29 ms·
Humanity Is Dangerously Pushing Its Ability to Tolerate Heat
- tvbv 3y agoThe scientific litterature and IPCC’s summaries warned about these phenomenon. When 2 billion people will be living under wet bulb temperature that can’t be tanked by the body it’s going to be a mess worldwide.
- hackerlight 3y agoPeople who live in the humid tropics are already on a knife's edge. A small increase makes the heat intolerable and you will see either mass death or mass waves of immigration. "Just build aircon" doesn't work when you're talking about people with intermittent (or no) electricity and who have an annual income equal to a single aircon unit.
- beAbU 3y agoSmol nit: immigration means moving into a country. In your example we'll see a lot of emigration, people moving out of the country. You emigrate from one country and thereafter you immigrate into another. Mnemonic: IN=IMmigrate, EXIT=Emigrate
- spyke112 3y agoEven smaller nit: Isn't it basically two sides of the same coin in this context? I'm not sure what the intent was in the previous post, but it could just as well be from the perspective of someone living in a desirable country worried about a lot of immigration of less fortunate people.
- beAbU 3y agoMy interpretation was that countries with growing cimate problems will start seeing more and more immigration, which is wrong. It'll see more and more emigration.
- tvbv 3y agoExactly.
- thworp 3y agoAll the more reason to urgently develop the world to at least the level of Malaysia / Thailand (or ~Western Europe ca. 1950). If we quit fossil fuels cold turkey it is those very same people in the tropics that will starve. But making that connection requires thinking about second order effects, a tall order for the degrowth cult.
- hackerlight 3y agoI want to continue growing, just replace fossil fuels with renewables or nuclear in all developed countries, and subsidize the same for poor countries who haven't historically emitted much and don't have the wealth to transition themselves. There isn't this false dichotomy of degrowth vs growth. We can grow our economy without growing emissions. https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2020/05/08/fatal-heat-humidity-emerging/ https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2020/05/08/fatal-heat-humi... The medium-term problem for these hot countries is that extreme heat negatively impacts education and economic productivity. Whenever there's a heatwave (which will become more frequent) they have to keep their kids home. Worker producitivity is negatively impacted. It's terrible for their economic development. The US and Australia and Canada continuing to pump more fossil fuels instead of simply building renewables does nothing help the average person in Sri Lanka living under 30+ degree heat. It is actively physically harming them in a very real way. It's an indirect, diffuse form of physical assault. The long-term problem for these hot countries is that wet bulb temperatures will make it literally uninhabitable unless you have electricity and aircon, which many don't. This is not a matter of if, it's a matter of when. If we keep emitting, temperatures will keep rising, until the point that this becomes true. It is causality. I want conservatives to think about this latter point because the consequences are mass immigration to colder countries, primarily the US and in Europe. Then the side-effect of that will probably be a rise in authoritarianism in these colder countries as a reaction to the mass immigration. None of this benefits anyone.
- thworp 3y agoThank you for the response and sorry if my comment was excessively snarky. I think we share the same concerns and have the same goals and even mostly agree on practical steps to get there. I've just seen and heard too many degrowth advocates (that really want to return to 19th century economy with 21st century populations) recently and it's really worrying me. > and subsidize the same for poor countries who haven't historically emitted much and don't have the wealth to transition themselves. Yes! With a fraction of the money sloshing around various "charities" and NGOs, mostly spent on salaries, you could build solar with storage for millions of people. Of course in practice it would be really complicated, you have to make sure the right people run the systems and there will be bad cases of corruption. But it really is the least we could do. > The US and Australia and Canada continuing to pump more fossil fuels The funny thing is that the market is turning even Australia and Texas into solar superpowers. Ever since solar became the cheapest form of generation both have seen an incredible boom in solar, with almost no policy incentives. This is a huge win for the planet, if people want to build solar because the incentives align they will just do it without costing larger society any (political) capital. > It is actively physically harming them in a very real way. It's an indirect, diffuse form of physical assault. I follow the logic and agree about the causality chain, but this is a road it's best not to go down. It quickly turns into personally blaming people for things they had no control over. That has never been a good way to persuade people. Imo it's also a lazy deflection, since humanity has never really paid any attention to its resource usage. The only difference is that Industrial societies gained the capability to affect the planet on such a large scale.
