8 ms·
Andy Bechtolsheim charged with insider trading
- hi 3y ago> "Bechtolsheim has agreed to pay a civil penalty of $923,740 for earning slightly more than half that for his illegal trades, and has also agreed to be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for five years. Forbes lists Bechtolsheim's net worth at somewhere north of $16 billion. The SEC fine is less than 0.006 percent of his holdings."
- ChadNauseam 3y agoI think the purpose of the fine is to disincentivize the behavior, not to sting necessarily. And to properly disincentivize the behavior it just has to make the behavior have negative expected value.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoA fine of 2X profit is only negative expected value if the chance of getting caught is at least 50%. I'm very confident that the chance of getting caught is far less than 50%.
- freeopinion 3y agoSo you're saying that for a VC, where a common approach is to invest $1 million each in 100 different startups and if just two of them turn into $50 million then you break even, a fine like this is already factored into the game? I wonder what the ROI difference is between the two gambles. 100 $1 million dollar bets returns $120 million? 20 $100000 insider trades returns $5 million - $1 million fines? A 20% return is pretty good. But if it takes 2-3 years per startup, it's not as good. And it ties up $100 million. A $2 million investment that pays out $4 million within a year is much more spectacular. Edit: I am not accusing anybody of having made 20 insider trades. I am just musing about potential business models.
- not2b 3y agoIn some businesses, yes, fines are just considered part of the cost of doing business.
- kortilla 3y agoWhy are you confident of that?
- hluska 3y agoOr twice the illegal earnings? I’m having some trouble parsing that quote.
- auntienomen 3y agoThe fine seems reasonable. He disgorges the profits, and then gets fined twice what he earned and banned from serving on boards (worth far more than $1m over 5 years). Big question for me is why was he doing crimes for such low stakes. It's like seeing a faang engineer rob a 7-11.
- LastTrain 3y agoShould we go with a similar approach for shoplifting? Give back the merch and pay a fine + no criminal charges?
- zabzonk 3y agoah, no. that's a working-class crime.
- gspencley 3y agoTo be fair, the punishment for shoplifting is often a slap on the wrist. I say this as someone who had a troubled youth and was caught shoplifting as a teenager. I got banned from the premises and no criminal charges even though the police did get involved. If I had been an adult it undoubtedly would have been a tad harsher but unless the theft amounts to many thousands of dollars I don't think prison time is ever on the table. Even then I'd be surprised. We're not talking about grand theft auto, we're talking about shoplifting. So it's usually misdemeanour. If the merchandise is retrieved then it is returned to the store and the store can sue the guilty party recover to damages if it's worth it. So I'm not really sure what kind of point you're trying to make. I think it's about inequality. I'm just not really sure how you get there by using shoplifting as your example.
- LastTrain 3y agoHey I think we both agree children should not be thrown in jail for shoplifting, or for insider trading. If you shoplift anything of significance you might be looking at least a night in jail, but more importantly a criminal record. If you shoplift over the threshold of grand larceny you will absolutely be spending a bit of time in jail and will have a criminal record. These are virtually non-existent outcomes for insider trading, even though people "guilty" of insider trading are also thieves. Guilty in quotes because WTF knows, they are rarely criminally prosecuted. So yeah, my point is generally about equality, but I was responding specifically to the casual "yeah that seems right" attitude about it.
- fourseventy 3y agoAs a billionaire, why commit insider trading for a few hundred grand in profit?
- bcrosby95 3y agoBecause they're trying to get the high score.
- datavirtue 3y agoThis. Do not underestimate the power of bordem to ruin lives. When people get bored enough rationality fades quickly.
- isodev 3y agoApparently it's only a problem if you get caught. How else is one supposed to become a "billionaire".
- WalterBright 3y ago> How else is one supposed to become a "billionaire". Invest everything you have into a company that put batteries into a kit car.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zabzonk 3y agothe greedy can never have enough
- ActionHank 3y agoNeed to get all that money so one day when they grow up they can buy twitter.
- arcticbull 3y ago
- danw1979 3y agoAndy is acused of buying “options in Acacia using the accounts of a close relative and associate.” Is it possible he passed on information to these other individuals, and lent them the money to make the trades, but he wasn’t intending on profiting himself ? And he’s taking the rap because, yes he’s actually guilty of crimes. I admit this is a generous and perhaps far fetched reading of the situation, but it’s bizarre that he’d risk the wrath of the SEC for a tiny gain in his individual fortunes.
