4 ms·
> If it's unpaid traffic tickets, then I do think it makes sense to suspend the license No, it still doesn't. Modern societies have a kink for adding requirem
by marcosdumay 3y ago
> If it's unpaid traffic tickets, then I do think it makes sense to suspend the license
No, it still doesn't. Modern societies have a kink for adding requirements for basic survival, but at the same time decreeing those same things "privileges, not rights" so that they can deny them with minimum oversight.
On places people have no other ways to move around, this is a human rights violation. Nothing less. (And yes, people should have options, that doesn't mean you can just say that out loud and take people's rights away. You have to do something if you want to use that claim.)
- SECProto 3y agoPeople get tickets for violating motor vehicle laws. These laws exist to protect all users of the road. If you can't follow the rules, you don't get to operate a vehicle that can easily kill other users. The only issue with license suspensions as a result of unpaid tickets, is that you can pay the ticket to buy your way out - an issue most places rectify by having a points system, so that drivers can't violate the law repeatedly just because they can pay. > On places people have no other ways to move around, this is a human rights violation. Nothing less. By this argument, driving tests should be illegal too. Or age limits on licensing. Or fees to renew plates or permits. If there's a "human rights violation", it's letting motorists known to repeatedly violate the law (putting my life in danger) continue to operate a vehicle.
- ben0x539 3y agoYou shoulda decided whether this is a "economic sanction" infraction or a "we can't let you drive for safety reason" infraction. If you decided it's the former, you shouldn't get to change it to the latter just because it turns out the driver can't pay.
- SECProto 3y agoYes, I covered that in my comment about points systems (they exist everywhere I've lived - get too many tickets and your license is suspended, regardless of if you pay it off). Unless you mean that there should be no fee to renew your license, no nandatory insurance, no gas taxes, etc?
- michaelmrose 3y agoThings like not having a license plate on the front wouldn't normally come with points no matter how many times you were caught.
- SECProto 3y agoYes, that is an issue and should be corrected. Every monetary penalty should also contribute towards license revocation.
- michaelmrose 3y agoThat is quit frankly silly penaltes should just be scaled based on income
- davkan 3y agoThe fine is intended to curb the poor behavior. If they can’t (or won’t) pay then it seems reasonable to proceed to a different punishment to curb that behavior. I’m all for pegging fines to income to reduce the likelyhood that fines cause serious harm to violators, beyond the desired effect. But at some point it may not be possible to do anything but take a license.
- Scoundreller 3y ago> The fine is intended to curb the poor’s behavior. Fixed that for you.
- davkan 3y ago> I’m all for pegging fines to income
- Terr_ 3y ago¿Por Qué No Los Dos? You're setting up a false-dichotomy where the only valid reaction to unsafe-driving is waiting for a major disaster and then taking their license away entirely. Compare to: "OSHA shouldn't be fining MegaCo for lacking metal safety-railings around the ManMangler 4000 unit, because if it was reeeealy about safety they'd shut down the entire factory until it was safe. Fines prove they aren't serious about safety and have some other dubious motive." Fines are a totally valid way to change behavior and deter the unsafe behavior from happening again in the future. They are both adjustable and reversible, unlike imprisonment or eye-for-an-eye. While I would love to see fines scaled by wealth to avoid disproportionately severe (or ineffective) effects, that's not the same as rejecting fines entirely.
- pierat 3y agoWow, talk about taking a comment to an absurd point. If OSHA was serious about safety, they would shut the offending machine down until remedied. If there's enough problems in a facility, then they shut the whole place down. But therein lies the problem - then the employees don't get paid. The "fine" should go to the employees for endangerment and payment of lack of work. But no, fines.
- SECProto 3y ago> Wow, talk about taking a comment to an absurd point. I think the one that "took a comment to an absurd point" is the one about driving being a human right.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThe safety of other people does not hinge on money, other than liability insurance. If you want to correct someone's bad or even intentionally irresponsible driving, there is nothing about the problem that implies money. In fact it's if anything, the opposite. Making the penalty for a ticket be money just means I can just pay the ticket like paying for the priviledge to ignore that rule. In fact I do this wrt to the front plate on one of my cars where it would be ugly. I don't want a plate there, but this state's rules say otherwise, but I get to just have what I want anyway. Once in a while, I get a ticket for it. I just pay it and continue not having a license plate on the front of that car. It's been over 20 years and several cars. How nice for me that the penalty for this important rule is just money!
