5 ms·
The end of the dark universe?
- pdonis 3y agoFor those who, like me, prefer to read the actual paper instead of some science journalist's spin on it, the arxiv preprint is here: https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.03116 https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.03116
- dsabanin 3y agoSabine Hossenfelder is a well known theoretical physicist.
- idiotsecant 3y agoShe's more well known lately for making edgy clickbait youTube videos than doing actual physics
- hollerith 3y agoOne person can do both things.
- Ygg2 3y agoEdgy? Are you watching the same mild lady make tame puns? Granted clickbait is what YouTube algorithm demand.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jxdxbx 3y agoI’ve followed her for a few years now sort of in horror as she’s become a YouTuber. She seems contrarian for the sake of it.
- autoexec 3y agoI don't know if I'd call her "contrarian" but I think it's safe to say she's not exactly filled with starry-eyed optimism. Maybe a lot scientists generally become increasingly jaded and skeptical after years of seeing a lot of big claims and hopes much of which end up amounting to very little, but physicists seem to have had an especially rough time.
- roywiggins 3y agoShe's been that way on physics forever, and she was at least interesting there, but she's moved on to subjects outside of her field, and that hasn't worked as well at all.
- The_Colonel 3y agoCan you elaborate? Her channel seems to be about science, it's common that science popularizers discuss science outside of their field of expertise...
- sph 3y agoScience is a large field. Being an expert in physics won't make you an expert in other scientific fields, yet somehow people love to know the opinion of their favourite heroes of any topic. Remind me of Jurgen Klopp rebuking some journos that wanted his opinion, as successful football coach, on COVID.
- mr_mitm 3y agoJust the field of physics is so large that most would probably not dare to state criticism in other sub fields. Like a Nobel prize winner in solid state physics would never judge the work of a high energy particle physicist and vice versa. Hossenfelder is definitely qualified to talk about the OP, but her videos about transgender people shouldn't be given more credit than videos from almost any other person.
- andrewflnr 3y agoI mean, yes, but her opinion still means more than a random science journalist's.
- refulgentis 3y agoHonestly, I'm watching a bunch of people punch down at imaginary people, I'm not sure there's really anything here than whining about a good article and bizarre irrational stack ranking
- andrewflnr 3y agoI'm not sure I know what you're talking about, but there's nothing imaginary about how bad some "science journalists" are, and the notion of a bunch of HN commenters "punching down" at either journalists or physicists with much bigger platforms than we have is dubious.
- refulgentis 3y agoSome people reflexively do this "I'm not sure I know what you're talking about" type lead-in, then can't help themself from replying anyway. I laugh at the silly attempt at negging and move on with my life. Why? - Comment is +5 - even though it cuts against the grain - because it was such a boring boorish thread. - you demonstrated you know exactly what I'm talking about.
- andrewflnr 3y agoI knew you were saying one of a couple rather weird things. I still don't know which, but I thought the substance of my comment addressed all of them and you haven't bothered to respond to that, so I guess my point stands? We were both nitpicking, so you don't get to claim the high ground.
- refulgentis 3y agoI'm not arguing with you at all, it wouldn't make any sense to, you're not making any claim other than imagining I claimed articles where the journalist doesn't know anything about the topic are always good. Recap: I observed the thread was absurd because: - it opened complaining about the science journalist writer who didn't know the topic. - after it was resolved the author wasn't a science journalist or someone who didn't know anything, people were arguing about the stack-ranking of the imaginary science journalist Now you're here, continuing to argue against a strawman for no discernable reason. We all get it, you and some other people are making sure we understand we're wrong, it can be bad when people write things they don't know about.
- naasking 3y agoClickbait implies she doesn't cover the topics in her thumbnails, or that they are misleading or inaccurate in some way. That hasn't been my experience watching her videos.
- xqcgrek2 3y agoSabine is great, and has made powerful enemies by calling out BS Certainly, her value and contributions to society have been infinitely greater than a string theorist.
- willis936 3y agoAnd made enemies by spewing BS e.g. her hot take on fusion scientists being deceptive is intellectually dishonest.
- a_gnostic 3y agoHer video on Flerfs is a good intro to the scientific method.
- pdonis 3y agoYes, but in the article under discussion, she's writing like a science journalist. A theoretical physicist's criticism of the paper belongs in a published paper of her own, not a pop science article.
