16 ms·
FTC and DOJ want to free McDonald's ice cream machines from DMCA repair rules
- jimbob45 3y agoRevoke patents for machines that aren’t demonstrably reparable. For that matter, suspend copyright for works that aren’t purchasable.
- mattashii 3y ago> For that matter, suspend copyright for works that aren’t purchasable. When do you start (or stop) counting something as "purchasable"? Does it mean I can copy the tapes of movies the day before their first screenings, but not the day after? Or if my local shop doesn't have a show on disk?
- fkyoureadthedoc 3y agoYou do realize that the proposal would work much the same as any other law? First a little more rigor would go into it than an off the cuff HN comment. Second, if you find something ambiguous then go to court and find out.
- mattashii 3y agoThat is exactly why I asked: I can't think of a definition that would be both intuitive and that would not rule out reasonable and valid sales strategies for some forms of art.
- glenstein 3y agoI understand individual actors following incentives wherever they lead. I wouldn't say condone, but understand. What I don't understand is how it came to pass that McDonalds, whom I would assume are canny and cutthroat in their own right, would find themselves maneuvered into a position like this. Is there no equivalent phenomenon when it comes to their grills, deep fryers, drive-thru comms systems, self-order kiosks, etc?
- jerf 3y agoThis isn't an answer, so much as a sketch of my guess at answer, but check out "path dependence": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence If they go down the right path right at the beginning, a bit of payoff in the right places in McDonalds (which, remember, can be just taking the right people out to a really nice dinner every so often), and it could be that one equipment supplier managed to go down a path that no other current supplier could ever hope to replicate because it really depends on some early decisions, and those suppliers no longer have any opportunity to make "early" decisions.
- glenstein 3y agoI've heard of path dependence but had not considered it in this context. Thanks for the link!
- mherkender 3y agoGiven the poor technical choices made regularly in old corporations, I'm guessing they had no idea what they got themselves into. That or it's their franchisee's problem and they don't have any incentive to fix it.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> That or it's their franchisee's problem and they don't have any incentive to fix it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29326999 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29326999
- karaterobot 3y agoI think of McDonald's as being pretty savvy, having dominated for decades in a competitive domain with large volume and low margins. In violation of Hanlon's Razor, I'd bet the reason is more malice rather than stupidity. Or rather, the specific form of malice more precisely called short-sighted greed.
- 3y ago
- shuntress 3y agoIs there some reason I'm not understanding why McDonald's can't or won't just change vendors? Why is there no competition in the commercial-grade ice cream machine market?
- bogwog 3y ago> Why is there no competition in the commercial-grade ice cream machine market? Maybe patents? That's what they're for, after all.
- AaronM 3y agoMcdonalds the corporation benefits from the argeement while the Mcdonalds franchises suffer from the same agreement.
- shuntress 3y agoAh, so this is just a backdoor fee in the franchise agreement? You (the franchisee) must use this specific machine that breaks all the time and for repairs to that machine you must use this specific vendor with whom we (the franchisor) have a "special" deal.
- 20after4 3y agoYes this exactly.
- CSSer 3y agoAlmost. There’s also an alternative machine available, but it’s not a serious competitor.
- MostlyStable 3y agowhich is part of why I'm so confused by the scheme. Sure, as other commenters have pointed out, it's the franchisees that are bearing this cost and not the "corporation" (which is allegedly getting a kickback), but I have to imagine that, at the margin and in the long term, the reputation that McDonalds has of never having working ice cream machines causes some harm (if caused zero harm, then the flip side is that there is zero value to them having the machines/product), so in the long term there are fewer franchises and therefore less money to the corporation. Rather than this complicated kick back scheme....why not just charge the franchisees more money? It's Mcdonald's gets the same amount of money, the franchisees pay the same amount of money, but you have ice cream machines with a greater uptime and therefore a better brand image which leads to greater long term growth. It just seems stupid and short sighted. I realize that humans do stupid and short sighted things all the time, but this one just seems really obvious. This almost feels like it has to be a cause of corruption where the the corporation isn't actually getting something but rather some executive got a direct kickback in order to slip this in, even though it's in the best interests of neither the franchisees nor the corporation.
