6 ms·
"Stock buybacks are a form of stock manipulation" - not really, they're a means of returning money to the shareholders while bypassing taxes on dividends. (Not
by pjc50 3y ago
"Stock buybacks are a form of stock manipulation" - not really, they're a means of returning money to the shareholders while bypassing taxes on dividends.
(Not an expert on the US tax system as I'm a Brit, but it seems that the tax treatment of dividends depends on how long the stock is held, and can be taxed at income tax rates, while stock buybacks result in inflating the stock value which is always CGT. Not sure what the tax treatment is for institutional investors?)
NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for, and we should completely expect them to do this because without it investors wouldn't invest in the first place. It's infinite zero-dividend growth that's weird (Amazon).
- dubcanada 3y agoTax just depends on how long it's held and if it is part of a major index. If you held long enough and it's part of a major index it is taxed the same as a stock buyback would (assuming you sold). Otherwise it's taxed as income.
- jsiepkes 3y agoIt's stock manipulation, we just chose not to see it as such. Just like alcohol is objectively a hard drug but we just chose not to categorize it as such.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 3y agoWhy is company X buying its own stock on the open market "manipulation" rather than any other purchaser?
- jsiepkes 3y agoBecause you have inside knowledge and you are altering the stock price.
- koolba 3y agoThe company is in charge of itself. Everything it does alters the price. Bought back shares strictly increase the price for existing shareholders as it takes them off the market. The entire concept is mainly due to stupidity in tax law that ends up double taxing direct dividends.
- chongli 3y agoStock buybacks are heavily regulated. They need to be tracked and publicly reported and the plans for buybacks need to be announced by the company ahead of time.
- jomohke 3y agoNote that buybacks must be announced beforehand by the company, so everyone selling their shares has the same knowledge.
- Drakim 3y agoWhy is me buying my own book to bring it to the best seller list any different than any other purchaser? Stocks are supposed to be a share of ownership in a company, and the price goes up and down because being an owner of a company goes up and down in desirability, based on how well the company is doing. Just like with buying your own book, buying your own stock artificially increases the desirability.
- bvaldivielso 3y agoThis is a misunderstanding of what stock buybacks are. Companies do not buy their stock from themselves. They buy the stock from participants in the market. Following your example, it'd be like the author of a book buying the book they wrote from someone else. If the author chooses to pay someone else 1000$ for their book, they can, but they will be wasting money. A company doing a stock buyback is trading off their own capital (they have to spend it, it's not an infinite money glitch where they buy it from themselves) to get back shares of the company itself at the then-market-price. The market chooses whether that's a good trade. It may not
- pas 3y agothat's an argument for why best seller lists are stupid. companies can create new stock anytime out of thin air, and that decreases the price. why can't they do the opposite? some owners of the company decide to buy stocks from the others, thus consolidating ownership. that's what stock buyback is. note, the argument for taxing buybacks is completely different, and valid. (and it might make sense, it might not, it depends on the circumstances. externalities tax (pollution, tax on induced traffic, etc), LVT (land value tax) and wealth tax would be much better, than taxing transactions.)
- jmholla 3y ago> companies can create new stock anytime out of thin air, and that decreases the price. why can't they do the opposite? So at any point, a company can devalue existing shares that people have already purchased? That also sounds like a problem.
- Retric 3y agoBecause it’s independent of other price signaling mechanisms. The company doesn’t buy the stock because it thinks that stock is a good investment, it does so because of how it influences future prices. Ignoring inflation if a company issues the same inflation adjusted dividend forever say 1% at current prices. In theory the stock should stay roughly the same over the next hundred or thousand years. However, with a buyback the stock would increase constantly forever with endless stock splits. The second option is great for long term owners in terms of taxes, but it’s also manipulation of the stock price.
- davrosthedalek 3y agoNo, it buys it /because it has money to spare/. Having the money to spare makes it a good investment.
- Retric 3y agoCompanies can have net profits and be terrible investments. The exact same company can be a great investment at 10$, and a terrible investment at 10,000$. You can’t separate stock price from if something is a good investment or not. The example I gave was low risk 1% dividend, that’s not a stock I would want to own. Net result the company, which has inside information, should expect the price to correct ie fall at some point and thus be a poor investment until that point. That doesn’t prevent them from buying it because the goal isn’t a positive ROI.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wmil 3y agoIf you're going to stretch the difference that much the why not go all out? CEOs are constantly attempting to manipulate the stock price by trying their best to do a good job.
