8 ms·
Botanical gardens can cool city air by an average of 5°C
- Solvency 3y agoNow, if only we can do something about the absolutely endemic heat desert effect we've created by caking our country in massive black asphalt parking lots and 6-lane freeways. Nope, can't examine that. Parking lots are peak human design. The most logical design solution for our species.
- o_____________o 3y agoObligatory mention of Not Just Bikes: https://www.youtube.com/@NotJustBikes/videos https://www.youtube.com/@NotJustBikes/videos
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y ago"The road to hell is paved with asphalt" saw this here on HN not long ago - https://devonzuegel.com/the-road-to-hell-is-paved-with-asphalt https://devonzuegel.com/the-road-to-hell-is-paved-with-aspha... They mention less heat as one of the multiple benefits of pavers / bricks. I used to dislike them by default - "They're bumpy". They're not bumpy. There's a shopping center in my town, and even a new Taco Bell, that use pavers for their parking lot, and I can't even notice. We could probably do pavers for new parking lots and keep asphalt / concrete for heavy-duty stuff like interstates and roads over 30 MPH and not lose much except the up-front cost of pavers. (But hey if Taco Bell thinks they're worth it...)
- apercu 3y ago"Bumpiness" could be climate related - I've spent a lot of time in the upper midwest US and Canada, the freeze/thaw cycles mean things move in the earth.
- Filligree 3y agoIf you've got freeze/thaw cycles, then your asphalt roads will be bumpy as well. Trust me on that one.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoOnly if the foundations are bad and the road surface is not rated for the axle load of the vehicles that drive on it. I live in Norway where it is hovering around freezing just now. The only places where this affects the road is where water has penetrated the foundations in such a way as to wash away some support or where heavy vehicles have cracked the road surface allowing water in which subsequently freezes. If the road is properly constructed and maintained with sufficiently good drainage on both sides frost heave (telehiv in Norwegian) should not be a problem.
- Filligree 3y agoI grew up in Northern Norway, and pretty clearly there are a lot of roads with telehiv. ;-) You're probably right about foundation quality. But there sure are a lot of roads that didn't get that right.
- freeone3000 3y agoIt might honestly be easier to fix freeze-thawed cracked pavers than having to rip up asphalt and lay it back down.
- dublinben 3y agoEvery residential street should be paved with bricks or other paving stones, instead of asphalt. It's safer, because people drive more slowly. The maintenance costs are also lower.
- quesera 3y agoBricks and pavers are very difficult to plow safely. They are also more expensive than asphalt. But for warm, affluent locations, they make sense.
- CalRobert 3y agoBut bumpy is good!!!! A bumpy street is one where you drive slowly and don't run over children riding bikes to school. A bumpy street is one where you pay attention. A bumpy street says "you may drive here but this is not a space _just_ for your car". If only they were more common outside the Netherlands. I love my bumpy, brick, tree-lined, narrow, street.
- NikkiA 3y agoTBF, my experience of america when I lived there, was that black asphalt was far less common than light grey (and thus higher albedo) concrete for both. Increasing albedo is considered to be one of the geo-engineering solutions to try.
- inglor_cz 3y agoI live in a place where we have a Tesco mall with a big parking lot nearby, but then I have to walk a path through a green area with mostly grass, but some trees and bushes as well. The temperature difference is staggering. In hot summer, the parking lot is unbearable and the green area feels much better. In early spring/late autumn, the parking lot is uhm-okay (though still ugly), while walking through the green area gives you shivers: cool and wet wind. Only in deep winter, during the freezing days, both areas feel the same.
- Mizza 3y agoI've become really obsessed with 'Miyawaki Forests' lately - small, dense, urban forests which can reach a mature state in only a few years. I hope they start showing up everywhere. Fuck minimum parking requirements, where are the minimum forest requirements?
- FredPret 3y agoIncredible - apparently you can do one in your back yard! https://canadiangeographic.ca/articles/the-many-benefits-of-the-minuscule-but-mighty-miyawaki-forests/ https://canadiangeographic.ca/articles/the-many-benefits-of-...
- crazygringo 3y agoI'm having a hard time picturing what they look like -- and the photo in that article is unrelated. Googling them, I can find images of a few proof-of-concept plots in the middle of fields but I can't find a single example of how they might integrate with a city. It would be nice to see some kind of before-and-after, even if just an illustration, to get a sense of how they would fit into a cityscape aesthetically and practically.