- ncr100 3y agoIs the DMCA worth keeping? There have been many anti-consumer news stories citing the DMCA as the linch pin.
- Voultapher 3y ago[flagged]
- LordKeren 3y agoIt could definitely use a strong revision / overhaul. But it is also the reason many sites can exist without being sued in to the ground over hosting copyright infringing material. DRM itself seems like the most pointed issue with the DMCA, but any change that reduces the efficacy or DRM is going to be fought by every large company in America
- kube-system 3y agoMost websites with user submitted content would not be able to exist without DMCA safe harbor provisions. The status quo before the whole "DMCA takedown request" process became a thing was that websites were liable for any user submitted content that was in violation. If the DMCA was repealed today, and tomorrow someone posted copyright content here on HN, then HN would be liable for copyright infringement. A repeal of the DMCA would essentially be a death sentence for social media.
- zer00eyz 3y ago>> A repeal of the DMCA would essentially be a death sentence for social media. How is this a bad thing? If we leave an exemption for search I would consider this a positive.
- kube-system 3y agoDid you like posting that comment? Would you like to continue posting comments on the internet? You probably wouldn't be doing so without Safe Harbor.
- pierat 3y agoThe real answer here is REMOVING the DMCA on criminalizing reverse engineering and DRM. If its your property, you should legally speaking tell any OTHER company to rightly fuck off about restrictions on your property. Intellectual property rights (copyright, patent, trademark) should NOT have any ground in restricting property rights of things directly owned. Instead, we see shit like Iphones where they use the term "SELL", and then continual and ongoing restrictions by the FORMER OWNER. If a company wants to maintain control, they should RENT it, with an explicit, simple to read rental agreement.
- kstrauser 3y agoAs the owner of an iPhone, I can legally do whatever I want with it. The restrictions are on developers who sign agreements with Apple. Nothing stops me legally from jailbreaking my own phone.
- pierat 3y agoWhich legally speaking, hogwash. This link covers 15 years of DMCA abuse, which you say doesn't apply to you. https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-fifteen-years-under-dmca https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-fifteen-ye... Your ignorance of this terrible law is not immunity of this law. Apple could as easily destroy your device with no recourse, or sue YOU personally for "defeat of technical prevention".
- kstrauser 3y agoI didn't see any cases there of someone getting hassled for modding their own gear. Which one should I be looking at that backs up your contention?
- prophesi 3y agoApple will be fighting against it every 3 years when DMCA exemptions have to be renewed. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/02/apple-says-jailbreaking-illegal https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/02/apple-says-jailbreakin... edit: after digging into this, my above statement is false as it no longer needs to be renewed every 3 years
- jmyeet 3y agoI see the expected comments about addressing symptoms here. Yes, intellectual property lock-in is bad. Confusion over why McDonald's put up with this (as in, in an idealized view of a free market, that problem would resolve itself). The problem is capitalism. And it's working as intended. IP, by definition, is just an enclosure [1]. McDonald's the corporation has an adversarial relationship with its franchisees and you see this in every franchise. The head corporation will simply try to extract the maximum possible wealth from their franchisees, even to their detriment. Profits tend to decrease over time. To keep profits growing, it inevitably leads to cutting quality to lower costs and predating on your customers, franchisees and employees. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure
- LordKeren 3y agoI’m not sure changing capitalism is a very viable solution to malfunctioning ice cream machines
- shuntress 3y agoOk so, this is good for McDonalds actually?
- jmyeet 3y agoIn the short-term financial sense, yes. McDonald's gave an exclusive contract for a particular ice cream machine. They then locked down those machines so only first-party repairers can fix them. It's a means of extracting wealth from the franchisees. The ice creame machine maker makes money on these service call outs so they have no incentive to make them reliable (the opposite, actually). And I'm sure McDonald's gets a piece of those service call outs. Now does this do long-term damage to the McDonald's brand? Maybe. But nobody actually cares about that.
- criddell 3y agoThey may have an adversarial relationship with franchisees, but the McDonald's corporation owns and runs 2800 restaurants themselves. You would think that's enough self-inflicted pain that they would do something.
