6 ms·
Can We Just Throw in the Towel on Airport Security Theater Already?
- bediger4000 3y agoHow many terrorists does any of the security theatre measures catch on a given day? One, ten, one hundred, one thousand? $20 says it's zero. How many bellicose self righteous idiots get through every day? Probably 10. Which causes more problems?
- jackphilson 3y agoThere's a detterence factor in play. Terrorists won't try to get through precisely because of the intense security.
- bigstrat2003 3y agoIf there were terrorists, they would just open fire on the crowded security checkpoints and kill hundreds of people without any complex scheme. This doesn't happen because there is no terrorist threat we need to be on guard against.
- StableAlkyne 3y agoIf it's so obvious, then why didn't this happen on 9/11? Edit: I'm aware that the TSA was created after 9/11. The point I'm making is that it's possible they were able to bring weapons aboard to hijack the planes because security was so lax.
- wrs 3y agoSecurity checkpoints weren’t crowded before 9/11 because it didn’t take 15 minutes to get through security. I guess this is becoming lost ancient history. There was no ID check. There wasn’t even a boarding pass check — you routinely accompanied departing friends to their gate to see them off. There was none of this shoes off, no liquids, laptop out of the bag, just an x-ray and a metal detector. The threat model before 9/11 was hijacking, not suicide bombers.
- noirbot 3y agoBecause a hour-long security line is something that happened after? IIRC there actually was a terrorist attack on a TSA line in the early 2000s.
- bediger4000 3y agoYes, that's why we couldn't bring more than 4 ounces of liquid on planes. The theatre about liquids did nothing to address the problems revealed by that attack.
- CrazyStat 3y agoThere weren’t crowded security checkpoints on 9/11.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoI think you'll find terrorists do exist, and you do need to be on your guard. Whether the specific airplane controls we have now are effective or required is still a good conversation to have, but you draw the wrong conclusion if you think there is simply no threat.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoI used to think this until I realized that the theoretical point isn't to prevent great loss of life, it's to prevent the usage of airplanes as a weapon. Malls, subways, concerts, sports games were always target-rich...targets, but a plane can be used to attack infrastructure and militarily significant targets (e.g. the Pentagon) and to kill far more people with lighter weapons than you could otherwise. Of course, this could never happen. It's been said to death, but the conventional wisdom before 9/11 was to allow plane hijackers to run their course and assume that all they wanted was cash, to just sit tight and wait for them to set down somewhere. Not even after, but mid 9/11 people realized that old paradigm was out and the passengers of the fourth plane the cockpit door, preventing the usage of the plane as a weapon. Post 9/11, nobody could hijack a plane with box-cutters anymore - enough people would rather be stabbed than see their plane be used as a weapon that it's simply insufficient, especially since if they crash the plane you're probably dead anyway.
- navane 3y agoSix people each bring 50ml tooth paste on a plane, after take off, they combine it to 300ml. What are you gonna do.
- harkinian 3y agoMaybe 300ml is still fine, but they set the limit to 50ml so it takes too many people to combine them into something useful. Also idk what a ml is.
- andrewaylett 3y agoI was quite shocked after a few years of liquid checks to discover that it is actually in response to a realistic threat. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_transatlantic_aircraft_plot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_transatlantic_aircraft_pl... -- details that emerged during the trial, and the conclusion reported by El Reg: https://www.theregister.com/2008/09/10/liquid_bomb_verdicts/ https://www.theregister.com/2008/09/10/liquid_bomb_verdicts/
- Ekaros 3y agoI always wondered about well planned groups. Like wouldn't they use other avenues, infiltrate not as passengers, but as workers or import stuff to shops and restaurants... Either by getting hired or paying some poorly paid worker.
- cm2187 3y agoI think not only zero, but zero cumulatively for the last 30 years. I can't think of a single example of a terrorist attack foiled at airport security.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe question is how many have they ever caught. Restricting it to a single day is way too ambitious. The answer is they are not telling you. They are not telling if it's zero either.
- s3r3nity 3y agoidk ... on the flip side I'm old enough to remember when the shoe bomber was caught MID-FLIGHT and people were rightfully scared.[1] Like, holy shit: you can hide bombs in your shoes?! And that was only THREE months after the 9/11 attacks. [1] https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/shoe-bomber-richard-reid-flight https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/shoe-bomber-rich...
- metabagel 3y agoThanks to that one idiot, we have to take off our shoes as part of the screening process.
- nprateem 3y agoIf it wasn't for this so-called "theatre", I'd have accidentally got on a plane with more than 50ml of toothpaste last week, and I'm sure I don't need to explain the damage that would have caused.
- buggy6257 3y agoHow are you still allowed to fly you monster
- swasheck 3y agolast week i accidentally flew SAN -> DEN with not one, but TWO new full-sized tubes of toothpaste without incident. we were so lucky to have avoided catastrophe.
- harkinian 3y agoI flew LAX -> SVO with a large folding knife in my pocket by accident, and somehow they didn't notice.