- burutthrow1234 3y agoTipping is still illegal if you know the recipient intends to trade. The person who asked him for advice trusted him with material non-public information, if he shares it and it gets traded on he's liable either way. To be clear the person who asked for advice was not tipping because they had a reasonable expectation that he would obey securities law and not trade based on the information. They were asking for actual business advice.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoOfficial release: https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2024-40 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2024-40
- zokier 3y agoI'm sure SEC has done their homework and knows what they are doing, but to me this is not that clear-cut case. Bechtolsheim heard a rumour that Acacia had gotten offer and traded based on that. But my reading is that to him it was just a rumour, he didn't know for certain that the deal was happening or what the terms of the deal were. Of course as a senior executive he should have known better, but still to me this is not the most heinous crime and closer to just a lapse of judgement.
- not2b 3y agoRead it again. He didn't hear a "rumor". He got it direct from a manager involved in the acquisition. Nothing in business is certain, but he knew that the acquisition was highly likely. Then he used the account of a relative (doesn't say he tipped off the relative, says he used the account), to hide his involvement most likely. If the SEC didn't have a strong case he wouldn't have settled so quickly.
- rKarpinski 3y ago> If the SEC didn't have a strong case he wouldn't have settled so quickly. No one wants to fight the federal government wether they are guilty or not. "Forbes lists Bechtolsheim's net worth at somewhere north of $16 billion. The SEC fine is less than 0.006 percent of his holdings." I'd settle immediately too. 900k fine or 400k illicit gains means nothing if you are worth 16B.
- kirubakaran 3y ago"I'd settle immediately too. 900k fine or 400k illicit gains means nothing if you are worth 16B." > [Andy] has also agreed to be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for five years Do you think that means nothing?
- StefanBatory 3y agoFor five years that feels like nothing major, in fact. He can still use his connections and return after that time, not there but somewhere for sure.
- mgdev 3y agoReading the actual case document, it's hard to chalk this up to anything but gross incompetence. Dude gets off the phone after learning the information, and immediately calls the brokerage to write puts that expire 11 days later (strike 1). He nails the strike price (keeping below 70; strike 2), and when the brokerage calls later he openly admits on the call that he traded on a nonpublic rumor (strike 3). Absolutely zero subterfuge. He either has a blatant disregard for the law, or is an extremely high-functioning idiot, or both.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blackhawkC17 3y agoThis case seems weird...if he's guilty of what the SEC accuses him of, then it's also a clear-cut criminal case the Department of Justice can pursue. That the DOJ didn't file charges makes it seem like the SEC's case is weak.
- electriclove 3y agoOr he just knows the right people so just gets an effective slap on the wrist.
- dekhn 3y agoI don't really have any comments about the insider trading (other than whyyyyyy?) but I'll never forget Andy driving up in a ferarri at the old SUN executive briefing center (now part of the Facebook's HQ) in 2007 and giving us a presentation on the Sun filesystem hardware they had just released (Sun Fire) and he was really, really keen on telling us just how many power you could stuff into a single rack (like, kilowatts power, as well as CPU heft). He was absolutely thrilled to geek out on the speeds and feeds and we also gave the ZFS author Mike Shapiro a bunch of crap about ZFS merging the logically distinct layers of storage (volume and FS management) while also strongly suspecting that ZFS's model would end up replacing Veritas or whatever it was people used in those days.
- jgtrosh 3y agoSaw Andy at one conf, I confirm he was wayy into minutiae. Geekiest presentation technical in a supposedly not-too-technical panel. But, not related to the insider trading.
- vundercind 3y ago> ZFS merging the logically distinct layers of storage (volume and FS management) This really weirded me out at first, but now feels so right.
- doubled112 3y agoOnce you use ZFS it is hard to go back to anything else because of this.
- roygbiv2 3y agoEverytime I log into my esxi host I wish the storage used zfs. I know proxmox does and I'll probably head that way eventually.
- doubled112 3y agoI use Proxmox at home because it has ZFS and built in backups. That was enough of a selling point for me. ESXi and VSphere not having backups built in feels like classic "create the problem, sell the solution" to me.
- 1024core 3y ago> Forbes lists Bechtolsheim's net worth at somewhere north of $16 billion. https://images.app.goo.gl/voCX3ST3yPCcnSrAA https://images.app.goo.gl/voCX3ST3yPCcnSrAA
- bithavoc 3y agoI don’t get why they need more money.
