11 ms·
People hate the idea of car-free cities until they live in one
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- asdajksah2123 3y agoPeople's aversion to change, even when the change is for something that is objectively better in every way, is really really annoying.
- mrshadowgoose 3y ago"Objectively better" according to my personal subjective values and beliefs. "Aversion to change" that I would like to force onto others.
- geodel 3y agoObviously people are the problem. That's why cities which are people free are the best cities.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoIt's a lot of work and money to convert a NA city to a car free one. It's probably impossible TBH. My city has the best public transit system in NA but still I can't imagine it be car free. It's going to literally kill people.
- b-side 3y agoI don't know where this sentiment comes from, you think NA cities didn't exist before the Ford Model-T? Many of these cities existed and worked even without everyone having a private horse/carriage they just had trolleys.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoI'm fine if you want to go back to the 19th century. I don't.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> you think NA cities didn't exist before the Ford Model-T? They existed but they were incredibly shitty, literally.
- epolanski 3y agoPeople mock the soviet way of building neighborhoods but it was miles better. Instead of extensive pointless suburbs where everybody has his house, they built huge 8/10 story buildings. The buildings were surrounded by parks, benches, places for kids to play. People aggregated a lot and everything was relatively close (building taller means you can build a lot closer to downtown). I have lived 6 months in Ohio, Columbus, and I can't but say you live much worse. One thing I noticed is that lack of good public transport is one of the major causes for neighborhoods to become ghettos and poor. You're a guy that lives some 15/20 miles off Columbus and there's a job in the city? Well, if you're that poor that you don't have a car you can't work there either. And nowadays you need at least 2/3k year for insurance alone. This lack of public transport is one of the major reasons why so many areas around big cities become slowly poor and ruined and people have tougher chances to start making a living. In 2024 with everybody owning a car Polish neighborhoods have transformed. Cars fill every single space. Kids are constrained to small often remote areas. Benches get removed to get more parking spaces. People don't aggregate anymore, there's a much smaller sense of a community. In many ways, the progress I have seen in Poland made the country just unhappier and lonelier. I would even bluntly say that my parents and my parents parents had it much better. They would party and dance every week, always on some trip or vacation. Sure, the party would have people bringing their own glasses, salami and something to drink, but people really enjoyed the times. Cars are just one of the major factors that transformed our cities for worse.
- osigurdson 3y agoWhy did people buy cars if they didn't need them?
- scotty79 3y agoStatus symbol, larger shopping (cargo bikes weren't ever a thing due to lack of bike paths), vacation, business.
- osigurdson 3y agoEverything other than status symbol seems legitimate
- ctxc 3y agoIt seems to me that your "objectively better in every way" is subjective. If it were objectively better in every way, I'd give my car up obviously. But there's the _small_ matter of major inconvenience with places inaccessible by public transport, erratic public transport, bad last-mile solutions with private transportation waiting to fleece us for all we're worth, leaving me questioning my life choices when the last mile costs 10x what 90% of the journey cost me in public transport, not to mention the overall experience of having to switch between multiple modes of transport each way. Climate change...yes, but I'm not altruistic enough to go through this everyday.
- throwbadubadu 3y ago> But there's the _small_ matter of major inconvenience with places inaccessible by public transport, erratic public transport, bad last-mile solutions with private transportation waiting to fleece us for all we're worth, Where do you live? I see places becoming inaccessible by car due to missing parking places and traffic jams and just love to take a bike / scooter / public transport (which could be much better even if we'd put more focus there, and would also help the poorer people) or by feet. The very few occasions I need a car could be handled by car sharing or delivery services.. I regret having bought one (:
- markus_zhang 3y agoI think it depends on, as you suggested, the location one lives. I think it is safe to say that if one has a family and live in the North America, there are few places, if there is any, that you can live a comfortable life without cars. I live in a city with advanced public transit system (of course, comparing to other NA apparently, not other continents). Theoretically, I can go around without much driving. But there are always moments that driving a car helps a lot. One example is going to Costco. A second example is to lay one's feet 50+ kms away from home. A third one is to go to a clinic whenever I would like. Cars enable flexibility. I think it's pretty hard to convince people to drop it, UNLESS the culture completely changes. Culture change would bring economical and political changes as well -- but that's a multi-decade process. This is why, may I say, that a car free policy is practically impossible for most, if not every NA city.
- JoshTriplett 3y agoPeople's tendency to describe a change they like as "objectively better" for everyone is really really annoying.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> People's aversion to change... When cars first became affordable in the US in the 1910's, due to mass production and financing, they were very quickly adopted in massive numbers. So I don't think it is fair to say that people have an aversion to change. Are you sure the annoyance isn't that they just don't want the changes you want them to want?
- andsoitis 3y agohttps://archive.is/2024.03.20-044756/https://www.wired.com/story/car-free-cities-opposition/ https://archive.is/2024.03.20-044756/https://www.wired.com/s...
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI know I hate driving in Pro-Car Cities.
- kijin 3y agoAnd that's the irony of cars. The more people love to drive, the less lovely the drive becomes.