- advisedwang 3y agoI wish they would just staff adequately! I'll take off my shoes, get scanned, listen to contradictory instructions, suffer "random" pat downs, whatever. Just have enough agents checking IDs and keeping scanning lines open so that the queue doesn't get to be 45mins long!
- jannyfer 3y agoScope, time, and cost (staffing level) - the triple constraint. In my opinion it's far better to cut down scope than to add cost.
- kibwen 3y agoWe can stop dancing around the issue while pretending we don't understand why the TSA exists. In the aftermath of 9/11, the government has to be seen doing "something". This was the something. Then, in the following years, the TSA evolved into a welfare program for veterans, because here in the US we can't dream of just giving people money, we have to invent bullshit jobs that make society worse.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoA jobs program with negative utility for the US. Would be nicer if the jobs program was picking up all the trash everywhere.
- rwmj 3y agoOr keeping public toilets gleaming clean, which seems to be the jobs program for the elderly in Japan.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoNo one values this work, and so it’s an identity and status issue. “Soldiers” vs janitors and people who keep the lights on. (“Support our troops”, “back the blue”, etc).
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> No one values this work No one pays for this work. Give people an appropriate salary and benefits like TSA workers get, and there will be no problem. Also, TSA worker is negative status.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> Also, TSA worker is negative status. Someone mentioned upthread this is a job for veterans because we won’t pay UBI or similar. It’s status enough, in some cases (“make work for veterans”.
- GiorgioG 3y agoIt's a job program. End of story.
- the_common_man 3y agoI don't understand the hate for TSA. Sure, it can be better. But does anyone dare board a plane when none of the passengers have been screened?
- xboxnolifes 3y agoTons of people did dare in the past, and also continue to dare with regards to other transit.
- eat_veggies 3y agoyes, the way people dared to board planes pre-9/11, and the way people dare to board trains, buses, and ferries today.
- drstewart 3y agoYou think people weren't screened pre 9/11? Are you under 24 years old by any chance?
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoLiterally just walked up to the gate. Only thing was the gate attendant checked your ID against the ticket. That was all. No metal detectors. No screening. Just walk up to the gate an get on. One time my mate forgot his drivers license, and missed the flight. So harsh!
- drstewart 3y agoYeah, no, you're definitely either under 24 or over 80.
- bombcar 3y agoIf said plane is the only unscreened flight out of Tel-Aviv? Maybe I'd have some reservations. But if all flights were completely unscreened? It wouldn't change what or when I fly. I already board unscreened trains and busses quite often.
- skadamat 3y agoI would love one presidential candidate to include this in their platform. I have yet to hear this (unless I just missed this person!). A massive overhaul & reduction in all of this security theater. NSA and others already do the heavy lifting of identifying people planning bad things. Can we just do a basic metal detector or something and call it a day?
- mistermann 3y agoA reduction in security theater may have a dependency on reduction in democracy theater. :(
- rwmj 3y agoWell one candidate has you covered. He wants to dismantle the DHS. Unfortunately his platform comes with a certain amount of other baggage. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025
- Spivak 3y agoTangent: Is this something actually serious or is it more of saber-rattling manifesto because good lord it's terrifying.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoOh, it's serious. Sure, he doesn't have the logistical or institutional knowledge and abilities to actually execute on it on its own, but his allies do, and they've shown that they'll do whatever it takes to keep riding this tiger, even at the cost of the country.
- ianburrell 3y agoIt is completely serious. It is put out by the Heritage Foundation and has input from a bunch of conservative organizations including many with close ties to Trump campaign.
- renata 3y ago
- insane_dreamer 3y agoJust stop with the stupid/useless take off your shoes, and take your laptops/ipads out of your bags, and I'm fine with the rest.
- toddmorey 3y agoIt seems most airports have stopped asking for devices and toiletries to be removed from your bag. That’s been a nice upgrade.
- exitb 3y agoThe ones I frequent tend to ask to remove the small liquids, but I don’t do that anyway. It almost never comes up, which somehow makes it even worse.
- JohnBooty 3y agoDo you know when they stopped? It's been ~14 months since I last flew in the US and they were still making me take evvvvverryyyything out. At the time I was typically travelling with a laptop, a tablet, and two USB-C portable monitors. It was quite a lot to unpack and re-pack. NB: Out of concern for the sanity of myself and my fellow travelers sharing a TSA I made sure I could do it as fast as humanly possible. Everything was packed to allow the quickest possible retrieval in line...
- notacoward 3y agoYou touch on one of the most annoying things about TSA: the inconsistency. Every airport seems to have slightly different rules, and the agents treat you like an idiot if you don't know theirs. Sorry, Mr. Cop School Reject, I've been to ten other airports this year and none of them did it your way. Even the same airport can vary sometimes. It's impossible to believe the rules are doing any good when each of them is skipped half the time and there's no effect at all.
- harkinian 3y agoMost of them still seem to require removing devices. I've only seen a few with the newer machines that don't require it.
- olliej 3y agoNo. If we don’t take our shoes off, how will we maintain our freedom?!?!
- saagarjha 3y agoI don’t get it. This country gives me the right to bare arms and yet asks me to show me feet?