- barfbagginus 3y agoI think it's important to point out that reading the abstract and then throwing it into gpt4 would result in a more informative article than the current one. The article spends about a third of its time waxing loquacious about MOND - hossenfelder's own theory - before dismissing the current paper for having equations that are just "too simple" . Now I'm not a physicist. I'm an applied category theorist working in business process modeling of all things. But when I was reading hossenfelder's article I was hoping it would describe how oppenheim models the spectral dispersion of stochastic gravity. This is the linchpin of how oppenheim predicts physically observable phenomenon from the model. That was missing. There have been other articles, which at least mentioned it in passing. I was hoping hossenfelder, being a physicist, could help clarify that for a wider audience. They made a choice not to.
- T-A 3y ago> waxing loquacious about MOND - hossenfelder's own theory "Modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) [...] Created in 1982 and first published in 1983 by Israeli physicist Mordehai Milgrom" [1] "Born 1946" [2] "Sabine Karin Doris Hossenfelder (born 18 September 1976) is a German" [3] I suppose a SciFi story where it eventually turns out that they are the same person (presumably as an unintended consequence of an experiment designed to test their theory) could be fun. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mordehai_Milgrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mordehai_Milgrom [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabine_Hossenfelder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabine_Hossenfelder
- barfbagginus 3y agoIn your reference [1] we see that hossenfelder has worked on their own version of MOND: "Testing MOND using the redshift-dependence of radial acceleration – Sabine Hossenfelder and Tobias Mistele propose a parameter-free MOND model they call Covariant Emergent Gravity and suggest that as measurements of radial acceleration improve, various MOND models and particle dark matter might be distinguishable because MOND predicts a much smaller redshift-dependence.[81]" That is the theory I'm talking about. It also seems like I exaggerated how much of the article was dedicated to MOND, which was my bad. The article is still poor coverage of the actual research
- mdturnerphys 3y agoThat's an older paper that was initially uploaded in 2018 and revised last year. The preprint under discussion is at https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19459 https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19459
- pdonis 3y agoOk, thanks for the update!
- d--b 3y agoSome journalist is Sabine Hossenfelder. And in this piece she is both excited and cautious, explaining fairly well what’s at stake. It’s interesting because I think her writing follows her thought process: - ugh? Yet another attempt to reconcile gravity and quantum physics - wait a minute, adding randomness to gravity is not a terrible idea - what? They say it explains both dark matter and dark energy? How cool! - meh… it probably doesnt work.
- ReptileMan 3y ago[flagged]
- denton-scratch 3y agoThat "science journalist" is actually Doctor Sabine Hossenfelder, a theoretical physicist.
- Arech 3y agoYes, and for non-specialists it's enough to know that the paper isn't even peer reviewed yet, and not waste time on bla-bla-heavy clickbaity pop article..
- sojuz151 3y agoThis theory is trying to justify MOND, and MOND by itself has many problems. It has problems with explaining the bullet cluster, CMB spectrum, and rotation curves of some galaxies. This paper was not even peer reviewed. This is almost certainly nothing burger
- naasking 3y agoThe theory is not trying to justify MOND. That's a gross mischaracterization. LCDM has it's own share of problems, including CMB spectrum issues and nearly zero predictive power for rotation curves.
- RickyS 3y agoThis theory is absolutely NOT trying to justify MOND
- barfbagginus 3y agoThe reason you think that this theory is trying to justify MOND is likely because hossenfelder spends about a third of the article discussing it instead of discussing the current theory. MOND is hossenfelder's pet theory - they've done work on a version of it called Covariant Emergent Gravity It's fine to say that any given new physical theory is almost certainly a nothingburger.. I agree with that. But please reread the article and confirm for yourself that what I say is true.
- refulgentis 3y agoThis is the second time you wrote a comment claiming it's a third of the essay. This time around, I feel like I should point out I went back and checked and it's in 6 sentences across 3 paragraphs in a 18 paragraph article. I don't know why you started a new account to make wildly exaggerated claims about a pretty good article, but here we are
- barfbagginus 3y agoI'll grant that I was exaggerating. That's my bad. It's only 1/6th of the essay. Re: making two comments: I made the first point to criticize the low quality of the article. It is a low quality and dismissive article that misses an opportunity to talk about the technical meat of the theory, even through analogy. That's still true. In the second comment I mentioned the mond thing it because it was directly related to a reader's misunderstanding, and because I felt introducing mond into the article was a red herring that had contributed to this misunderstanding. They reader thought this was specifically a MOND theory, and was therefore dismissing it out of hand. I don't think we should dismiss this theory so easily as that. Re: Alt account This is my only account. I lost the credentials to my old account, and it wasn't linked to my email. Re: criticism I drop stink bombs on things that I think are likely to misinform, and if I am wrong, I'm happy to correct myself. Re: correction I thank you for your comment and your correction. I know it was probably not very pleasant to write, and I know my self correction is not to the extent that you wanted, but your paragraph count helped me see I was exaggerating the MOND claim. Overcoming my own tendency to exaggerate things is very important for me, since it gets me in trouble, or gets my otherwise good arguments dismissed. I sincerely thank you for helping me with that. Re: changing my opinion about the article I still regard this article as an opaque and low effort treatment of the work at hand. Perhaps you could express how a particularly clear point in the article helped you understand more from the paper when you were reading it? That kind of testimony could help me understand how to see this as a good article, and to see where the value is. Thanks! Sending Regards
- neerd 3y agoHow does this new theory explain the evidence for dark matter from galaxy collisions?