- CharlieDigital 3y agoI was back in Taiwan last year after an extended absence. It's pretty amazing how easy it is to get around with a combination of the mass rapid transit (MRT) system and high speed rail (HSR). When I was last there, you still needed to take a bus or taxi from TPE to the city center. Now right from TPE airport, you can be in either Taipei city center in 30 minutes (MRT) or on the other end of the island in short order (HSR). Which is kind of fun because the southern end of the island has a totally different vibe. Within Taipei, you can get to where you need to using the MRT and walk (fun because there's so many interesting nooks and back alleys anyways) or use bike rentals. There's also abundant buses as well connecting from the MRT stations. Taichung has a single MRT line that connects east to west right off of the HSR line. Kaohsiung has a few MRT lines and surface light rail that connect the major attractions. All of it quite cheap to get around, incredibly clean and well maintained, and just all around made it much more enjoyable wandering the city. The only time we felt the need for a car was visiting the more remote north/east coasts and only because we wanted to save time versus waiting for the slower trains that run those routes. Whenever I land in SFO, I wonder who's bright idea it was to not have an easy connector to CalTrain at Milbrae (or I'm doing something wrong -- I feel like I don't fully understand the right way to get to Milbrae from SFO). Then on weekends, there's barely any service so if you land on a Sunday for a business trip, you'll waste so much time waiting for the train. Indeed, it is jarring when we returned to the US.
- ecshafer 3y agoThe way Taiwan, Hong Kong, Japan, and South Korea fund trains is a big difference with the US (though ironically is similar to how the US used to fund trains in the 1800s). The companies (usually in some kind of private-public partnership from my understanding) who build and run the trains in East Asia typically get land around the train stop to develop into malls, shops, apartments, etc. These sales and rents then fund the train lines. This incentive to keep everything nice on the trains and around the stops to help the other sides funding is important I think.
- stetrain 3y agoThis is sort of the model that Brightline (Fortress Investment) is using. They are spending money on the train service in hopes of increasing the values of their real estate investments.
- nothercastle 3y agoCar free cities are great but you have to have a lot of problems solved for them to work . You need high density, lots of public services from libraries to pools all these need to be close. Public transport has to be safe so you have to actually enforce laws and arrest vagrants. Car free needs a lot of things to go right where car full cities can be pretty disfunctional
- willcipriano 3y ago"Do you like car free cities?" "Oh yes!" "Cool, Get out then." https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=925wmb-4Yr4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=925wmb-4Yr4
- pjerem 3y agoThat’s not true. 2/3 of Parisians don’t even own a car and Paris is a very average city when it comes safety. Density is also pretty low for one of the biggest European cities. And it’s just a known example, there are a lot of cities way smaller than Paris where it’s easy to live car free.
- nothercastle 3y agoThe French work week is 7 hours so they get an extra hour to fuck around with public transportation a day. So that might help quite a bit. Still I’d be curious how upper middle class folks with kids survive without cars. Maybe that 33% covers the affluent folks with kids tho.
- jddj 3y agoAre you saying here that you think traveling by metro in Paris takes an hour longer than driving would?
- nothercastle 3y agoYeah if you have to change transit method it adds a lot of extra time. So metro+ bus adds at least half an hour each way
- Havoc 3y agoPlus car travel is dead time since you’re forced to pay attention to the road at least somewhat. I’d rather have a longer journey that is hands free
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI see what you're saying, but long road trips are not that way for me. I am easily lost in my own boredom and thoughts on the road. All my good ideas seem to emerge then. (Perhaps, unfortunately, to a lesser degree I "multitask" when city driving as well.)
- hawski 3y agoI find looking through a window of an S-Bahn to be a superior thought generator.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoI have never been able to make use of the longer transit time on a bus when commuting, because they are always standing room only or shoulder to shoulder with barely enough room to hold a phone
- tejohnso 3y agoNot even sure how you'd start off hating the idea. Less noise, less pollution, shorter commute, cheaper infrastructure, more green, more walking, improved health...I mean...just off the top of my head I'm thinking of tons of advantages. I can't think of a single disadvantage. The only reason I need a car is because the city / neighbourhood is configured around the expectation that everyone has a car.
- Kalium 3y agoIf your entire life is based around your car, it's your most important and powerful symbol of autonomy, wealth, and personal liberty. The prospect of someone in government deciding one day that the life you live is no longer welcome and your touchstone is evil is incredibly jarring, at the very least. If you also live in an area where you cannot imagine how you could possibly live without using your car frequently, the prospect of a car-free city sounds a lot like you're being hung out to dry by people who don't care what happens to you. These reactions are a combination of poor messaging by those affecting change and a failure of a imagination by the car-bound. The first, at least, is avoidable.
