5 ms·
Is it really bait and switch if almost zero users are affected by the change? (except philosophically)
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Is it really bait and switch if almost zero users are affected by the change? (except philosophically)
- RyEgswuCsn 3y agoIt's salami bait and switch.
- repeekad 3y agoIt’s bait and switch to community developers who contributed free labor to a for profit company for what is now either a fork or a more restrictive license
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoThis shows a fundamental misunderstanding of how open source licenses work. I am completely sick of this take. It’s intellectually dishonest, or extremely ignorant.
- repeekad 3y agoNever attribute to malice that which can be explained by stupidity Reading the other comments the switch does make more sense, if you want to freeload off of the work redis has done for the project then you’ll have to join whatever community remains on the forked version, and anyone who cares about this kind of stuff should probably understand what’s permissible in the previous license, which clearly includes it being switched out like this
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nicolas_t 3y agoWhat percentage of commits were made by community developers?
- otterz 3y agoWhy should that matter? I'm sure the percentage would be way smaller if this was the license used initially.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wasmitnetzen 3y agoAll clients will still be Open Source and a lot were initially written by the community as far as I'm aware, so they're actually still asking for free labor there.
- rsstack 3y agoThe company Redis only adopted the Redis project (and changed its name) a few years ago. Redis started as a community project and was run that way for almost a decade.
- bbotond 3y agoAbout 75% afaik.
- kjksf 3y agoThe version they contributed to is still available under the same permissive license that was in effect when they were contributing the code. The license change only affects the code written in the future and now people can change their mind about contributing. That seems fair to me. Maybe you think that morally the license should never change but there is no clause in the license to prevent changing the license, so that would not be a reasonable expectation.
- happymellon 3y agoThey contributed free labour under a licence that says that anyone can do anything they want, including offering it under a different licence.
- gramakri2 3y agoWhy do you think almost zero users are affected by this change? If a business was built on hosting redis or providing managed redis, that company is now inviable, no? note: I am not disagreeing with the license change, just asking why you think nobody is affected.
- vineyardmike 3y agoIf a company is built on hosting redis - and is now unviable, they should be pretty incentivized to fork the previous version and maintain it themselves. Isn’t that the power of open source? I doubt there were many (if any) non-AWS businesses that were affected. To earn a profit you need to continue to work, I don’t feel bad when a corporation is negatively affected after their leeching or rent seeking is disturbed. Even if it was previously acceptable behavior.
- tejasbaldev 3y agoThat's exactly the point. Companies providing managed services on top of popular opensource projects are not contributing to the respective OSS project at the scale at which they've been benefitting commercially from these projects.
- jen20 3y agoAiven is a good example - I don’t know if they contribute to Redis, but they appear to offer a managed service based upon it.
- 3y ago
- fweimer 3y agoAnyone installing a distribution package will be impacted eventually. https://qa.debian.org/popcon.php?package=redis https://qa.debian.org/popcon.php?package=redis