25 ms·
Vehicle brakes produce charged particles that may harm public health: study
- dirtyoldmick 3y ago[flagged]
- frickinLasers 3y agoNice hot take. Did you read the article? Their proposed solution--using the charge to facilitate removing the particles from the air--seems more helpful.
- lobsterthief 3y agoDo you really see the world that black and white? How about research into other brake materials that are less harmful? Or any number of other things.
- simlevesque 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > In Comments > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. > Please don't post shallow dismissal
- leoh 3y agoIndeed, to replace a brake you must remove it first; and better brake pads there are. Oerlikon of Switzerland has brake pad technology that has near zero emissions and does not need replacing. It’s not in production due to pressure for revenue from service shops.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWe can't save the planet or ourselves because it's not profitable.
- robertlagrant 3y agoSelling brake pads that don't wear out would be immensely profitable. Things people want get bought.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoI dunno mate. If I were a brake pad salesman I'd prefer they last less not more.
- robertlagrant 3y agoSo? There would only be one "brake pad salesman" left, who would sell indestructible brake pads to car manufacturers, and all the others would go bust.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoRight. It's not like they can form a cartel and collectively decide how long a brake pad should last, just like the incandescent light bulb cartel [1] of the early 20th century or the NAND flash memory cartel of the 21st century. Mate you're far too naive to believe what you're saying. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel
- samatman 3y agoA theoretical cartel can do precisely nothing, since it's a mere mental construct. It takes an actual cartel to fix prices (ignoring as a distraction the fact that the link you provide gives several good reasons to think that planned obsolescence was not the primary factor in the lifetime of incandescent bulbs). There is no brake pad cartel. If there is, demonstrate it. If not, again, an imaginary cartel can only do imaginary things. It can't do real things.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago
- samatman 3y agoSomething about this story doesn't add up. Service shops aren't even vaguely a cartel, if Bob's Brakes won't install the magic brake pads which never wear out, then Alan's Excellent Brakes shop will. If, on the other hand, a company has a vaporware product, that's a great excuse to offer the public.
- mschuster91 3y ago> If, on the other hand, a company has a vaporware product, that's a great excuse to offer the public. I explained a bit more in a sister comment. The stuff ain't vaporware and Oerlikon no vaporware producer either - they're in the brake business for many, many decades, with a rich history especially in train brakes.
- Arrath 3y agoPresumably these infinite brake pads are part of the regenerative energy generating portion of a perpetual motion machine as well?
- leoh 3y agoThe lifetime of most cars a mere hundred thousand miles. If you consider that the current top-end for brakes is ~60k miles and an improvement of ~30% is possible, we're already at ~78k miles -- and this area has scarcely been invested and researched. I'll let you find sources, I've already given you the name of one of the major R&D firms.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Oerlikon of Switzerland has brake pad technology that has near zero emissions and does not need replacing. It’s not in production due to pressure for revenue from service shops. You're likely referring to DiscCover [1], a relatively recent development - at least Volvo Trucks has an agreement to use that technology [2]. The problem is that the car industry is notorious for long product development cycles. New inventions (unless you're Tesla, obviously) tend to take many years before they go from after-market / high performance tuning shops to mainstream models. It's not as bad as in aeronautics (if you want examples, look at GA still using leaded fuel and engine/airframe designs from the 70s or earlier), but still, there's no need to suggest conspiracies. [1] https://www.oerlikon.com/sustainabilityreport-2020/en/environment/ https://www.oerlikon.com/sustainabilityreport-2020/en/enviro... [2] https://www.oerlikon.com/annualreport-2019/de/segmentberichte/ https://www.oerlikon.com/annualreport-2019/de/segmentbericht...