- jraph 3y ago> it's your most important and powerful symbol of autonomy, wealth, and personal liberty Cars as virtue signaling? I'm not quite sympathetic to this case. This person's liberty is causing harm to everyone else and I don't care for their symbol of wealth. I'd like to say, "get off my lawn", were the lawn is actually my city. My liberty of not being polluted by noise and fine particles, and of easily and safely moving on as a pedestrian or biker, and of my earth's climate not being harmed is important as well. People could have their cars outside the city, reachable with good public transport, so it's not even like they couldn't have their symbol of wealth somewhere. It would also make sense that people don't have their personal cars in cities. We could have car sharing systems like we have for city bikes, which work great. Most cars sleep most of the times, this doesn't make quite sense. We could have fewer cars achieving the same usefulness with better a organization less focused on the individuals. Maybe a solution is that the car stops being seen as a symbol of wealth and liberty, and more like a liability / necessary evil, because this also doesn't make sense. Wanting to look wealthy is already a cursed concept. Why should anyone care that anyone looks wealthy? This is not what's important in life. What you think and what you do matters much more. Of course, this is a very good point, and this needs to be addressed. To be clear, I'm not arguing with you, I'm agreeing.
- dgellow 3y agoI have to live in a bubble then. I never heard people express hate of care free cities, but I hear the opposite all the time, people complaining how horrible car-centric cities are. But I’m a Western European who lived in cities all my life, don’t have a driving license, and has zero interest in cars ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bombcar 3y agoNever move to the US - you’ll find yourself behind the wheel of an F350 with triple gun racks before you know it and not even realize it ;)
- vladms 3y agoI would have expected the article to give some clear pool/metric/statistics about "people hate the idea ... ". There are indeed loud people and big interest groups that oppose car free cities, but I am not sure about "people" in general. Sure, you need means of transport and to be able to live, and you can't change things over night, but if you would ask people "would you prefer to have a supermarket 5 minutes away or one 20 kilometers away" I doubt anybody would say "no I want only things far to be forced to use a car".
- Ekaros 3y agoHow about one 5 minutes away where I can go with my car? Which I feel like these people are trying to stop...
- eropple 3y agoIf your single car is rivalrous to several other people's ability to live and work in the urban core, yes, that's a pretty good reason to discourage the car. Massachusetts has park-and-ride, and it's pretty great!
- lucumo 3y ago> but if you would ask people "would you prefer to have a supermarket 5 minutes away or one 20 kilometers away" I doubt anybody would say "no I want only things far to be forced to use a car". For most people it's not about the supermarket. Those are a dime a dozen and all the same. It's easy to provide those in sufficient amounts everywhere. Now try it with jobs. Not any job, but your job. Is it possible to have your job be 5 minutes from your home. How about in 5 years when your job is underpaid or unfulfilling? Is your next job also 5 minutes away? Or do you now have to move? And 5 years after that, when you're laid off? I find that loads of people start out enjoying the car-free experience. And then they get a job in the next town. And/or they get kids, so commute-time takes away from kids-time. Life becomes too busy to spend the extra 30 minutes commuting per day that public transport would cost. Between the trade-off bad job, no time, and car/public transport, the car quickly becomes the best solution. Even if you don't like driving.
- DrBazza 3y agoThe open paragraph regarding London is very much 'of now'. Air pollution in London in the 2000s has been the lowest it has been in over a century. The Great Smog of 1952 killed perhaps 10,000 people over a very short period. And the article doesn't make clear the ONS-estimated 36,000 a year deaths is across the entire UK not just London. It just feels like the modern journalism's trend for hyperbole and over exaggeration. That's not to say that pollution shouldn't be reduced as much as possible. It's not so bad that you don't see tens of thousands of runners and cyclists in and around London every single day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London
- ghaff 3y agoThe title is a bit hyperbolic. It's mostly about reducing the number of cars in the urban core, improving public transit, and making the infrastructure more pedestrian and bike-friendly. Which, while easier said than done, is a lot more achievable than being literally car-free--especially in more than a fairly small area.
- em1sar 3y ago[dead]
- lenerdenator 3y agoWhat're you talking about? It's awesome driving 25 miles each way to and from work in this city with more highway miles per capita than any other city in the country. sits down at desk; starts breathing exercises to calm the anxiety from the Mad Max-esque driving on the interstates
- lucumo 3y agoThere's probably also a bit of selection bias going on. People who prefer car usage will be less likely to go live in places where car ownership is difficult. The longer a city is "car-free" the more of that bias will accumulate. There's really not much in the article to suggest that the same people are first against and later in favour. It shouldn't be surprising that some people prefer to live in car-free places, but that's all you can conclude without doing polling the same people before and after a change to car-freeness.
- jddj 3y agoN of 1 here, but I've lived extensively in both environments. Love cars, got my licence on my birthday the first day I could apply. That said, I'm noticeably happier and healthier whenever I don't need to own one. My quality of life is higher when living somewhere everything is accessible by walking and by efficient public transport.
- lucumo 3y agoWell, I'm an N of 1 too :-) I'm lucky to live in a place that gives me plenty of options. And I have a tech workers idea of tenure, in that I change jobs every few years. So I've done them all. Cycling to work is the best. When the sun shines and birds are singing. It's a miserable experience when it's pouring rain and the headwind is strong. Public transport is kind of nice for reading, or catching up on a bit of sleep. But it takes forever, and you're dependent on its schedule. And the walk on both ends is only fun in spring and summer. Umbrella's make it less bad than cycling when it rains, but it isn't great. Driving is annoying when the traffic is bad, but it is by far the fastest for everything over a few kilometers. The roof and the AC protect against the worst of the weather. You have full flexibility on when to go. And while a podcast or audiobook isn't as good as a newspaper or ebook, it's not bad either. Also, you can fart in peace. Honestly, the whole "shops are nearby" are such an uninteresting part of the car-free discussion to me. I have to get to work more often than I have to get groceries. And nowadays, I just get them delivered, just like everything else.
