15 ms·
Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
- FredPret 3y agoUnbelievable how much we can work out from just the odd photon hitting us from somewhere in the great unknown.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- golemotron 3y agoOccam's Razor does a lot of heavy lifting.
- daxfohl 3y agoIt's astounding to me that space is so empty that in the billions of light years from here to the edge of the universe, there's orders of magnitude less total interference than what you get from a small cloud. It's also astounding that celestial objects emit enough photons that thousands per second travel within the arc that goes the distance from the star to somewhere inside the radius of your pupil. And if this wasn't the case, then we'd never even be aware of any of this.
- suzzer99 3y agoAlso that the light and gravitational waves from colliding neutron stars can travel 100 million light years and arrive at earth within a second of each other. That's a mind-bogglingly small amount of drag.
- CobrastanJorji 3y ago"The odd photon hitting us" is also a pretty good description of eyesight, radio, and fiber optics.
- fooker 3y agoClearly the even photon is for parity checking and error correction ;)
- eikenberry 3y ago[flagged]
- _dain_ 3y ago[flagged]
- mr_mitm 3y agoAlmost all claims any serious scientist makes concern the observable universe. Also, these are very smart people. You'd be surprised what we can work out with a few very reasonable assumptions and the observations we made. The dismissiveness really isn't warranted.
- eikenberry 3y agoSo you're saying the scientific media is where the "dumb people" are, not the scientists themselves. While I agree, it doesn't really change the point that these sorts of headlines/articles are heliocentric in nature and mischaracterize our understanding of the universe. IE. I'm criticizing pop-science, not science.
- eikenberry 3y ago> Almost all claims any serious scientist makes concern the observable universe. One last thought on this.. I understand these sorts of understood meanings work fine when speaking with professional peers, as they'd understand the assumption. But if you continue to do this when speaking to people outside your field, you will not be saying what you mean to say and will be teaching people incorrect ideas.
- xcv123 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe
- beaned 3y agoStupid question: how do we know that the universe is strictly exponentially expanding, and not both expanding and contracting in perpetuity like a sin wave? And could such an idea have anything to do with the Hubble tension?
- Vecr 3y agoThat's the "big crunch" theory. It's been pretty dubious for quite a while now though.
- beaned 3y agoThe "big crunch" wikipedia says that it's an idea about the end of the universe, where expansion will reverse and everything will collapse back in on itself. That is not what I'm asking. I'm asking if expansion and contraction could fluctuate in perpetuity, like stress waves through a block of jello.
- mr_mitm 3y agoWe believe that the universe is accurately described by the Friedman-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker metric, for which we have good reasons, and which only allows a few trajectories of the scale factor. I'm not aware of any model with a sine-like scale factor, but there are people considering cyclical cosmologies. But they would still be a series of big bangs and big crunches.
- JohnMakin 3y agoThis sort of brushes on it but for a long time there was hope at resolving the Hubble Tension by saying that Hubble telescope’s measurements were incorrect, because that would be the most simple explanation. This was not the case, so if anything, the mystery deepens. I don’t know for certain but I believe Hubble’s estimation has been widely accepted for a while though, because we’ve been using the 13.8 billion cosmological age estimate ever since I started brushing up my layman's understanding of the subject.
- orra 3y ago> we’ve been using the 13.8 billion cosmological age estimate ever since I started brushing up my layman's understanding of the subject. I remembered the age of the universe as as 13.7 billion years, but I wasn't sure why that was. Well, the initial WMAP results in 2003 supported an age of 13.7 billion years. Later results nudged this upwards to 13.8 billion years. Of course, all the results have error bars.
- explaininjs 3y ago> Of course, all the results have error bars. Not to mention the underlying philosophical assumptions, such that the "rate of time" has been constant across all of... time. Aka: How do we know a "year" 13 Billion "years" ago bears any resemblance to one now? What would it mean for it not to?
- fooker 3y agoPhilosophical indeed, as it's impossible to define the idea of a rate of time, when the idea of rate is defined in terms on time itself.
