6 ms·
Superconductivity scandal: the story of deception in a physics lab
- wnevets 3y agoIIRC people assumed it was a mistake when the claimed turned out to be false I didn't realize he was a career conman.
- dotnet00 3y agoIn case others are coming into this thinking about LK-99, the article isn't about that. I had figured the LK-99 team might actually have something interesting considering that they were promising a proper presentation of their work at the American Physical Society. I had heard it had been withdrawn and wrote it off as another case of academic fraud, but looking it up right now, apparently it's weirder than that. Someone pretended to be the corresponding author and submitted a withdrawal, but this was fixed and the conference the presentation is at should be happening around these days.
- DarmokJalad1701 3y agoIt already happened a few days ago (March 4th). They showed more results, but nothing ground-breaking. There is another group that is also replicating the results and publishing results (SCT Lab or something). Their paper is currently pending.
- progrus 3y agoThey’re waiting for Arxiv to approve because patents may be denied if they go around that system.
- adastra22 3y agoLK-99 is interesting because it really is like another example of cold fusion. And I don't mean what you probably infer from that. If you look into the way that hydrogen adsorbs into a platinum lattice, and how phonon resonance modes can induce tremendous crushing forces on anything between two platinum atoms, cold fusion actually looks quite plausible. It's not like perpetual motion--there's a clear possible mechanism for it which is surprisingly fully compatible with the laws of physics as we understand them. That said, Pons and Fleischmann rushed publication on shoddy data, making a mockery of themselves and causing cold fusion to become an untouchable subject no one would go near a generation later due to perceived guilt by association. The theory behind LK-99 is pretty solid. The linear structure of these apatite compounds create chains of conductive electron bands that in theory might have sufficient band gaps to enable superconductivity. If you could get atomic precision in the copper/lead alternating pattern that creates those stresses. However I fear any research into room-temperature linear superconductors will now be as taboo as cold fusion.
- worik 3y ago> That said, Pons and Fleischmann rushed publication on shoddy data, making a mockery of themselves and causing cold fusion to become an untouchable subject no one would go near a generation later Yes, they were shoddy But no, the field was swamped within weeks with people trying to replicate it. It has lost its luster, and become a parody, but that is because it was wrong It took a decade for the excitement to die down
- adastra22 3y agoPons and Fleischmann's experimental setup did not produce cold fusion. But some other variation or different catalyst material might. Yet effectively no one has carried on this work. LK-99, or at least the manufactured samples of it, is not a superconductor. But some other variation or different manufacturing technique might. Yet I predict no one is going to look very hard in the years to come.
- kergonath 3y ago> If you look into the way that hydrogen adsorbs into a platinum lattice, and how phonon resonance modes can induce tremendous crushing forces on anything between two platinum atoms, cold fusion actually looks quite plausible. No, it is not. These things are well understood. The behaviour of hydrogen in crystals is studied a lot. In metals because of issues with hydrogen embrittlement and fusion stuff, in some oxides for the storage of hydrogen for energy applications, and in material in general because proton irradiation is a common tool when studying them. All of this to say that this is not something that was never investigated. > It's not like perpetual motion--there's a clear possible mechanism for it which is surprisingly fully compatible with the laws of physics as we understand them. The orders of magnitude just do not match. The pressures involved is typically 1 GPa (usually less in metals, more in ceramics). That is far from enough to bring nuclei sufficiently close for fusion. There is a reason why nobody claims this, and it is not because we don’t look at the behaviour of hydrogen (or other light nuclei like deuterium, tritium, helium, or lithium for that matter). > The theory behind LK-99 is pretty solid. The linear structure of these apatite compounds create chains of conductive electron bands that in theory might have sufficient band gaps to enable superconductivity. Again, it is not. Some preliminary electronic structure calculations showed interesting features, but these features were no indication of superconducting behaviour, and indeed LK-99 is not a superconductor. There were plenty of people who tried to reproduce the results and it clearly showed that the initial paper was wrong. > If you could get atomic precision in the copper/lead alternating pattern that creates those stresses. Our understanding of what causes superconductivity and the creation of Cooper pairs is not complete. Otherwise, we’d design materials with the right properties from the beginning, rather than testing a lot of stuff just to see what works. > However I fear any research into room-temperature linear superconductors will now be as taboo as cold fusion. Contrary to cold fusion, superconduction is actually a thing. Current high-temperature superconductors work at the temperature of liquid nitrogen; finding one that works 100K higher is not that much of a stretch. The gap is not 6 orders of magnitude like with cold fusion. In fact, there is quite a lot of funding for research on high-temperature superconductors even this year so your fear is not really well founded.
