3 ms·
Those are not realistic scenarios. While many people do receive some sort of housing assistance from parents, the number who inherit a home with no mortgage is
by nradov 3y ago
Those are not realistic scenarios. While many people do receive some sort of housing assistance from parents, the number who inherit a home with no mortgage is tiny. And in the rare cases that it does happen, the heirs tend to be close to retirement age themselves.
Likewise, almost no one has unrealized annual capital gains on their primary residence which are anywhere near their regular income. US median household income is $75K and median single family house price is $387K. Virtually no one is seeing 19% annual price appreciation on their home.
- carlosjobim 3y agoSo what happens is that people are paying on their mortgages and then they have a windfall from the inheritance and can get out of debt if they want to, or not if they think their current mortgage is a good deal. In the past decades, what I've seen is that a debt-free house is normal inheritance when it comes to real estate. But maybe not for the future. Yes, as you say the heirs are usually not young themselves, but maybe with 10-15 years left of working before retirement. And as retirement ages get pushed up for today's young to 70 years and further, this means these people are staying at the workplace and will be staying there. > Likewise, almost no one has unrealized annual capital gains on their primary residence which are anywhere near their regular income. Then we live in different worlds. With people and places I know it is normal to have a higher return in real estate appreciation than from labour. Mainly because taxes take away most of your salary, while real estate appreciation is tax free. People have been talking about "real estate careers" for a long time now. Meaning that they're borrowing the maximum amount possible and getting more and more expensive homes as their main career, while their day job is just a way to make minimum mortgage payments and qualify for more expensive mortgages.
- nradov 3y agoYes, we live in different worlds. To be more specific, you live in a fantasy world. The circumstances you describe are so rare as to be irrelevant to any macroeconomic analysis. It is possible to make a fortune through leveraged real estate investments on multiple properties. But doing that with just a single primary residence is virtually impossible regardless of tax effects or financial engineering.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> Virtually no one is seeing 19% annual price appreciation on their home. What? Issaquah Washington, 88.2% this year, from $625K in 2019 to $1.36M this year. Kirkland Washington, 56% this year, from $700K in 2019 to $1.4M this year. Inglewood Washington, 43% this year, from $676K in 2019 to $1.3M this year. just from a few moments of quick digging and looking in one census tract.
- nradov 3y agoThose numbers don't represent value increases on individual properties. The mix of sales has shifted. And cherry picking data from a handful of locations is meaningless and off topic for the macroeconomic issue under discussion here.
- lumost 3y agoThis occurs far more often than you expect. When I first started in Tech 15 years ago in a major urban environment - I was extremely surprised to see young professionals living in housing that I viewed as utterly unaffordable. For a time I assumed that I must have a missunderstanding of the labor market, and that the designer/engineer/assistant at company X must make substantially more than I did as a software engineer at company Y. Over time, I noticed this was not atypical. Many professionals in dense urban areas use familial connections to purchase a home when they are ~22-25 through one of several arrangements ranging from. "Buy me the house now, and I'll buy you out when I can afford a mortgage", or "Give me a downpayment now, and I'll cover mortgage", or "provide downpayment, you hold onto equity, I cover mortgage and we split marginal equity appreciation". I had a very silly conversation at a FAANG team event where the principal engineer and I were discussing finally being able to purchase a home after working for 10+ years. A junior engineer chimed in earnestly asking why we didn't have a rich uncle lend us the downpayment money :shrug: In 2024, housing in urban areas is still appreciating at 8% per year in desirable markets - on a 1 MM house, this is easily more than the average income for the city.