- explaininjs 3y agoYes, an external reference clock is needed. If a computer chugs along doing { counter++; } at 1 clock cycle per clock cycle for 13.7 billion clock cycles, it will think 13.7 billion clock cycles have passed when counter is 13.7 billion. On the other hand, if a computer chugs along at one clock cycle per clock cycle for 1 clock cycle, and reads &counter and sees 13.7 billion, it will think 13.7 billion clock cycles have passed. Either way it's perfectly capable of introspecting it's source code and logically stepping back until the memory location was 0 to see how many clock cycles would have been required to reach it's current state, but that sort of reasoning is completely devoid of meaning without both perfect knowledge of what the true start state was, and a guarantee that no external influences have occurred. Here in reality, we know neither the our start state nor our isolation level, but the hubris of many is too string to not at least try finding some logical step-back functions and iterating them until they don't know how to go any further, then proudly proclaiming that "The Start". (after all - how could it not be The Start, look, I can iterate the inverse of my step-backward function from then to now and it matches! QED!)
- gregorymichael 3y agoWhat are the implications?
- kromem 3y agoBasically it means that we can't regard the Hubble result as a mismeasurement and the age of the universe seems to be different depending on how you measure it. From the article: "The bottom line is that the so-called Hubble Tension between what happens in the nearby Universe compared to the early Universe’s expansion remains a nagging puzzle for cosmologists. There may be something woven into the fabric of space that we don’t yet understand."
- washadjeffmad 3y agoSounds like they don't want to spoil everyone's research grants!
- jdiff 3y agoOutside of the tinfoil, it just sounds like the universe is complex and not always predictable.
- washadjeffmad 3y agoI meant it as a comment on the phrasing. Potentially jeopardizing a field's cash flow is a legitimate worry, and I see a few have felt that, as well.
- bigbillheck 3y agoThere's a whole lot of open problems in cosmology, nobody's going to be out of work if they solve this one.
- harywilke 3y agoIt's amazing that barely a 100 years ago The Great Debate in astronomy was weather the Milky Way was the extent of the universe or things like Andromeda were their own 'island universes'. In the 1920s, Edwin Hubble showed that Andromeda was far outside the Milky Way by measuring Cepheid variable stars. These are the same stars that we are measuring today in this debate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Debate_(astronomy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Debate_(astronomy)
- nsilvestri 3y agoThis URL is a stub, and the full article can be read at https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Webb/Webb_Hubble_confirm_Universe_s_expansion_rate https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Webb/W...
- cwillu 3y agoAdded bonus: it has 50% less animated “responsive” design.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjbinx007 3y agoI wonder if the mods can change the main article link to the one you provided instead?
- dang 3y agoIndeed we can!
- dang 3y agoThanks! We've changed to that from https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2024/03/Webb_Hubble_confirm_Universe_s_expansion_rate https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2024/03/Webb_Hubbl... above.
- westurner 3y agoHubble's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble%27s_law Expansion of the universe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe : > While objects cannot move faster than light, this limitation only applies with respect to local reference frames and does not limit the recession rates of cosmologically distant objects Given that v is velocity in the opposite direction, and c is the constant reference frame speed of light; do we account for velocity in determining whether light traveling at c towards earth will ever reach us? v - c < 0 if v>c v + c > c if v>0 Are tachyons FTL, is there entanglement FTL? How far away in light years does a mirror in space need to be in order to see dinosaurs that existed say 100 million years ago?
- blackbear_ 3y ago> do we account for velocity in determining whether light traveling at c towards earth will ever reach us? As far as I know this is not necessary because the speed of light is constant regardless of the velocity of both the source and the observer (this is Einstein's special relativity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_relativity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_relativity)
- westurner 3y ago> Expansion of the universe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe : >> While objects cannot move faster than light, this limitation only applies with respect to local reference frames and does not limit the recession rates of cosmologically distant objects Then the length traveled changes for two photons emitted when they cross the starting line at different velocities: const d = distance = 1 # d_start = 0 # d_finish = d c: Velocity # of a photon in a vacuum v1: Velocity # of photon emission source 1 v2: Velocity # of photon emission source 2 v1 + c != v2 + c distance / (v1 + c) ?= distance / (v2 + c) ((v1 + c)*t) - ((v2+c)*t) ?!= 0 Should (v + c) be prematurely reduced to just (c), with a confirmed universal expansion rate?