- feoren 3y agoIf you're ever wondering why something in the U.S. can't be made better, the answer is often that the existing rent-collectors must be allowed to continue collecting their rent at all costs. This is why we can't have the government file taxes on our behalf: because Intuit would no longer be collecting rent, and rent-collecting must be protected at all costs. This is why we can't have a single-payer healthcare system: because insurance companies must keep collecting their rent. This is why the TSA is here to stay: it collects rent from the taxpayers, the airports, and the passengers. Any modification to the system must include ways for the rent-collectors to continue collecting rent from someone. TSA Precheck is a way for you to say: it's fine, TSA, I'll pay rent directly to you, so that I can avoid the worst parts of your services. It, of course, has nothing to do with actually pre-checking that certain passenger are low-risk -- it's just a solution to the problem of "but if we made the system more efficient, how would we still collect rent?" Collect it directly from the passengers themselves, for the privilege of avoiding the worst parts of dealing with you.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoGood comment. I'll add that one solution is to simply not fly through TSA airports. I flew JSX last weekend and security was a swab for explosives and a metal detector. It took 30 seconds. Ticket says to arrive to the airport 15 minutes before departure. I'm not sure how scalable flying out of regional airports is, but the extra $200 was worth the price for a) not burning an hour arriving and b) having a large enough seat to work while airborne. And the other option is of course to invest in HSR where possible.
- daveguy 3y agoWhy stop there? ...Let them fly private! I don't know about you, but $200 is a lot for me to pay to save an hour.
- bradlys 3y agoI don’t typically spend an hour at the airport either. This is why SFO is generally amazing and my favorite airport in the country. I often show up after boarding has started and have never been close to missing a flight.
- etaioinshrdlu 3y agoI'm not convinced the TSA is needed to stop terrorism, but it probably helps a good deal with protecting passengers from ordinary psychotic Americans, of which there seem to be a significant increase over the last 20 or so years.
- saagarjha 3y agoOrdinary psychotic Americans who get upset at me if I ask if I need to take my computer out and put it in a bin? Not sure it’s doing a good job at that.
- deltarholamda 3y agoI've watched enough YouTube videos, I don't think it's working.
- ethanbond 3y agoLast year TSA intercepted almost seven thousand firearms at security checkpoints, 93% of which were loaded. So take all those crazy people, then add firearms into their vicinity, or a firearm into the hands of a well-meaning but panicking co-passenger now trying to "secure" a crowd of 300 people 30,000 feet in the air.
- notacoward 3y agoSo TSA creates these unnecessarily long lines and stressful conditions, and some of the people in those lines have guns? Only a matter of time before that ends very badly.
- dylan604 3y agoRonny Chieng's bit on The Daily Show was good. "So now it includes a Zoom meeting?"
- ilamont 3y agoSpeaking of irritating airport protocols: If you are a US citizen or permanent resident and you're coming into the US from abroad, download the CBP MPC app. You add family members to it with a passport scan, then up to 4 hours before passing through customs, submit your arrival location, take a photo of yourself, and then use the "Mobile Passport Control" lane. https://www.cbp.gov/travel/us-citizens/mobile-passport-control https://www.cbp.gov/travel/us-citizens/mobile-passport-contr... Used it last month coming through SFO and almost no one is in the MPC line compared to 1000+ in the standard lines.
- kyboren 3y agoThis is bullshit. It's a ploy to further under-staff the screening area and even further discourage people from exercising their right to a manual screening procedure that does not involve a full-body scan. I insist on a manual opt-out every time I fly, and I've noticed particularly in LAS that TSA seems intentionally to delay that screening process as an extrajudicial punishment and disincentive. It's outrageous and this intentional crippling of manual processes to which passengers are entitled needs to be checked, not expanded. What TSA needs is proper oversight, better KPIs, and a cultural overhaul to stop treating passengers so terribly. TSA ought to provide an SLA commitment, consistently and openly report on their actual service level, reward managers who improve it, and fire/demote those managers who degrade it.
- BobaFloutist 3y ago>What TSA needs is proper oversight, better KPIs, and a cultural overhaul to stop treating passengers so terribly. TSA ought to provide an SLA commitment, consistently and openly report on their actual service level, reward managers who improve it, and fire/demote those managers who degrade it. I agree, we need to teach TSA to Scrum and we need to do it yesterday!
- nullc 3y ago> I insist on a manual opt-out every time I fly, and I've noticed particularly in LAS that TSA seems intentionally to delay that screening process as an extrajudicial punishment and disincentive. Make sure you put your bags through first before opting out.
- jmward01 3y agoThe most important safety measure implemented was strong doors leading to the flight station. The cost/benefit for every other 'security' measure has clearly not been worth it. The amount of time people spend standing in line, arriving early, etc etc has a real cost in human life and vastly outweighs the supposed security and safety benefits we have gotten from airport security.
- veilmail 3y ago[dead]
- syngrog66 3y agoall US border security is theatre. ports are part of it any malevolent (smart, resourced) actor who wants to move people or items in or out has obvious ways to do it
- zzz999 3y agoI'm still not sure why cotton is allowed on planes since it could be nitrocellulose aka gun cotton