- burkaman 3y agoHere's a NYT article with some good photos, gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/24/climate/tiny-forests-climate-miyawaki.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Yk0.ks58.DcgYBhM_lD5P&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/24/climate/tiny-forests-clim... Here's a photo of what it looks like when it's first planted: https://voice.somervillema.gov/miyawaki-micro-forest https://voice.somervillema.gov/miyawaki-micro-forest
- 3D30497420 3y agoAnother good article: https://www.creatingtomorrowsforests.co.uk/blog/the-miyawaki-method-for-creating-forests https://www.creatingtomorrowsforests.co.uk/blog/the-miyawaki...
- pkphilip 3y agoI have always been very curious as to why many cities do not push for more forests to cool down the place. I studied in a college with a lot of trees on campus and the temperature was at least 5 C cooler than just outside the college.
- nxm 3y agoBecause more housing is seen as a more immediate and higher need
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoBecause parking spaces or other such things are more profitable for business owners and the city. Nobody can monetarily profit from trees, unless you were to charge people money for time spent under their shade.
- bongodongobob 3y agoYou act is if the people living there don't want parking spaces.
- c0nfused 3y agoAs city dweller, I really would like less parking in my city. Turns out surface parking is a better $/sqft than garages once you count maintenance. This means that the core part of the city where density is greatest is ringed by a 2-5 block wide wasteland of surface lots. Its not great. Especially now that work from home is a thing and the divide between people who live here and people who drive here to work is obvious because the suburb people aren't here any more but their parking spaces still are
- BurningFrog 3y agoReading past the headline, the effect is from trees providing shadow, and evaporating water cooling the air. You don't need any actual botanical gardens.
- tonmoy 3y agoBut it’s probably the easiest and cheapest way. Another plus point would be creating habitat for smaller animals and morale boost for the city inhabitants
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoWell, both require making land available, and while amenity gardening is manageable, a botanical garden is often a research site that requires a lot of expertise to set up and maintain. Mind you, that's just fine, the county can and should hire people.
- Filligree 3y ago> botanical garden is often a research site that requires a lot of expertise to set up and maintain But it doesn't have to be, right? It's just that we don't have very many, so the ones that do exist end up being research sites.
- BurningFrog 3y agoLooking out my window, I see trees planted on the sidewalk along a road. It takes little space away from pedestrians, but provides a lot of shade. That seems both easier, cheaper and better that taking up whole city blocks.
- GrumpyNl 3y agoWe need more trees, i am shouting that for years.
- andsoitis 3y agoIf your city cannot afford botanical gardens, then planting trees on sidewalks, more boulevards, and other places not only bestow ecological benefits but is also good for the human psyche and reduces crime. https://www.fs.usda.gov/research/treesearch/40701 https://www.fs.usda.gov/research/treesearch/40701
- sokoloff 3y agoDoes planting trees reduce crime? Or are areas that have planted trees areas that also tend to have reduced crime? The abstract of that paper indicates an inverse correlation between trees and crime, but stops well short of claiming or proving a causal relationship.
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> Or are areas that have planted trees areas that also tend to have reduced crime? Perhaps fake it till you make it? Worth a try surely.
- B56b 3y agoThe correlation they saw was after controlling for potentially confounding variables, like income level, housing stock, density, and demographics, as explained in this article: https://caseytrees.org/2023/09/mythbusting-trees-and-crime/ https://caseytrees.org/2023/09/mythbusting-trees-and-crime/. So of course it's not proof of causation, but reverse causation(nice neighborhoods lead to more trees planted) seems unlikely to explain the effect.
- loloquwowndueo 3y ago[flagged]
- everdrive 3y agoThis is a straw man and does not feel particularly valid. I've never seen trees planted _in the streets_ and have always seen them planted along sidewalks. I don't believe trees steal parking spaces. Also, even with A/C, extreme temperatures can be a significant pain. Your car still gets scorching hot, and you waste a lot of energy cooling it down. (and further, it takes time for the A/C to actually start working.
- Filligree 3y agoYou've never seen trees in the street? They're fairly common here in Dublin, either along the midline or separating cars from cyclists.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoYou are talking past each other. They mean planted in the roadway.
