5 ms·
California's fast food law exempts Panera Gov. Newsom's relationship
- ClassyJacket 3y agoSo, nothing will change except now every fast food place in California will bake its own bread. Look out for McDonald's fresh bread, west coasters.
- LinuxBender 3y agoThe exemption only applies to businesses that specifically only make bread and nothing else. Even bagels disqualify the exemption. It was found that the exemption will only apply to Panera, giving them an advantage over everyone else having to pay $20/hr whereas Panera will continue paying $11.70/hr. Additional discussion on Breaking Points [1]. [1] - https://youtu.be/2YZ43uU4Z8s?&t=268 https://youtu.be/2YZ43uU4Z8s?&t=268
- x86x87 3y agoWhy would anyone take a job at 11.70/hr when one at 20$/hour is available? This makes zero sense.
- noncoml 3y agoRight. I don’t understand why people keep choosing to be poor and in need /s Are we living in our own little bubble much?
- ipaddr 3y agoThe lowest paying jobs in expensive cities are hard to fill because other jobs exist. If all jobs are filled then people the best / average / slightly below average will have a choice while the worst won't.
- ars 3y agoBecause the $20/hour price is artificial, so there aren't enough of them. If the price were not artificial it would balance until the number of jobs = number of seekers. But it won't, instead it becomes a lottery of sorts. It also means far less job security for anyone who has such a job, because there are so many seekers employers will hold all the power, and will fire people easily. So it's also a high-stress job, but presumably worth it for that pay. Which also answers your question: People will take lower paying jobs in order to have a bit more flexibility to request time off, or to make mistakes without fear.
- x86x87 3y agonormally I would agree with you, but the 20$/hr is required across the board for all fast food workers, correct? so, it's not like you get to choose how much you pay a worker (you may choose to have less workers for example but you cannot pay less than 20).
- ars 3y agoAre there no other jobs in California that pay less? If this is a global floor in California, it's going to lead to some interesting things. It will have the effect of flattening out the income of a huge chunk of society. A huge number of people in California will all have identical income. It will be cheaper to make things across the border and import them. So the kinds of jobs needed will change. California will lose local jobs but gain jobs having to do with coordination and importation.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoPositions aren't infinite. Even if you want the $20/hr job, so do a lot of other people.
- sparky_z 3y agoHuh? That doesn't sound correct, and isn't supported by the video you linked. Panera doesn't just make bread. They have a huge menu that includes bagels, pasta dishes, etc.
- ahallock 3y agoThat is completely corrupt. The government is picking winners and losers. What about sub shops that bake their own rolls?
- not-my-account 3y agoWell, at the very least we will see employees leaving Panera in droves and I'd bet they'd be forced to increase their wages to just keep the doors open.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 3y agoNot when other places are closing because they're forced to raise prices to still make a profit while paying higher wages, meaning less customers.
- bribroder 3y ago> The exemption only applies to businesses that specifically only make bread and nothing else. Even bagels disqualify the exemption This is not accurate. The exemption applies to businesses that sell bread starting before September 2023. The exemption excludes restaurants that sell bagels and/or croissants but who don't sell bread. https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/pay-a-higher-minimum-wage-unless-youre-friends-with-governor-newsom/ https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/pay-a-higher-minimum-w...
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoSo if I start a bakery in 2024 I am disadvantaged? What if Panera starts a new location in 2024? A new counter at an existing location? I say with the sincerest sadness that every welfare scheme generates boundary problems like this. But this law comes across as particularly capricious.
- RandallBrown 3y agoI'm not sure that's correct. > An establishment that on September 1, 2022, operates a bakery that produces for sale on the establishment’s premises bread as defined under Part 136 of Subchapter B of Chapter I of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations shall not be considered a fast food restaurant, so long as it continues to operate such a bakery. This exemption applies only where the establishment produces for sale bread as a stand-alone menu item, and does not apply if the bread is available for sale solely as part of another menu item. Jimmy John's would also be exempt by this wording since they sell their old bread (or at least I think they do). I guess Subway wouldn't since I don't think you can buy just bread from them.
- ethbr1 3y agoSide note, Jimmy John's day old bread fed me through college. If you're poor and there's a JJ's nearby, hard to get better. Just walk up to the counter and ask if they have day old bread. I think you might have to pay in cash? Vaguely remember it being so cheap that card didn't make sense.
- Aurornis 3y agoThe carveout only applies to companies that met the criteria prior to a certain date. They really worked hard to close loopholes that would have allowed any other company to use it.
- mysterydip 3y agoTry the new McBread today!
- Farfignoggen 3y agoLOL as Panera loses its employees to the competition that are forced to pay 8+ dollars more per hour and at a more rapid pace thereafter! And no one wants to take any position at Panera if they can get higher paying food service work across the street! Most workers will just find other employers that pay more and thus the experiment will start for Panera on how the prevailing wage levels in the Golden Bear state will force Panera to raise wages regardless!