- bell-cot 3y agoBetter Idea: A Lemon Law for commercial equipment. Doesn't matter if Taylor uses copyright, DMCA, patents, contract law, replace-every-10-hours proprietary filters, brittle plastic gears, or what - companies that inflict unreliable & high-maintenance crap on the economy need to suffer sustained fiscal agony.
- kube-system 3y agoThat doesn't really make any sense in the context of a franchise. AFAIK McDonalds franchises are required to buy those specific Taylor machines.
- bell-cot 3y agoWhy doesn't it make sense? Taylor makes crap, Taylor sells crap to "Smallville Burgers, LLC", Taylor pays agonizing penalties & fines. Doesn't matter if the victim bought the Taylor equipment because McD's contract required it, or because their daughter is a Swiftie.
- kube-system 3y agoTaylor doesn't think there's anything wrong with their machine, the maintenance is just onerous. The result of applying any Lemon Law here would be that Taylor buys the machine back. Leaving the franchisee without an ice cream machine, and potentially out of a franchise. Given that an ice cream machine costs thousands, and MCD franchises cost millions, it is a no brainer to just deal with the machine.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoIf Taylor just buys everything back, they no longer have a business, no? Wouldn't that be a good incentive structure for change?
- kube-system 3y agoTaylor wouldn't be buying anything back because no franchisee wants to torpedo their investment over an ice cream machine.
- aow83u45oaw8u 3y agoWhy should McDonalds be individually saved from a shitty contract that they signed? How about we fix the crappy DMCA anti-circumvention clause that has been causing problems for tons of people since 1999? Oh, because this will provide press coverage and notoriety for somebody who's probably up for reelection soon.
- dylan604 3y agoSometimes a contract is a bad contract, but it's not known how bad at first reading. There should absolutely be a mechanism for nullifying in whole or in part contracts that are this way. Especially if the contract forces you to purchase equipment that does not work. After all, a contract is just a piece of paper than can easily be torn up. You're trying to make it some magical binding spell type of thing instead
- LoganDark 3y ago> After all, a contract is just a piece of paper than can easily be torn up. The piece of paper just represents the contract, other forms of contracts exist (such as digital, verbal). I agree there should be an easier way to get out of shitty ones. But make it too easy and you make contracts too weak. It's a balancing act.
- treyd 3y agoThere is a mechanism, a judge can decide to unilaterally annul a contract and order the parties involve to form a new one that they mediate the negotiation and terms of.
- dylan604 3y agoincluding if there's an arbitration clause?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- connicpu 3y ago
- ck2 3y agoThe final laws that eventually solidify for "right to repair" are going to be so corrupt for industry they will be useless for consumers. Build an "open source" ice cream machine. Not so easy for a tractor I guess but it sounds like China could make one that would last a year for a fraction of the price.
- scarface_74 3y agoCorporate likes the status quo since they get a kickback from the manufacturer for each repair The more I read about franchises, the more I’m convinced that most people are just “buying a job” and not starting a business. https://www.mashed.com/178309/how-much-mcdonalds-franchise-owners-really-make-per-year/ https://www.mashed.com/178309/how-much-mcdonalds-franchise-o... The rate of return from starting a McDonald’s franchise is less than the average return of just throwing your money into an index fund and most owners work ungodly hours
- 20after4 3y agoJust being a manager in the fast food industry is a really bad job, also. Overworked and underpaid. I wouldn't want anything to do with any of it.
- bombcar 3y agoThe key is they're buying a job they can buy more of later; if you get a McDs off the ground (you need about $500k in cash and assets - like land, you can borrow the rest) you will have a much easier time expanding. Most McDs franchises run a few of them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whartung 3y agoThe McDs ice cream experience is just flat out the worst. It's like ice cream lottery. "Boy, a bit of ice cream might be nice!" And it's a total crapshoot. Drive up with no idea whether it's going to happen or not. You want to just write it off, give up, "McDs doesn't sell ice cream". But then you go another day, and there it is on the menu, teasing you! Lies. Deception. So aggravating.
- DANmode 3y agoYou know who doesn't lie about ice cream availability? Ice cream parlours!
