadow of doubt trying to make their users addicted. To even suggest they are not addictive is beyond pale, and makes you look like a not serious attempt at the discussion, or worse. Your second sentence is null after your first.
- YeBanKo 3y agoTheir website is an epitome of idiocy of modern web product design. They want my email, because we are all "stardust". There is no clear explanation of what their product is or how it's different from a photo app and a notebook. Instead of a proper description of their business, they send to the Business Insider article about the founder who wants to prevent unhappiness.
- alistairw 3y agoI was reading your comments as a classic overly negative hn comment but then went straight to that website and wow, yep that's bad. I can't tell if they're trying to sell me groundbreaking new brain scan technology or very dodgy supplements. Possibly one of the most vague product sites I've seen and there are a lot that come up on here. I'm surprised this happens in tech so much. I feel I'm always very aware of people in the real world having no idea what I work on, so I always need to give background and context. I have noticed people in other industries haven't experienced that their whole life so often rattle off jargon that means nothing to me. Looks like all the founders are US based, maybe it's a cultural thing.
- YeBanKo 3y agoThis is definitely a thing. Few years ago I was at a cloud conference and met who worked for a failure large and known security company in a tech position. They have all kinds of offerings. While he was talking to someone, I decided to speak to one of their sales guys. I shared a bit about what my company did and what kind of infra we were using and then asked him what they offered and specifically what they could offer to us. This was one of dumbest conversation I had ever had. The guys had no f*cking clue what his company was selling beyond "we sell turn key enterprise security solution", it was so painful. I even tried to steer him into trying to sell us some vulnerability scans or traffic analysis for threat detection. Yeah, I get it, it maybe niche, he is in a non technical, they have many offerings, he hadn't been there too long (iirc about a year, which is long enough for sales), but it was still unacceptable. To me it's the same phenomenon – lack of clarity in communication – not exactly sure what the root cause.
- gumby 3y agoBack when my kid was born I bought a video cam. I upgraded the videocam a couple of times, but I realized I didn't use it much because when I did I was videoing not being part of what was going on. As a result there isn't much video of the kid, but I don't regret it. By the timewe switched to video cams in our pockets, I had pretty much given up, and apart from a few few-second captures, I haven't shot any video in years. And TBH I don't miss it at all. Apps like this are simply more of the same.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- numbers 3y agoI am more interested in the author's blog navigation, so cool!
- scoates 3y agoHello. Thanks! This old blog design is showing its age, certainly, but I appreciate the nod to URL Sentences: https://shiflett.org/blog/2010/url-sentences https://shiflett.org/blog/2010/url-sentences
- forgotmyinfo 3y agoWhat happens when Matter gets acquired? I'm sorry, but all this self back-patting is a bit too little too late for this jaded guy, especially because a thousand other companies have made the same promises in cheery blog posts, before something happens and my social security number winds up on a sticky note on some hacker's monitor in Belarus. Hell, I've worked for companies where I was forced to break users' trust because some executive critter told me to when it was clear the profit faucet wasn't opened nearly enough. So thanks, but this isn't enough anymore. We need laws that will guarantee that every company that handles our data will do it thoughtfully and safely. In the meantime, I'm not expecting much.
- scoates 3y agoHello. Agreed that we need comprehensive privacy reform. You should probably read the article, though. (-; I have access to everything (on the tech side) at Matter, and if you put your social security number into the app, I wouldn't be able to access it to write it on a sticky note. That's the whole point. PS I'm also old and jaded. (-;
- travisjungroth 3y agoI don’t think the article really answers this. All these decisions you’ve made to not store data are decisions that you could unmake. To put it concretely: if everyone at Matter tomorrow became malevolent and wanted user data, what happens? For example, if you push an app that sends home my private text, how would I know? Could you?
- defen 3y agoIsn't this an argument against putting any personal information into any app? Signal could turn malevolent tomorrow and start sending all your chats to their servers, which could have life-threatening implications for people vs just potentially being embarrassing.