- arbitrage 3y ago
- tzs 3y agoA little background based on a few articles about this plus my recollection of PBS Space Time videos on this: There are at least two ways to try to figure out the rate of expansion of the universe (which is called the Hubble Constant). • From variations in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) which are the result of certain conditions in the early universe it is possible to figure out what the expansion rate should be now. • From looking at very distant galaxies and noting how far away they are and how fast they are receding from us the expansion rate can be calculated. Theory says that these should give the same expansion rate. When the rates were first found using those two methods they gave different results, but the error bars on both were large enough to overlap. People expected then that further refinement of both methods to decrease the error bars would converge to some common value. That did not happen. Refinement of the CMB measurements got to 67 +/- 0.5, and refinement of the galaxy distance/speed method got to 73 +/- 1. Those do not overlap. This non-overlap between the possible ranges given by the two methods is called the Hubble tension, and it is one of the most irksome problems in cosmology. Possible explanations include: • Some sort of error in how we measure the variations in the CMB. • Some sort of error in the distant galaxy distance or speed measurements, which until the James Webb telescope were almost entirely Hubble telescope measurements. • We're missing something in our understanding of the physics. These new results add a bunch of data from the James Webb telescope, which observes in different wavelengths than Hubble. These results fit with the Hubble measurements. They do not resolve the Hubble tension. What they do is remove most doubt that the distant galaxy results involve some sort of Hubble measurement error. I believe cosmologists are pretty confident of the CMB measurements, and so this will be interpreted as telling us that the Hubble tension is not just a problem with our measurements. There is either physics that we got wrong or physics we need to discover.
- rf15 3y agoThis, together with the endless philosophising around dark energy, dark matter and whatnot paints a pretty strong arrow towards our models having some flaws when it comes to their large-scale application. I hope to live long enough to see where we made our mistake and get a better model.
- 3y ago
- rmbyrro 3y agoThe scale of the universe sometimes feels terrifying to me
- swader999 3y agoIt's not if you consider we can only move at less than the speed of light or that we go on forever.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThe thing that strikes me, is the detailed image description. That looks like good fodder for an ML visitor.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- harywilke 3y agoDr.Becky goes over this in a video [0] from a year ago about the divergent results obtained by the two main ways we measure the rate of expansion. Cosmic Microwave Background Vs. Supernovae. As the accuracy of each method has improved, the end results have diverged. [0] 'theJWST just made the "Crisis in Cosmology" WORSE' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hps-HfpL1vc&t=858s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hps-HfpL1vc&t=858s
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pigpang 3y agoUnfortunatelly, title of article on HN contradicts content of article, so many HN readers skip article because of "confirmed" (in other words: nothing new). IMHO, a Tired Light theory will better explain facts, but it will require paradigm shift, so there will be a lot of resistance before revolution.
- luc4sdreyer 3y ago> but it will require paradigm shift, so there will be a lot of resistance before revolution. I think the main point of resistance is the incompatibility with observations. All Tired light models have been falsified: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tired_light#Specific_falsified_models https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tired_light#Specific_falsified... If you're aware of a model that can fit some or all of our observations, please share it!
- pigpang 3y agoI have my own theory, which is not disproved yet: gravitational background noise slow down light a bit. Gravitation affects whole stream of photons in uniform way, not individual photons. Moreover, it doesn't change direction of photons, so no blur or scattering. My napking maths, which I did few months ago, tells that gravitational delaying should case effect of same magnitude as in red shift, (I did calculation for one frequency only, for proper calculation I need to know the temperature of the noise).
- luxuryballs 3y agothose are some pretty old energy waves
- arcastroe 3y agoI've asked this question before, but I don't think I received a good answer, so figured I'd try asking again. How do we know that galaxies are accelerating away from us and not moving at constant speed? People often point to the observation that the further away a galaxy is, the faster it appears to be moving away from us, implying acceleration. However, wouldn't we expect to see the same observation even without any acceleration? Imagine there are some objects in space all moving in random directions and speeds, relative to Earth. After long enough time, all objects will appear to be moving away from Earth, even if they were moving towards it initially. And after long enough time, the objects that move fastest should be farthest away, by the simple definition of speed! In short, even if galaxies weren't accelerating, we would still see that the further away a galaxy is, the faster it recedes.
- runeb 3y agoTheir light is more red shifted the farther away they are. I'm no expert on this, but I believe in a constant-speed scenario they would have equal red shift no matter the distance
- willis936 3y agoThe assumption made here is that relative velocity is the only method that would redshift light. Gravitational redshift is a thing and our model of gravity is incomplete.
