9 ms·
X becoming a 'ghost town' of bots as AI-generated spam content floods internet
- pipeline_peak 3y agoI’d rather have an AI ghost town That points closer to letting people say what they want than a what we had before Musk’s takeover.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago> I’d rather have an AI ghost town That points closer to letting people say what they want than a what we had before Musk’s takeover. Can you give us an example of something you wanted to say and weren't allowed?
- pipeline_peak 3y agoThat a lot of companies who practice "diversity" and "inclusion" are racially and gender selective. It's not good for businesses because it reduces the talent pool. Also that Bud Light was pressured into a pro-trans campaign that did a lot of damage. I think it's well known there were many figure heads who knew their brand would suffer.
- yowzadave 3y agoI find it hard to believe that you were disallowed from writing these statements on Twitter before Musk took over.
- pipeline_peak 3y agoThen why was Trump banned?
- rsynnott 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capitol_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capito...
- pipeline_peak 3y agoSo Alt-right supporters who he wasn’t directly affiliated with and even went lengths to publicly denounced. He was banned from Twitter for not even saying anything, that’s what you’re telling me.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoYou couldn't say that on Twitter? I'm skeptical. Did you try? If so, what happened? If you didn't try, you don't really know.
- pipeline_peak 3y agoWhy was Trump banned?
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoI have no idea, and I also have no idea how youd think that answering a question with an unrelated question leads to a productive conversation. Are you suggesting that Trump was banned for saying that diversity reduces the talent pool? What are you saying? Make a point. Your evasiveness suggests to me that your original claim was BS.
- pipeline_peak 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39539591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39539591
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoYes, I heard it the first time that you didn't answer my question and instead changed subject. The fact is that no one was stopping you from saying on Twitter that diversity is bad for the talent pool, you just made it up.
- slater 3y agoStrong "Oh, you know the ones..." vibes coming from that guy.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago99% of the times when people talk about "freedom of speech on Twitter", those are the ones. I suspect that getting banned on Twitter for saying something ambiguous that was misinterpreted is a tiny minority compared to those who are hellbent of hounding their pet hate minority and get banned for it.
- riffly 3y agohttps://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4681964-meghan-murphy-back-on-twitter https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4681964-meghan-mu... for example.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago"men aren't women though"? I'm really just checking if I know what to look at because I don't normally go to moms net is that what you're referring to?
- riffly 3y agoYes that's right. This is about Meghan Murphy, a journalist and feminist activist from Canada. That's what she tweeted when Musk let her back on Twitter, in reference to having been banned, temporarily, for saying "men aren't women though" in 2018. Later that year, she was then banned indefinitely for replying "yeah it's him" in reference to a male who had sued a number of female aestheticians in Vancouver for refusing to wax his scrotum. But, because this male identified himself as a woman, Murphy was banned from Twitter for "misgendering" him. This was, in general, a category of speech you weren't allowed to express on Twitter in the pre-Musk era. Even if you were talking about a male who was attempting to force women to touch his ballsack by court order. The Mumsnet link is from when she returned to Twitter, in the later comments it has a bit more backstory of what happened. This article explains it better: https://afterellen.com/twitter-bans-meghan-murphy-founder-of-canadas-leading-feminist-website https://afterellen.com/twitter-bans-meghan-murphy-founder-of...
- egberts1 3y agoTrick to avoiding bots is to: * never add followers of very recent creation date * ignore followers of lopsided ratio of followers * mentally map and gauge responses before adding followers * always block those likes on your tweets who have met above criterions. Hardest part of maintaining your clean bot-free Twitter account is re-reviewing your 5K followers for bot-like profile. Until most of above are fixed, the decline of natural and organic Twitter membership will continue.
- 47thpresident 3y agoThere's an interesting phenomenon, where certain keywords in your post will trigger bot rings to advertise their services. Keywords such as: "Crypto", "Metamask", "Hacked", "IPTV". https://twitter.com/avion19e/status/1761816241390473228 https://twitter.com/avion19e/status/1761816241390473228
- pyb 3y agoI get new bots trying to follow my account nearly every single day. They all follow the same pattern : young asian lady posting platitudes and holiday pics.
- zephrx1111 3y agoNot really for me.
- uslic001 3y agoI see 90% less bots than I did a year ago. When a new bot comes up they get quashed much faster than when it was Twitter.
- davidmoore9952 3y ago\ . . , , , , . ' , . : @.