- jddj 3y ago
- jmbwell 3y agoAnecdotally, in Houston at least, it does seem true that people come back from travel abroad and talk about walking around, using public transit, and if renting a car, only for drives through the countryside or a particular tour. And then complain about having to resume a tedious commute. It’s almost a cliche, like study abroad students coming home with new affectations. Or, if they went to certain other places, complaining about how terrifying the traffic was, like “you wouldn’t believe these roundabouts, there were no signs, mopeds everywhere, it was lawless! traffic worse than here!” To some maybe the connection is more obvious than to others, but as they say, you can lead the horse to public transportation but you can’t make it vote for people who support allocating resources for it.
- mwagstaff 3y agoAs someone who has worked in London for many years, the difference is amazing. Biking in the city is now enjoyable, and the air quality is (subjectively, even without the data) dramatically better. There was an incredible resistance to the recently introduced ULEZ (Ultra Low Emissions Zone) expansion, but I'm incredibly grateful for the sake of my children, if nothing else, that it has been pushed through.
- djtango 3y agoI'm pretty sure I've shortened my life for having lived in zone 1 for so many years due to air pollution. Cycling around London is also the fastest way for an astounding radius of travel. I can beat uber and the underground for most journeys using a Lime bike.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI remember about 20 years ago I was taking my bicycle on the train, and this involved a transfer through London. You can't take full-size bicycles on the London Underground, so I cycled across London from Kings Cross to Waterloo, and I definitely remember being reasonably terrified the whole way. If that has greatly improved since then, then that's wonderful.
- 946789987649 3y agoThat's a pretty short journey (probably about 15 minutes), but yes it will definitely be a lot better now. I think also part of it comes down to 1. getting used to it, and 2. the time you cycle at. Rush hour, while more hectic, actually is quite a bit easier because you're often going far quicker than any cars.
- grumpy_coder 3y agoThe lack of those smelly poor people also makes for a nicer environment.
- dbuxton 3y agoI'd quibble with the title. Based on my experience in London, most middle-class/white collar workers love car-free living. Most blue-collar workers don't like it. They continue not liking it once it becomes reality. (Although maybe they realize that it's not as bad as they feared). I think this is basically another example of political polarization, combined with employment patterns. White collar workers broadly speaking place a higher value on their time and mostly belong to "tribes" that value their health and environment. Removing cars is great for that as bikes give control over journey times (and in most cases in e.g. London reduce them) while positively impacting the other. Blue collar workers may not be able to do their jobs with just a messenger bag containing a laptop and airpods. Also, their political identity has been dragged further towards the radical-individualism end of the spectrum where collective action on e.g. environment is hard, and trust for bossy health authorities telling them to exercise more is low. The slightly strange side effect is that you end up with an item which is way cheaper (a bike at e.g. school dropoff vs a car) that becomes a signifier of social status. I am sure there are loads of examples of this phenomenon but none spring immediately to mind!
- stetrain 3y agoI don't think most advocates for reduction in car dependency in urban environments think that trades people shouldn't have vehicles to carry tools and materials around in.
- rufus_foreman 3y agoThe title of the article mentions car-free cities. I don't interpret that to mean that a Ford F-150 is fine, do you?
- ghaff 3y agoThe title may imply this but the article really doesn't. Go to an actual "car-less" area of a city like Brussels and there are delivery vehicles at least in the morning, work vehicles of various kinds, street sweepers, etc. Even at the relatively extreme end of pedestrianized malls, there are still a fair number of vehicles around.
- darthrupert 3y agoI would pay an additional 10% tax if it would be earmarked to public transportation.
- tfrutuoso 3y agoMore anti-car drivel. Sure there must be a balance but car-free isn't the way and won't be a thing. They had to scrap the Streatham Wells LTN after a three-mile bus journeys took two hours - and not everyone can walk three miles, let alone the entire route.
