5 ms·
Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
- jerpint 3y agoCompanies have been syphoning this data for free for years to train their models. Why would the proprietor of the data not be able to sell it? Assuming of course their terms of use plainly and clearly state that the data belongs to them
- kobalsky 3y agothings changed, and they want a piece of the cake now. they get the chance to adapt to new stuff that's happening and profit from it, however the only ones left without a say are the users that generated that content. I think it would be fair to say that previously accepted terms and conditions shouldn't ethically count for this, and user data previously generated should be shared for AI training only on an opt in basis.
- zdragnar 3y ago> user data previously generated should be shared for AI training only on an opt in basis. Wouldn't all of the populate models and applications (chatgpt, copiolot, etc) have to be burned to the ground and start clean? My understanding was that pretty much every one of these were trained on "stolen" data, i.e. without prior agreement with the authors / content creators.
- takeda 3y agoI don't think that would be a concern if a proper law would be passed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoI think the law was clear before that any data on public internet which doesn't require signing the TOS or login is publicly scrapable. People have been doing it for decades for things like market sentiment analysis and even reselling the data for the same. Why would AI wave suddenly change it.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> user data previously generated should be shared for AI training only on an opt in basis. This seems obviously backwards and a boon to enormous corporations. If you want to build a search engine, you have to index everything possible, or it won't be able to find that and then it's useless. Transacting with each individual person in the world would only be possible for megacorps -- it's already expensive enough to index everything if you don't have to do that. It's also perverse that someone could have a right to prevent someone else from providing true information about them. If you're standing there making a false claim, you shouldn't have a right to prevent someone else from proving you wrong just because the evidence is from your own past. But search engines have been ML since even before LLMs, and LLMs are fundamentally the same. How can someone have a default right to deny the public access to facts? Now, maybe there are some things you want to keep private, and then if you share them with someone you want to bind them to not sharing that information with others, like an NDA. But that's opt-out, not opt-in, and you can't really do that for things that are public.
- card_zero 3y agoThe EU disagrees, and have implemented the right to data erasure from search indexes. In the GDPR and applicable to Google since 2016, it says here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten
- rpdillon 3y agoThat's opt-out, not opt-in.
- card_zero 3y agoIs it? It's not "like an NDA". You get the data erased (if it is agreed that your privacy is more important than the public interest) after the fact of the data being made public.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago
- littlestymaar 3y ago> Why would the proprietor of the data not be able to sell it? Assuming of course their terms of use plainly and clearly state that the data belongs to them And assuming we collectively (as “we the people ”) grant them the ability to actually own this data. There's plenty of good reasons to consider that the data doesn't belong to reddit, that it's just public stuff that they happen to host in exchange for user traffic and advertising revenues.
- realusername 3y agoLegally maybe that all works, but ethically the data doesn't belong more to Reddit than Google. They should find a better economic model than selling user data.
- goplayoutside 3y agohttps://archive.is/jr78G https://archive.is/jr78G
- tinco 3y agoDoes anyone know why they stopped with the awards thing? I really thought it was a clever way of monetizing and I still regularly feel like buying a reddit comment a reward. Was it really that they were embarrassed by how little money it was making?
- Pokerface777 3y agoI thought it was a really bad idea... I would rather send someone cash or crypto... Glad they stopped it, but I was not aware of it because I stopped using reddit.
- happytiger 3y agoWhen I signed up for Reddit AI wasn’t even a thing. Now everything I’ve ever written is being mined against my wishes to build machine that I do not wish for my information to be used to train. And I have no option to opt out, at all. This isn’t a good situation, and if I had known I was going to end up training AI for free, I never would have started with Reddit. This was never an intended use. I hope they put some restrictions on companies like Reddit. They’re moving far beyond what anyone ever intended to provide them, and these use cases are probably something most users wouldn’t want if they had a choice.
- fincycaden 3y ago[flagged]
- happytiger 3y agoHis writings do seem precient. His methods of expressing his distaste for societies direction still suck though.
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoNot least of which because they were woefully ineffective while they were inflicting suffering and fear. Still, one can sympathise with his hopeless, impotent rage more, the longer one sticks around on this planet.
- deprecative 3y agoHe did teach us that nothing will change because we don't want it to. I think that, at least, is significant.
- squigz 3y agoDoesn't the Reddit TOS give them a license to do basically whatever they want with your submissions?
- lionkor 3y agoI'll just start an online therapy company, and when i have enough data, I'll just change the ToS and sell it all to the highest bidder. See, if I do this right before IPO, it's good!
- threadweaver34 3y agoThis might be one of the few times a big tech name you know is actually selling your data. Most of the time when people say that, they mean Google and Facebook, but they actually keep your data to themselves and use it for ad targeting.
- healthyusa 3y agoAI looks at TRILLIONS of words. Doubt a post complaining about it’s impossible to get a girlfriend is going to add much to a LLM. That seems to about 50% of the posts. AKA today on Reddit: My GF say we have to wait for 4 years before we have sex. She left me this week for a guy she met on a plane, she has not left this guys hotel room in a week. What do I do? And the “advice” is endless posts.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoBy the same argument, it should be legal to steal candy bars from the grocery store since “they have so many other things”
- mcmoor 3y agoSome hypermarkets do ignore small shopliftings until a certain threshold. One can feel free to steal 0.0001 of a penny if they afford their own transaction cost and no police will persecute this either.
- appplication 3y agoPerhaps more frustratingly, I’ve found that even when I manually went through my Reddit history and edited my posts and then later did the same and deleted them all, they still exist in the original unedited form. I can find old posts via google search for my username, or posts I commented on, despite Reddit self telling me they have no history of my posts. I also, rarely, get a necro reply where someone replies to a very old post I wrote, which reminds me that these are still out there and discoverable, despite my attempts to edit and delete the information. Reddit has no respect for its users. Your posts are not your posts. They belong to Reddit. As an EU citizen, it feels like what they are doing is probably illegal, but there is no recourse for the average user.
- ivanjermakov 3y ago> I can find old posts via google search for my username This has nothing to do with Reddit I believe. Data for such results is stored in Google's indexes, created by scraping Reddit back when your original comments were in place.
- appplication 3y agoOh, I mean I can actually go to Reddit and read them there, along with my username
- IlPeach 3y agoI even wonder if this can be reported to the whatever EU commission or group monitors and regulated data usage. I'm pretty ignorant on the matter.
- mbirth 3y agoReddit only associates the last 1000 comments with your profile. I’ve also spent the last few months regularly checking Google for another stray comment of mine and edit and delete it. However, if you get a Reddit data takeout, all your posts and comments should show up in there.