- cromulent 3y agoA friend of mine who lives in Queensland (Sunshine Coast) was talking about a recent spell of 32° and 100% humidity and how oppressive it was. My understanding is that such weather is not survivable long term [1] without air conditioning. A power failure would be disastrous. [1] https://www.psu.edu/news/research/story/humans-cant-endure-temperatures-and-humidities-high-previously-thought/ https://www.psu.edu/news/research/story/humans-cant-endure-t...
- lstodd 3y agoTry living in Goa in the monsoon season. Or even rewatch Apocalypse Now or basically any Vietnam war movie. I assure you, even 36C/100% is survivable.
- bowsamic 3y agoSurvivable for many, but still dangerous. 36C is at the limit though. 35C is already dangerous
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThe science says otherwise, but specific populations are likely better adapted to higher temperatures than the average. An extended period of 36C/100% is going to pose serious danger for most people
- vouaobrasil 3y agoYes that is true. I am very good at tolerating very high heat. But like you said, past the bulb temperature nothing can save you if you don't have something colder to exchang heat with.
- llamaimperative 3y agoThe average daily high for Goa in July is like 30C. No, 36C at 100% for an extended period (6-8 hours) is extremely, extremely lethal. Could some people survive it? Probably. But yeah, exaggerating how hot Goa is to dismiss the problem is sort of exactly the problem.
- seiferteric 3y agoThis is why I think we should be seriously considering atmospheric aerosol injection already. Not sure why there aren't more large government funded studies of this.
- infotainment 3y agoI believe this was the plot of the movie Snowpiercer. I would be a bit worried about accidental side effects; atmospheric alteration on a large scale seems like a dangerous game.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAnd book Termination Shock. One Billionaire took it upon himself to seed sulfur in upper atmosphere. And Not for global warming, but in The Matrix, humans darkened the skies to fight the machines.
- nozzlegear 3y agoTermination Shock is an excellent book, I'd highly recommend it if you're interested in the genre of "climate fiction" as I am. It deals with the effects of extreme heat in Texas; the rising sea levels in the Netherlands; how unpredictable weather patterns could affect the bread basket of India and the people living there; and much more. Easily one of my favorite books of the last few years.
- seiferteric 3y ago> atmospheric alteration on a large scale seems like a dangerous game. Were already doing that...
- ImHereToVote 3y agoYes, but we are doing the bad kind of alteration. The good kind of alteration is completely untested. /s
- ponector 3y ago
- coldtea 3y agoFun fact I remember reading in some studies: increased heat increases tendency for violence. Ah, not the ones I had in mind, but these will do: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/07/16/two-new-studies-warn-that-hotter-world-will-be-more-violent-one/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/07/16/two-new-s... https://www2.psych.ubc.ca/~schaller/308Readings/Anderson2001.pdf https://www2.psych.ubc.ca/~schaller/308Readings/Anderson2001...
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoEntirely obvious for anyone living in a city that both heat and the full moon have a tangible effect on that.
- amelius 3y agoExplanation?
- Server6 3y agoIts hot during the day, so people come out at night and can see if there's a full moon. Considering that it's still night, people may be drinking and can be generally up to no good.
- stephenitis 3y agofull moon? citation needed please
- coldtea 3y agoHere's one: "The incidence of crimes reported to three police stations in different towns (one rural, one urban, one industrial) was studied to see if it varied with the day of the lunar cycle. The period of the study covered 1978-82. The incidence of crimes committed on full moon days was much higher than on all other days, new moon days, and seventh days after the full moon and new moon". https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1444800/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1444800/ And here's a different take from Finland: "Conclusions Contrary to current scientific opinion, an association exists between moon phases and homicides, and contrary to what has been previously assumed, homicides declined during the full moon, especially in earlier decades. However, the causality of the association remains elusive" https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/9/1/e022759 https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/9/1/e022759
- wiz21c 3y agofta: "Our best hope in the face of inevitable rises in heat? Cooperation. “We’ve built forecasting systems that will warn us when disasters are incoming by working together at enormous scale. We must continue to do the same.” This sentence basically says "we don't need to make less disasters, just better handle them".
- wolfram74 3y agoWell, the global system has a lot of mass. It'll take time to fix the things we've messed up. To survive in the interim while we do that, there'll need to be some harm mitigation measures.
- marcinzm 3y agoTo me it says "we'll never succeed at making fewer disasters given how we've done so far, so we better learn to handle them better."
- Panzer04 3y agoIt's pretty clear attempting to get numerous bad actors to fix their polluting behaviour isn't going to make things happen any faster (and is in any case a monumentally different task). So we must deal with the problem after it occurs, instead.