- pdonis 3y ago> The assumption made here is that relative velocity is the only method that would redshift light. Not in our actual model of the universe, no. The redshift of light is determined by the spacetime geometry and the worldlines of the emitter and receiver. That is a general formula that works in any spacetime. > Gravitational redshift is a thing Not for the universe as a whole, no. Gravitational redshift is only meaningful in certain kinds of spacetimes, namely stationary spacetimes (which, roughly speaking, describe objects that either don't change with time at all, or which are periodic, like a rotating planet or star). The spacetime that describes our universe as a whole is not stationary and there is no meaningful concept of gravitational redshift. > our model of gravity is incomplete In the sense that we do not have a quantum theory of gravity, yes. But that does not affect anything under discussion here. Our current theory of gravity, GR, works fine for treating the expansion of the universe and whether or not it is accelerating.
- m3kw9 3y agoIf we can travel faster than light does it blow up the theory that the universe expands? Because if we can travel faster than light the universe is theoretically be infinite if I can go to a point pas the furthest reaches of stars/matter.
- not2b 3y agoIf we can travel faster than light, that would blow up all the theories that say that we cannot. And FTL travel would imply time travel (if in your reference frame, something is traveling faster than light, there's another reference frame where it is going backwards in time). A lot of science fiction just sweeps this under the table and pretends that we have Newtonian absolute time to go along with the FTL travel.
- m3kw9 3y agoIf we can do FTL it may just prove that light speed can be achieved by brute force, or an alternative method. No laws needs to be broken and new laws can be found. Like quantum physics and classical physics.
- mjfl 3y agoIt is very fortunate that the universe is expanding. This provides a virtually unlimited source of energy.
- digging 3y agoWithout being able to harvest dark energy, it's actually the exact opposite.
- mjfl 3y agoThe extra energy comes from the increase in gravitational potential energy between objects. The accelerating increase in this potential energy implies the total energy of the universe is increasing. I’m not talking about harvesting dark energy directly.
- antod 3y agoI'm no physicist, but isn't the gravitational potential energy between two objects inversely proportional to the distance between them?
- mjfl 3y agoit is, in the negative direction though. So increasing the distance increases the potential energy by making -1/r closer to zero.
- antod 3y agoHeh, I had to go off and read some stuff to get my head around what "negative" potential energy would even mean (high school physics was decades ago). So... the negative is just a convention to represent work done against the "field", and positive is work done by the field? ie more of a vector than actually being negative energy? I think I get that bit now. So now I'm wondering if that still applies to an expanding universe vs eg a rocket leaving earth. If things aren't moving further apart by work (ie force x distance) being done against their gravitational fields so much as space time expanding, is there an increase in potential energy? And then if objects are moving apart faster than escape velocity, could that still be seen as increasing potential energy? I think I'm confusing myself further...
- fsckboy 3y agogiven that a telescope conceived while Bill Clinton was president in the 1990's got named so as to complete the name "Webb Hubble", let's please please please call the next telescope "Chelsea". https://pagesix.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2020/02/chelsea-clinton-2.jpg https://pagesix.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2020/02/chels... https://www.wnd.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Webb-Hubbell_Chelsea-Clinton.jpg https://www.wnd.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Webb-Hubbell_... (Chelsea Clinton's resemblance to Clinton family friend Webb Hubble has prompted speculation...)
- yen223 3y agoI now really want to know what prompt was used to generate this text
- acyou 3y agoEven though the title is copied from the article, we should change the title to "New data indicates the Webb and Hubble telescopes agree on the universe's expansion rate, but not with the cosmic microwave background measurement based expansion rate"
- arbitrage 3y agoThat's a mouthful. The title should be "Hubble Tension almost certainly not caused by measurement error."
- russdill 3y agoEven the article seems confusing at first. The new measurements don't seem to be shedding light on anything or removing any confusion. They just confirm that hubble measurements already made. The Hubble tension remains as confounding a problem as ever.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sixnineshot 3y ago[flagged]
- dbtc 3y agoCan someone help me understand - point me toward some reading or ELI5 - what is the universe expanding into? (Or probably, why is that question not formulated well?)
- digging 3y agoThe universe is not expanding into anything. It is infinite. However, new space is being created in the voids between objects. It isn't super intuitive or particularly easy to grasp, things are just getting farther apart.