- e40 3y agoYeah, that was my first thought. I didn't imagine he had that much, though, and it makes it even more of a head scratcher.
- tombert 3y agoI think I get it now. I did a reasonably good job at timing Nvidia stock. I bought three shares in February of last year, and it's more than tripled since then. Initially I was really happy to have bought when I did, but almost as quickly I started thinking "damn, if I had bought ten shares..." or "if I had bought an option contract instead..." as if me making two grand wasn't objectively a great thing. It's not rational, but I think it must just be instinct to always want "more", no matter how silly it becomes. It seems like the first thing people want when they have a billion dollars is a second billion dollars.
- toyg 3y agoThis is particularly true for financial matters, where everything is just a number; and particularly true for someone whose lifestyle won't be materially impacted by outcomes. It's just a game.
- bastardoperator 3y agoGambling has been known to be addictive.
- tombert 3y ago
- exabrial 3y agoHonestly I could care less what a few rich guys do when the get tips over golf games, as ultimately doesn't really affect me. Couple of light fines for the amount profited seems reasonable. However, the people that need to be jailed are in congress and public policy makers using their positions to enrich themselves. Pelosi has an astounding ability to absolutely nail her really really deep options picks. https://www.reddit.com/r/unusual_whales/comments/l42l9w/nancy_pelosi_and_tsla/ https://www.reddit.com/r/unusual_whales/comments/l42l9w/nanc...
- colechristensen 3y agoInsider trading takes a lot out of the pockets of literally everybody else, there’s barely any punishment when you get caught, and you’re really quite unlikely to get caught at all. It is a problem you should care about.
- arcticbull 3y agoYep, it takes money out of the pocket of whoever's on the other end of that options trade.
- TuringNYC 3y agoIt also manipulates the stock underlyer, which the average person owns, either directly or via retirement plans.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoManipulates it to make it more accurate and predictable?
- colechristensen 3y agoNot more accurate and predictable to public information, which is what a public stock value is supposed to represent.
- nextworddev 3y agoUnrelated - does crypto even have SEC enforced insider trading rules?
- tombert 3y agoNot quite insider trading, but John McAfee was charged with pump and dumping schemes with cryptocurrency. He killed himself before he was convicted, but there appears to be at least some kind of enforcement.
- miohtama 3y agoIt is debated and debatable whether CFTC, SEC or neither has authority. However insider trade is crime regardless, and and a criminal investigation can be done by police. See: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-coinbase-insider-sentenced-first-ever-cryptocurrency-insider-trading-case https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-coinbase-insider...
- the_panopticon 3y agoAt least it was just a fine and he avoided having to visit “Club Fed” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ImClone_stock_trading_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ImClone_stock_trading_case
- tombert 3y agoYou know, if you're going to insider trade, I really think it's a bad idea to buy options. If he had just bought shares, he might have some plausible deniability to say that "I really believed in the company and I wanted to invest in it". It might still alert the authorities, but I feel it's less likely and I don't think they'd necessarily have enough to charge him. With options, it is decidedly not an investment, just a gamble. Gambling is way easier if you are able to cheat.
- gimmeThaBeet 3y agoAt this point it borders on cliche, but he broke at least like 4 of Matt Levine's (Not Legal Advice) Insider Trading Laws: - Don't do it - Don't do it by buying short-dated out-of-the-money call options on merger targets. - Don't email or text about it. - Don't do it in your [mother's] account.
- tombert 3y agoI hadn't heard of those, but that's brilliant. The second one in particular just seems so obvious to me. Options are a case where you either "win or you lose everything", and even more you have to "win by a certain time". Options are kind of fun to gamble with, I've done it once, but the advantage of vanilla shares is that you can wait as long as you need to to "win". It doesn't provoke nearly as many red flags.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoYes, lower leverage means fewer red flags... but more leverage means more money ;)
- tlogan 3y agoIt’s important to note that when large option trades aren’t part of a hedging strategy, they almost certainly attract scrutiny from the SEC.
- TuringNYC 3y ago
- jiveturkey 3y ago> Bechtolsheim has agreed to pay a civil penalty of $923,740 for earning slightly more than half that for his illegal trades, and has also agreed to be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for five years. sadly, no deterrent effect here the fine is adequate. but he should have a done a year at Club Fed and a lifetime ban on public boards.
