7 ms·
Just like priests and counselors in the courts of ancient kings, modern economists are masters of telling those with power and wealth what they want to hear. A
by bell-cot 3y ago
Just like priests and counselors in the courts of ancient kings, modern economists are masters of telling those with power and wealth what they want to hear. And beautifully wrapped, in the trappings of moral legitimacy and learned wisdom.
Sure, economists actually know some basics - just as the ancient priest knew that a cartload of grain burned as an offering to his god would not be available to feed the poor. But it ain't enough that you'd want to trust anything they say.
(Vs. - ask any competent engineer about the sort of control inputs which are needed to maintain smooth-ish operation of a half-decent system (be it an airplane in flight, sewage treatment plant, blast furnace, whatever) which is actually understood. And compare to (say) the Federal Reserve's handling of the economy in recent decades.)
- master-lincoln 3y agoAnd just like the foundation knowledge of priests is made up, economist theories have turned out to be non-reproducible many times...
- yawpitch 3y agoI don’t think even supply and demand is reliably reproducible in real world conditions, at least not in the way vinegar + baking soda is reliable.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPeople expect supply and demand to show its effects immediately, whereas it takes years in some markets due to things like sticky prices in things like wages or overwhelming demand relative to supply and hence underestimating the amount of additional supply needed.
- sumtechguy 3y agoThat is in next years budget
- flakeoil 3y agoBut why simplify it into a simple supply and demand curve when at the end it means nothing because you did not include all the other important factors?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThe root causes are still supply and demand. The time lag is not going to change that, it just changes how forward looking you need to be (or how much lower your expectations of hitting your target should be).
- sobellian 3y agoAll models are wrong, some are useful. I took EE in college. Circuits are laughably more complicated than a linear circuits class might lead you to believe. Other engineers are taught the drag equation. It technically includes "all the other important factors" but only because they stuff it all into the drag coefficient. Back to EE. In fields and waves you are shown how light is a wave. They don't take the opportunity to jump into a full unit on QM. For pedagogical reasons people teach foundational concepts first. In this thread there seem to be many people who are unaware of what actual economists do, what they are capable of, but are quite confident they have it all wrong.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThe human mind naturally seeks clarity and confidence over correctness. Once you realize this, this and much more make a lot more sense.
- yawpitch 3y agoI see a whole lot of confirmation bias and circular reasoning in that statement, which makes supply and demand sound an awful lot like phlogistons, the luminiferous ether, epicycles, and other famous fudge factors that millennia of humans have used to maintain their neither testable or falsifiable worldviews. Swap out just a few phrases and we’re at insufficient faith being why the Messiah didn’t return as predicted.
- sobellian 3y agoSo to be clear, S&D is a statement about market prices at equilibrium, i.e. the steady state. Parent pointed out that transient effects matter. Not sure how you got from that to circular reasoning.
- yawpitch 3y agoTo paraphrase, “if you don’t see the immediate effects of S&D, wait for the eventual effects of S&D”… this can only be said by someone who already believes S&D is reliably reproducible.
- sobellian 3y agoThis is no more circular than the observation that an RC circuit has a settling time. If you want a reliable instant reproduction of S&D, they exist. In college I had a lecture where the students were given a role (producer or consumer) and a budget, and the price indeed converged as predicted (despite my best efforts to set up a cartel of producers). Just don't expect the US economy to cooperate and provide a controlled lab setting.
- passwordoops 3y agoI was shocked when I learned the current economic models don't even account for energy inputs. Supposedly if you decide all energy inputs suddenly stop, GDP is predicted to drop on the order of 5-10% instead of, say, cease to exist
- mpreda 3y agoThe economic models are concerned with accurately modelling the impact of normal/expected events/variations. The event you propose is not one worth modelling (being impossible).
- RandomLensman 3y agoI don't think most typical GDP models are designed for situations were large parts of the population will die. Models are also likely not to be designed to accurately reflect the result of a large nuclear war, for example. Typical models will account for energy price and elasticity, though, and if you want models for more catastrophic situations then those exist, but it's a different type of modelling.
- dandy23 3y agoThe problem with economic models is that they remove almost all parameters except a few. But the removed parameters account for like 90% of the outcome. That's the only way you can create models of something as complex as society. It's way more complex and chaotic than weather and still economists think they can predict months and years into the future.
- RandomLensman 3y agoFor smaller economies modelling some months into the future is actually pretty decently possible. Of course, there could always be big events throwing everything in a new state. There are also very very granular models.
- flakeoil 3y ago
- pydry 3y ago>Just like priests and counselors in the courts of ancient kings, modern economists are masters of telling those with power and wealth what they want to hear. Which those with power and wealth channel via, among other things, think tanks like the AEI and donations to universities: https://publicintegrity.org/politics/koch-foundation-proposal-to-college-teach-our-curriculum-get-millions/ https://publicintegrity.org/politics/koch-foundation-proposa... There's a reason economists get paid more than all of the other social sciences. If you want to piss off an economist, suggest that they might be a rational utility maximizing agent in a market where there is a high demand for misleading information.
- vlan0 3y agoThe illusion of control. In a life that is anything but certain. Tales of the ego.
- 1980phipsi 3y agoThe problem is that the system in the case of the economy is composed of billions of humans, not machines. The economy is much more complex, which makes it harder to understand and forecast where it’s going. That doesn’t mean one is right or wrong. It just means there are limits to our knowledge.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoTrying to align the fickle, changing, unpredictable interests of billions of people is actually impossible
- pif 3y ago> It just means there are limits to our knowledge. Sure there are! But, do economist acknowledge such limits? This is the question!