- mysterydip 3y agoAs a car person, I'd love to see some kind of ordinance in my city of "any single-story paid parking lot is required to add a rooftop park that covers 90% of the area of the lot". I'm sure it adds to their $0/yr maintenance, but it would benefit everyone else.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 3y agoThis feels misleading. I totally believe that botanical gardens cool the air within them. That's what happens when you have an area full of trees and shade, with denser vegetation than a park. But I have a hard time believing that they have any significant effect on the city air 5 or 10 blocks away, where the asphalt is baking in the sun. So I'm not sure what the point of this article is, because it's not like we're going to replace half the blocks in a city with botanical gardens, as nice as that would be. Meanwhile, the article claims claims planting trees on the street has less effect, but surely is far more important -- because it affects the whole city, rather than a small localized area in and around a botanic garden? So there seems to be a major flaw in this article, in that it's comparing the cooling effects of various interventions (botanical gardens, street trees, etc.) but without ever specifying how the sizes or densities are being compared. Honestly, I can't even imagine what a unit of comparison between botanical gardens and street trees would be, since botanical gardens replace streets and buildings, while street trees merely add to them. It's apples and oranges.
- mariusor 3y agoI don't see anywhere in TFA where it's implied that the temperature drops as an average, or that somehow it extends past the green area. I feel like you've been misled by a strawman that you created yourself.
- nottorp 3y agoEmpirically, it extends a tiny bit past the green area. When I go for walks in summer in my city, it's noticeable how the temperature drops while on the sidewalk when I walk past a green area as opposed to past a building.
- cnity 3y agoThermodynamically it must. High temperature will flow towards low temperature areas like a heat-sink, where it is cooled by the shade and vapour.
- ddalex 3y agoI wonder if they could cool down a desert; let's say, make nuclear reactors and plant them on the edge of Sahara, and do one thing with them: desalinate water from the sea; use the water to irrigate large portions of the desert, and plant them with bamboo; this will cool the desert, sequester CO2, and have global influence on the climate warming. Back on the envelope calculations: 3.5 kWh/m^3 to desalinate water, 10 nuclear reactors, 1sq meter for a bamboo plant, you can water and grow 5.5 billion bamboo plant; let's say each plant fixes 10kg of CO2 per year, you reduce 10% of world's emissions in one clean sweep, for a total investment of maybe 100 billion USD
- jamie_ca 3y agoDesalination doesn't produce (freshwater + salt), it produces (freshwater + saltier water). Dealing with the waste brine is a challenge if you want to process that much in such a localized area.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe area is very clearly not "localized".
- quesera 3y agoThe real problem is that the cost would be outrageous. If you go this route for greening the Sahara, you could allot 5% for the evaporation ponds to turn brine into dry salt. There are other reasons it will never happen, but this one is solvable! :)
- lostlogin 3y agoThat’s a vast amount of salt. They can go from destabilising the world energy supply to messing with world salt supply.
- xbmcuser 3y agoyou can't do mass change like that. This will change weather patterns could result in a lot of rain being sucked into the Sahara and make South America a desert. https://news.mongabay.com/2015/03/how-the-sahara-keeps-the-amazon-rainforest-going/ https://news.mongabay.com/2015/03/how-the-sahara-keeps-the-a...
- karaterobot 3y agoThe chart and table in that article are confusing. They seem to indicate that if a city has botanical gardens, wetlands, green walls, street trees, balconies, permeable paving, woodlands, playgrounds, adopted public spaces, and mixed biomes, the air temperature would be reduced by 35°C. If so, I'm prepared to ban all these things to prevent our cities from becoming frozen hellscapes.
- walthamstow 3y agoI'm not sure. I live in London, 51 degrees north. We have a lot of parks in London, but the bus stops near them still have deep grooves of melted asphalt from recent heatwaves.
- n4r9 3y agoPerhaps it would be even worse without the parks? This article suggests that variation in temperature across the city does correlate with vegetation cover: > the Kilburn and South Hampstead area, with 38% vegetation cover, experienced heat over 7°C hotter than Regent’s Park, with 89% vegetation cover, a short distance away. https://www.pbctoday.co.uk/news/digital-construction-news/bim-news/londons-most-exteme-urban-heat-island-4-5c-hotter-rural-areas/132127/ https://www.pbctoday.co.uk/news/digital-construction-news/bi...