- Osiris 3y agoWhy do people that have more money than they can spend in a lifetime engage in such high risk activities to acquire even more money that they also cannot spend in a lifetime? It seems like it's more about the emotional connection to "winning", having more than others? What's the risk/reward tradeoff look like here? It looks heavily skewed toward the risk side of the equation.
- chihuahua 3y agoYes, I do not understand this mindset: "I have $16 billion dollars, and I'm going to do something risky/illegal so I can have $16.0005 billion dollars"
- missedthecue 3y agoSample bias too. A lot of poor people would insider trade if they 1. had brokerage accounts and capital 2. had material non-disclosed information coming across their desk. Turns out only moneyed people are likely to have the combination, and we only see the ones that chose to act on it in the news, even if 99% wouldn't.
- eggy 3y agoI wish the SEC would clean house of all the congress members and senators, Democrat and Republican, around 75 to 97 at last count, who had bought or sold stock or bonds, or other financial assets related to their congressional work. It's always the corporate boogeyman is always target number one in America. Pelosi and her ilk, including her husband, should have to live by the same laws as the people they supposedly represent. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/13/us/politics/congress-members-stock-trading-list.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/13/us/politics/c...
- tompetry 3y agoIf he's earning just 5% a year on that $16B net worth, that's about ~$2.2m per day. Yet he used this info to gain $500k?
- AS37 3y agoAs long as this took him less than 90 minutes it would be a higher hourly rate of income. Not to mention that doing this would not reduce his other earnings. Or maybe he did it for the thrill.
- WalterBright 3y agoI once saw a documentary on teenagers' coordination before, during, and after their growth spurt. They were able to show that during their growth spurt, they were uncoordinated and awkward. The uncoordination came from errors in thinking the body was smaller than it was. It seems to take a while for the brain to adjust to their larger size. If one's wealth goes up quickly by orders of magnitude, I'd expect it takes time to reframe one's thinking to match.
- az226 3y agoYeah it doesn’t add up.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- electriclove 3y agoDon't people go to jail for insider trading? Why did that not happen here?
- sgt 3y agoYou can't put Andy Bechtolsheim in jail. The guy is a legend!
- tptacek 3y agoWelp, there's the answer to the question I asked 6 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37601847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37601847
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- arcastroe 3y agoI've always wondered where the line is drawn for insider trading. What is material non-public Information? Say you find easily calculable mathematical solutions that break the security of crypto and you dump all your coins because you know they'll be worthless once you publish your research/algorithm. Is that insider trading? Or would you be in the clear because you derived your algorithm from already public information that everyone else already had too? Does the time scale matter? If you solve, dump, wait a few years, then publish, is it no longer insider trading?
- zharknado 3y agoIANAL but that doesn’t sound like insider trading to me. That’s more like activist short-selling à la Hindenburg Research. This is assuming you don’t have ties to the organization that issues the token, if one exists.
- maxlybbert 3y agoIn the US, insider trading requires material nonpublic information, but it officially also requires that somebody break a fiduciary duty to the company involved. So, in your hypothetical, the person breaking cryptography algorithms knows something nobody else does (i.e., isn’t public), and that secret is definitely material. But the researcher didn’t get that information through a breach of fiduciary duty, so it’s legal to trade.
- pests 3y agoI wanted to reply to something @eastdakota said to you in that comment chain: > If you do a ton of work to launch satellites to fly over Walmart parking lots and then model the correlation of how full they are to what the company’s next earnings will be: that seems like you worked hard and earned an edge you can trade on without getting in trouble. > [..] if you made it your business to ride the Acela every day between Greenwich and NYC, bought special hearing aides that let you better eavesdrop on conversations, and made significant profits trading on the information then you’d be more likely to be successfully prosecuted. Aren't those both the same? > Feels like anyone has a theoretically equal opportunity to do the same work you did and get the same trading edge. Feels the same here too. Just some musings while reading that old thread. (all quoted comments @eastdakota)
- gnicholas 3y ago> Bechtolsheim "immediately" acquired Acacia option contracts when learning of the pending purchase by Cisco, which earned him $415,726 in profit when markets opened and Acacia shares rose 35 percent on news of the purchase. Seems like a relatively small amount of money for a billionaire to risk jail for.
- fsckboy 3y agothe crime is "trading on inside (non public) information". Insiders are actually allowed to trade, that's what happens when employees sell shares. "insider trading" is regulated in various ways, but Bechtolsheim was not an insider in this case.