- notarant124e348 3y agoSo, living in one of those cities (AMS) I have a few takes. I'm not ranting, just expressing my frustration: 1. Cars exists because they are more comfortable. I don't care that biking should better, it's not when it rains sideways, it's cold and windy. Biking sucks. I would pay top money to not be in a bike, not be outside getting drenched, and usually do ubering everywhere to the dismay of Dutch people, 2. Cities designed around biking are uber tied to public transport. I'm a lefty, I think that's great, but it's not, because the first time there are cuts to public service you find yourself living in the middle of nowhere and can only bike, because cars are too expensive to own. This happened in the Netherlands with NS slashing intercity trips, and increasing prices. I had colleagues now that now to live several hours per day in a packed commuter train. I can't see how that's better. 3. Any type of DIY activity becomes a nightmare. Want to rent move a couch? Good luck! Back home, you could load the thing on a nice Volvo and be happy. 4. Electric bikes are effectively not policed because it's the new thing we need to incentivize, and it becomes immediately super dangerous. I know people that had serious injuries because of crashes. Cars are inherently safer, especially modern SUV like volvos or tesla, 5. Accessibility becomes a nightmare, especially if you are in a wheelchair, your commute times are going to skyrocket, All this "bikes are amazing" just reeks of some bad degrowth ideology. There is a duality between cars are bad and hydrocarbons are bad. Except they are literally the engine of growth, and for some reasons we decided that we should phase out hydrocarbons and replace them with some silly not reliable energy alternative (solar, wind). I can't see how this ends in a different way than how it went in Europe with our energy policy. Cities are meant to grow and drive the economy, not to be Disneyland parks. If I want to bike I can go to Italy on a seaside town, I don't need to bike 356 days a year.
- Ekaros 3y ago> 4. Electric bikes are effectively not policed because it's the new thing we need to incentivize, and it becomes immediately super dangerous. I know people that had serious injuries because of crashes. Cars are inherently safer, especially modern SUV like volvos or tesla, Starting to get interesting in Finland. Not yet bicycles, but scooters with weight over 25kg or speed over 25km/h or 1kw will soon require insurance... And likely any bike with specs over those will also be a moped and thus require both insurance and registration... I see no reason why those sort of limitations won't come more prevevalent.
- scarygliders 3y agoI don't hate the idea of living in car-free cities. It's cities I hate the idea of living in. Which is why I choose not to live in cities. And is why I need a car. Fuck cities, I hate 'em.
- exe34 3y agoYou don't need a car, you want a car. Plenty of people live without cars. Even outside cities.
- slothtrop 3y agoIt's far more cumbersome outside of cities because of distance/time and unreliable alternate transportation. It might as well not even be an option, if one decides to go without then they are consciously absorbing the inconvenience because it's an important ideological issue to them.
- exe34 3y agoNo they're choosing to live somewhere.
- slothtrop 3y agoNot even sure what you're trying to say here. People tend to live where they work, and that can be rural areas. If you're saying they should be faulted for that choice, it doesn't make much sense. Few people move there in the first place, mostly young people leave to go to the city.
- Ekaros 3y agoThere is plenty of things we do not need. Like phones, computers, tvs, books, more than bare variety of food and drinks. More than couple of cubic meters of living space. Choosing what clothes or footwear to wear... All things we could do without...
- scarygliders 3y ago
- snapplebobapple 3y agoI dont want a car free city, buti desperately want a car de-emphasized city where for most trips the car is an option but its not the beat option vs walking/biking/transit with this idelly achieved by making those other methods of trnsit dramatically better not by making cars dramatically worse. Kind of like what they have done in the netherlands
- 65 3y agoThis describes Chicago.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoMore like it describes Amsterdam. Chicago is not ideal for many other reasons (taxes, useless government, crime, terrible weather for substantial parts of the year)
- kijin 3y ago> In the US, between 50 and 60 percent of the downtowns of many cities are dedicated to parking alone. This is the part I find the craziest about American cities. You are using some of the most valuable parcels of real estate in your country as parking lots! Part of the reason seems to be that you guys have too much land anyway, so those parcels aren't that valuable. Because if they really were prime real estate, somebody would have discovered that it's more profitable to move the parking underground and build (apartments|condos|shops|offices) above. If you insist on wasting land on above-ground parking lots, at least put some solar panels or something similarly useful on top.
- enaaem 3y agoPeople will obvious hate the idea of “car-free cities”. Why would you push for the most extremist outcome that doesn’t exist anywhere? Advocate for more realistic goals like less car dependence or pedestrian friendly cities.
- Kindling7257 3y agoThis whole idea is fucking terrifying. Normalizing not having cars i.e. making people dependent on the government from birth. If you didn't understand what Americans were complaining about with gun laws you will soon.
- Mashimo 3y ago> making people dependent on the government from birth. Roads are also mostly build by the Government. A lot of people around the world are born in government build/run hospitals.
- m000 3y agoAren't you missing a "/s"? I hope you are.
- oulipo 3y agoAre you a troll? Nothing better than a city without car, it's exactly the reverse: we have pure freedom (and health)
- NinjaSaves 3y agoA new government comes in and limits your ability to use it. What now? Car-free cities seem nice until they're used as leverage. No cars means massive power for a tiny number of people. Not everyone is a troll when they disagree with you.
- eropple 3y agoWho exactly do you think maintains the roads that cars need to run on? Or are you bombing around your carmaxxing city in a lifted 4Runner all day just in case you gotta Go Off-Road Because The Government Closed The Roads? The whole concept is silly on its face.
- Asraelite 3y agoA government can always take away your driver's license. In practice this happens far, far more often than restricting use of public transport.
- incomingpain 3y agoMost cities in my country are car-free optional. I have multiple bus routes literally in front of my house. I could own a place downtown and go without a car, which im considering. The cities which mandate to be car-free are doing so out of obligation. Mainly due to civil engineering decisions from 500 years ago which have screwed them over. They basically want to go back to horses. So in reality, people hate the idea of car-free cities and choose thusly. There is no 'until they live in one'.
