4 ms·
Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 Covid vaccines
- canadiantim 3y agoCuriously, they don't mention why the man has received 217 Covid vaccines, except for "private reasons".
- mikeyouse 3y agoThe Lancet link has slightly more detail - sounds like he's a bit crazy and they were investigating him because they thought there was fraud happening but then they realized he was just 'hypervaccinated' and so they didn't file charges and enrolled him in this study; > Here, we report on a 62-year-old male hypervaccinated individual from Magdeburg, Germany (HIM), who deliberately and for private reasons received 217 vaccinations against SARS-CoV-2 within a period of 29 months (figure A; appendix 1 tab 1). HIM's hypervaccination occurred outside of a clinical study context and against national vaccination recommendations. Evidence for 130 vaccinations in a 9 month period was collected by the public prosecutor of Magdeburg, Germany, who opened an investigation of this case with the allegation of fraud, but criminal charges were not filed. 108 vaccinations are individually recorded and partly overlap with the total of 130 prosecutor-confirmed vaccinations (appendix 2 p 12). To investigate the immunological consequences of hypervaccination in this unique situation, we submitted an analysis proposal to HIM via the public prosecutor. HIM then actively and voluntarily consented to provide medical information and donate blood and saliva. This procedure was approved by the local Ethics Committee of the University Hospital of Erlangen, Germany. Throughout the entire hypervaccination schedule HIM did not report any vaccination-related side effects. From November 2019, to October 2023, 62 routine clinical chemistry parameters showed no abnormalities attributable to hypervaccination (appendix 1 tab 2). Furthermore, HIM had no signs of a past SARS-CoV-2 infection, as indicated by repeatedly negative SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests, PCRs and nucleocapsid serology (figure A; appendix 1 tab 1). https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(24)00134-8/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...
- andrewflnr 3y agoI don't know, maybe they just gave him a break on the charges in exchange for cooperating with the study. You know the scientists would try to pull something like that to study a unique case if at all possible, and I know I would "actively and voluntarily consent" to that if my alternative was jail.
- mikeyouse 3y agoThat'd be super unethical and they point out it passed their IRB so that's unlikely to have been the case. I believe their system is like the US where the docs/pharmacies are reimbursed for each dose given so the prosecutors likely were doing basic fraud detection and saw that 100+ doses were associated with the same person which lead them to investigate -- it's probably not illegal to get hundreds of vaccinations hence the lack of charges and it just so happened to have provided an interesting data point for researchers.
- andrewflnr 3y agoFair point about the ethics angle. I guess. Personally I think it's morally fine (clearly a win-win for him and society) but it does look like coercion and there's a case for avoiding "even the appearance of evil"...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- petesergeant 3y ago> 62-year-male … for private reasons Without being crass, I can definitely see a world in which someone showing up to do something they know they’re not meant to do, interacting with a nurse (likely female, likely in a uniform), and getting a small but manageable amount of pain being a fetish thing.
- NoGravitas 3y agoYou're getting downvoted for this, but there were people who actually developed a fetish for intranasal stimulation back when covid testing was still common (and presumably many more who joked about it - see "nussy").
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 3y agoApparently he was selling forged vaccination passports: https://apnews.com/article/covid-health-germany-europe-document-forgery-120b2c4db8aa71ffeadf766a9829910b https://apnews.com/article/covid-health-germany-europe-docum...
- kiba 3y agoCareful reading suggested he was arrested under suspicion of selling vaccine cards, not that he actually sold vaccine cards.
- lapcat 3y ago"Police confiscated several blank vaccination cards from him and initiated criminal proceedings." What are you trying to say? (1) He wasn't actually trying to selling vaccine cards? (2) He was trying to selling vaccine cards but hadn't yet succeeded? Given the evidence — the confiscated cards and the sheer number of shots already administered — both (1) and (2) seem like absurd presuppositions. We're not a jury, and this is not a trial. We can't send him to jail, but we can say he's clearly guilty as hell.
- lern_too_spel 3y agoIt sounds like he just wanted to get a lot of vaccinations and used blank cards to not arouse suspicion from the person administering the vaccine and stamping the card.