- CrazyStat 3y agoFrom your link > Take for example our DiscCover coating solution: authorities worldwide have introduced stringent limits for exhaust emissions — including NOX, CO2 and particulate matter. Increasingly, regulators are turning their attention to fine dust emissions from brake wear. On average, 31% of passenger- vehicle-related emissions are caused by brake wear. This results in more than 90 000 metric tons of fine dust per year in the OECD countries alone. The DiscCover solutions from Oerlikon Balzers and Oerlikon Metco significantly reduce fine dust from brake discs so that our customers are equipped to comply with stricter regulations as they improve their environmental footprint. and elsewhere [1] > We can help brake system manufacturers and designers prepare for stricter regulations by significantly reducing fine dust and extending disk life Reducing fine dust is great, but (1) this seems to only be about brake discs, not brake pads, and (2) there's no support in Oerlikon marketing materials for GP's claim that this magically means brake pads don't need replacing. > Oerlikon of Switzerland has brake pad technology that has near zero emissions and does not need replacing This seems not unlike the stories that go around about how someone was sold a 200mpg prototype car by accident but then the car company took it back because they don't want people to have them. [1] https://www.oerlikon.com/balzers/us/en/markets/heat-treatment-solutions-for-automotive-components-brake-disks/ https://www.oerlikon.com/balzers/us/en/markets/heat-treatmen...
- u320 3y agoElectric vehicles are heavier, which means they must spend more brake pads to stop. But they also use regenerative breaking, which reduces pad wear. So I'm not sure if they make it worse or not.
- cbolton 3y agoI hope we'll crack down on heavy SUVs vs normal cars before electric vs ICE.
- ok_dad 3y agoTires are somewhere near the top for distributing microplastics and heavier cars cause more tire wear, so yea we should get on that. I live next to a main road and we run filters in our house and have to wash the surfaces at least once a week to get off the oil and rubber dust. You can't just dust that stuff either, you have to wash it with soap. I almost regret buying this place, but where else would I have bought in this economy!?
- gr2m 3y agoI drive an EV for over a year, I barely use the break any more. Single pedal driving is wonderful
- qwertox 3y agoCurious: How do you roll towards a red traffic light, do you somehow push a "neutral" button?
- emsign 3y agoWe need to go back to horseback riding. It's inevitable.
- itishappy 3y agoI suspect horses come with their own health issues. Can you imagine a city parking garage for horses?
- fragmede 3y agoYou mean a stable? They had those in ancient times in castles. A multi-story stable is funny to picture, but I don't see why not.
- itishappy 3y agoI do indeed mean a stable! I don't imagine the particulates coming out of stables are going to be all that great. Also, my car doesn't get sick if I park it next to somebody's beater.
- fragmede 3y agoThere are classes of parking garages too. I’m not parking my hypothetical dream Ferrari next to some poor person’s beat up Honda civic from the 90’s to get dinged and the windows broken. The underground parking garage at Apple must be astounding.
- varelaz 3y agoClickbait. "The toxicity and health effects of brake wear particles are largely unknown". Is there any real harm found? What's the concentration of them close to the dangerous road? What's effect of them comparing to pm10 or pm2.5?
- whatshisface 3y agoThe brake pad particles are pm10 and pm2.5.
- varelaz 3y agoWell I meant other particles treated in the regular study of them. Because effect of pm10 and pm2.5 is studied. Do break pad particles somehow worse than usual.
- grecy 3y agoDo you really need an independent peer-reviewed study to know if inhaling brake dust is bad for you or not? At some point, it's important to trust your instincts. I don't think you need a medical degree to understand that inhaling tiny particles made of nasty stuff leads to bad health outcomes.
- wkearney99 3y agoWhile the sentiment on that is laudable, it's that kind of assuming that leads all kinds of idiots to jump to entirely ridiculous conclusions.
- grecy 3y agoGiven that we're on HN, I was assuming that everyone here is educated and has some kind of basic reasoning skills. Common knowledge and all that.
- varelaz 3y agoInstincts often cheat you. I'm not saying that it's healthy but Does it really have any effect at all? What's the concentration of particles? How harful is it comparing to cooking or peeling onions? Do we need to care about it at all?
- legulere 3y agoThe article still leaves off tire wear which is another way cars emit particles.
- bastawhiz 3y agoI mean, if you want to bring up all the particles cars give off, look no further than the tail pipe on most cars.
- briandw 3y agoBreak use on my EV is about once per trip. I have to stop after backing up and that seems to need the breaks. Honestly not sure if that's just a bad habit at this point or of regen doesn't work in reverse.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ThinkBeat 3y agoThis will come from all ground transportation sources, right? Busses, trains, trams, subways etc. Probably the heavier the vehicle the more particles are likely to be produced?