- andreareina 3y agoOne of the quantities described by Einstein's equations of General Relativity is the metric tensor—a matrix of matrices—that describes how "far" things are in space and time given the stuff in the local environment. One of the things that the equation tells us is that objects that are not gravitationally bound will tend to get farther away from each other as time passes. We call this the expansion of space. As far as we can tell, there isn't anything "outside" the universe is expanding "into"; distances just become larger somehow.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- modelofdemocray 3y agoit's not going to expand faster than what you're able to observe
- sudom82 3y agoThis article is titled "Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate", however I don't see the expansion rate actually listed there, or in the comments. I see a mention of age, but not the rate. Does anyone know the rate? I clicked through to the paper itself[1], but wasn't able to interpret it from the details I could see [1]: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/2041-8213/ad1ddd https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/2041-8213/ad1ddd
- russdill 3y agoIt seems like a better title would be "Webb confirms Hubble's measurement of Universe's expansion rate"
- ta8645 3y agoDon't know why, but I recently got this gentleman's channel in my feed, who believes that there is no expansion at all: https://youtu.be/TGpjGVNVYEg?t=397 https://youtu.be/TGpjGVNVYEg?t=397 It's beyond my depth to explain why he's wrong.
- pmayrgundter 3y agoAlexander Unziker. Also Eric Lerner, Pierre Robitaille
- physicles 3y agoThe article mentions the cosmic distance ladder, which is one of my favorite things in all of science. How do we know how far away the really far stuff is? It's non-trivial and I find the history fascinating. It all started with knowing the distance from the earth to the sun. Nobody had a clue until Richer and Cassini got within 10% in 1672. Then we nailed it down in 1769 with James Cook's voyage to Tahiti, the primary purpose of which was to observe the transit of Venus from the other side of the world. From there if you know basic geometry, you can observe the nearby stars shift a bit when the earth goes around the sun (parallax), but that only works to about 10k light years. Then, we discovered a couple unbelievably convenient astrophysics hacks: Cepheid variables (Henrietta Swan Leavitt, 1908) and Type 1A supernovae (Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, 1935, the namesake of the Chandra X-Ray Observatory). These allowed us to move out a couple more rungs on the ladder. From there, the relationship between redshift and distance becomes significant and that takes us to the edge. https://www.uwa.edu.au/science/-/media/Faculties/Science/Docs/Explanation-of-the-cosmic-distance-ladder.pdf https://www.uwa.edu.au/science/-/media/Faculties/Science/Doc...
- rexer 3y agoGreat comment! Maybe you can help me with a book recommendation? I was recently looking for a book which was basically your comment, but more in depth and covered the last couple thousand years. I wanted a to read about the history of astronomy - yknow, what was the state of the art in, say, 1350 or whatever. If you know of anything, I’d be super interested!
- physicles 3y agoUnfortunately I don't have any books to recommend. I don't remember where I learned about Cepheid variables and type 1a supernovae (maybe science shows, maybe youtube, ...) but I learned about the transit of Venus stuff on a big Wikipedia rabbit hole one evening. I think the pre-quantum mechanics era for physics and astronomy is super interesting. People figured out so much with such primitive tools, and it's all very accessible and easy to understand.
- tails4e 3y ago
- bighoki2885000 3y ago[dead]
- quijoteuniv 3y agoIs it 42?
- merek 3y agoFor those interested in the cosmic distance ladder, David Butler has an excellent youtube series "How far away is it?", detailing the methods used to estimate distance along the cosmic distance ladder, the history, and examples. I highly recommend. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpH1IDQEoE8QWWTnWG5cK4ePCqg9W2608 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpH1IDQEoE8QWWTnWG5cK...
- jon_adler 3y agoThank you. This series of videos is extremely helpful for understanding the concepts referred to in the article.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoThe universe is not expanding. The atoms are getting smaller.
- pantulis 3y agoPlay player Euclid.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI don’t really understand how we can make conclusions about the entire universe when literally all of the data is collecting from one point in space. Couldn’t there be local effects that obfuscate global behavior? Is there an implicit caveat asterisk on all such statements that is like “as far as we can possibly tell from the data we have” and the reality is we really, really don’t know for sure?