- Terr_ 3y ago> I can just pay No, you've mis-identified the problem as "the punishment is only a single sum of money." What actually makes it ineffective is "it's a fixed sum which some people (like me) are rich enough to casually ignore". Compounded by "infrequent enforcement." The truth of this is easy to illustrate: Simply imagine that instead of a ~$100 fine every ~5 years, the missing plate was detected every week and the fine compounded by +5% each time until it reached 10% of your wages. It's technically still "just money"... but would your behavior be the same?
- Brian_K_White 3y agoJust raises the bar. It's still a penalty that doesn't relate to the misdeed, and hurts different people differently. The problem is we use money as a form of pain, because that is one facet of it, money can sure hurt, but taking money from one person is like taking away a finger or a leg, decimating their ability to function at all things in life, and then everyone punishes that person even more, now for not being a productive contributing member of society. Meanwhile another person can supply "fingers" all day and not be even inconvenienced let alone handicapped. But taking money as a form of pain appeals to assholes, and funds their organizations, win-win!
- 3y ago
- Terr_ 3y agoBy that logic, do you also believe everyone should be allowed to drive without any liability insurance? Just like speeding tickets, it is also a cost imposed around behavior that is considered to be endangering other people. At what point does a hypothetical/rare edge case of "trapped unable to travel anywhere unless I drive my own vehicle so I need to be allowed to do it badly" overwhelm the the commonplace issue of bad-driving causing harm?
- ambichook 3y agopeople keep talking about drivers being uninsured but i have to ask, is that not part of what car registration is supposed to cover? where i'm from there's mandatory third party insurance which is bundled in with your rego, its impossible to drive a car that is registered unless you have insurance, is that not the case in the US? what do your rego fees go to?
- Terr_ 3y agoDetails might vary between different US states, but to generalize from my own experience, proof of liability insurance is never needed for periodic registration. It's asked for when: 1. You're in an actual accident. 2. You get pulled over by the police for some reason. 3. Before driving away a recently purchased car from a dealership and the car has a lien on it. It's a requirement of the bank that lent you the money using the car itself as collateral. If you purchased it fully, they don't care. Fees for yearly car registration/renewals go towards transportation projects in the state/county/city. TLDR: Americans can get away with driving uninsured on public roads for quite a while before getting caught.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Details might vary between different US states, but to generalize from my own experience, proof of liability insurance is never needed for periodic registration. In California, it is required within 30 days of initial registration, and within 45 when the previous insurance was cancelled (insurers are required to share this information with DMV.) This is mandatory liability insurance (which you can substitute with a bond, instead); if you are buying a car on credit, the lender will generally require it be covered immediately, and that the coverage include sufficient coverage for the loss of the vehicle, not just legally required liability coverage, because the lender wants to be sure they are paid no matter what happens to the car.
- tekla 3y agoSo what happens if a driver is known to be unsafe, (DUI, whatever)? Allow them to keep driving no matter what?
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI agree with you that taking away someone's driving privileges in many cases can be impinging on their human right to travel freely. And you are kinda right that generally human rights should not be violated. But one human right can always be violated to preserve another human right [1]. In this case, a person X's human right to travel freely is balanced by everyone else's human right to travel freely (or particularly the subright to be able to travel without risk of bodily harm). The latter is why we have licenses for driving. If someone does not respect other people's human rights then their human right can be taken away. I would however, oppose, taking away someone's license for lesser reasons than other people's human rights. For instance, I would support poor people not having to pay license fees. [1] In fact, a huge part of law is how we balance each human right against other human rights.
- Scoundreller 3y ago> but at the same time decreeing those same things "privileges, not rights" so that they can deny them with minimum oversight. Can we apply the same “it’s a privilege, not a right” logic to big corporate licenses, like spectrum?