- throwawaymaths 3y agoIirc, One of the articles has a diagram with four dark matter less galaxies in a sweeping curve. But if you look at the diagram, there's no less than two other dark matter less galaxies off the curve so one must wonder if it's just a coincidence
- joe_the_user 3y agoAnother article on Jonathan Oppenheim's theory classical-but-random gravity: https://www.sciencenews.org/article/gravity-quantum-mechanics-physics-theory https://www.sciencenews.org/article/gravity-quantum-mechanic...
- tambourine_man 3y agoThe paper has not been peer-reviewed yet.
- xcv123 3y agoIs this article not a peer review? Written by Sabine Hossenfelder. German theoretical physicist. "An exciting new theory reconciles gravity and quantum physics. I think it’s wrong. But I may be too." I suppose the theory needs to be tested.
- podiki 3y agoA peer review and a popular article exploring the proposal, though written by someone pretty qualified, are not the same thing. At the very least the audience and evidence presented are not nearly the same.
- scotty79 3y agoI think this theory is wrong about the sources of randomness. But it's super cool that they show that a bit of randomness could explain dark matter and energy. Personally I believe that the randomness might come from chaotic "background" gravitational waves from sources outside of universe and from times before Big Bang.
- mr_mitm 3y agoNo. Peer review is an established process in which the editor chooses usually two to four expert peers who review the paper. It is double blinded to reduce bias. It is also not the point of peer review to judge the correctness of the theory. Reviewers check relevance, novelty, plausibility, consistency, overall correctness of methodology. "I think this is wrong" is not something an editor would accept as an argument not to publish. That's something you can write in a new paper. And I don't think Hossenfelder would like to see it not published just because she thinks it's wrong.
- eli_gottlieb 3y agoI'm not familiar with physics publishing. Is Physical Review X not a journal whose website would list peer-reviewed papers? https://journals.aps.org/prx/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevX.13.041040 https://journals.aps.org/prx/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevX.13.04...
- crooked-v 3y ago[flagged]
- dukeofdoom 3y ago[flagged]
- podiki 3y agoIn classic internet fashion I only did a quick skim/search of the article and preprint of the paper (linked in this article). However, neither make mention of the bullet cluster [0] or "particle dark matter" and seem to rely more on galaxy rotation curves. While the bullet cluster may not be as definitive as we would like, it is at the very least very strongly suggestive of particle dark matter or something similar. As far as I remember modified gravitational theories without particle dark matter don't offer a good explanation of the bullet cluster (in short, evidence of a non- or weakly interacting but gravitational matter). I won't argue with schemes like MOND or this proposal that can explain rotation curves, but the bullet cluster at the very least is a more interesting test these days. Without even a mention of some alternative explanation here (from my quick look), it is a non-starter for a dark matter-less theory. And a pretty glaring omission (again, maybe I missed it) for what is a well-known observation. Still, alternatives for quantum gravity, and anything that might say something about dark energy, are exciting. Falsifiable ones especially. But if you didn't address the bullet cluster then... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster
- podiki 3y agoAfter a little more of a skim: the paper seems mostly to be about reproducing an equation like that of MOND (modified Newtonian dynamics). Which, fine, some people are fans of MOND (not most, and for good reason from the theoretical which this might address, to the practical like previous comment), but there's a whole lot more than just the dynamics of rotating galaxies to consider. Without even going into that (bullet cluster, lensing, n-body simulations, galaxy formation, etc.) it doesn't (yet?) replace anything.
- sigmoid10 3y agoMost important is still the CMB. Back then everything was ionized and yet we have extremely good evidence of matter that only contributed gravitationally to density perturbations and not via the ordinary electromagnetic path. There is no way to explain this merely by modifying the law of gravity. So even if MOND or similar approaches turn out to be correct, they can never explain all aspects of dark matter. Only particles can.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y agoPreviously: "Anomalous contribution to galactic rotation curves due to stochastic spacetime (arxiv.org)" 7 days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39650489 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39650489 Also discusses Professor Oppenheim's paper.