- roenxi 3y agoIf that was true, it would have happened without the law getting involved. The implications of this are obvious from some basic supply-demand logic. Say before the law came into effect there were 100 people, 100 jobs and the market rate of pay is $12/hr. Now there going to be more people willing to take work (say, 110 people), probably less jobs - say 99 for the sake of argument and the market rate is set to $20/hr. Panera will still fill the same number of positions and likely pay a little less than $12 (maybe $10). They can also offer lower prices so they'll probably do roaring business and make more profit. A carve out won't hurt Panera. It'll make them much more profitable.
- yumraj 3y agoDoesn’t that assume that unlimited jobs are available and every worker has a choice? In reality the $20 jobs will fill first and remaining might have to take $12 jobs. No?
- zmgsabst 3y agoSure — those jobs will go first to the best employees. And Panera will become that place where you know the quality and staff are worse, in both the “get my order wrong” and “seem to have a drug problem” senses. Panera will then have to pay above market to attract quality back when they’ve developed a toxic workplace culture. All while customers are shifting habits.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoDoes this law impact the ability of unionized Panera workers to bargain for wages at the same minimum wage floor? There are 188 Panera Bread locations in California [1]. More Starbucks locations have unionized nationwide than that [2]. [1] https://www.panerabread.com/en-us/cafe/locations/ca https://www.panerabread.com/en-us/cafe/locations/ca [2] https://unionelections.org/data/starbucks/ https://unionelections.org/data/starbucks/
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago[flagged]
- ethbr1 3y agoI am fascinated to know what the bargain was here. Surely it wasn't as simple as "I helped fund your campaign, this is that favor." The direct donation amount doesn't seem nearly substantial enough. Agreement not to support or fund inevitable repeal referendum? SuperPAC funding?
- epistasis 3y agoThe owner is an old friend, I think they might have gone to the same school. Edit: found a source here > Flynn, who attended the same high school as Newsom, has been involved in business dealings with the California governor, according to Bloomberg News. https://nypost.com/2024/02/28/business/panera-bread-exempt-from-california-wage-law-after-newsom-donation/ https://nypost.com/2024/02/28/business/panera-bread-exempt-f...
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI mean genuinely, in my limited but non trivial experience here, it’s that simple. Is just generally not this out in the open, and brazen. That says a lot about where we have gotten as a country, that brazen corruption is overlooked to such a degree that people do not feel that it affects them. The Overton window in action
- epistasis 3y agoWhat are you talking about when you say "people do not feel like it affects them"? Because all across the political spectrum people are furious about this today.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI was recently talking with one of my close friends who has been a state senator for about a decade now. They said that, whereas when they got into politics seriously in the 2000s there was an expectation that you were elected to serve your constituents and if “something happened to fall off the table into your pocket” it was kind of overlooked. Compare this to now, where if you do not come into an election with corporate sponsorship, with increasingly specific grift-based policy goals, the corporate money lobby will just over power you to stay off the ballot or crush you with propaganda Kari Lake a Republican talked about how she was approached recently to basically no response anywhere.
- gretch 3y agoAs a bay area resident: I don't think this carveout materially amounts to much. There are sooooo many open fast food positions and if they all go to $20 (currently at $17 in my area) then panera has to keep up. It is still a free option though. However, that answer from Newsom was piss poor. He says "it's just part of the sausage making" and negotiation process. Ultimately dodging the question since no substance on motivation was supplied as to why baking bread makes things different. He's not the kinda guy I want as a state leader and governor. Unfortunately, we never get any exciting competition against the scumbag either.
- golgappa 3y ago[dead]
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI’m confused. Was this an executive order or did it come out of the legislature? If the latter, then why does Newsom’s comment bother you so much? There are probably a lot of weird exemption in there, especially since it goes after an industry, you have to define fast food now.
- gretch 3y agoHe got up on that stand to answer questions. If he’s going to go up and proceed to dodge questions, then he needs to just go home and stop scheduling press events. I don’t want a coward for a leader.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIt all felt weird anyways. Why would bakeries be considered fast food, or why was fast food singled out compared to other minimum wage jobs? This seems like bad legislation when they should have just hiked the minimum wage (which is probably already effectively over $20/hour in most CA cities).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mavelikara 3y agoI hope businesses advertise that this law applies to them, so that customers can prioritize them over those that don’t.
- golgappa 3y ago[dead]
- CalChris 3y agoThis story makes no sense. First, Newsom doesn't write laws; the legislature writes laws. Second, the title says Panera but the article says Panera Bread and chain restaurants like it. Lastly, it says lawmakers are calling for an investigation into the deal, an investigation into a law they wrote, not Newsom. Newsom even pointed out that Panera wasn't exempt. https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/panera-newsom-wage-exemption-18696927.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/panera-newsom-w...
- sroussey 3y agoClickbait works though. Even on HN.
- hayst4ck 3y agoThe problem is that it is consistent with the average person's understanding of politicians. Newsom was caught in several situations of "rules for thee, but not for me" during COVID, the conflict of interest that is congressional stock trading was defended as a right, and supreme court justices are openly taking bribes without consequences. Citizens united said the rich can spend as much money as they want to get their standard-bearer elected. Even if it's not true, it's consistent, so it's not "clickbait working" so much as a story that completely makes sense given the current magnitude of corruption in American politics.