- travisjungroth 3y ago
- montereynack 3y agoI sympathize a lot with the headline statement; it boggles my mind on a lot of the data residency/integrity/confidentiality measures taken around massive data silos (as well as the infra teams companies bring to bear to manage, scale and then inevitably publish gospel articles on the web about) when companies could just opt… NOT to collect that data? I really like the model of “It stays on your device, we never see it. At most we get bare-minimum location statistics.” Although I question the assertion that their metrics system won’t be turned against them; seems obvious that anything programmed can be reprogrammed or updated, especially in the modern update-focused age. I don’t think they addressed that beyond a general statement that they took pains to assure that their users won’t ever be spied on. Would be interested in a technical article on that. Side note, we at Sentinel Devices are taking exactly this “we don’t hold your data” approach for industrial machinery. Think automated AI pipelines that are air-gapped. And we’re hiring! If you’re interested, reach out to hello@sentineldevices.com
- jmward01 3y agoI agree with the core idea, avoid saving info so you can't ever leak it. I personally think our legal framework should be based on consequences to encourage this mentality more. If you are hacked I don't care even a little that you did everything right, I just care that my information got taken. You should be held liable even if you did what the industry thought was right.
- Terr_ 3y agoDisclosure liability insurance, low premiums if there was nothing to leak. Of course, that assumes a different world where companies actually pay for screwing up in the first place.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoObviously, IANAL In a sense, that gradation is present for other offenses. You kill a man by accident? It may end up being involuntary manslaughter. You kill that same man with malice and planning? It charge will move to aggravated and premeditated murder. At the end of the day, a life was taken and some level of judicial review should take place. That does not appear to happen for 'hack' events.
- ribosometronome 3y agoAre involuntary manslaughter cases not usually predicated on some sort of negligence or other criminal activity on the part of the manslaughter? I don't think I've ever heard of anyone being punished for being the person in the wrong place when someone else decides to commit suicide by train or vehicle, for example. If we take the comparison down a step (and into what I think is maybe a more comparable situation), I routinely see warnings in parking lots that they are not liable for stolen property or damage and imagine those are generally probably pretty accurate outside of, again, some negligence on the side of the business.
- gretch 3y agoThe difference between this situation is that you still committed an action, compared to simply being acted on. A better analogy would be like if you were a bank holding peoples' money. Armed assailants break into the money and take it. Is the bank liable because it did not have adequate defenses for the attack? But the bank situation is easy to solve because it's money and money is fungible, so you solve it with insurance. Leaked data can't be revoked and it's hard to quantify. If you make the policy wrong, you essentially end up punishing a victim party (the end users are victims, but the firm that was attacked is also a victim).
- erehweb 3y agoThe thing I wonder is - how will Matter make money? Is the plan to just get this via subscriptions?
- Almondsetat 3y ago>how will Matter make money? it won't, Matter
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThis aligns pretty well, with my own PoV. I can tell you that it has not made me popular with my coworkers. This whole blasted industry has become completely drenched in PID harvesting, and incredibly casual treatment of said PID. My solitaire apps are constantly trying to get me to sign up for leaderboards and challenges. I have been denying pig-butchering (most likely) signups for our new app, at about a 30% rate. It's pretty damn sobering (each signup is manually vetted. We don't really care about quantity). We are restricted to US, Canada, and India, and have barely made any efforts to promote the app, but the scammers jumped all over it. Right now, they are primitive (we have a specific demographic that is hard to fake), but I expect that to change. I have just come to accept that baddies will get in, so it's important that the liquor cabinet be empty, if they try raiding it.
- Terretta 3y agoThis is why B2B SaaS should stop charging enterprise price for SSO, and just REQUIRE an IdP or the Oauth/OIDC/whatever flow: https://vaultvision.com/blog/what-is-oidc https://vaultvision.com/blog/what-is-oidc The user experience is these "continue with" buttons: - https://id.atlassian.com/login https://id.atlassian.com/login - https://www.xsplit.com/user/auth https://www.xsplit.com/user/auth Then you don't have their account creds to lose. Personal data, PII, etc. is risk debt.
- 3pm 3y agoRelated concept is Datensparsamkeit: https://martinfowler.com/bliki/Datensparsamkeit.html https://martinfowler.com/bliki/Datensparsamkeit.html
- internetter 3y agoAlso tangentially related: https://www.w3.org/2001/tag/doc/leastPower.html https://www.w3.org/2001/tag/doc/leastPower.html
- nedt 3y agoThe even better term is Datenenthaltsamkeit - data abstinence. Not just storing less, but really only storing something if there is no other option.