- npalli 3y agoTrue, X is becoming unbearable. Used to be - 90% of replies were from normal people. Nowadays, it is just 90% bots in all replies. Maybe the result of firing 70% of the employees shows up after some delay.
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoI've never been on twitter but that's never been my understanding of it from people's descriptions.
- pyb 3y agoMaybe X management actually find value the illusion of activity that bots provide. It's probably not fooling anyone, but...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- burrish 3y agoimo it wasn't caused by firing the employees, it's making it possible to earn money with engagements that made X plagued with bots, you will see the most bots under the reply of tweet with at least +10k likes trying to latch into engagements.
- kramerger 3y agoSo fireing everyone working with spam issues and shutting down automated spam detection tools to save a few bucks has nothing to do with this?
- infotainment 3y agoIt’s likely both that and all of the horrible product decisions are having an impact. I’m sure elevating replies with a “blue check” didn’t help either, since now bot replies can easily sail to the top of the list.
- 3y ago
- sylware 3y agoAI bot = headless blink/webkit, a mouse and a keyboard tied to properly trained neural net (training can be achieved with click farms with real humans).
- karim79 3y agoMy experience with X is mostly is as follows: - Spam post (AI generated?) - Another spam post (AI generated?) - And here is an ad for a revolutionary mop which lets you mop not just the floor, but the walls and the ceiling as well! - Spam post (AI generated?) - ...
- kotaKat 3y agoHey now, you forgot, that mop is just an Aliexpress dropship :) ... Bonus points for a Community Note that calls it out as a dropship and also links to the Aliexpress listing with their own custom affiliate tag bolted onto it.
- passedandfuture 3y agoX definitely feels hollowed out. Most of my follows are spambots, and I hardly get engagement anymore. A few days ago I created an account on Bluesky and it's much livelier. There is a living ecosystem there.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoDoesn't feel hollowed out to me personally. But there are way more bots. I'm sure they'll crackdown on that at some point
- anonzzzies 3y ago> I'm sure they'll crackdown on that at some point How? Only Blue can post + comment? Looking in my X experience, a lot of spammers are not afraid of paying. I see way too many obviously generated spam posts/comments from Blue users. What other ways are there?
- acdha 3y agoThe problem with the bot crackdown ideas is that they mostly involve hiring people which Musk laid off (getting the boss to admit his mistake is never easy, and he’s more egotistical than average) and it’ll tank the numbers that their customers see. Advertisers like the idea of not paying for bot activity but they’re going to be paying less overall and if the numbers go down significantly some are going to argue for refunds because X wasn’t doing adequate bot control before. Similarly, people like to see high follower counts but if those drop precipitously when a new antispam is announced, it’s really going to contribute to the “this place is over” impression most of the remaining users already have.
- jart 3y agoWhat is all this noise about bots? I have 36k followers on Twitter. I'm on it all the time. I don't think I've ever seen a bot. What exactly do these bots do and how would you know they're bots?
- a_gnostic 3y ago> and how would you know they're bots? "If they disagree, they're bots. Also LLM, crypto, and ads."
- nickthegreek 3y agoRead the blue check replies on ANY popular tweet. If you dont see a bot, you dont want to see a bot.
- flohofwoe 3y agoI'm also seeing almost exclusively random scam ads with AI generated images at the moment (on the mobile client, thankfully the ads don't make it through uBlock Origin in the desktop web client). Never thought I would reminisce the good old times when actual companies advertised on twitter ;)
- numpad0 3y ago[flagged]
- 2devnull 3y agoAlso YouTube, but the bot comments are all backdated to appear older.
- The_Colonel 3y agoThat doesn't bother me really, I'd be fine if the youtube comments did not exist at all.
- yowzadave 3y agoI actually love the youtube comments you see on old music videos--they are almost entirely aging people reminiscing about music from their era, recounting stories about people they knew and experiences they had while listening to the music. Drop into the comment section for the song "80's Ladies" by KT Oslin if you want to feel a bracing sense of your own mortality.
- ivanjermakov 3y agoI block them with uBlock. They are very rarely contribute anything to the video.
- _heimdall 3y agoThis problem isn't going to be unique to Twitter even if we're seeing it there first. Any site with user generated content will be chasing a never ending battle against bots churning out LLM content. There's really no way around it from what I can tell. How does one actually recognize and block not content online in an automated way? When the platform is digital and we now have digital means of generating content, the battle is lost IMO. Maybe it could be delayed by some kind of platform or regulatory change requiring state issued ID for all internet users. I think that has come up before and it feels very similar to what a few Googlers proposed (before the community dog piled on it). That's not a version of the internet I'd want to use though, and if that's the only avenue for avoiding a web full of bots it sure seems like the days are numbered.