- gpderetta 3y agoIs a company issuing its own stock (i.e. selling) also market manipulation? It brings the price down. Buyback is the reverse operation. The difference from actual price manipulation, is that the price change in issues and buybacks is a permanent effect of the material change of the number of outstanding shares, not a fledging effect of the change in trade volume, i.e. the intrinsic value of the stock goes up or down. edit: of course buybacks, like dividends, decrease the value of a company, and issuing stock increase it, so it is not clear cut.
- throwaway_ab 3y agoFor them to be effective at returning money to shareholders, the action of buying stock is intended to take stock out of supply thus increasing share price value. Exactly as you say. Yet, this is clearly a form of stock manipulation, as it's an action to manipulate the share price. Whilst it is stock manipulation, it's debatable if it should be legal. I believe it should be legal, it's an efficient way to increase share value without adding to someone's income, thus often carries no immediate taxable obligation. However one could argue that these methods of moving wealth around without taxable events triggering adds to the fuel for calls to tax unrealised gains on all stock. So in the long run we are all worse off. Those laws will likely come regardless, as a way to fight the billionaire class, so stopping stock buybacks at this stage is unlikely to do anything.
- Drakim 3y agoIt does effectively legalize a form of insider trading though, a company would never do a massive stock buyback right before dropping bad news because the stocks they are now holding goes down in the price.
- andsoitis 3y ago> form of insider trading Rule 10b-18 is designed to prevent companies from using buybacks to manipulate the market, stating that share buy backs must meet 4 conditions: 1. all shares must be purchased during a single day and from a single broker or via a single deal 2. larger companies cannot authorize buybacks within the last 10mins of the day and smaller companies can't authorize them within the last 30 mins 3. companies have to buy back their stocks at a price lower than or equal to the highest independent bid 4. companies can't buy back more than 25% of the average daily volume
- matwood 3y agoDividends also change the share price, should those be illegal? What about announcing new products?
- scotty79 3y ago> "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for That's what shareholders want you to think. But societally and economically companies are mostly for everything else. If no company ever paid a single dividend or never bought back any of its stock nothing bad would happen. There are a lot of companies doing exactly that. But if companies stopped doing everything else they do that they are supposedly not for, the economy would end.
- mypastself 3y agoExcept that even then, an investor can sell their shares. If they couldn’t, no company would ever be able to raise money in a public offering.
- fiprofessor 3y agoWho would invest in or create a company that would never pay a dividend and never bought back its stock? How would shareholders ever yield gains from their investment? Short of some entity buying all stock and taking the company private (to then withdraw profits), there would be no way to return profits to shareholders. The companies currently not doing those things are in a growth phase, with the expectation that in the future they probably will be issuing dividends/buybacks.
- Aspos 3y agoThose who benefit from the company exist would invest in it: state, employees, clients.
- Eisenstein 3y ago> The companies currently not doing those things are in a growth phase, with the expectation that in the future they probably will be issuing dividends/buybacks. Berkshire-Hathaway has only paid dividends once since Buffet took over, and is the highest priced stock listed on the NYSE.
- fiprofessor 3y ago
- patrickthebold 3y agoCouple of comments: Usually when people buy shares they are going to try and get the most shares for the least amount of money, but the incentives are a bit different for stock buybacks. I don't know if buybacks are large enough to "move the market" but I'd be curious to see details on how exactly orders are placed. I'm a big believer that we need more non-profits that simple exist to employ people and provide goods and services. I realize this is just a charity and depends on the good will of people with capital.
- overstay8930 3y agoYou're probably thinking of co-ops, it is much harder to be a non-profit for most types of companies.
- oatmeal1 3y agoAgreed. It is a huge problem though that share buybacks are a way actual production (wages) is taxed at a higher rate than passive income.
- delusional 3y ago> NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for And here I thought Intel was for producing computer chips. Silly me. I forget the entirety of human history was just an elaborate pyramid scheme.