- rightbyte 3y agoHeavy vehicles like busses and trucks more often have drum brakes which I guess are better from a air pollution view?
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agodrum breaks have the breaks enclosed so the particles won't be in the air
- rickydroll 3y agoIf you've ever worked on a vehicle with drum brakes, you would see the foolishness in your statement. Brake dust goes everywhere, whether it be drums or disc brakes. Older drum brakes were even more hazardous because the brake linings were built with asbestos, at least until the 1990s for US-made brake products. Aftermarket and foreign-made brake pads apparently still have asbestos in them. I'm not too worried about this. It's an engineering problem and now that is been raised, we can find solutions.
- FredPret 3y ago> It's an engineering problem and now that is been raised, we can find solutions. This should be the default attitude of society
- akira2501 3y agoIt should at least be the default attitude on this site.
- londons_explore 3y ago
- _aavaa_ 3y agoAnother day another set of researchers justifying their research which then gets spun as anti-EV FUD.
- wyldfire 3y agoWhy would that happen? EVs use their brakes much less often. when I read the article it occurred to me that this could eventually used to justify policy that would subsidize EVs more than they are.
- thebruce87m 3y agoThe article has this statement: > The new study reveals a problem that may grow as electric cars become more and more common over the next several decades. Electric cars, Smith explained, are not truly zero-emission vehicles, so municipalities need to think about strategies to reduce emissions from brake use as well as tailpipes. Which completely ignores regenerative braking.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoThe first sentence of the abstract also shows a technically correct statement easily used for disingenuous framings: “The coming decades promise a transition from internal combustion engines to electric, and with it a greater relative contribution of nonexhaust sources to urban air pollution.”
- decafninja 3y agoThe brake dust argument is something I’ve noticed coming more from the “ban all cars” crowd more than the “anti-EV/pro-ICE” crowd. I assume the objective is that these people want to see things go from ICE cars to public transportation instead of EVs.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoAnd while setting up cities to go from car-centric cities to something that's walkable and/or easily accessibly by bus/train/bike for the majority of able-bodied people is something I agree with, that's a change that will take decades to roll out. In the meantime, the cars are here to stay, so we might as well push to get cleaner ones.
- beembeem 3y ago> All you would need to do is to collect them with an electrostatic precipitator – a device that exposes the charged particles to an electric field and efficiently sweeps them away.” How do they propose to do this? A little device mounted near each brake pad? A skim of the paper doesn't appear to show an opinion from them beyond citing this prior study [1]. The conclusion of the cited paper appears to show a progression towards a target: > This study is our first step to install dust collectors in actual vehicles, in order to reduce the brake wear PM emissions. In this study, we evaluated the collection efficiencies of an inertial separator, an ESP, and a hybrid precipitator, independently. In the next stage, we will design a suction system that considers the structure and space of the brake system; then, the full dust collector system setup will be installed on a vehicle. At the final stage, the actual collection efficiency of the dust collector will be measured under various on-road driving conditions. [1] https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/13/7/1121 https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/13/7/1121
- petre 3y agoToo complicated, why not use a magnetic brake instead? The electric motor on hybrids essentially operates like a magnetic brake during regen. Works in 80% of the scenarios and for the rest of 20% we can just use the regular brakes.
- Tade0 3y agoOr run the motor in reverse in the final stage of braking. I drive a hybrid and, when parking, switch between drive and reverse even while still rolling the opposite direction as it's easy for the motor to deal with such loads.
- aaronax 3y agoI do the same in ICE cars with automatic transmissions and it seems just fine. I think the torque converter handles the opposition elegantly.
- alcyone 3y agoI didn't see an explanation of the effects that charged particles have on my health. This research and finding seems important but including some effects other than "pollution" would be great. Anyone have specifics?
- frickinLasers 3y agoI think it's a poorly titled article. The salient points for me were: - Braking produces [probably] unhealthy dust. - Much of that dust is electrically charged, meaning sweeping it out of the air (perhaps before it leaves the wheelwell) is easy. It would be interesting to know whether inhaling charged particles is more or less harmful than neutral particles, though.