- NinjaSaves 3y agoMy biggest point on car free cities is that it is supported fervently by the people who would gain massive amounts of power over others if nobody had a car. If you're dependent on public transport, it can be taken away from you as leverage.
- toinebeg 3y agoWell if your dependent on oil to make your car run, the people who have the power to block oil distribution have a huge leverage. I don't get your argument, we have a huge dependency on the oil distribution infrastructure. A switch in transportation system is a switch in the type of infrastructure, not a freedom vs control thing.
- bryan_w 3y agoThe difference is incentives. The oil company wants my money whereas public transit is ran on hope and well wishes. Winds shift and policy can change at any time
- toinebeg 3y agoWell not on hope and well wishes, more on planning and political will. As the oil, If your gas station is filled it's not only a thanks you the money you give the oil company but a large infrastructure work and political and geopolitical framework that make it happen.
- nrb 3y agoAs leverage for what? If everyone is using the public transport, wouldn’t “taking it away”, if that were even possible, be a massive self-own for the local and state economy? Also, what about countries using this method with overwhelming success?
- rangestransform 3y agoThe union for the door opener in the middle and glorified AEB at the front of the train has the entire city by the balls See: London tube strikes and NYC subway drivers blocking one person train operation contractually
- marginallen 3y ago[dead]
- alkonaut 3y agoHaving a car free city center sounds like a good idea. It's not a car free city though (that sounds horrible, not to mention impossible). A city needs less dense areas and at some point outside the city center density will be low enough to a) not have public transit at the required frequency and b) be home for the type of places you need a car for (Lumberyard, car wash, ...).
- frereubu 3y agoThe funny thing that's been happening in the UK about Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) is that there's been lots of press about them being unpopular, driven to a large extent by the current Conservative government who seem to be trying to play to their base. And the threats against people who support them mentioned in the article are real. But rather embarassingly for the government, when they did some proper research it turned out that a large majority of people want them, and they don't have nearly as many negative side effects as claimed once they've bedded in: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/mar/08/low-traffic-neighbourhoods-generally-popular-report-ordered-by-sunak-finds https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/mar/08/low-traffic-...
- gadders 3y agoThe fines for going down the wrong street without a permit were used by the local councils as a new revenue source.
- jdlyga 3y agoItaly strikes the right balance by having car-free zones for pedestrian areas. Other cities could really use this approach. In Times Square in New York, you have a major road running right through the main pedestrian area, leading to a bit of conflict. And it's usually Ubers and other vehicles who could've easily gone a different way.
- PodgieTar 3y agoI live in a nice little city in the Netherlands, Leiden. I am from the U.K. I cannot believe people would want to live any other way than with accessible bike paths and walkable streets. It is mad.
- NinjaSaves 3y agoYou either think mandatory car-free cities are a terrifyingly dystopian idea, or you've never experienced human culture outside of dense urban areas.
- eropple 3y agoThis is weirdly projective and I'm happy to be an obvious counterpoint to it. I grew up in the middle of nowhere. I moved to a city and didn't have a car for years. It was great and I wish I could've sustained it. As-is, I have a car (the absolute cheapest thing I could find, for Home Depot runs during home renovation) but drive it once a week and commute to the city center by public transit because New England lets you do that, even if it's not as convenient as I'd like.
- apexalpha 3y agoThese (American) articles on urbanism and what not always make it seems much more insane than it is. I live in the Netherlands, a country usually lauded for it's bicycles and public transport and what not. And let me tell you: We still drive cars. All the time. Even in Amsterdam, our biggest city, 4/10 families still owns their personal car. In the Netherlands as a whole it's 9.5/10 or so. It's about THE MIX of options.
- dijit 3y agoyeah, it needs to be reframed as "car-dependency" because that's the major issue, everyone is forced into driving because there's no viable options. If every move you make requires a car, the traffic situation is always deleterious.
- enaaem 3y agoIt’s important to emphasise that the additional transport options made driving BETTER.
- pxtail 3y ago> These (American) articles on urbanism and what not always make it seems much more insane than it is. Wholeheartedly agree, and what is also funny that usually it is described from POV of citizen living in: tier one city center with mild weather whole year round and relatively flat topography/terrain - and at the same time it's written in a way that suggest that it's THE SOLUTION absolutely applicable everywhere else.
- piva00 3y agoThe solution applicable almost everywhere with some dozens of thousands of population is multimodal. Public transportation supported by infrastructure for cycling and cars relegated to their place in a multimodal system: inconvenient for shorter/regular trips, accessible for when it's needed. Stockholm doesn't have mild weather all year long, it's not flat, and still people will use public transportation or a bike. Oslo is definitely not flat, definitely not mild year round and even there people take public transportation, bike, etc.
- porompompero 3y agoImagine that a toxic substance like asphalt would be in every street of the world... oooops! That's real!