- luc4sdreyer 3y ago>from one point in space - We have multiple observatories on and around the planet - The Earth is moving around the Sun - The Sun is moving around the centre of the galaxy - The galaxy is moving towards the great attractor, etc The Copernican principle states that humans, on the Earth or in the Solar System, are not privileged observers of the universe, that observations from the Earth are representative of observations from the average position in the universe. This has been tested in various ways: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_principle#Tests_of_the_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_principle#Tests_of_... A nice PBS spacetime video about the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-6oU3jXAho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-6oU3jXAho You can also ask how do we know that the laws of physics haven't changed over time. We don't. But at some point you have to make a few basic assumptions in order to have any hope of making scientific progress.
- mr_mitm 3y ago> “as far as we can possibly tell from the data we have” Isn't that self evident in all cases? In cosmology, the implicit assumptions are the Corpernican principle and that GR is correct. That is covered in introductory texts, but unless stated otherwise, it is usually not mentioned, especially not in press releases. I mean, maybe you're just a Boltzmann brain floating in space and nothing is real. Fun to think about, sure, but expecting to state the basics in any and all cases is unrealistic.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI’m not talking about physics being different in different places. I’m talking about the signal we are getting from far away quite likely being altered between its origin and when it gets to us. Different branches of science have vastly different degrees of certainty. I don’t feel there is sufficient effort put towards communicating this well to the public, especially with respect to the Big Bang, and that annoys me because lay people seem to use it as a factual version of an origin myth when really it probably isn’t any more factual than any other random myth you could pick. It’s very irresponsible to replace the cultural origin myth, which is psychologically important to humans. The whole “explosion from nothing” myth may actually be contributing to modern people’s feelings of meaninglessness.
- isolli 3y ago[Naive question warning] What if the cosmological constant (from which, if I understand correctly, the Hubble constant is derived) is not constant? Could a changing comological "constant" explain the discrepancy between the various methods of calculating the Hubble constant? From Wikipedia [0]: The cosmological constant "was revived and reinterpreted as the energy density of space, or vacuum energy, that arises in quantum mechanics. It is closely associated with the concept of dark energy." Do vacuum energy and dark energy have to be constant? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant
- kmm 3y agoThe Hubble constant is not necessarily derived from the cosmological constant. To be clear, it's not even a constant either, it's a proportionality factor between the recessional velocity of distant objects and their distance from us. Though in some usages it refers to the value of this factor at the current time, which would in fact make it a constant. Regardless, even without a cosmological constant, after the Big Bang you'd still have an expanding universe, possibly collapsing or endlessly expanding, and I like to think of the Hubble constant/parameter in this case as representing the "momentum" the matter in the universe has left from the Big Bang. The cosmological constant does in fact have to be constant within the constraints of general relativity. The mathematical machinery of GR only allows two parameters: Newton's constant G, representing the coupling of matter to gravity, and the cosmological constant. Both have to be true constants, numbers with a unit. However, this is only true of the most basic theory of dark energy, where you directly add a constant to the general relativistic lagrangian. More complicated theories, like, for example, quintessence, involve adding new dynamical fields to the theory. The "effective cosmological constant" associated to such theories, quantifying the effect these fields are having on the expansion of the universe, can dynamically change over time, and some of these theories are proposed to solve the Hubble tension. To be clear, although none of these theories are fringe or pseudoscience, they haven't been accepted as a final explanation either, resolving these issues is still a work in progress, at this point they're all simply interesting hypotheses.