- daft_pink 3y agoJust want to point out that most electric and hybrid vehicles use regenerative braking most of the time and only use real brakes at very slow speeds or in emergencies. So it might be totally misleading to say that electric vehicles are the problem, when they are probably the solution.
- imbusy111 3y agoThe article has weird reasoning. If we remove tailpipe emissions, which are by far the largest, then brake/tire wear emissions become visible and are next in the list to deal with. But we won't deal with the latter before the former is dealt with.
- loeg 3y agoThey're just orthogonal concerns. There is no ordering between them.
- xdavidliu 3y ago> If we remove tailpipe emissions, which are by far the largest im gonna need a source on your claim. heres a source that claims the opposite https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/07/09/tire-brake-tailpipes-emissions-pollution-cars/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/07/0... > our brakes and tires isn’t benign, either. Tests by Emissions Analytics, an engineering consulting company based in England, found tires produce about 2,000 times more particle pollution by mass than tailpipes.
- Karellen 3y ago> tires produce about 2,000 times more particle pollution by mass than tailpipes. (emphasis mine) The fact that the majority of tailpipe pollution is not particulate means that tailpipe pollution can be the biggest problem we need to fix, even if it isn't the biggest particle pollution problem.
- linksnapzz 3y ago
- alliao 3y agoair filtration isn't expensive nor hard... last generation cleaned water, perhaps we should clean the air. start small, indoors and transportation, reduce exposure simple stuff and just gotta do it.
- TylerE 3y agoThe problem is that all the bad stuff from cars by definition is OUTIDE, where it's essentially impossible to filter besides wearing a properly fitting respirator.
- autoexec 3y agoAir filtration is a really great idea, but it doesn't help if you want to spend time in your own yard or open a window. Thankfully we haven't yet reached the point where we're all forced to live in hermetically sealed houses with filtered air pumped in, or where we need to wear a hazmat suit outdoors. I'd prefer to clean up the air and avoid excessively or needlessly polluting it further so that we can enjoy it rather than having to living in a bubble. We can't filter our way out of this problem. If we can build cars better to reduce their harms and there are ways to place particle collectors near streets and houses to reduce the environment impacts of traffic I'm all for it.
- autoexec 3y agoThe problem of "brake dust" on human health and air quality has been known for a long time (https://phys.org/news/2020-01-air-pollution-effects-immune-cells.html https://phys.org/news/2020-01-air-pollution-effects-immune-c...) before that there were also issues with asbestos in brakes, but thankfully those haven't been used since the 90s as far as I know. This is the first I'm hearing about electrically charged particles though. The bottom line is that proximity to traffic is horrible for your health and your air quality. Electric cars can help with some of the problems but don't solve all of them. The people with the least amount of money end up having to move to apartments near highways and so they often suffer the worst impacts, but I've seen very nice and expensive apartments and houses very close to (or directly on) busy streets. Noise is usually the obvious and immediate consideration, and I doubt many people are aware of the risks they expose themselves and their families to just by opening a window in the summer.
- jasonfarnon 3y agoIf you looked nationally at wealth vs proximity to traffic, I would wager the "people with the least amount of money" are not the closest to traffic; are you suggesting otherwise? If only because of all the wealth that has come to cities in the last 20-25 yrs. Within that already wealthy urban demo I would agree, yes, the poorer wealthy are nearer to urban highways and thoroughfare than the wealthier wealthy.
- CharlesW 3y agohttps://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/su6203a8.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/su6203a8.htm "In the United States, it is widely accepted that economically disadvantaged and minority populations share a disproportionate burden of air pollution exposure and risk (26,27). A growing body of evidence demonstrates that minority populations and persons of lower socioeconomic status experience higher residential exposure to traffic and traffic-related air pollution than nonminorities and persons of higher socioeconomic status (5,28–31). Two recent studies have confirmed that these racial/ethnic and socioeconomic disparities also exist on a national scale (32,33)."
