18 ms·
Mozilla Drops Onerep After CEO Admits to Running People-Search Networks
- Socnic 3y ago[flagged]
- nullindividual 3y agoReading the article may be helpful for you as the answer is clearly outlined in the first sentence. Here, I'll copy and paste it for you: > The nonprofit organization that supports the Firefox web browser said today it is winding down its new partnership with Onerep, an identity protection service recently bundled with Firefox that offers to remove users from hundreds of people-search sites.
- Socnic 3y agoSorry and thanks. Mozilla must have done their homework on that one, lol. Now I wonder if the new CEO made that deal in the first place. What a joke.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoKrebs broke this story last week. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/ceo-of-data-privacy-company-onerep-com-founded-dozens-of-people-search-firms/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/ceo-of-data-privacy-comp... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39709089 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39709089 Seems more like Mozilla had someone graciously hand them their finished homework they didn't even know was due. I appreciate their intentions but this is probably embarrassing for someone working there.
- seanhunter 3y agoOnerep, which is/was a "reputation service" that ostensibly searched to see whether you were listed by various people search services and removed you if you were. As explained in the article, Mozilla were planning to bundle their service along with automatic searches of haveIbeenpwned and presumably other stuff. Turns out the CEO of onerep was also running some of the people search services (ie creating the problem and then purporting to sell the solution).
- cbsmith 3y agoI get the concerns about conflict of interest, but I can get behind the CEO's point that their expertise in the space helps them to build better defenses.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoExcept the CEO still operates Nuwber. It's hard to believe he's learned from his mistake if he's still actively helming said mistake.
- Drakim 3y agoYeah, I'm 100% for forgiving and giving people a second chance. It's no different than a black hat hacker becoming a security researcher. But there is a clear conflict of interest if he is still actively engaging in the dubious behavior.
- cbsmith 3y agoI think there's a distinction between criminal activity and the usual conflict of interest.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cbsmith 3y agoI wasn't saying he has learned from his mistake. I'm just saying he no doubt has expertise.
- abhorrence 3y agoCouldn’t you make a similar argument about protection rackets? Their experience shaking down places for money helps them build better defenses against it, right?
- cbsmith 3y ago
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoI think Mozilla's heart was in the right place here, but pretty disappointing that they didn't vet their partner more thoroughly than what some GMU grad students were able to uncover. Also makes me wonder what other shady connections fellow services might have, waiting to be uncovered. Looking at you, popular podcast sponsor, DeleteMe!
- slvrspoon 3y agoCo-founder DeleteMe here. Been building and delivering privacy tools and chatting on HN for 15 years. Happy to answer questions but please easy on unfounded accusations :)
- IntToDouble 3y agoPuzzling they chose to partner with Onerep when Kanary was part of Mozilla's incubator and is just a fundamentally stellar service.
- ckozlowski 3y agoCan you share more?
- IntToDouble 3y agoIn terms of the incubator, looks like it was replaced with Mozilla Ventures: https://builders.mozilla.community/ https://builders.mozilla.community/ https://builders.mozilla.community/old/alumni.html https://builders.mozilla.community/old/alumni.html With respect to Kanary, I have my entire family the platform and it's drastically reduced the amount of garbage (figurative) that comes through our door. Needed help with something non-standard the CEO personally took care of things while learning more about our specific use case.
- griffinkelly 3y agoSecond the recommendation for Kanary. Formerly had a lot of inbound spam, has seriously cut it.
- syngrog66 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SpaceManNabs 3y agoI thought people were being ridiculous when they were angry at mozilla for bundling with Pocket. After this, maybe the slope was more slippery than I thought.
- wolverine876 3y agoHow would this situation indicate a slippery slope of decision-making? Mozilla didn't know about OneRep's CEO's history; nobody did until Krebs uncovered it.
- criddell 3y agoIt goes back many years before Kreb’s wrote about it. Optery has a nice write up of the situation here: https://www.optery.com/optery-statement-following-investigative-report-on-onerep-by-krebs-on-security/ https://www.optery.com/optery-statement-following-investigat...
- krebsonsecurity 3y agoTheir earlier statement said they were aware of the CEO's history but were assured that part of his life was behind him. From that statement on March 15: “We were aware of the past affiliations with the entities named in the article and were assured they had ended prior to our work together,” the statement reads. “We’re now looking into this further. We will always put the privacy and security of our customers first and will provide updates as needed.” https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/ceo-of-data-privacy-company-onerep-com-founded-dozens-of-people-search-firms/#more-66752 https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/ceo-of-data-privacy-comp...