- anonymousab 3y agoSince this is a case of McDonald's corporate and Taylor joining hands to exploit their franchisees, I'm not sure how this will help. If they get it have the legal right to repair the machines, it's kinda pointless if McDonald's corporate merely needs to send down an order such that all franchises must not repair their own ice cream machines, as they would for any other kickback-driven franchise requirement.
- bee_rider 3y agoWow, the apocryphal story I thought was just that the machines were a pain to clean, so they were always “broken.” I had no idea there was a whole corporate kickback scheme behind it all.
- reilly3000 3y agoI was a bit shocked to learn about a $900M lawsuit over a Raspberry Pi device. At first I thought it was Taylor suing them out of existence, but it’s actually Kytch suing McDonald’s https://www.farm-equipment.com/blogs/6-opinions-columns/post/21533-r2r-meltdown-and-a-900-million-lawsuit-against-mcdonalds https://www.farm-equipment.com/blogs/6-opinions-columns/post...
- lxe 3y agoWe should add more specific exceptions to 1201 of DMCA to prevent rampant abuse and this unrepairability nonsense.
- dexwiz 3y agoThe whole Taylor repair scenario reeks of some sort of corporate kickback scheme. Taylor makes a deal with corporate that forces franchises to buy a subpar machine. Every time the machine goes down Taylor gets a repair order and corporate extracts power by potentially revoking the franchise if the owner seeks other means to repair it. Talking to McDonalds workers one main complaint was that every item on the menu required a special machine. McDonald’s more closely resembles a factory than a kitchen.
- gamepsys 3y ago> every item on the menu required a special machine * One of McDonald's well known qualities is how consistent their products are. This is largely because every McDonald uses the same ingredients, the same equipment, and the same process. * Assembly line production is a key part of how McDonald's maintains speed. Not surprised to see that the equipment resembles factory equipment. * All of this is highly visible to the customer. You see inside the kitchen when you place an order inside the restaurant.
- anonymouse008 3y agoThat's curious - we use the Taylor machines with almost '0 downtime' besides maintenance (scheduled and rarely interferes with customers). The tech who installed our machines says it's all a skill issue with anyone who can't keep these machines up. According to him, the issues are rare / negligent maintenance and very old product left entirely too long in the machine. He will have one from our machines, but never from some other establishments.
- rkagerer 3y agoOut of curiosity, who's "we"?
- sirspacey 3y agoI suspect Taylor’s social media listening company. This looks pretty similar to the boilerplate response they put on Reddit, where they get torn to shreds by McD managers who are Reddit users and disagree. Doubt we’ll see that response here.
- anonymouse008 3y agoLols no // caffeine dealers
- DANmode 3y agoOkay, good to be speculative in situations such as this, but after skimming that user's page for even 3 seconds, one can see this was a lazy, really off-base accusation - unless this user sold their HN account. Is that the accusation? If so, better to email the site admins, rather than alert the fraudster, or distact from discussion.
- jolux 3y agoThe specific one used at McDonald's, the C602? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald%27s_ice_cream_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald%27s_ice_cream_machine The C602 is supposedly exclusive to McDonald's, which if you watch the video posted elsewhere in this thread, explains why their machines are less reliable than those of other chains.
- notherhacker 3y agoThey shouldn't get an exception, the law is painful as designed and consumers have to deal with it so should they. The underlying laws should be removed. IP laws like this are unenforceable at a global level and don't help/protect the consumers. All they do is create artificial walled gardens. There is no reason that its illegal to jailbreak an iPhone, or repair a tractor, or hack your bmw seat warmer. This is going to continue to lead us to a corporate hellscape. China has a more free market in this regard until the party shows up with a gun to tell you to do something for political reasons, but meanwhile they are able to leverage a more free market.
- kevincox 3y agoI completely agree. The DCMA Anti-Circumvention rules are just a hack to make it easier to enforce copyright protections. But why should we make that easier? Why do we have a law making it illegal to do something that may be used for illegal purposes? It's a dumb law, let's get rid of it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- runlevel1 3y agoIn the US, IP law flows from this line of the Constitution: > [Congress shall have power] to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries. Are laws like this really helping promote the progress of science and useful arts? Because it sure does seem like it's doing the opposite.