- simne 3y agoIt is known problem. May be most researched is "brake dust" in tube, where it is literally seen with naked eye. Other place where "brake dust" seen but nobody care, in airplanes, may be because airplane brakes are not just emit dust, but literally smoke :)
- incompatible 3y agoI wonder what the air quality is like in and around racing car circuits, given brake, tire, and exhaust pipe emissions.
- spike021 3y agoI'd also be curious about brake pad composites. In car brakes you can have slightly different designs/materials for pads which cause the balance of noise<->dust<->temperature performance to differ. For instance if you want to reduce dust emission, generally you get brakes that are much louder in my experience until they warm up but they are much "cleaner".
- adonovan 3y agoIt was especially terrible before 2006, which is when NASCAR's exemption to the lead ban finally expired, creating a perfect natural experiment to answer the question: how much did the health of people downwind of NASCAR arenas improve after the ban, and conversely, what was the dollar cost of the health externality of lead. Spoiler alert: more than $1000 / gram (approx. 1 tank of fuel). https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20190654 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20190654
- fddrdplktrew 3y agoWhat about tire dust?
- JAKC056 3y ago[dead]
- NoPicklez 3y agoThe credibility and purpose of the article was shot down when they said the problem would be getting WORSE with EV's. Firstly, the problem becomes less of an issue with EV's and they shared no evidence to support that moving to EV's would increase non-exhaust based pollution. Lastly, there have been plenty of studies over the last two decades which show charged particles from car brakes.
- Gabrys1 3y agoThere's probably more tyre pollution from EVs to be fair.
- lm28469 3y agoEVs are 50%-100% heavier and a lot of them accelerate faster than supercars from the 80s...
- recursive 3y agoEVs tend to be heavier, but your numbers seem high. A Corolla sedan is +30% weight over a model 3. https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/toyota-corolla-2018-sedan-eu-vs-tesla-model-3-2017-sedan/ https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/toyota-corolla-2018...
- recursive 3y agoEdit: Meant to say a model 3 is heavier than the Corolla by 30%.
- NoPicklez 3y agoYou cannot infer that just because a car is ~50% heavier that it means it spews out more brake particles. EV's use regenerative braking similar to that of engine braking in your car and this accounts for limited use of the brake pads in comparison to combustion engines. Those numbers you present are a little inflated when it comes to like for like currently. Furthermore, there are combustion engine vehicles which are far far heavier than EV 4wd's. Acceleration is not performed under braking either so I don't see your latest point.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoA startup I worked for years ago initially had a temporary office in a coworking space that catered to artists and craftspeople, in a renovated warehouse near the freeway loop downtown. They didn't have air conditioning, which isn't particularly strange in the PNW, but we did learn opening the windows for breeze was a very bad idea. The amount of tire and brake dust/soot that would pile up in a single afternoon was disturbing. We were only in there temporarily for a few months, but boy did it underscore to me how much of an unappreciated health and pollution hazard freeways are.
- Tade0 3y agoI went to Switzerland once and as I walking over a bridge stretching above a highway, I noticed the smell of hydrocarbons and machinery in general. It takes Alpine air as a point of reference to feel it, which says a lot about the ambient level of pollution in cities.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIn Wilmington, CA, the pollution from refineries and the port of LA is often so intense that you can smell it within your car as well as see the brown tinge that hangs thick and low in the air driving southbound into the area. Its amazing that people still have to live under that today in this state of supposed environmental leaders both public and private. I guess the port makes too much money for the economy for anyone to care about the health outcomes of the people who are saddled with living near it.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIf you are within a mile down wind or so of a highway the increase of pollution is really significant. The same is true for very busy roads which unfortunately often means most of an entire urban area is at risk for health problems from pollution due to busy roads.
- Gabrys1 3y ago> The new study reveals a problem that may grow as electric cars become more and more common over the next several decades. EVs produce way less brake dust because manufacturers and drivers are obsessed with regenerative braking.
- iancmceachern 3y agoTires too
- okokwhatever 3y agoOk, again another discussion about how cool EVs are because they're gonna save the world and blablaba. Why dont we talk about the size, weight and pollution produced by the process of building a battery and how many houses can be energized by the electric consumption of just one of this machines? Just to balance the conversation, you know.