- bell-cot 3y agoAnd yet the electrical engineers have (considering) very little trouble keeping huge national and international electrical power grids stable. Despite billions of self-interested humans using electrical power with zero-ish regard for that stability. Admittedly, it does help that those with the real power, whom the EE's ultimately serve, want stable electrical power grids. Vs. the folks who the economists serve want wealth, power, legitimacy, status, excuses for blatantly self-serving official behavior, ...and plausible deniability, when things keep miserably going wrong from the PoV of the 99.9%.
- sobellian 3y agoThe federal reserve is actually quite good at preventing panics. Compare the frequency of panics in the 19th century to 21st century.
- notRobot 3y ago> modern economists are masters of telling those with power and wealth what they want to hear This is undoubtedly true. Do they have self-awareness around this? Or do they believe the things they say?
- jordanb 3y agoThat's almost the wrong question. Self-delusion is a skill. The really good ones are good at convincing themselves that what they're saying is true. It's like the old George Costanza line: "Remember Jerry: it's not a lie, if you believe it."
- woooooo 3y agoIt's been a few generations since Bretton Woods, today's true believers have been soaking up the prevailing consensus since high school. No need to convince yourself if it's all you've ever known.
- bell-cot 3y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" -Upton Sinclair
- bell-cot 3y agoTo maximize neural efficiency (and minimize embarrassing leaks) ~99% of economists should believe the gospel which they preach. While being quietly open to sudden changes in their theology, whenever reality yet again proves their creed disastrously wrong. Said changes, of course, are strictly a matter for their ~1% "Most Senior and Revered" priesthood to decide.
- gilbetron 3y ago> To maximize neural efficiency That's a fascinating premise, I need to chew on it.
- starbugs 3y ago
- tootie 3y agoI think that's selection bias. There's loads of economists studying all sorts of things and the vast majority are nowhere near the halls of power. And a lot that are listened to are selected for saying politically palatable things despite their lack of credibility. Probably the most influential economist of the last 50 years is Art Laffer and it's because he can draw nice charts validating tax cuts are a good idea. He has almost no academic credentials behind this.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> just as the ancient priest knew that a cartload of grain burned as an offering to his god would not be available to feed the poor Did any culture do this? The Greeks famously burned bones wrapped in fat for their gods, and there is a myth explaining how the gods had to be tricked into accepting the inedible part of the animal. Chinese food sacrifices are placed in a position of honor for a while, after which they are taken away and eaten. The gods don't actually want any food, so practices will evolve -- really quickly -- in the direction of not giving them any, or at least not making the gifts permanent.
- AlexandrB 3y ago> And compare to (say) the Federal Reserve's handling of the economy in recent decades. Can you elaborate on this point? It seems to me like the federal reserve has done a fine job with the tools/mission they have. Their goal is to manage growth and keep inflation within some reasonable bounds and they seem to be doing that ok. They don't have the power to build more housing, change zoning laws, or dictate how the government responds to a global pandemic.
- GardenLetter27 3y agoThat isn't helpful though, we need to understand some ideas of economics to make good decisions for innovation and maximising human potential. Read "Why Nations Fail" for example - all nations are struggling with different parts of that: entrenched interests pushing for over-regulation to stop competition in the EU, NIMBY interests through-out the West blocking housing investments and free trade / movement in the housing market (planning permission, fees, rent controls, etc.), conservative landowners / aristocrats deliberately keeping their population poor and controlled whilst they live in luxury in developing countries.
- dgellow 3y agoAnother point of view would be that those with power and wealth only listen to experts who tell them what they want to hear. If I’m already convinced A is good I can just ignore experts saying otherwise, then justify doing A because my experts said so. All of this to say, the dynamics goes both ways.
- pjc50 3y ago> ask any competent engineer about the sort of control inputs which are needed to maintain smooth-ish operation of a half-decent system The Taylor Rule system of inflation control actually works extremely well. Being a system with one input and one output variable, classical control theory can be easily applied. But - very importantly - this kind of control system is not immune to external shocks (someone trying to push over your inverted pendulum), has a huge phase lag (months to years), and also does not take into account other side effects (unemployment!). Which is why the Russian invasion of Ukraine triggered a worldwide transient (impulse response) inflation. https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/72-inflation-targeting.htm https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/72-inflati... That said, economics has a serious problem with politically motivated bad economics, and the multiple "schools" warring with one another.
- GenerWork 3y ago>Which is why the Russian invasion of Ukraine triggered a worldwide transient (impulse response) inflation. I think the worlds response to Covid (money printing) had a lot more to do with inflation that Russia invading Ukraine.
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoIt's important to distinguish between the US and Europe, when talking about this. From a US perspective, the impact of Russia's invasion of Ukraine on energy prices (and hence inflation) was relatively muted. For Europe, on the other hand, the impact was incredibly large. Additionally, Ukraine supplied huge amounts of grain to EU farmers for livestock, which put a double impact onto food prices in the year following. Finally, the money printing during Covid was wildly different in terms of distributional impacts between the US and Europe, so it's relatively unhelpful to talk about global impacts.
- gilleain 3y ago> other side effects (unemployment!) It was startling to see discussion of interest rates that talked about how increasing unemployment brought down inflation - almost as if it was a good thing to increase unemployment... Sometimes people think of these abstract models of human systems as if the system itself is the important thing, not the humans that make it up. Like considering social systems as 'Darwinian' without considering that 'survival of the fittest' implies 'death of the unfit'.
- captainbland 3y ago"The thing is, you’ve been listening to the wrong expert. You need to listen to the right expert. And you need to know what an expert is going to advise you before he advises you."