- aembleton 3y agoComputer chips that they sell for a profit that they return to shareholders
- fiprofessor 3y agoPrior to the Bush era tax cuts, all dividends were taxed at the income rate, which I think explains the biggest motivation in the shift from dividends to buybacks in that era. Nowadays, as you say, there is no difference in tax rates for qualified dividends. However, one big remaining benefit of buybacks is that a dividend forces one to incur a taxable event when the dividend is issued, even if one chooses to immediately re-invest the dividend in the company (as many people still in the accumulation phase of investing do). On the other hand, a buyback does not force those people to sell. On the other hand, a buyback should lower the market cap of a stock, so cap-weighted index funds ought to sell and re-balance when a buyback is issued, so most index investors would seemingly end up selling. However, they end up being able to avoid most of the capital gains taxes by re-balancing through redemptions and heartbeat trades.
- gizmondo 3y ago> On the other hand, a buyback should lower the market cap of a stock You got it backwards. If a stock is priced fairly, a buyback is value-neutral. Reduction of the cash on hand is offset by the increase of future cash flow per share. It's dividends that reduce the market cap.
- fiprofessor 3y agoNo, because the future cash flow per share is not reflected in the current market cap. Perhaps you are thinking of share price instead: there it is true that dividends reduce share price, while buybacks are share-price neutral at least theoretically, though it is commonly believed by many people that they do affect price. (Hence, under that same theoretical model, market cap must decrease if share price remains the same because market cap is total number of outstanding shares * share price. So if the former decreases while the latter stays the same, market cap must have decreased.)
- gizmondo 3y agoYou're right, I need a coffee.
- 3y ago
- paganel 3y ago>NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for That's debatable in many instances of the modern economic system. Of course, some instances of capitalism focus on that particular goal you've mentioned, but that wasn't always the case and it still isn't, depending on the socio-economic circumstances.
- concinds 3y agoThey're a means of "returning money", but they also pump up the stock price, to which managers' TCs are linked. Hence they are a form of manipulation. Unlike dividends, they don't return money to all shareholders, but to those who sell shares, which are the wealthiest, unnecessarily increasing inequality. Excessive buybacks and underinvestment are a big reason why Intel failed. Gelsinger (CEO) talked about this publicly. It's not just "returning money to shareholders", because it leads to perverse incentives and underinvestment. Under Otellini, Intel returned 109% of its profits to shareholders.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> They're a means of "returning money", but they also pump up the stock price, to which managers' TCs are linked. Hence they are a form of manipulation. Why would you say they're pumping up the stock price, rather than just raising the price? Is it a temporary pumping effect, like an Elon Musk tweet from 2017, or is it actually increasing the value of the remaining shares?
- concinds 3y agoProbably only the latter. My point was that executives (share sellers) benefit and it creates potentially toxic incentives.
- kjreact 3y agoExecutives are always incentivized to increase share value; that’s their job. Note: it’s the board of directors that issues new shares not executives. Executives can sit on the board, but the two are not the same. Executives are actually appointed by the board. The reason stock buybacks are viewed somewhat negatively is because it’s a lazy way to increase share value. Preferably executives would use the money to come up with new products/services to increase revenues. But if we’re talking about huge mega corporations, who already spend a lot of money on R&D, capex and/or acquisitions, then using some additional cash flow on buybacks makes sense. In Intel’s case, the buyback merits some discussion because it is implied that government subsidies are being used to buyback shares which is not the intention of the subsidy. Edit: IMO, I don’t think Intel underinvested, I believe they invested in many failed ventures and under their past and current leadership they are not able to grow the company in any meaningful way.
- bradleyjg 3y agoI have no idea why journalists have such a hate boner for stock buybacks. Dividends can get favorable tax treatment too. Just allows owners to time the tax hit.
- matwood 3y agoIt's like I mentioned when this came up yesterday, it's just a favorite boogieman.
- Workaccount2 3y agoIt gets clicks from people who aren't old enough yet to have any assets.
- supertrope 3y agoMost people don't own individual stocks. So their audience just pictures top hat wearing capitalists when they hear stock buybacks. It's the same reason why tenants garner sympathy while landlords are quickly called slumlords.