- neilv 3y agoI suspect that vetting this kind of partnership needs someone who is ferociously knowledgeable, principled, and skeptical. Not someone who's mainly looking at it from a business development or career angle. Now the aftermath could use a fighter, looking for how they could legally disassemble the entire racket. Not only because it's arguably on-mission, but more importantly because Mozilla has a reputation to redeem on this now. (For example, no matter how that party has squeaked by wrt consumers, maybe there's a new angle in their dealings with Mozilla, such as a different kind of fraud. And Mozilla is much more able to pursue the matter than most individuals would be.)
- myself248 3y agoThis. If they can go after the guy for fraudulent misrepresentation or something, I'd be on the sidelines cheering every jab, maybe contributing if there's a legal "attack the stalker companies" fund.
- stefan_ 3y agoPursue what? God knows they should pursue building a browser. It’s a simple concept, it doesn’t need ChatGPT-set-to-dramatic words.
- Nextgrid 3y agoBuilding a browser is harder than posting puff pieces about privacy. Mozilla has sadly strayed away from being a browser company into being some PR company that happens to make minor changes to a browser once in a blue moon.
- neilv 3y agoAgreed, a lot of the behavior looks like that. But if we ask why we want them to build a browser, would you agree that privacy+security+freedom+democracy online are the main reasons we have? If so, then would you say much of their current messaging has the right idea? Would you also say that we've seen genuine progress (and also regression resistance) in that direction with the browser? Personally, I'd say yes to all those. Two things that I don't understand are what one executive was getting paid, and some of their decisions during that executive's tenure, for a long time. One guess is that some people were letting it be run like a tech company, and furthermore a tech company coasting along in some ways without being very effective. And that would have to be multiple people, since everyone answers to someone. If that guess were accurate, then not only do you have to ask the watchers why that was allowed to happen, and figure out how to fix that, but you also have to look for cascading effects within the organization from that having gone on.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoTalk about hedging your bets!
- micromacrofoot 3y agoI used OneRep for a few years and it did what it advertised, but that's certainly shady as hell and I'm glad I stopped using their service. Are there any more trustworthy alternatives? data brokers are scum.
- tjames7000 3y agoI co-founded easyoptouts.com a few years ago because all of the existing options were way too expensive. We focus on publicly-accessible people-search sites. Our customers are happy, and you can check out our privacy policy to see how we handle data.
- beyondd 3y agoFor an alternative, take a look at Optery (YC W22). We've been flagging the situation at OneRep for years and put a statement out following the Krebs article (link below). We launched to the public as a Show HN in 2021 and as a Launch HN in 2022. Full disclosure, I'm one of the Optery founders. https://www.optery.com/optery-statement-following-investigative-report-on-onerep-by-krebs-on-security/ https://www.optery.com/optery-statement-following-investigat...
- michael9423 3y agoWhat do you think about Kanary?
- beyondd 3y agoObviously I'm biased so I think Optery is better, but here are two un-biased reviews written by the lead analyst for security at PCMag.com: https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/optery https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/optery https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/the-kanary https://www.pcmag.com/reviews/the-kanary Here's another well-researched and unbiased review: https://blog.infostruction.com/2023/08/12/privacy-powerhouses-optery-kanary-deleteme-and-onerep/ https://blog.infostruction.com/2023/08/12/privacy-powerhouse...
- eaurouge 3y ago
- ds 3y agoAll the existing databroker remover tools are flawed because they make use of manual labor to remove you from sites, primarily done by people in third world countries. We @ https://redact.dev https://redact.dev are working on a pure software mechanism for doing these optouts directly from your own device. We already have full mass deletions for over 40 social media and utilitys.
- tjames7000 3y agoeasyoptouts.com, which I work on, doesn't use manual labor - everything is automated! It's definitely important to avoid giving more people access to the data. edit: and as a result of automation, our prices are also way lower than most similar services
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoIn other words, would you describe your site as the Gillette razor attachment mechanism of online data deletion?
- mgiampapa 3y agoThis explains some trends where posts are being edited on Reddit with nonsense then deleted. Personally, I think this kind of behavior makes the web poorer as a knowledge base. Yes you have a right to do it with your own content, but doing it at scale makes the internet a less useful tool and it makes me a bit sad since the scrapers will already have the data anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Brian_K_White 3y agoHopefully it just makes sites remove the ability to edit or delete things once they've been published. Especially forums where things have been referenced by other things. As much as I routinely fine-tune and fix up a comment after initially writing, I will happily go back to the old days before such ability became common, in trade for the sanity of references that don't disappear or change meaning after the fact. The typos don't hurt as much as the swiss cheese and schitzo conversations.