- InSteady 3y agoThis is such a no brainer. The article states he has official records of 134 vaccinations. They wont just keep stamping the same card endlessly until it is completely covered. How else is he going to accomplish this absurd undertaking but to have access to a bunch of official vaccination documents? It's not outside the realm of possibility that he was also selling them, but I feel like Occam and Hanlon both agree that unless there is direct evidence, he's probably not some criminal mastermind getting rich. He's just a random person with either a fetish or something to prove.
- schoen 3y agoMost explanations I can think of would involve an anxiety, delusional, memory, or cognitive disorder. Or an art project, scientific self-experimentation, or an deliberate effort to experience an adverse reaction in order to qualify for a vaccine injury payment? [ Edit: Wow, I didn't even think of the fraud possibility mentioned in other comments. :-( :-( In some places maybe people are also directly paid to receive vaccines? ] I wonder if there's anyone for whom 217 total lifetime vaccine doses (cumulative across various vaccines) would be considered medically indicated. Maybe if you got childhood vaccines on an inefficient schedule, moved around between countries with different recommendations, got a bunch of travel or special occupational hazard or special exposure risk immunizations, eventually got multi-dose old age vaccine series, and also got the annual flu shot every year? Oh, I guess if you go to both the northern and the southern hemisphere every year, you could have two different annual flu shots indicated (since the hemispheres have different flu shot formulations). I think that could do it when combined with the other stuff.
- triceratops 3y agoHe read Bruce Lee's adage about the man who practices one kick 5000 times. /s
- rossdavidh 3y agoSo, I'm glad that these researchers investigated the case, and reported their findings, but I am not surprised. It would be odd if our immune system, as had apparently been speculated, became less effective against pathogens that it saw a lot. People who live in low-tech areas with, for example, a lot of malaria, will need to have immune systems that remain vigilant, year after year. Moreover, if a pathogen is in general circulation, a person might easily be exposed to it many, many times in a few years, as you keep coming into contact with people who have it. I would be surprised if it caused the immune system to no longer respond. More plausible would be that something about the vaccine itself might become less effective, since it is after all not an actual pathogen but rather a piece of one which we are attempting to "trick" the immune system into treating like a pathogen. I believe the term for this part of a vaccine is "adjuvant" (although IANAImmunologist). Most of the vaccinations appear to be mRNA based, if I am reading the appendix of the Lancet article correctly, so it is interesting to see evidence that this method remains "convincing" to the immune system (n=1).
- echelon 3y ago> I would be surprised if it caused the immune system to no longer respond. I wonder if overfitting to Covid epitopes would cause proliferation of Covid recognition at the expense of other recognition? Moreover, I wonder if it could lead to overwhelming activation, recruitment, and inflammation in the presence of weakened Covid virus (low dose, environmental background) that would ordinarily be cleared? This definitely deserves more study.
- tbrownaw 3y ago> It would be odd if our immune system, as had apparently been speculated, became less effective against pathogens that it saw a lot. This is how allergy treatments work. Apparently some infections (at least dengue) are worse the second time. So it's not an absurd idea.
- InSteady 3y ago>This is how allergy treatments work. But allergens are not pathogens, we are looking at substantially different immune pathways and function (allergens have no lifecycle, let alone one involving host cells). >Apparently some infections (at least dengue) are worse the second time. There is some compelling evidence to suggest it is specifically having a low, but not zero, level of antibodies that paradoxically increases the chance of severe infection in dengue fever specifically. Possibly by enhancing dengue's ability to infiltrate cells when it is only slightly coated with antibodies [1]. So even in this rather unusual case, it is not seeing dengue a lot, but rather seeing it exactly once and then seeing it again after several years without any contact that appears to cause this issue. [1] - https://www.statnews.com/2017/11/02/dengue-second-infection/ https://www.statnews.com/2017/11/02/dengue-second-infection/
- atleastoptimal 3y ago>Don't talk to me unless you're gigavaxxed Still, I'm sure the amount of mRNA he was exposed to is only a fraction of the amount the body is exposed to during a severe Covid infection.
- cjensen 3y agoJust to clarify a bit of confusion here ... Covid infections do not expose you to additional mRNA. The mRNA is an instruction sequence used to trick a small number of your cells into producing small virus parts for a short amount of time. For example "produce a covid spike protein." It's harmless to the cells to produce a few useless proteins like this, and the resulting proteins train your immune system to recognize covid.