- stpn 3y agoI really love this sentiment. Unfortunately, it also seems really hard to build many kinds of applications in a way that follows this line of thinking. I've been building a personal finance app with privacy in mind, but there are some places where you might begrudgingly "hold" a users' data that are just unavoidable. For instance, if we want to be a serious competitor and have bank integrations, then plaid etc. will require you to run a server that can see the data, even if you don't want it. We also don't collect names in our app, just an email, but good luck collecting payments, avoiding fraud or reporting taxes without collecting name and address. We've built our system to be as minimally invasive (e.g. in the above, financial data is only proxied to the user's device, never stored on the server), but that's only the "intention" part - there's just not a way to take the full measure.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoYou can always make an app that is not competitive with those which do store user data…
- stephenr 3y ago> good luck collecting payments, avoiding fraud or reporting taxes without collecting name and address A client of mine collected just shy of $2M last calendar year (2023), and we only store an email address, and a password. The trick is, let the organisations that (apparently) need that extra data, collect the extra data themselves. Payments are offered via PayPal, Stripe and Amazon Pay, using their hosted payment pages. It works amazingly well. The Stripe and PayPal options can even be achieved without JS, if you wish. I believe you could also achieve a similar lack of PII using a JS-heavy 'embedded' solution for Stripe and maybe PayPal, but don't quote me on that.
- stpn 3y agoOh yes, to be clear we’re not collecting any of that data ourselves, but it is in our stripe account. I suppose that data isn’t in _our system_ per se, but the arrangement is still relying on our privacy intentions over any systematic guarantee (“we simply don’t have this data”) we could give.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThe best infosec advice I ever received was “data is toxic”.
- Fnoord 3y agoCame here to comment on that: see the essay 'Data Is a Toxic Asset, So Why Not Throw It Out?' by Bruce Schneier [1] [1] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic_asse.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_t...
- pizzafeelsright 3y agocomputers are built to process data and networks were made to share data infosec does the opposite
- masterrr 3y agoIt's a very sensitive topic for the health data! Too many apps sending data left and right, 23andme scandal.. very few apps (e.g. Carrot Care on iOS) adopt such great philosophy.
- jazdw 3y agoExcept you can leak data even if you don't hold it. You are focusing on data at rest. Not storing the data obviously helps massively, but a bug or maliciously inserted code could lead to user data becoming compromised.
- xu_ituairo 3y agoWe shouldn’t let perfect be the enemy of good
- jazdw 3y agoWe shouldn't make blanket statements
- galina700 3y ago[dead]
- aksss 3y agoFor a SaaS app I built, I am using a third-party IDP/IDaaS, and thought about holding all user data as metadata in that directory so the only thing my app database stored was a foreign key for user, and I'd be able to really leverage the warrantied security of the provider. In the end I needed faster access to the user metadata so now am storing in database. Meh. Not sure if first idea was a good one or not - I know that depending on the type of breach, that user info stored in the directory could still be accessed, but was really attracted to the idea of not having a damn bit of it in my own db for purpose of getting just a bit closer to the idea of not leaking it if it's not there.
- idkdotcom 3y ago[dead]
- wolverine876 3y agoFrom their privacy policy: https://matter.xyz/privacy https://matter.xyz/privacy > If we make changes to this privacy policy, we will update it here and update the effective date at the top. (We can’t email you about changes because we don’t collect everyone’s email addresses.) Changes to this policy will not apply retroactively. Effectively they can change it any time and you probably won't know. If they violate it, what power do you have to enforce it? Pay an attorney six figures? For what damages under what law? Also, I'm not sure what 'retroactively' means here, legally: They have my data and change the policy; can they tomorrow use my data according to the new policy? (Not that it matters much, because I won't know about the changes anyway.)
- andrewnicolalde 3y agoPerhaps it means that a change to the policy can’t be used to justify actions taken that would have broken a prior version of the policy but which don’t violate the new one. Granted, I don’t have a complete understanding of the legal enforceability of a company’s privacy policy.
- refulgentis 3y agoThis is exactly as good as it gets as a privacy extremist - if they don't have your email, they won't send it, if they change it, the changes won't apply to you. They explicitly ruled out using your data according the new policy - retroactively means, if they update it, the updated version doesn't apply to you.