- humansareok1 3y agoOr we can't make less disasters so we better handle them.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI've heard this argument used to say climate change isn't happening, because there are less deaths. Hurricanes aren't getting stronger, because there are less deaths. But ignores we are getting better at predicting land falls and evacuating. Responding to disasters 'better', doesn't mean disasters are not getting worse. And there is some diminishing return, eventually the disasters will overwhelm the ability to respond.
- nedrylandJP 3y agoDon't worry, our lawmakers will save us. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/08/florida-bill-extreme-heat-worker-protection https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/08/florida-bill...
- infotainment 3y agoCan we just declare political entities who push climate negative policies an existential threat to humanity and neutralize them?
- wwilim 3y agoIf only everybody everywhere voted for left-wing parties instead of right-wing populists...
- adrianN 3y agoIf only everyone voted for parties who don't deny science...
- mistermann 3y agoAh yes, our two most sacred institutions: democracy and science, neither of which have a (literally) actionable plan to solve the problem at its source: human behavior. The twin hills that humanity may die on if something doesn't happen to wake people up to their foolishness.
- adrianN 3y agoWe have a large number of actionable plans that happen to reduce profits for very rich organizations that hence spend a lot of money to prevent their implementation.
- mistermann 3y agoYour "actionable" makes assumptions about the true nature of several things, one of them being democracy. I can make a semi-actionable plan to fly, but if I am not able to achieve flight via the plan, in fact, my plan is not fully actionable, so this fully part is a pretty big deal. What if you people are wrong? Like, what is it about certain topics that cause having backup plans to be a bad idea? Why are there certain topics that people are determined to not contemplate, even if they are literally existential threats? If we can't talk about the topics themselves, could we at least talk about the second order mass psychological phenomenon, or is that off limits too? I pose this as a question to humans in general, sorry if I'm taking it out on you individually.
- wwilim 3y agoSleep underground during the day, crawl out at sunset and work through the night
- cute_boi 3y agoThis assumes we don't need any ecosystem like farming etc in that area.
- bell-cot 3y agoAnd it doesn't work longer-term, because "cool ground sandwiched between hot lithosphere and hot atmosphere" ain't gonna remain cool.
- triceratops 3y agoDo you think everyone already has basements?
- nrvn 3y agoPeople from Middle East and Northern Africa who have been living in harsh conditions for the last several THOUSAND years send regards to all climate change researchers.
- miramba 3y ago...and the rest of Africa, Indonesia and northern South America too. Talk about eurocentric...
- silverquiet 3y agoCan we make the conditions for them even harsher? Does that not seem like a problem?
- Qem 3y agoThey face dry heat, not humid, extreme heat. These are different problems. Dry heat easier to solve.
- genman 3y agoYou mean the desert people, like the people living in complete opposite conditions to high humidity?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lp4vn 3y agoI used to live in a subtropical region when I was a child in the 90s and it's pretty remarkable how hot the winters are today over there. That experience alone taught me that no way the climate change is not real. It's a bit like with the economy, you feel something is pretty wrong, but a lot of people for one reason or another will deny and try to brush it off, then after many years you get to see articles about how tough times have been in the last X years.
- jessekv 3y agoCountries stock up on masks to prepare for future pandemics. What can/do they stock up on to prepare for extended heat waves? Ground water reserves? Generators and fuel? Underground shelters?
- tejohnso 3y agoI don't know about countries, but I'd look into a ground source off grid heat pump.
- bell-cot 3y ago's/look into a/look into an extremely reliable/' (At least in my part of America, HVAC equipment failures under season-maximum loads are extremely common. And if failure = death...) And maybe keep kinda quiet about it, too. If your nice & friendly neighbors are facing death by heat stroke, they could grow considerably less nice & friendly.
- scruple 3y agoWe have solar and a battery and I think about this sometimes. Air conditioners are very noisy and solar panels are on display for anyone to see. People know. It's not an actual, safe off-grid solution during a major event when you're in the middle of suburbia.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> What can/do they stock up on to prepare for extended heat waves? Power.