- pvaldes 3y ago> This article suggests Is more like a proven fact. Temperatures measured on hard landscape of modern parks based on stone is consistently higher than on old fashioned parks with big trees and fallen leaves. Sadly, cities still love this sun scorched inhospitable parks with passion because: 1) civil responsibility. A branch can kill a person and politicians hate this possibility 2) they are much easier to tidy up and much cheaper to maintain. Cheaper in the sense of "people will pay for their air conditioner, not us". 3) Vehicles can pass easily over stone surfaces (Also cleaning vehicles). Is not so easy to clean and drive over gravel
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI used to live in Chicago, and they managed this by putting a concrete pad at the bus stops that were high-frequency enough to get the grooves. The concrete pads are not bus-sized! They are only placed where the bus wheels are when the bus comes to a stop, with a little bit of a buffer since the bus doesn't stop in exactly the same place every time.
- lostlogin 3y ago> but the bus stops near them still have deep grooves of melted asphalt from recent heatwaves. Are you sure it isn’t from massively heavy busses repeatedly taking the same route across ‘not-that-hard’ tarmac?
- marklubi 3y ago[flagged]
- readthenotes1 3y agoApparently botanical is the preferred adjective for the garden that holds a bunch of plants. Even worse than the article talking about botanical gardens, should it not have just talked about heavily forested parks?
- NeoTar 3y agoApparently not, since both terms have been around for at least three hundred and fifty years... Botanical: Of or relating to botany, or the biological characteristics and attributes of the plants with which it is concerned. (1627) Botanic: Of or relating to botany or plants; = botanical, adj. A.1. (1647) "Botanical Garden" has been attested since the early 1700's (https://www.oed.com/dictionary/botanical-garden_n?tab=factsheet#991178514010 https://www.oed.com/dictionary/botanical-garden_n?tab=factsh...) whilst Botanic garden (although attested from earlier) is now just listed as a synonym of Botanical Garden (https://www.oed.com/search/dictionary/?scope=Entries&q=botanic+garden https://www.oed.com/search/dictionary/?scope=Entries&q=botan...).
- burkaman 3y agoThat might be true in Latin but that isn't how English works. Botanic and botanical are synonyms, just like cyclic/cyclical, geologic/geological, mystic/mystical. Generally the -al versions are more common, but either one is fine.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI wonder if the centers of cities are hotter now that they are all pavement and buildings than they were when they were grasslands or forests? Could this contribute to warming? Could warmer cities even cause us to overestimate the current temperature because the temperature 100 years ago on a prairie was less than the temperature today in a parking lot?
- bluGill 3y agoDo you want to account for the people living denser in those cities and thus freeing up room in more rural areas?
- gatane 3y agoAnother reason to do guerrilla gardening, or seed bombs: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seed_ball#Seed_bombing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seed_ball#Seed_bombing
- pvaldes 3y ago> seed bombing Please don't encourage anybody to do this. Let it to people that knows what they are doing. Invasive species burn millions and aren't a joke
- bane 3y agoI hope that the renewed interest in urban gardens and the appreciation for plant life in urban landscapes persists. The benefits can be wild in terms of improved quality of life for those living in the city. I live very near an urban core that is undergoing rapid development and densification. That core is part of a larger planned area that includes apartments, condos, town houses, and suburban style homes going back more than 50 years. The nearby suburban areas are walkable, and almost entirely embedded in so much greenery it's virtually a wildlife preserve. A local association owns some significant percentage of the land and has strict rules about development on their property which keeps it out of the hands of developers and well forested. My understanding was that all of these thousands of acres were virtually tree free farmland when it was selected for development. Now the entire area is absolutely filled with 30-70 foot (10-20 meter or so) trees planted when development started, dense undergrowth, and absolutely chock full of various kinds of wildlife like deer, foxes, raptors, and so on. Yards are allowed, but not really required, so many people have just let them go fallow and return to nature, or keep minimal outdoor areas for lawn furniture or play areas for their kids. The urban area needs a place for rainwater runoff to go, so the runoff areas dump into artificial streams which have been designated as parks, and provided with paved trails, and bridges and so on. They too have become heavily forested, the only sign that they're part of the local urban infrastructure is the occasional manhole cover. The runoff condenses into a selection of local artificial lakes that open up opportunities for waterfront property and parks, and personal watercraft and recreation areas. I live in a suburban home, 3 miles from the middle of the urban core which features an Apple store and other big named retailers, as well as offices, restaurants, recreation etc. It's a nice walk on weekends or evenings. The core is connected into the nearby major city and other nearby urban areas and the local airport via light rail. In the summer, we're about 5-10 deg F cooler than all of the surrounding areas, and much more humid in general. Because of the trees, we get very little wind. It can sometimes be difficult to predict how to dress when going out as our house sits even cooler than that, and stepping outside is still not representative of the way it feels in other nearby areas. It can be cold in our home in the early fall and late spring when the outside sits at around 20 deg C or 70 deg F. In some parts of the world this may sound absolutely normal, but here in the U.S. it's absolutely bonkers that it exists. My understanding was that it was explicitly patterned on a "more European" style of land development.