- johnea 3y agoI definetely wouldn't want Mozilla to support people-search organizations, but I also wonder if that's really happening here. I have to believe the expertise gained in people-sesarch would be exactly the expertise one needs to remove people from the roles used by those organizations. The real question is whether or not there is data brokerage out of Onerep. This seems like a triumph of optics over substance...
- toyg 3y agoIt's not just experience, the guy is still invested in a company that does the Bad Stuff. He's playing both angles.
- citizenpaul 3y agoI've had to make the hard acceptance that privacy is absolutely irrevocably dead. Anyone with power or money can now find out not only anything about you but likely even more than you know or realize about yourself. Who has time to do a through documented introspection of every aspect of their own life and actions regularly. Along with every possible connection that this also leads to? No one. Unless there is massive senate/house/pres unification on absolutely crushing the endless disgusting behavior of spying on people to diminish them and enrich yourself is made illegal WITH CONSEQUENCES. Nothing will change. This will never happen because the US gov is the both the biggest customer and purveyor of these services. Mozilla is basically the last place that even gives lip service to privacy and they are in bed with this guy. That is how hopeless the situation is.
- jart 3y ago> Anyone with power or money Data brokers post a lot of your PII on the clear web for free. It doesn't cost anything to find out someone's names, the address of every place they've lived, the names of their family members, etc.
- citizenpaul 3y agoThat is also true. Though that info is less reliable much of the time. I search myself every now and then and most of those sites are just plain wrong about me.
- reilly3000 3y agoWhat a win for internet journalism.
- is_true 3y agoWow, this kind of companies should be nuked. I cannot wait the EU to notice this problem.
- petesergeant 3y agoAt least as scary are the companies (company?) who allow you to do a facial recognition search over the entire crawlable web.
- is_true 3y agoYep.
- Sephr 3y agoI would only trust a tool for sending mass opt-out requests to every company that I've interacted with if it was free and open source. Even with good intentions, commerce becomes yet another tracking instrument.
- jart 3y agoNot possible. Open source code doesn't have limited power of attorney. Data brokers would also read its code and thwart whatever logic it uses to fill out forms.
- Sephr 3y agoYou have power of attorney for yourself. Open source tools can run on your own systems and represent you.
- Zuiii 3y agoExactly. What we really need is a public, open list of all tracker companies that anyone can contribute to (like adblock lists). What we do with that list is up to us and our governments.
- jart 3y agoIf the open source software interacts with the data brokers as you, then how would it do that without giving up even more of your personal information? Services like Optery also lose the ability to remove your information from a data broker if you have a direct account with them. So you better hope that open source maintainer doesn't lose interest after a while, since if they do, you'll be permanently doomed to logging into hundreds of broker sites each year to refresh your opt-out.
- Sephr 3y ago> how would it do that without giving up even more of your personal information Open source doesn't mean hosted by a third party. You would run the software on your own computer.
- codehalo 3y agoSvd Cfg DC as c
- hayst4ck 3y agoIf company A creates a problem that company B is paid to solve, then company B benefits when company A is able to make the problem bigger. Therefore Company A and company B both have a vested interest in the problem continuing to be problematic. Both are in a symbiotic relationship that allows them to both extract a profit while providing no net benefit to society. This is rent-seeking (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking). Rent-seeking is an economic drag and ethically indefensible. Regulation is how this problem gets solved and it's the only way it gets solved.
- croemer 3y agoProtection racket...
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThere was an article on HN recently about government agencies (but also applied to private companies) that are setup to solve problem X and often evolve to, not necessarily causing it, but making it harder to solve.
- legacynl 3y agoBut that blog post was wrong an ill informed.
- Brananarchy 3y agoIf it's the one I'm thinking of: the title was about government, but all of the examples in the article were private firms with profit motives. The author implied that government must work the same way as industry, but that's a huge assumption. The article had no examples of public agencies perpetuating the problems they set out to solve.
- MacsHeadroom 3y agoWere these private firms funded by the government?
- 3y ago
- Zuiii 3y agoIn the sprite of ad-block lists, I suggest we create an open list of all known companies that people can easily add to. Information about these shady-ass orgs should be divorced from enforcement against them.
- 7734128 3y agoCalled it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39280369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39280369
- legacynl 3y agoYeah but you provided no evidence, no reasoning, or anything else that might have elevated your comment above a mere guess. If you throw enough spaghetti at the wall, some will stick.
- noqc 3y ago@dang, why did this get delisted?