- mr_mitm 3y agoDark energy is a constant in the standard model (equivalent to the cosmological constant) and all observations I'm aware of besides the Hubble tension are consistent with it being constant. But nothing stops you from going beyond the standard model, and people have done that and proposed models with a dynamic dark energy density, for example quintessence models. They'd solve some theoretical issues with the standard model, but so far no observations have been precise enough to differentiate between those models and the standard model. Having a dynamic dark energy is a proposed solution to the Hubble tension: https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.01183 https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.01183 That is, besides a whole family of potential other solutions: Dark energy in extended parameter spaces [289] Early Dark Energy [235] Early Dark Energy [229] Dynamical Dark Energy [309] Phantom Dark Energy [11] Decaying Warm DM [474] Metastable Dark Energy [314] Dynamical Dark Energy [11, 281, 309] Neutrino-DM Interaction [506] PEDE [392, 394] GEDE [397] Interacting dark radiation [517] Elaborated Vacuum Metamorphosis [400–402] Vacuum Metamorphosis [402] Self-Interacting Neutrinos [700, 701] IDE [314, 636, 637, 639, 652, 657, 661–663] IDE [314, 653, 656, 661, 663, 670] IDE [656] Self-interacting sterile neutrinos [711] Critically Emergent Dark Energy [997] Unified Cosmologies [747] Generalized Chaplygin gas model [744] f (T ) gravity [814] Scalar-tensor gravity [856] Galileon gravity [876, 882] ¨Uber-gravity [59] Modified recombination [986] Power Law Inflation [966] Reconstructed PPS [978] Super ΛCDM [1007] f (T ) [818] Coupled Dark Energy [650]
- jug 3y agoI can recommend Dr. Becky's introduction to the issues surrounding the Hubble Tension and recent JWST measurements in this 16 minute clip, as she introduces laymen to the problems well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hps-HfpL1vc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hps-HfpL1vc It's an older clip, but it checks out... ;) (still JWST discoveries and she most importantly introduces the viewer to the still remaining conflicts)
- ptmargah 3y ago[dead]
- kovacs_x 3y agoI'm 1000% sure, in 20, 50, 100, 500 years humans will look back on "science of 20/21th century" as we look now on say 16/17th century- there were some things that were "mostly" right, but most of it was incorrect / inprecise / incomplete and was a fantasy of earlier thought up models. It's been like that always. Don't think it'll be different this time. Though people of every time thought they had (almost) complete understanding of the universe. I remember reading that at the beginning of 20th century science was largerly considered complete... we know how it turned out! (think relativity, quantum physics, etc.) Think about that! (ps. me personally I just cannot stomach that universe is only <15B "years" old. Not saying there was no BANG! (ie. large cosmic event) back then and we're products of it :), but don't think it was "the beginning of everything". Seems very much like "god created universe!" type of thinking)
- Vecr 3y agoWhy? Sure, maybe a better number to give is "somewhere around 20", but it's difficult to tell how the "true number" could be over 100 or even 50.
- miramba 3y agoExplanation needed. How can you, a primitive ape on a tiny remote planet with an average lifespan of 80 years (not meant as an insult, I am too), be sure about what happened 15, 20 or 100 BILLION years ago? I think this is what parent meant with: "people of every time thought they had (almost) complete understanding of the universe." - "Don't think it'll be different this time."
- swamp40 3y agoI cannot for the life of me understand how you look at the cosmic background radiation - which appears equally in every direction you look, for as far away as you can see - and say this is evidence of a "big bang", originating from a single spot at a single point in time. And the universe just "expanded faster than light" to cover everywhere with the same consistent drab layer of cosmic background radiation. It seems like a child's fairy tale to me.
- SkyBelow 3y ago>originating from a single spot at a single point in time That's based on a simplified model of the big bang which isn't what scientist use. It is everywhere, and time itself isn't defined. One major result of this is that many people treat the visible universe as the universe, but those are two different concepts and while the visible universe is finite, the universe might not be (it might be infinite, finite unbounded, or finite unbounded). Also, science isn't saying "This is what happened". It is saying "Our best model to date says this is happening". In the end it is only a model and the model is still open to being refined and there is always the possibility of data resulting in the entire model being overturned, though often this leads to an ever more complex model that is harder to work with but better fits the experimental data (such as the wave/particle nature of light which is hard for a person to conceptualize).
- gitaarik 3y agoAnother interesting measurement discrepancy that scientists initially ascribed to measurement error is the Axis of Evil. The first space telescope Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE), launched in the 90's, that made a map the cosmic microwave background (CMB) included a pattern in it which aligns the CMB with the solar system's plane very precicely, which is hard to ascribe to chance. This contradicts the Copernican principle, which says that earth and the solar system is not special and any solar system and location in the universe is not special. Scientists thought it must be something to do with the COBE telescope which caused this anomaly. They thought it would disappear with the next space telescope. The second space telescope that measured the CMB, the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), launched in 2001, made a more precise, higher resolution image of the CMB. However, the anomaly was still there. Still scientists thought there must be something wrong in the measurements or calculations. They were keeping their hopes up for the third space telescope that would measure the CMB. The third space telescope, the Planck Surveyor, launched in 2009, made even more precise measurements. However, the anomaly still persists, and to this day. That is why the anomaly has gotten the name "Axis of Evil", because it defies all our understanding of the universe!
- thehappypm 3y agoFascinating! The flat earthers may be wrong about the Earth, but maybe the universe is rather flat!