- wolverine876 3y ago> if they don't have your email, they won't send it They could post a notice in their app, for example. > They explicitly ruled out using your data according the new policy - retroactively means, if they update it, the updated version doesn't apply to you. I think it's much more vague than that. Maybe it's not retroactive to prior actions of theirs or to prior data they had. You're assuming it's not to prior users.
- kelnos 3y agoMy read there is that it won't apply retroactively to data you've already given them, but will apply to data you give them in the future, regardless of they are able to notify you of the change or not.
- indymike 3y ago> You can't leak users' data if you don't hold it False. You can't leak a user's data if you never have it to begin with. If you process it, you are at risk of leaking it.
- kerkeslager 3y agoFalse. In order to process a user's data, you must inherently hold it while processing it. Alternatively, stop being pedantic.
- indymike 3y agoFalse != True.
- krebsonsecurity 3y agoThis is the way. You don't have to protect what you don't collect. Mullvad is an excellent example of this. They don't even want you to pick a password, and they're fine if you just mail them cash as payment.
- petesergeant 3y agoDon’t see this yet in the comments so: https://idlewords.com/talks/haunted_by_data.htm https://idlewords.com/talks/haunted_by_data.htm
- RaoulP 3y agoInteresting, thanks. See also Fnoord's comment elsewhere in this thread.
- tppiotrowski 3y agoI try to follow this mantra on my website. I don't want user accounts so if you pay for something I email you a unique link to access it. No login and password and you can use a burner email address if you'd like. I don't care. I don't worry what happens with my user data if I get acquired because no one will ever want to buy a business with 0 registered users. :)
- SecurityLagoon 3y agoExactly. I work in cyber security and I am more convinced by the day that the answer is not having the data to steal rather than attempting to mitigate every possible threat. This combined with zero trust and 2fa/passkeys will go much further than many other snake oil solutions the industry loves.
- rangestransform 3y agoGood principle but the godforsaken states of America will never allow it, KYC and AML laws force financial service providers to keep pictures of your ID for eternity
- cheema33 3y ago> If one of our users' data became valuable to an evil nation state and they kidnapped my family, I'll be honest, I'd probably have to hand over the data. How is this prevented, when the evil nation asks you to modify the code to your app to do what you said you wouldn't do? i.e. Steal the data.
- gnicholas 3y agoEasy: have a livestream of his family and if they’re ever unexpectedly absent then assume that a backdoor was just installed.
- mcdonje 3y agoSemi-related: The point of GDPR opt-outs is it's something that's offensive to the user, which should give the site owners pause. "Is it really worth it to jump through these hoops and give the users annoying popups so we can set trackers?" Instead, the industry rallied around popups and tried to shift the blame to the GDPR.
- iamacyborg 3y agoA worrying number of folks in industry seem to think the GDPR mandates popups in the first place.
- Animats 3y agoAre they willing to contractually commit to not holding the user's data, with penalties? If not, they're not serious. Remember "Facebook - It's free and always will be."
- cvalka 3y agoDon't request it Don't store it Don't keep it.
- arkh 3y agoThat's one of the principles highlighted by the GDPR: data minimization. Once you can be fined for losing data, it suddenly is not free. No more "let's store everything and see what we can do with it later".
- andai 3y ago> Matter is an iPhone app, so we store data on your phone with Core Data, and in a private database that syncs within your iCloud account, but is set up in a way that even we can't access it. But Apple can? From the title, "We outsourced storing user data to an evil megacorporation" isn't exactly what I was hoping for...
- sunshinerag 3y agoor Google can on Android by the same argument.
- textinterface 3y agoI've had ideas for side-projects before, but most times I never actually went to building them because I got too scared of holding private data (sometimes sensitive information such as financial data). I thought of just building offline apps for the browser and letting the user sync data using Dropbox or some competitor, but never found an open source project to facilitate that kind of thing (an actual db that syncs through Dropbox). I also heard that locally storing a Dropbox token in the browser could be dangerous (assuming an offline-app-for-the-browser architecture, for example), which meant I'd have to build actual native apps. But then, isn't it dangerous to store a token in the OS as well? I might never build a side project. But damn, I wish there weren't bad people willing to steal data out there.