- fooblat 3y agoAs an American who moved to Berlin 15 years ago, I love not needing a car. We like to visit Paris, Amsterdam, London, Florence, and more cities multiple times a year and we never get a car. Between public transportation and my bicycle, I can get just about anywhere I need to and usually faster than in a car. If I need a car for some unusual errand, which is rare like once a year, I use an app to cheaply rent a car of the needed size for a few hours. Recently had to go to the US for a short trip and I had to rent a car. It felt insane how much time I had to spend in my car just to visit people who all live in the same metro area, due to all the sprawl.
- stackedinserter 3y agoAMA, I lived in a car-free city for 10 years. It's not free of cars (there's plenty of them there), but public transit is good and you can live your life without owning a car. The main requirements: a) you need to be comfortable with living in a small apartment, b) you shouldn't have any interests outside of the city c) stick "one day - one errand" rule. YMMV, but I felt essentially locked inside a big city and hated it.
- op00to 3y agoWhen I was in university, I worked on a study that collected people’s preferences for different types of developments. When you asked them what they wanted, they basically said easy driving and parking. When you showed pictures of different types of development (sprawl, transit oriented development, etc), they overwhelmingly picked the car-free option. People don’t know what they want.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoI lived without a car for a decade (London / other towns in the UK) and then I moved to a place in EU where I need a car but things are pretty close by. I can get a bus but they're not frequent enough to replace cars. Overall the better quality of life (food, weather, access to seaside, real estate affordability, lower cost of living in general) weighs WAY more than having to drive a car or not. It's a nice to have but not "life-changing". The important bit is to have the stores you need nearby so you don't have to drive 30m to get a coffee and 1h to go shopping. That's what wrong with the USA. Most of Europe has towns like this: you still need cars, but everything is close by. Pros: - I can go wherever I want - I can carry a lot more groceries / stuff - I don't stress about timetables anymore - No need to rent a car to do trivial work Cons: - Need to pay for car, insurance, parking - Higher risk of accidents - Risk of fines (speed limits are ridiculous, same for alchol tolerance)
- fennecbutt 3y agoYup, everyone's gotta drive to the supermarket in their 9999999 tonne landtank SUV now. It's so bad in London now, traffic is just becoming all SUVs. I'd love for them to be banned, but consumers want SUVs...so there'll never be a ban. There's not even that much space inside an SUV either!! Back in NZ we actually used utes and other large vehicles for what they're actually meant for.
- pbmonster 3y agoParis just voted to have tripple parking fees for vehicles heavier than 1.6 tons. Maybe this is the way to go.
- _ea1k 3y agoIt is amazing how bad we are at walkable infrastructure in the US. There are housing developments <.5 miles from a grocery store with no sidewalks in between. Why not at least have a path for bikes?
- potac 3y agoJust look at Pontevedra in Spain. 90% pedestrianised city and several years with 0 traffic related deaths. Lovely city!
- throwawa14223 3y agoI'm always amazed how different people are. Living in a high density city made me miserable because there were constantly people around me. On the other hand I love semi-rural low density suburbs (What I can afford) and extreme rural even more. If I saw these policies enacted I would try hard to get out.
- steelframe 3y agoThese days I'm finding myself doing half my trips on a bicycle and half in a car. In my experience one of the biggest barriers to micromobility in America is cultural. Motorists can be aggressive and complacent because their vehicles are big and have airbags, and so long as they aren't impaired they won't be held accountable for harm they cause with their vehicles. Cyclists and pedestrians can act in a way that is entitled and reckless because they know they probably won't be held accountable for their behavior either. Except some of them sometimes forget that the laws of physics are less flexible. A few years ago I was driving my son somewhere, and a cyclist blew through a red light and slammed into the side of my car. Fortunately the only injuries were the ones that the cyclist inflicted on himself through his reckless disregard for the law. Judging how much damage he did to my car, if my son and I had been on our e-bikes instead then I think that guy could have easily killed my kid. Knowing that there are too many cyclists and motorists who behave with complete disregard for the law makes me feel like I really have no choice but to put my child in a big steel cage with airbags and crumple zones if we're going to travel anywhere on American roads. And before you ask, this was not in a big city, so public transportation was not a viable option for us that day. My personal experience seeing peoples' general behavior and attitudes on roads in both Japan and Amsterdam makes me wish we could find a way to adopt some of that culture.
- scoofy 3y agoPeople will always be entitled, but there needn't be dangerous contact. As a lifelong cyclist, the main problem (in my opinion) America faces here is the fact that we have exclusively car-first infrastructure. The American stop sign, to me, is the symbol of how entrenched everything is here. Stop signs make zero sense for any mode of transportation except for cars. A physical, traffic-calming rotary at every intersection, in every neighborhood would be much more sensible, and reduce conflicts. We could add collapsing bollards to create cycling corridors that cyclists actually want to be on, instead of the insane decision we've made to mix our cyclists and vehicles with a single line of paint on some of the busiest roads in the cities we live in. Where all of this runs into a problem is with emergency response vehicles. Because our fire/EMS infrastructure is path-dependent with our transportation infrastructure, they tend to bitch and moan any time physical barriers are put up, or pedestrian malls are introduced. The system is the way it is, and if it changes, they believe it will cause them problems. The Fire Department in SF has been one of the biggest roadblocks to creating safe parallel corridors for cycling infrastructure, blocking bollards, neutering rotaries to the point if ineffectiveness, blocking traffic calming features unless they allow for high-speed fire/EMS vehicles, thus defeating the purpose. If anyone wanted to make a long lasting impact on American society, this is the problem I would focus on solving. I think building emergency response vehicles (specifically fire, and ambulances) that can interact with a traffic calming feature that is impassible to normal vehicles but passable to bicycles and pedestrians (say via high clearance) would do more for saving lives, reducing emissions, and stemming the tide of the American development pattern across the world than almost anything else.