- andmarios 3y agoIt can be both at the same time. By buying out your stock, you alter the company's assets, but the price of the stock remains the same since you still have the same number of stocks issued. You just replaced your money assets with stock assets. Once you cancel the stocks you bought back, the rest of the shares will hold a more significant percentage of the company and increase in value. But this is one part of the equation. The other part is that your stock is inside a market, and buyers and sellers combined determine its price. If you keep buying your stock, you create buying pressure, helping keep the price from falling.
- boringg 3y agoStock buy backs functionally work no different them dividends at the end of the day. Your returns instead of getting issued as cash from a dividend are in the form of higher share value. Taxed as short term or long term capital gains vs dividend. Its a form of stock manipulation if you mean that buying stock increases the value of the stock. It doesn't mean its a form of manipulation in some kind of illegal unethical way that i think this comment thread is trying to make it sound.
- jorvi 3y ago> NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for You have absorbed modern market brokenthink. Companies are for creating goods or services to sell to other parties. They existed long before the idea of shareholders. Following your logic, companies pre-VOC had no existing purpose.
- andsoitis 3y ago> Companies are for creating goods or services to sell to other parties. They existed long before the idea of shareholders. Following your logic, companies pre-VOC had no existing purpose. Sure, but the owners (sole proprietors, shareholders, partners, etc.) of most companies want to make profit selling those services and goods. The more money you make the more you can grow the company or reward yourself (as owner).
- gtirloni 3y ago> Companies are for creating goods or services to sell to other parties Out of autruism? If not, it's to make money for owners. Shareholders are sort of owners thus to make money for shareholders.
- ada1981 3y agoYes, actually. >> For the first companies, the privilege of incorporation, often via royal charter, was granted selectively to facilitate activities that contributed to the population’s welfare, such as the construction of roads, canals, hospitals and schools. Allowing shareholders to profit was seen as a means to that end. Companies were deeply interwoven within the country’s or town’s social fabric, and were meant to contribute to its collective prosperity. << https://qz.com/work/1188731/the-idea-that-companies-should-benefit-society-is-as-old-as-capitalism https://qz.com/work/1188731/the-idea-that-companies-should-b...
- gtirloni 3y agoThat's an aspiration, not reality.
- 3y ago
- boh 3y agoFrom a basic economics perspective, companies conduct buybacks when they have no other use for the money. Since re-investment supports shareholders on a longer timescale, Intel has essentially let the market know they don't have any other use for the money they have. The point of investing in a company is the funds to be used to generate wealth. If I invest in your company and you just give me back my money, what's the point of the company (especially if its money requiring extra leverage to produce). Buybacks are inefficient use of invested capital (see NVidia's stock price if you need a comparison for a more efficient use of cash and its effect on shareholder value).
- gizmondo 3y agoWhether they are efficient or not entirely depends on the company. For every NVidia you can find another company (or ten) that reinvests inefficiently because managers tend to like building empires at the expense of their shareholders.
- boh 3y agoOf course. Intel, specifically, does not make a compelling case that they spent their cash efficiently.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for And here I thought companies are there to provide me, the consumer, and the customer, with useful products and services. If the purpose is return of money to shareholders, then the best strategy is to over leverage the company, spend every penny on stock buybacks, then default on all obligations to suppliers, pension funds and customers. Because you can fund stock buybacks with debt, but you could not do that with dividends. We have made economic destruction profitable and it’s happening across our economy - water companies in UK are going bankrupt because they have huge debt that they took out just for stock buybacks, and not for anything else, and now interest rates are up. Same thing happened with airlines, and many other firms.
- pjc50 3y agoIt's always been "both"? (specifically for the PLC-type company). People invest in the expectation of a return, to be achieved by doing business. It's usually phrased as "maximize shareholder value", which is ambiguous about the timeframe, but for most cases the value is understood to be over the indefinite future. Not that that stops people from taking short term decisions which can be bad in the long term. > Because you can fund stock buybacks with debt, but you could not do that with dividends. There are plenty of companies with large debs that pay dividends on the US market, such as Ford. The overleveraged self-destruction is bad, but that tends to be a feature of private equity deals where there is a single majority owner doing it on purpose (e.g. Maplin, Jaguar Land Rover). Harder to do with a publicly owned company where the investors can see what you are doing and may sue you. The UK water companies should never have been privatized in the first place. They're dysfunctional because water isn't a normal market and arguably can't be, so they're ripe for this kind of looting of the state by capital depletion.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoIt is a silly notion there is anything wrong per se about stock buybacks. Just as you can sell stock when you need cash (and lose some control) it is simply buying stock back when you saved some cash (and regain control). The only reason stock buybacks are thought of in negative light is that they seem to be a way for companies to not pay taxes... but the tax law is not companies' fault! It is our fault for the tax law to be this way!
