6 ms·
All sounds great. I'm quite curious what their objection to Apple's browser choice screen is though: > The Commission is concerned that Apple's measures, inclu
by IshKebab 3y ago
All sounds great. I'm quite curious what their objection to Apple's browser choice screen is though:
> The Commission is concerned that Apple's measures, including the design of the web browser choice screen, may be preventing users from truly exercising their choice of services within the Apple ecosystem, in contravention of Article 6(3) of the DMA.
Looks relatively reasonable to me:
https://preview.redd.it/ios-17-4-db1-new-default-browser-pop-up-available-now-v0-eon2agynhmfc1.jpeg?width=1080&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=eefa61cc6b9f9af89b016dade4c1515fb1763784 https://preview.redd.it/ios-17-4-db1-new-default-browser-pop...
Is it because they always put Safari at the top and then try to randomise in a mix of browsers most people won't have heard of?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 3y agoWhen you look at the list you have to be concerned about the state of the browser market. Chromium is going to dominate desktop and mobile and entrench pro-advertising measures eg. browser fingerprinting, long term first party cookies etc for years to come. Meta and Google must be thrilled. Of course it makes a mockery of GDPR and other privacy measures EU has been pushing.
- shuckles 3y agoBut users are demanding choice in browsers, and they are picking the least private, most pro-advertising one en masse! What’s its biggest benefit? It offers a suite of native-replacement, in-the-standards-process-but-not-finalized APIs so developers can write slow, bloated applications once and run them everywhere! This is what users want!
- st3fan 3y agoIt is only good for Google. Not for the web.
- hu3 3y agoThanks for sharing. I'm curious about the sorting of that list. From the image (mirror: https://i.imgur.com/pjo78lS.png https://i.imgur.com/pjo78lS.png): Safari Vivaldi Opera Web@Work Edge Onion Browser Seznam.cz Brave Firefox? (cut in half) Is it Safari first then randomized names? It doesn't look alphabetical order to me. Chrome doesn't even show up, Firefox is almost hidden.
- microtherion 3y agoI don't know how the list is generated. But as others have pointed out, there seems to be established precedent that hardcoding Safari first would not be compliant. And alphabetizing would create bad incentives (Calling dibs on "Aardvark" as a browser name, BTW). The problem I see with randomization is that with all the browsers that are skins on Chromium nowadays, this would be likely to steer users into a Chromium based browser.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Macha 3y ago> Calling dibs on "Aardvark" as a browser name, BTW It's ok, I'm naming mine after Aachen
- throwaway-blaze 3y agoAABrowser is mine.
- a1369209993 3y agoDibs on !0A Aangstrom.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoGreen and eco, go for it.
- deleted 3y ago
- oaiey 3y agoThis screen has already so much dark history by Microsoft on Windows.
- jsnell 3y agoHaving Safari hardcoded to the first position in the list certainly won't fly. The Windows browser choice ballot and the Android search engine choice screens eventually settled on a two tier with the five most popular options in a random order at the top, and a second tier was shown after them also in a random order. But the other problem is the "not now" button, because it's what the large majority of users will click. Does it by any chance have the effect that Safari is kept as the default, and the question is never asked again? The Windows browser choice ballot and the Android search engine choice screens forced the user to make a choice.
- bilbo0s 3y agoIsn't having the 5 top choices always be the same kind of the same violation? It entrenches the big guys.
- zarathustreal 3y agoThe idea that any of this is or ever was a problem to the end user is laughable honestly, this is political theater. End users want to be able to browse the web, that’s the point of a web browser. Most of them are based on the same underlying technology and implementations. Throwing around political power to force OS teams to spend engineering resources on the illusion of choice is actively harmful for basically zero benefit to the end user.
- Hasu 3y agoIt's not a problem for the end user to be unable to pick which browser they want to use? Speak for yourself, I would consider being forced into a single browser choice a huge problem, to the point that I will not buy a device that does it.
- Ajedi32 3y agoThe fact that alternate browser engines were banned on iOS was indeed a huge problem, but I think the current legislation goes too far. As the GP said, many users won't care. I think trying to force them to care by presenting a randomized list of a dozen different options at setup time is misguided. I don't see the issue with merely having a default so long as there's an easy way to change it and Apple isn't applying any rules or restrictions to competing browsers that they don't apply to their own.
- lycos 3y agoInteresting! When I got presented this list Safari wasn't even "above the fold" which surprised me, so I assumed it was randomised. When I clicked Safari it also opened an App Store sheet for Safari, which I thought was weird but probably done to keep it consistent with the other options (more like "see more details" before making the choice definitive/installing)
- ergonaught 3y ago“Select your birthdate from this randomized list of possible dates.” You wouldn’t. Cannot imagine why this is being downvoted. Presenting users with a randomized list is a dark pattern that discourages use of the associated feature.
- shuckles 3y agoRandomization is required by the regulation. Another instance of what a smart person wants out of a feature and what the EU wants being very different things.
- dotnet00 3y agoIt's being downvoted because randomizing something that is by its nature chronological is very obviously different from randomizing the order of something where you want to explicitly avoid giving the impression that one takes priority over another.
- sloowm 3y agoIt might be that Apple enforces the use of webkit.
- krzyk 3y agoAre those real browsers or just reskins of Safaris inner web components?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Vinnl 3y agoCriticism I have seen: - Safari will always still be installed and have its icon on the first page of your home screen by default, even if you choose another browser. - Choosing another browser doesn't actually select it - it brings you to their app store page, where you still have to tap the (relatively tiny) install button. - If you already have other browsers installed that are not included in the choice screen (e.g. Firefox Nightly, I believe), then you're still forced to install/pick a different browser.
- concinds 3y agoMore: - you can't uninstall Safari. The DMA clearly requires Apple to allow uninstalling it. - the Share Sheet for in-app webview privileges Safari (Safari-specific "Add to Reading List", "Add Bookmark" at the top) regardless of default browser. - apps with in-app webviews can roll out a custom engine, but otherwise it uses WebKit regardless of default browser. It should obviously use the webview facility provided by the default browser, if it offers one. - confusing to change defaults. There's no central "Default Apps" screen in Settings. You have to go in the Settings app, scroll way down to a given browser, and then you can change the default. So the default browser setting is weirdly treated as an app-specific setting rather than a system setting. - If Safari is not the default, you can change your default browser within "Settings.app >> Safari". If Safari is the default, you can't change your default browser there at all. Whereas the default browser selection menu will always be shown in the Settings.app submenu of third-party browsers.
- throwaway-blaze 3y agoThe default browser has no technical ability in iOS (currently) to supply an in-app component to replace WKWebView or SFSafariViewController, and frankly as an app developer I shudder at the idea of having to test our use of in-app browsers against every browser, every release.
- layer8 3y agoI think that in-app browsers that are solely used to render the app, and not separately accessible web pages, should be considered an implementation detail of the app. That also means that apps should be free to bring their own browser engine for that purpose (à la Electron). However, where apps provide access to web sites that are also accessible outside the app, the user should be able to configure the browser for that (possibly different from the system default). That should pose no particular problem for app developers, as those external web sites need to work under different browsers anyway.
- fassssst 3y agoChrome is the most popular browser and Apple’s largest competitor and isn’t on the first page?