- awful 3y agoWhile this definitely does not compare this experience, it did show this young person the utility; in the early 70s when Disney World opened, we used the trams in Fort Wilderness to get around for a week; shopping and back and forth to the camp store, going to the activities in the day, evening and at night. Just running around. Did this all with and without parents, and I think they were possibly electric at that time as they stopped right outside your campsite at the corner and must have been very quiet, or maybe diesel, just don't recall. We simply learned the schedule, hopped on and then off, and simply had a great time. Like many things Disney, I thought I was looking at the future and was pleased.
- pjmlp 3y agoThe ones that have to actually commute, not so much.
- ghusto 3y agoI know they've spent millions on car reduction schemes, but it's mostly wasted money. If you want people to see cycling as a viable alternative, then make it a viable alternative. I used to live in London, and now live somewhere where I cycle anywhere that's under 15Km — because it's viable (and more enjoyable!). London is not that, and they haven't done anything to make it that. Painting bits of the road doesn't magically give you a "cycle network".
- kkfx 3y agoWell, might be unpopular but... I hate cities, no matter with cars or not: I hate cities because I love efficiency AND evolution. - creating large buildings, so large aqueducts, that normally have to grab water far away, altering MUCH the natural water distribution cycle for a big radius around cities, so large sewers who push much concentrated pollution (recall: without oxygen we die, with too much oxygen we die as well, in nature "a poison" is something at a poisonous concentration) is not a good thing, yes we spare land, but we consume MUCH more, not much less contrary contrary to common belief, which I suspect is the result of interested propaganda; - large cities, large buildings are things we can't quickly evolve. There are too much people, to physically near interests to being able to agree and realize something new, and in a changing world, so a changing society being able to evolve is needed; - large cities often are somewhere because in a far past there was much reasons to have them there, sometimes some reasons are still valid (like local climate, water availability, accessibility, ...) but sometimes are not there anymore and other reasons NOT to be there are much more relevant. Again moving light homes/sheds/compact warehouses it's far easier than moving large complex. Jakarta is the extreme example and the new Nusantara is a good demonstration of the insustainability, similarly "most efficient modern cities" like modern Fordlandia, like Telosa, Arkadag, Prospera, Innopolis, ... are good example of the same: cities are giant factories made to transform citizens into workers, that do not own the factory, do not decide their jobs, that have nothing and mush follow the stream to been able to earn enough to get services, and services costly enough to ensure they keep working at maximum, getting essentially nothing in the end. Trapped in a process they can't really control or direct. Modern cities can ONLY works with mass transit, private cars in such dense are are an unsustainable nightmare, but modern cities are unsustainable and a nightmare themselves. Like money in modern world is a tool to extract values from most, in very few private cleptocratic hands, cities are a tool to force people working and conform to the few who organize them. I like freedom, so I do not like cities. If you try to REALLY be curious in the scientific sense, you'll end up simulating costs, raw materials and so on of a fictional city vs a fictional spread area, NOT like USA suburbs but like European Rivieras (meaning work and residential areas intermixed) and the result is that the spread version (not too much spread, not too dense) is CHEAPER and obviously can evolve better. Oh, yes, a multi-storey NEW building is more efficient than a set of NEW homes. Today. In 50 years you can't upgrade the multi-storey now not so new building while you can upgrade/re-create from the ground small homes. So in the long run the initial energy efficiency drop. The bigger structure demand much more raw materials than many little/lighter ones as well. Similarly trains are more efficient than roads, but demand much more to be build and kept up. Going by air demand a lot more energy to go from A to B, but do not demand an road/rail infra between A and B and so on. In the past we have experimented mainframes, than we understand clusters are better, more resilient, easy to evolve and so on. Sure, they are harder to be made and used efficiently, but that's is. Try, for sure and think about dense city life vs sparse life. Think about how much you spend depending where you live, think about how much packaging you use just to eat/drink downtown vs at your own home, how efficient a small food domestic stock can be respect of buy grocery every days and so on. I've done the math and tried myself having left a big city for mountings (of course, in a not that remote area).
- zephrx1111 3y agoThis is insulting my 30 years life in developing countries. My country was poor, everybody was biking. I dreamt of leaving that country and could drive my own car.
- histories 3y agoBerlin has a plan to have the Ring car-free: https://volksentscheid-berlin-autofrei.de/ https://volksentscheid-berlin-autofrei.de/ No idea if it will actually happen