- loughnane 3y agoI struggle with this too. I've got a side project now that's a django app w/ a typical database setup. I'd _love_ to set up some sort of E2EE along with it, but the support for a novice like me to do that isn't really there. Maybe once it matures a bit I'll deploy E2EE, but i gather it's a bunch of work.
- textinterface 3y agoHey, after I posted that, I went and gave a second look online to see if I could find something that would allow me to develop a local-first app with offline persistence and syncing capabilities. I ended up finding some possibilities out there that could potentially help me build stuff. One of them is RxDB [1], which offers WebRTC syncing - you'd still need a signaling server, I suppose, but all sensitive information could be synced E2E-encrypted via WebRTC. Then there's CRDT's [2], which is a universe that turned out to have multiple possibilities that match (at least partially) my needs. In particular, the next thing I want to take a look at is cr-sqlite [3], which might be just thing I needed to kick-off some side-projects. I'm posting here cause I just found some hope of not needing to build a traditional client-server app and having to deal with all the hassle involved in securing a server (and with fear that my efforts could be not good enough), and I thought someone else could benefit from getting to know these things. [1] https://rxdb.info/ https://rxdb.info/ [2] https://crdt.tech/ https://crdt.tech/ [3] https://github.com/vlcn-io/cr-sqlite https://github.com/vlcn-io/cr-sqlite
- sonicanatidae 3y agoSadly, this will never occur because there is too much money to be made by selling this same consumer data and you can't sell what you don't store.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jcalx 3y agoSimilarly from Notes From An Emergency [1] by Maciej Cegłowski: "It's not clear that anyone can secure large data collections over time. The asymmetry between offense and defense may be too great. If defense at scale is possible, the only way to do it is by pouring millions of dollars into hiring the best people to defend it. Data breaches at the highest levels have shown us that the threats are real and ongoing. And for every breach we know about, there are many silent ones that we won't learn about for years. A successful defense, however, just increases the risk. Pile up enough treasure behind the castle walls and you'll eventually attract someone who can climb them. The feudal system makes the Internet more brittle, ensuring that when a breach finally comes, it will be disastrous." [1] https://idlewords.com/talks/notes_from_an_emergency.htm https://idlewords.com/talks/notes_from_an_emergency.htm
- ComplexSystems 3y ago> When users add memories to the app, they'll usually add content such as images. We don't want to (and we don't) hold these, either—at least not in a way we can see them. We primarily store these images on your device, but because the size of this storage is limited, we do have a system for storing assets such as images that have been encrypted on-device, and the actual photo contents or the decryption keys are never sent to us. We store data for users, here, but to us it looks like random noise (the binary ciphertext), never like a photo of whatever it is you're storing a photo of. Just for clarification, you are storing on your servers encrypted versions of all of the pictures the user enters? Just not storing keys? If so - storing encrypted user data is not necessarily the end of the world, but why advertise it as though you aren't storing user data at all? You are doing what many other companies do, which is store encrypted user data. Backblaze does the same thing. Or maybe I am misunderstanding.
- sunshinerag 3y agoI read it as the encrypted data is on the user's devices and not servers?
- mxuribe 3y agoThis is why i wish projects like TBL's Solid [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_(web_decentralization_project) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_(web_decentralization_pr...] would take off some more. I happily pay providers for an application (or at least the service/utility that an app. provides) because that is often the value they is brought to bear for my benefit...but the data, ah the data is something I don't want anyone to control but me. Projects like Solid pave a possible path forward that *could possibly* enable an ecosystem where we still can legitimately pay a provider for value they provide a la an app or service, but still we as users would exert maximum control over our data sovereignty. I hope this author and others continue to keep thinking of data in this way.
- ingigauti 3y agoLittle over a week ago I published a programming language called plang (as in pseudo language). It does exactly what you are describing in this post, all data is local, has identity (so no passwords), data is encrypted on local device but with ability to sync between devices securely. Another benefit it has is that the code is verifiable, the app you create is just series of JSON files that anybody can read, do verifiable. Yet another benefit is that the code is written in natural language, making it easy to understand what is suppose to happen. I call it intent programming. You can see more about it at plang.is