- 1024core 3y ago"Publish or perish" takes yet another victim.
- Simulacra 3y agoIt could be worse than that. How did he get into the program in the first place should be examined.
- StressedDev 3y agoNot really. Publish or perish does not force academics to commit fraud or to abuse their subordinates. It does not force them to behave unethically. Professor Dias choose to lie, choose to abuse, and choose to submit papers with fake data. I agree publish or perish may not be the best system but we should not excuse people for being corrupt. People can and do chose to behave ethically. Those who don't should be punished.
- fifnir 3y agoHow amazing is it to read all this on nature itself, the journal whose peer-review method failed again and again.
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoFun fact: Nature used to publish papers without any peer review whatsoever right up to the mid-60s. The selection was based on what the editors thought was interesting or provocative. Legend has it that the submissions tracking system consisted of a particularly wide windowsill, in which the submitted manuscripts were stacked up in piles for each month.
- pfisherman 3y agoNature and Science are kind like the tabloids of scientific publishing. Legitimate news mixed with unsubstantiated gossip; all with a high “sexiness” factor that draws attention and moves copy.
- dsign 3y agoExactly. It's bad motivations all the way: - Nature published a paper twice after the reviewers voted "no". Of course, it is not a voting process, the editor makes their decision. But evidently the editor didn't use the referee's input for that decision. That input, must I say, is free work that academics do for the journal. Click-baitiness simply weighted more to the editor and her supervisors. People should just stop paying attention to what Nature publishes. - The students... I think this is the worst part of the story. Sometimes, students are on a student visa that depends on them holding for dear life to their university position. Been there, done that. I remember when I did my PhD: four to five international students--very well prepared I must say--to one from the host country. The ones from the host country were the ones with the best soft skills but they rarely put the long hours. I'll never forget that Iranian student who was a political refugee passing as a PhD student, because she couldn't bear the indignity of an asylum process. She couldn't return to her home country either. - The replication...For the first retraction, I could find nowhere in the article that replication attempts were made. If those replication attempts were impossible to produce with the data published in the article itself, then its not a scientific paper, but a promotional brochure. In fact, some promotional materials are more extensive than Nature's articles; they really want to make the thing very short and academics are forced to jump through hoops to condense their publications, until they are practically impossible to understand, not to mention replicate. Again, the only solution to that problem is to ignore Nature.
- perihelions 3y ago- "203 K (70 °C)" 203 K is -70 °C, not +70 °C
- evilduck 3y agoMaybe the author was an accountant?
- wyldfire 3y agoWouldn't they put ((70 °C)) in that case?
- dekhn 3y agono, they write it in red
- eichin 3y agoOh, is this another "excel vs. scientific communication" thing? ( https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/negative-numbers-aren-t-showing-with-parentheses-in-excel-682a1cc5-701a-4ce7-92db-cc9eebc5ffa0 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/negative-numbers-... and https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/change-the-way-negative-numbers-are-displayed-104b47a6-8ae2-471f-8f73-c4b96e7bb146 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/change-the-way-ne... )
- levocardia 3y ago>Students say that Dias gave them an ultimatum: remove their names, or let him send the draft. Despite their worries, the students say they had no choice but to acquiesce. “I just remember being very intimidated,” one student says. The student says they regret not speaking up more to Dias. “But it’s scary at the time. What if I do and he makes the rest of my life miserable?” Indeed it is scary, because as a student your PI can in fact ruin your life and ruin your career, without much recourse in most cases. This behind-the-scenes is a good insight into the bad incentives and lack of accountability for PIs in academic research. I suspect this kind of thing happens all the time in smaller fields, and never gets discovered because it's not a headline-grabbing topic like room-temp superconductivity. I had a bioengineering PhD friend who said she spotted obviously fraudulent papers all the time in her field--publications claiming they grew such-and-such bacteria in so-and-so medium, when she knew damn well that said bacteria cannot grow in said medium.