- Vecr 3y agoIt's not harmless to the cells, otherwise there would be no killer T-cell response elicited by the vaccine. I'm not sure what percent of cells get killed, but it's absolutely not zero. It codes for the whole (but genetically modified) spike as well. The CDC saying something does not make it true.
- cjensen 3y agoThat's incorrect. The immune response is to simple fragments of the covid virus -- which is literally how all traditional vaccines work. The only difference with mRNA vaccines is that instead of giving you a single shot of virus fragments, the new vaccines convince your own cells to product those fragments over a period of a day or two. Your comment suggesting that the CDC is lying is both ridiculous and also confused about which government body approves vaccines.
- Vecr 3y agoFor anyone who doesn't know, the FDA approves vaccines and the CDC recommends them (or sometimes does not).
- 3y ago
- water9 3y ago[flagged]
- huytersd 3y agoEh even 217 doesn’t compare to the rna from getting sick with covid once.
- hollerith 3y agoThe mRNA in the vaccine has been modified so that the body cannot disassemble it as easily as it can ordinary mRNA.
- jiggawatts 3y agoYes. That's the point. Katalin Karikó deserved her 2023 Nobel Prize for that invention.
- hollerith 3y agoThat might be your point, but my point is that the argument (for vaccine safety) I replied to does not go through.
- ARandomerDude 3y ago[flagged]
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 3y agoHow much are we talking?
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoSeems heart disease is the leading cause of death in Germany so it's not the dumbest bet, despite the intended premise.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoHaven't heart problems been the leading cause of death in adults for like, eighty years?
- spondylosaurus 3y ago> The man who has now been examined by researchers at FAU claims to have received 217 vaccinations for private reasons. There is official confirmation for 134 of these vaccinations. Well hold on. Only 134?
- mannyv 3y agoOne vaccine good, 217 vaccines better.
- lwansbrough 3y agoVaxxed?
- TMWNN 3y ago[flagged]
- InSteady 3y agoCan we please as a rule avoid reposting reddit reposts of 4chan shitposts? This is not why I come to HN. It would sadden me if this ever became normalized.
- mr_spothawk 3y ago* a youthful 8 month old user account has entered the chats *
- lamp987 3y agoWhy if its funny and relevant?
- DantesKite 3y agoI’m curious if the breadth of the antigenic response increased as a result or significantly narrowed. Perhaps I missed it but it seems like a large part of the focus was on whether or not that many vaccinations had damaged his immune response.
- gniv 3y agoHe got mostly the Pfizer vaccine (called BNT in the spreadsheet), but not just. Early on he got J&J, AstraZeneca and Moderna. Later also Sanofi. In January and February 2022, he went almost twice a day, every day!
- kybernetyk 3y agogetting a vaccine 217 times? is this mental illness?
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y ago[flagged]
- fnordian_slip 3y agoPlease avoid trolling on hn. Larping as an uneducated racist anti-vaxxer who still doesn't understand vaccines counts as trolling, so please just don't do it. Thank you.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y ago[flagged]
- fnordian_slip 3y agoBecause I assume that on hn, most people are familiar with the fact that the vaccine makes it a lot less likely to get the disease, and decreases the symptoms if you do get it. Also, people who are not trolling typically don't use the expression "Kung-Flu", since I would expect that even anti-vaxxers usually have enough self-respect not to parrot the embarrassing utterings of a certain former US president. But since it is impossible to assert that a very committed troll is actually a troll, let's pretend you are an honest person, and actually asking if people believe that you need 217 vaccines to get complete immunity from COVID. Let's even steel-man your argument, and pretend you understand how vaccines work, understand herd immunity, and therefore did not mean complete immunity. Then the answer is: "no" 217 is not the needed number.
- GuB-42 3y agoI once wondered if a way to avoid Covid, for healthcare workers and the likes would be to have constant exposure. For example, by working, unprotected and on a day to day basis around covid patients just after recovery from an initial infection (and later, vaccine). The idea is to stimulate the immune system constantly to not let the virus have any chance. While the virus and vaccine are not the same, the fact that the body seems to not have a problem with constant exposure could make it an idea not as dumb as it may seem.