- harimau777 3y agoDon't the companies, their industry organizations, and the people who own them lobby congress to make that tax law? It seems to me that in that case, tax law is their fault.
- tgv 3y agoTrading stock isn't investing. There's no reason for companies to give money to shareholders that simply bought their shares on the stock market. The company doesn't profit from that.
- daft_pink 3y agoJust want to mention since many commentors on this seem to miss this, three important points about stock buybacks missed by the back and forth partisan talking points on this comment: 1. They only make sense when the stock is undervalued and aren’t purely driven by taxes. If the stock is undervalued, then investors benefit by owning more of the company for less. If the stock is overvalued, then investors don’t benefit. The overall value of the price compared to its long term real value is important. There is a basic problem with this, because company executives probably never want to admit that their stock is overvalued. 2. Companies with strong incomes relative to their price can afford to do buybacks or with strong cash positions are the ones that make sense to do buybacks. Companies like this might be overvalued. When you see companies internet companies with zero income doing buybacks it makes very little sense and only established companies. Companies with strong financial positions relative to their stock price are more likely to be undervalued. 3. Because of the discounted cash value of income model for dividends where the value of a stock is based on future income and cash flow, dividends generally have to be stable and regular to ascribe significant value to a stock, which is why companies that have built up large cash balances but don’t expect to regularly pay dividends opt for buybacks, because they don’t want to create the constant pressure to regularly pay dividends.
- nr378 3y ago1. Stock buybacks are always anti-dilutive regardless of the value of the stock, and so investors always benefit as future earnings are concentrated amongst fewer shares (all other things being equal). It's true that a lower price/value increases the magnitude of this effect, but the effect is always present. 2. Zero income stocks can still do buybacks when they're returning capital raised from shareholders to shareholders (this is essentially just partially reversing a funding round, which again undoes some of the dilution). 3. Companies can be deemed to be significantly valuable without paying any dividends. Companies that have a long history of paying dividends but then suddenly stop tend to be in distress, which is then reflected in their share price.
- daft_pink 3y agoThese statements might be logically true, but I feel the logic ignores the overall strategic factors involved in buying back stock and that management needs to consider whether the stock is over or under valued, whether earnings are strong enough for this to make logical sense and the supply and demand among investors for dividend stocks and the ultimate value of a single lump sum distributed to investors vs the value of increased future earnings to the investor from the anti-dilutive impact of buying back stock. Discussing only the tax strategy as is happening in this thread is really stepping over some really important strategic operational factors.
- StableAlkyne 3y ago> not really, they're a means of returning money to the shareholders while bypassing taxes on dividends. This is actually a new idea. Prior to a change by the Reagan administration in 1982, they were considered to be an illegal form of market manipulation. Dividends served the purpose of dumping excess funds to shareholders.
- User23 3y agoStock buybacks only pass money to those shareholders whose stock the company buys back. The buyback may raise the overall market price of the stock, but it also might not.
- throw0101b 3y ago> NB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for […] That is one theory of corporate governance: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shareholder_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shareholder_value * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine There are others: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stakeholder_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stakeholder_theory * https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/06/26/the-shareholder-value-myth/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/06/26/the-shareholder-v... * https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/the-shareholders-vs-stakeholders-debate/ https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/the-shareholders-vs-stak...
- danbruc 3y agoNB that "returning money to the shareholders" is ultimately what companies are for [...] This could not be further from the truth. Companies - and actually the entire economy - only exists for one purpose, to satisfy the needs of the people, to efficiently produce good and service that people need or desire. Profits are just means to the end, a control signal to steer the economy. Not that they are not important, but they are not why we have companies.
- miga 3y agoStock buybacks return money to the investors.