- rsynnott 3y agoIn general you'd deal with it by blocking where possible, and where not possible, prioritising comment threads by engagement. Twitter's special sauce for the bots is its pay-for-attention model; note that all the bots in the article are blueticks, and thus get promoted to the top of the replies. This makes it a far softer target than a normal social network, where uninteresting bot comments would generally end up deprioritised due to lack of interest.
- numpad0 3y ago> How does one actually recognize and block not content online in an automated way? By gauging content popularity. People are good at consuming and obsoleting something abstract as an entire generative pipeline as content of its own. GenAIs and LLM had been doing great among its users but not reaching outside of it, and as required upkeep costs to fight its obsolescence grows non-linearly I'd predict it'll run out of investment sooner or later(before factoring in negative PR). Hard ID systems don't work. If it worked Facebook wouldn't have acquired Instagram and wouldn't be in competition against Twitter in the first place.
- _heimdall 3y ago> By gauging content popularity Isn't that already roughly how Twitter's feed algorithm works? I don't use Twitter, but from both the article and comments here it sounds like many people feel their feed is already full of LLM content.
- baud147258 3y agoI follow a handful of people and read some of the answers to their tweets and I don't think I've seen any that were obviously bots or AI generated spam. And spam (usually for NFT or similar crap) has gone down since last year, at least in the areas of Twitter I frequent. I'm not saying that it's the case everywhere on the platform, but at least for me the 'quality' of tweets hasn't gone down
- poulpy123 3y agoI personally see more bot and spam, but except for a month or two at the beginning, they are detected and deleted pretty quickly. I've seen a huge surge of clickbait tweets since the monetization of bluecheck accounts but that's not the same. The note feature is great for the moment
- bananapub 3y agomy counter-anecdote is that it's far worse than fifteen months ago and I'm reporting dozens of cryptocurrency scammers - both regular blue tick garbage replies, as well as blue ticks paying for ads - a day.
- ganeshkrishnan 3y agoQuality of tweets has actually become better over the last year. Even in the last few weeks, most of the get rich schemes are correctly tagged as spam and hidden. Also x traffic has risen over any other social media.. Not sure how abc made the judgement
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hereme888 3y ago[flagged]
- dorkwood 3y agoI think he's great. He's the only person on the planet who's been able to deliver us full self-driving cars. So many said it wasn't even possible with current technology, and yet you can go on their website right now and purchase one. Simply incredible.
- pwdisswordfishc 3y agoSoon enough, all the people will go and only bots will remain. You know what, Musk is a genius after all for monetizing Blue. He will then be taking money from bot accounts only for them to engage with other bot accounts, with none of them wiser
- 2devnull 3y agobig bux government money too, and political parties dark moneys. Endless cash flows
- pityJuke 3y agoTwitter is so bizarre in parts. I saw some guy complain about the spam within replies... only for the comment itself to become spam [0]. And don't get me started on the various Metamask/tech support/Onlyfans bot rings that are on the platform. Or the fact that a cat account got bought by a crypto coin [1]. This tweet from English football Twitter summarises the core issue the best [2]. [0]: https://internettalk.substack.com/p/anyone-else-tired-a-brief-look-at https://internettalk.substack.com/p/anyone-else-tired-a-brie... (disclaimer: I wrote this) [1]: https://twitter.com/ultrarotom/status/1762433167003169046 https://twitter.com/ultrarotom/status/1762433167003169046 [2]: https://twitter.com/liamb0117/status/1761391828836741333 https://twitter.com/liamb0117/status/1761391828836741333
- rsynnott 3y agoI think [1] is possibly the least weird; this would occasionally happen on old-Twitter, too.
- orwin 3y agoSport Twitter is much more invaded by bots than tech Twitter tbf
- pityJuke 3y agoI'd vaguely extend that to "entertainment" Twitter. Possibly even, "popular and an audience that is more suspectible to scams/promotion".
- rightbyte 3y agoInteresting. Bots are probably scraping for popular posts and reposting them? I've saw this alot on Reddit before boycotting them.
- whiplash451 3y agoIntuitively, the blue check mark combined with identity verification should split X traffic into two worlds fairly well. At least that’s my hope.
- thatjoeoverthr 3y agoCybersecurity is offence and defence. LLMs make defence proportionally harder.