- slashdev 3y agoCold kills more people according to the literature [1]. Heat deaths are rising, cold deaths are falling. Not in the same places though. Countries near the equator are going to suffer more than countries at higher latitudes. Demand for air conditioning is expected to more than triple by 2050 (consuming as much electricity as all of China and India today). [2] [1] https://www.thinkglobalhealth.org/article/hot-cold-and-deadly https://www.thinkglobalhealth.org/article/hot-cold-and-deadl... [2] https://www.climatecentral.org/climate-matters/hotter-climate-higher-cooling-demand-2023 https://www.climatecentral.org/climate-matters/hotter-climat...
- tejohnso 3y ago> Demand for air conditioning is expected to more than triple by 2050 Which further exacerbates the problem. Another unfortunate feedback loop for us.
- petrocrat 3y agoThough demand for heating should be falling simultaneously, no? I wonder what the net CO2 tradeoff is there. At least historically with burning fuels to create heat, that likely contributed more per unit of degree-change than AC, however with Heat pumps now that's probably either a wash or reversed, if I had to guess.
- megaman821 3y agoYeah, there is a lot more energy spent for heating, https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/homes.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/homes.php. Climate change is a problem, but this narrative that poor people near the tropics will needs to use some energy, the world is ending is kinda gross. Even with ACs they will only use a fraction of the energy of people living in Finland or Canada. Plus, the energy they do use will have a lower carbon footprint.
- anonreeeeplor 3y ago[flagged]
- calabin 3y agoHow do you reconcile recent extreme weather and weather events with your apparent view that most climate reporting is fake? Or that recent years have all been the hottest in modern human history? Your comment isn't very useful, and not in the spirit of HN with regard to helpful/thoughtful discussion. It's just complaining without evidence.
- scoot 3y agoDemo-what-ic? The article (admittedly brief and as lacking corroborative research) was published in WIRED UK, and quotes "Tom Matthews, a senior lecturer in environmental geography at King’s College London". The examples included the UK in summer 2022 (I lived through that. Not fun, and I'm glad it was only a few days!), Lagos, Karachi, and Shanghai. No the US isn't immune [0], but regardless, to argue that this specific article is Democratic election propaganda is just nuts. The world does not revolve around your oyster. [0] https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-people-die-from-extreme-heat-in-the-us/ https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-people-die-from-extre... (but pick your source – there are many)
- flightster 3y agoCooling by a degree takes less energy than heating by a degree (not to mention it's electric). Cooling a house from 35 (outside) to 23 (inside) takes is better for "the environment" than heating one from 11 to 23.
- api_or_ipa 3y agoWhy wouldn’t running a heat pump in reverse to heat a room be ~same energy as running it in forward to cool a room? I suspect you’re comparing an airconditioner against a resistive heating unit.
- flightster 3y agoYes with heat pumps you're 100% correct but right now most of the US north does not use heat pumps to heat their house while the vast majority of the south US does use A/C which is way better per degree of temperature change than say heating oil which the vast majority of New England still uses.
- jameshart 3y agoWhat’s the basis for this claim? Maintaining a fixed temperature difference across a wall with a fixed thermal conductivity takes the same amount of energy no matter which side of the wall you want to keep the heat. On the other hand, any inefficiencies in your heat transfer capability, any incoming solar radiation, and any other activity going on inside a space (like lighting, cooking or refrigeration, or just people metabolizing their breakfast) tend to add heat to it. So maintaining a cooler temperature on the side where you’re trying to do stuff seems likely to be more inefficient than heating it.
- amelius 3y agoWe're basically boiled frogs, except we're the ones applying the heat.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoHumanity? Really? If so, it's because of such newspeak. To be clear, it's primarily The West and primarily greed (i.e., profits at all costs) that are conducting this experiment. What is this? A reprint of a press release from Big Oil and Big Ag? And Big Gov? Most of the billions didn't choose it. A good chunk of the billions aren't even aware. Shame on you Wired for diluting the accountability and giving those who should be blamed a free pass. Sheeshhhhhh. Humanity? My arse.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoClassic HN irony, down voted...which only proves the point being made. That is, from too early a biased \ distracting narrative has been rolled out; most just feel in line and parroted that mindset as good zombies do. Yes Virginia, they even roam the sacred intellectual grounds of Planet HN. In short, we can't solve a problem, when we can't even have The Problem properly described, scooped, attributed to, etc. To blame "Humanity" *is* a step in the wrong direction. It is naive, at best.
- lakomen 3y agoWe all know this, but what's the point when not enough is being done to make our habitat better or at least not make it largely inhabitable. And in some cases, looking at Australia, it's gone full throttle CO2, like it's not sitting in a glasshouse already.