- jcranmer 3y agoYep, when I was reading this article, as I kept hearing about what Dias was doing to his students, I was getting ready to throttle him. The students here didn't really do anything wrong, but Dias used his position of authority to essentially blackmail the students into becoming complicit in fraud, and attempted to justify it essentially with an "everybody does it" excuse. Kudos to them for taking the initiative to retract their paper over the head of their PI! That takes a lot of courage, given the immense powers an advisor holds over their students.
- strangattractor 3y ago> Soon after the CSH paper was published, Jorge Hirsch, a condensed-matter theorist at the University of California, San Diego, began pressing Dias to release the raw magnetic-susceptibility data, which were not included in the paper. More than a year later, Dias and Salamat finally made the raw data public. Explain to me why Nature would publish a paper without having access to/requiring the data. Could it be Nature wanted to be the first to publish such a ground breaking discovery? Dishonest people are simply a fact of life. The entire point - supposedly - of peer review is to insure that scientist do not make unsubstantiated claims. Job well done Nature. Job well done.
- rwmj 3y agoSurely with something as concrete as a substance, you accept the paper to give it a priority date, and then you wait on publication until an independent lab has verified the claimed properties? It either is or it isn't a room-temperature superconductor. Of all the problems in science, this seems like one of the easier ones to fix.
- dotnet00 3y agoWho's going to pay for the independent replication, especially if the result hasn't been published? Peer review is done for free because it's relatively less effort compared to a replication, and even then it's only barely tolerable.
- rwmj 3y agoThere's a big dispute about who pays the cost of publishing papers these days, so throw it in that bucket.
- dotnet00 3y agoIt costs a lot less to publish a paper compared to replicating a study.
- rwmj 3y agoI didn't say replicate the study, I said test if the material is a superconductor, which isn't nearly as difficult.
- dotnet00 3y agoThat is replicating the study when the study is about the superconducting properties of a material. I think the LK-99 thing made it pretty clear that it is pretty difficult to do, there are lots of variables and lots of things that need to be ruled out to prove that something is superconducting.
- fabian2k 3y agoShowing your co-authors the manuscript for the first time a few hours before you submit it to Nature is not how it's done, not at all. That is really unusual and a giant red flag, though the PhD students were probably not experienced enough to judge just how weird this was. And I could imagine that in that field the PI could convince them e.g. by stating they wanted to avoid getting scooped or something like that.
- bluenose69 3y agoAlso, an analysis shows that Dias' thesis was largely (21 percent) plagiarized [1, 2]. 1. https://www.science.org/content/article/plagiarism-allegations-pursue-physicist-behind-stunning-superconductivity-claims https://www.science.org/content/article/plagiarism-allegatio... 2. https://www.science.org/do/10.1126/science.adi2603/full/dias_thesis_report_visualization-1681926283033.pdf https://www.science.org/do/10.1126/science.adi2603/full/dias...
- lykahb 3y agoWhat is the point of fabricating data here? An extraordinary claim about room-temperature superconductivity is going to receive a lot of scrutiny that it wouldn't stand. It's not an average publication made to pad up the H index and meet the dept requirements.
- Vegenoid 3y agoI was wondering the same, and it seems like the only way it makes any sense is if you think that you really are on to something, and you want to make sure that nobody beats you to the punch. So you fudge the numbers and publish it, hoping that you, or maybe even someone else, makes it actually work, and your name gets associated with the discovery. I'd love to hear any other possible explanations for this behavior, because it seems to delusional to fabricate this and think you wouldn't get caught.
- rgmerk 3y agoIt’s very common for researchers to be convinced of things they can’t currently prove. Why else are you going to spend years of your life bashing your head against a brick wall trying to prove it? Sometimes that belief pays off spectacularly. Often it results in a junior researcher’s career going down the toilet because they or their supervisor backed the wrong horse and they ended up with nothing exciting to publish.
- WalterBright 3y agoHow did anyone think the deception wouldn't be promptly found out? Too many people would rush to replicate it.
- sega_sai 3y agoOk Dias is an a**hole (especially for manipulating students), but Nature is at fault here. They chose to publish those papers, ignoring referee/data concerns.