- anymouse123456 3y agoAnecdata of one. I have a very old Twitter account. I visit x a few times for ~10 minutes each on most days. Engage with a few tens of EE/Hardware/Software folks. Follow and followed by ~750 people. The ads and engagement farming posts are both annoying, but on balance the conversations tend to be good and the info tends to be informative. My feeling is that it's better now than it was a year ago. I haven't noticed an increase in bot-like conversations. Possibly major factor: I actively unfollow and often block anyone who shouts about political subjects as I'm generally not interested in those conversations online.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoA) the plural of anecdote is anecdotes. This is English, not Latin. B) if you have a single anecdote, sure you should be using the singular...?
- tlb 3y agoThe OED approves of the GP's usage. https://www.oed.com/dictionary/anecdata_n?tl=true https://www.oed.com/dictionary/anecdata_n?tl=true
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoSure, next thing you're gonna tell me that bureaucracy X says the singular is anecdatum.
- andreygrehov 3y agoI think "anecdata" is a play on the words "anecdote" and "data" - an anecdote that includes supportive data.
- Izkata 3y agoIt is a combination of the two words, but the meaning is the other way around - they're throwing in their anecdote with everyone else's to build data.
- mandmandam 3y agoI've been saying it for a long time - Musk intends for X to become irrelevant. Every action he has taken since he announced his intent to buy has backed this up. Why people listen to his words is a total mystery to me. He's a consummate liar. His actions re Twitter are clear as day. Billionaires saw the way Twitter was empowering people and said 'Fuck this noise. Who can we get to destroy this from the inside...'
- andreygrehov 3y agoI see 0 spam or AI generated content on X. I remember there were a ton of crypto spammers back in the days, but it’s a day and night compared to today.
- bitwize 3y agoWell, dead internet theory is coming true. And we've just seen a paper about AI-generated playable game levels, which means those customized copies of Super Mario 64 should start appearing real soon now. (I wonder if Nintendo will attempt to sue the AIs?)
- cityzen 3y agoWell, you know not all Average Andy’s can run a social media site. Or install Windows.
- hereme888 3y agoMost of the spam I [rarely] see is pro-Hamas terrorist sympathisers, many likely bots. My comments reliably get liked by some lonely Asian or East European lady with random quotes on their account (mostly bots). But as far as actual tweets/content and interactions: it's all real people, super interesting, and very up to date news flying at the speed of light.
- haffi112 3y agoFor what I follow, it looks genuine. However, for many viral posts, many of the responses have nothing to do with the original post. It looks like bots/users that are riding off of the success of the viral post in an attempt to get more views/likes/followers. It's a sad behaviour that lessens the experience of the platform.
- arandomusername 3y agoYup, a lot of them, specially in posts that post interesting facts etc. I mute every account like that, and get a lot better experience now.
- runjake 3y agoI like what X has become. I follow a small group of people and friends, none of whom are too popular. But instead of opening the app and seeing them, I get forced to some "For You" page full of spam, scams, and Elon tweets. A bunch of commenters claim they don't see any of this and I wonder if they are on whatever the paid plan is called, in some favorable A/B category, or just flat-out lying. Everywhere I look is fulling of gambling ads, crypto scams, drop-shipping scams, community notes about those scams with their own scams in them, and of course, adolescent Elon tweets[1]. Whenever I tweet something high quality (interesting finding or howto), I almost never see any activity metrics for it. At best gets a view or two. Sometimes I'll ask a friend for feedback on a tweet I just made, but they are unable to find it. So this has led me to check X maybe once a week or less. I used to read through my follow timeline once a week, but with the ads and the spam/scam replies in threads I've kind of drifted down to glancing at my follow list on occasion. It's great. Between what's happened with Twitter and Reddit, I've freed up so much more time and brain space that I wasn't aware I was expending. And you don't get FOMO for low quality content, spam, and scams. 1. This isn't a politically-motivated jab, I'm politically-moderate. It's more "Elon is the same age as me, but he acts more like my adolescent kids than a man." Edit: I like that I posted this comment and in the half second it took to post, it's been downvoted. I think HN might have a bot problem?
- a_gnostic 3y ago> Edit: I like that I posted this comment and in the half second it took to post, it's been downvoted. I think HN might have a bot problem? Your comment started with "I like what X has become", in reply to a submission complaining about what X has become. Some of these people don't read past the title of articles, so don't be surprised at losing internet points over technically somewhat agreeing with them.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoLove Twitter these days. Its the best way to make money. All you need is pay for twitter blue and then use bots to reply to anything remotely connected to your topic. I get over 20 leads everyday through bots. It's never been easier with bots and AI.