- inglor_cz 3y agoAnecdotally, Spanish cities seem to have really beautiful and well-kept gardens. Might have something to do with mitigating the hot climate. (Córdoba during the summer is a veritable oven.)
- Ekaros 3y agoHmm, what is the general availability of water resources these would need in areas that would benefit most of them? If there is already droughts I don't think too much water usage could be afforded adding more vegetation.
- bluGill 3y agoIf you are planting native trees there should be no problem - there have been droughts before and so the trees can handle them. You might need to water them for the first 5 years, but after that they should be okay. Select trees that are not native (or native species but from a very different location) and you can run into problems.
- quixoticelixer- 3y agoNative trees aren't always the 'best' option in modified urban environments. Just becuase they grew on what used to be there doesn't mean they will like what is there now
- vondur 3y agoI think this should be common knowledge that planting trees and having native green spaces in cities helps keep things cooler. In my neighborhood in Los Angeles, we have people who don't want trees in their yards and one who actually damaged a city planted tree in order to get rid of it. To a certain extent I get it, trees have to be maintained, which does cost money. We have a large and fast growing pepper tree in our yard, which is just over the line where the city would maintain it. We usually spend $700/year to have it trimmed back from hitting the house. I really appreciate how much shading it provides in the late afternoon in the summer.
- dunk010 3y agoExcept plants increase the humidity, exasperating conditions.
- quixoticelixer- 3y agoBut they make it cooler more than they make it more humid
- p0w3n3d 3y agoAny grass can cool the city 5°C but city need to maintain it and first of all, need to sacrifice the money the city would make off of building another four flats on it
- quixoticelixer- 3y agoAny grass can not cool the city by 5c
- zahma 3y agoI hope this isn’t a revelation to anyone at this point. Of course greenery reduces heat, but more than anything it means removing concrete, which mitigates the urban heat island effect. (Urban heat islands absorb heat energy during the day, amplifying extremes, and release heat at night, making it impossible for effective cooling.) And yet there is still so much resistance or otherwise apathy to the idea of planting more trees and removing space for vehicles — as if it’s merely some hippy-dippy shit only good for gentrification.
- vetinari 3y agoPlanting more trees and removing space for vehicles are two different things; it is not necessary to make them dependent. Those who do, usually do it for their anti-vehicle agenda, and planting green is only an excuse / a tool, not the objective or intent to improve the environment. If you want more space for parks and green, you can do it also other way. For example, like Hausmann did in Paris.
- zahma 3y agoIn a hierarchy of urban planning, I’d favor removing space for cars over demolishing precious space for affordable housing. To that effect, I wouldn’t point to Haussmann who bulldozed plenty of homes and neighborhoods for his unified vision of Paris connected by major thoroughfares. As a result, we have few parks and the city lacks any kind of real arboreal shelter except on some of the boulevards. He was a visionary, but he didn’t have scientific papers or the threat of climate change to contend with. The idea I have in mind is that the control over cities has been wrested from its citizens. A special car commuting class has more comfort moving about a city like Paris than regular inhabitants — but at what cost and borne by whom? Removing space for cars means removing vehicles, which re-empowers city-dwellers, cleans the air, and cools the city.
- woodruffw 3y agoIn much of the US, the two are interdependent: to plant more trees on streets, for example, many US cities will need to trim the arterial roads that swallowed up neighborhood sidewalks half a century ago.
- LispSporks22 3y agoI didn’t notice it until I got a motorcycle and started riding, because there’s very little between you and the environment and you’re moving so fast you can definitely feel the cooler and hotter parts of a city. Areas with trees, not necessarily sharing the road definitely feel a few degrees cooler
- nhggfu 3y agoshame they used an image of a table, instead of a html table. [accessibility fail]