- russellbeattie 3y agoNewsom is a future presidential candidate. Misinformation, scandals, accusations of fraud, etc. will be the norm for the next four years. This isn't a new thing in presidential politics, nor specific to either party. Politics is a contact sport, and the competitors play the long game.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoIt's more than a little bit disingenuous to suggest that it's misinformation to link Newsom to a bill he claims to have collaborated on. Besides, with PG&E reporting record profits and the CPUC granting PG&E's every rate hike you really don't need to resort to misinformation. Folks just have to start waving their utility bills around if Newsom is dumb enough to run for president. I'm a little surprised his tenure as governor is turning out this way. As mayor he definitely dialed down the rampant cronyism and corruption that defined Brown's reign.
- gnicholas 3y agoThe most intriguing part is that you not only have to bake your own bread, you also have to sell it standalone (not just part of a burger/sub). Seems like it would be very easy for Subway to start selling their store-baked bread standalone — have they done this already, or are they paying the new wage?
- sroussey 3y agoI think it was done for donuts shops.
- akira2501 3y agoYou have to have been selling bread this way when the law took effect, is my understanding.. so, you can't just start handing out loaves of bread tomorrow and then claim the exemption. It's not that just one provision of the law appears corrupt, it's that so many other peculiar provisions point to corruption as well, as if being someone who retailed bread in 2023 makes you different from someone who does so in 2024.
- gnicholas 3y agoInteresting, it does look like you have to have been baking bread as of 2022, but the part about selling it separately is phrased in the present tense. This has two effects: • Subway-type restaurants could be exempt if they start selling bread standalone, so long as they were baking bread in 2022 • any restaurant/donut shop/etc. would not qualify for the exemption if they were not operating in 2022. I have not read the whole law, just this part: > (i) An establishment that on September 1, 2022, operates a bakery that produces for sale on the establishment’s premises bread as defined under Part 136 of Subchapter B of Chapter I of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations shall not be considered a fast food restaurant, so long as it continues to operate such a bakery. This exemption applies only where the establishment produces for sale bread as a stand-alone menu item, and does not apply if the bread is available for sale solely as part of another menu item. [1] 1: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB257 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- 1-6 3y agoWait till you hear how close Newsom is with PG&E. https://youtu.be/HgHMKq3igEw?feature=shared https://youtu.be/HgHMKq3igEw?feature=shared
- yieldcrv 3y ago[flagged]
- alphabettsy 3y agoThe Governor doesn’t write laws though. What other exemptions exist? Is this the only one or something?
- olliej 3y agoSo for people who don't understand how government works: The governor does not create legislation, they simply sign or veto legislation the legislative branch passes. Another thing the story doesn't acknowledge: the donor in question just owns a lot of fast food franchises, including non-Panera ones. Let's be clear, it's very suspicious to me that this story is suddenly getting a lot of coverage but not stating the origin of the exemption. But the other thing is billionaires donate a lot of money to many politicians, hell non-billionaires donate a lot of money to many politicians. Given the gross excess of donations in US politics I feel you could create more or less any conspiracy or corruption story you want to for almost any legislator and legislation combo you like.
- akira2501 3y ago> The governor does not create legislation The governor is NOT ENTITLED to create legislation. That doesn't mean it's somehow physically unrealizable in our universe for him to draft the law and then submit it to the legislative branch and for them to "rubber stamp" it.
- trts 3y agothe number of people saying this in this thread is what feels inorganic to me. what created this era where people are eager to come to the defense of incumbents? what's wrong is wrong; this isn't good policy. someone reported on it, people are finding out and they don't like it.
- coolspot 3y agoYeah, top comment is also sus. Are there HN upvoting/downvoting farms?
- olliej 3y agobecause people are responding to the sudden surge of this one story, so keep seeing exactly the same near identical story from multiple different sources on multiple different sites, so have have already gotten tired of the same BS everywhere. As far as I can make out this piece of (still BS) legislation was present for independent bakeries, and that happens to also cover outlets like Panera. But people who own multiple franchises have lots of money so make large political donations, and they own a bunch of businesses so a pile of legislation in notoriously anti-worker US laws eventually benefit them. This was my point: if you want to, you will find a donor that benefits from a law that someone they donated to has signed.
- Aunche 3y agoEveryone is rightfully outraged if Panera gets an exception to the minimum wage, but why have a separate minimum wage for fast food workers in the first place? Isn't that similarly arbitrary?
- gnicholas 3y agoYeah, IIRC the CA legislature was going to pass a law requiring franchisers (McDonald’s etc.) to assume liability for anything that happened at franchisee-owned locations. In turn, the franchisers threatened to put a ballot initiative in place to allow voters to have the last word. Then the parties came to the table and this was the compromise.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Discussion yesterday: Why Is Panera Exempted from California's New Minimum Wage Law? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39542601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39542601
- honeybadger1 3y agoHe's a typical politician.